HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sapphireblue

388 karma · joined April 13, 2016

submissionscomments
sapphireblue··on Infosec's Jerk Problem (2013)
There is a fundamental conflict of interest between security people and developers/owners/the general public. Infosec isn't interested in curing fundamental IT insecurity by, say, using safe languages (like Rust or something JVM-based or maybe JavaScript which is also a safe GCed language) for application development and using safe OSes that aren't built around 70s state-of-art (ugh.. really no production ready examples here). Instead infosec community - both "blackhat" attackers and "whitehat" protectors - profits from business as usual: a never-ending stream of zero days, CVEs, buffer overflows, side-channel attacks. It's not in their true interest to kill their cash cow.

Remember: If we, developers, used modern safe programming technologies, such as safe languages and OSes built around capability-based security, 99% of security exploits wouldn't even exist.

sapphireblue··on Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automation
This. Looks like a classical story of ideas guy using an engineer with relevant education and a decade of experience, then kicking him out. Looks very unjust to me, esp. considering there is big SV establishment (YC) on the other side.
sapphireblue··on How Far to AI Utopia?
Of course there is no certainty. For example the Moore's "law" (~ economic trend) has officially died. We can't rely on free bi-annual compute doubling anymore.

Still, deep learning has become a very powerful tool and we haven't discovered all possible applications just yet. DL models can learn a huge array of tasks, most of these tasks haven't been tried yet. Maybe there is a way to achieve some limited form of general intelligence even with current state of art (deepmind's A3C agent) if one trained it in some special way nobody haven't thought of yet.

sapphireblue··on How Far to AI Utopia?
To be honest Watson didn't use any deep learning (I read the paper, see http://www.aaai.org/ojs/index.php/aimagazine/article/view/23... ). It uses an ensemble of dozens of question-answering algorithms. Still it's very cool. A name DeepQA was a bit misleading, perhaps "wide QA" would be better.

RNN chatbots are the future, but for now they aren't stable enough to fulfill customers' elevated expectations. Also there is a problem with objective function that rewards interesting conversation, there is some new research on this problem that hasn't made it into open RNN chatbots yet. The standard objective function was giving most probable answers, it turned out to be boring.

I agree with grandparent that Reinforcement Learning is a right approach for training an intellectual chatbot, but there is a problem of well-designed training curriculum (i.e. some systematic scheme of rewarding and punishing the RL agent). I wouldn't wonder if facebook's M team tries different approaches, including RL, to train on their data.

sapphireblue··on Cruise
If you put these 700k in Vanguard, you could get ~3.21% per year forever. That works out to 22k$/year. Perhaps it's below poverty line in US, but for some countries that could be upper part of middle-class income.
sapphireblue··on Cruise
Who said you need to stay in SV once you are done? 1M should allow for pretty comfortable lifestyle in low-cost area.
sapphireblue··on Cruise
If he gets his 1M$ he may never ever have to work again.
sapphireblue··on How Far to AI Utopia?
The progress in machine learning/deep learning for last 5 years has been literally staggering. Read about new state of art results. There is already superhuman visual object recognition, voice recognition, good machine translation, description of scenes in natural language, question answering (facebook babi dataset), visual question answering, algorithm learning (neural turing machines, neural GPUs), and finally really strong reinforcement learning (deepmind's DQN, A3C algorithms).

The last one, reinforcement learning, is really important because it's a basis for general intelligence. By rewarding/punishing a reinforcement learning agent you can train it to execute very complex tasks, for example navigating a maze with pixel input or controlling a robot body to do some tasks. DeepMind is on the cutting edge of this kind of research, you can read about their latest agent here http://arxiv.org/abs/1602.01783

With such rate of progress it's not inconceivable if a sub-human but general intelligence could be developed in 10-20 years, or even sooner.

sapphireblue··on How Far to AI Utopia?
I don't have a college degree (that doesn't mean I don't have lots of technical experience though, including some machine learning at amateur level) and I'm not from the 1st world, but I disagree with you on that matter. I don't see how education will help us reach a truly utopian future. It looks like the developed world has pretty much hit the ceiling of what's possible for society controlled by (educated) humans. While I find 1st world an overall nice place, it is in no way an utopia: the day-to-day experience for average person isn't that good neither long- nor short- term. If that's the best we can do with education, we should probably take another path instead of repeating the same mistakes done by the developed world

It looks like the main problem of modern world is complexity. The infrastructure (physical, social, IT) has become too complex for mere humans to control. Humans are slow, learn slowly, have limited attention spans, limited capability of understanding complex nonlinear systems (e.g. markets, social dynamics). IMHO the world is currently in the state of severe deficit of attention. There is too much problems on all levels, yet humanity as a whole has only so much attention to apply to these problems, so only the absolutely critical issues are solved (e.g. 2008 financial crisis or flint water scandal) while everything else is neglected until it becomes critical.

Machine Intelligence (both Machine Learning and more general AIs, e.g. agents based on unsupervised+reinforcement learning) could give intelligent attention to every big and tiny problem there is: in politics, society, infrastructure, healthcare, etc. on Instead of having to deal with a constant stream of crises AI systems could prevent them from occurring before the catastrophical event took place, just like with preventive medicine. That and automated manufacturing & distribution could give way to a really pleasant life experience.

Of course it sounds too easy to be true. Looks like the biggest obstacle to realizing this variant of utopian future is politics. Human primate is naturally hierarchical, and these instincts influence our society & way of life profoundly. Modern society looks like a pyramid with wealthy & powerful on the top, a docile (but shrinking) middle class in the middle and controlled poor at the base. The people on top and in the middle are quite well off, and they are afraid of losing power (even to machines, even if there will be a mathematical proof that everyone will be better off after we delegate decision making to AI agents).

It looks to me that from the perspective of the rich & powerful there really is no need in automation/AI: why do they need robots when they are used to hiring poor people to serve them? Why do they need automation when with the power of money they can order thousands of people to manufacture any product/experience for them? That's the status quo that will have to be disrupted to have AI/robot-based automated utopia for everyone, IMHO.

← PreviousPage 3 of 3