HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sankalpb

68 karma · joined March 25, 2020

submissionscomments
sankalpb··on Ask HN: Is HN a ‘healthy online community’? I’m doing a case study for a class
Hi there, when it happened, did that experience of being downvoted change your perspective on the 'health' of HN? can you say more about contrasts between a human conversation and the conversations on HN?
sankalpb··on Ask HN: Is HN a ‘healthy online community’? I’m doing a case study for a class
Thanks for raising this point on whether or not 'community' can be reasonably used here, as it's an important one. Admittedly, I did not push deeper on the term 'community' at first, though I notice that the HN Welcome tab refers to this space as a 'community site'. That may well just be a descriptor for the site, but that doesn't adequately address your point. I haven't trained as an anthropologist, so the aspect about 'shared resources and problems' is helpful for me see here. Would you say, 'community' can be multiple in its definition by different members of a group? Would you say that any or all all members of a group must collectively agree on the status of their group as a 'community' to in fact be considered a community?
sankalpb··on Ask HN: Is HN a ‘healthy online community’? I’m doing a case study for a class
Thanks, I'm interested by your sense that health is assessed after 'leaders of the community define what their goals are' and not, for instance, that 'members of the community' define their goals collectively, could you say more about this?
sankalpb··on Ask HN: Is HN a ‘healthy online community’? I’m doing a case study for a class
Hi, can you say more about how you have come to view HN as a 'them' - do you see the HN community as separate and apart from you as a member?
sankalpb··on Ask HN: Is HN a ‘healthy online community’? I’m doing a case study for a class
Thanks, I appreciate a distinction that you're making between 'aggregation' and 'community conversation/engagement'. Have you been able to notice whether those 'button-pushing' types of comments ('highly emotional', 'imprecise in statement', 'poorly thought') are ones that push the buttons of the rest of the community as well? Do you consider yourself an outlier in this regard (having this sense for 'button-pushing' posts)?
sankalpb··on Ask HN: Is HN a ‘healthy online community’? I’m doing a case study for a class
Hey, I'm curious what makes having 'a number of interesting links' an indicator of being 'healthy' as an online community? Also, what makes a discussion 'mediocre' for you?
sankalpb··on Ask HN: Is HN a ‘healthy online community’? I’m doing a case study for a class
Hi, I'm not sure I follow - would you elaborate on these metaphors?
sankalpb··on Ask HN: Is HN a ‘healthy online community’? I’m doing a case study for a class
Thanks for this thorough response! I'm fascinated by the point you raise about 'having no interest in commenting' until being far enough along in your career to 'have actual insight to share on relevant topics'. Can you say more about what it was that made you feel ready to comment, and how doing so at that time, as opposed to commenting before, may or may not have changed your sense of participation in the HN community?
sankalpb··on Ask HN: Is HN a ‘healthy online community’? I’m doing a case study for a class
I also like when there are links or examples to support the reasoning behind a statement, though I don't mind if statements don't have them. Can you say more about what makes 'crickets' worse?
sankalpb··on Ask HN: Is HN a ‘healthy online community’? I’m doing a case study for a class
thanks, I hadn't heard of that community before!
← PreviousPage 2 of 2