HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sarjann

157 karma · joined November 11, 2023

submissionscomments
sarjann··on An open letter to Dario: if you mean it, open the weights
Not sure if I missed something but not sure what justification he gave that Open Weights would improve safety.

The counter argument from Anthropic is easy. If we open weights we can't detact it after being published / the guard rails that run on top of the models would be lost. Also abliteration would be much easier to do when a model's been publically release.

I'm not a fan of Anthropic but the argument in the article seems stupid.

sarjann··on OpenAI Agents API
Been using bedrock agent core and seems to work fine for me. Although there might be a better abstraction.
sarjann··on The Gemini app is now available for Windows
I still can't stand the fact that in order to use their mobile app you must allow sharing data for training. No thanks will close the app and it seems like they follow the same thing with their desktop app.

Outside of that, if I want to use Gemini through the browser they link allowing your data to be trained on with persistence of chats. If I don't want my data trained on I must allow them to train on my data.

For those reasons it's pretty much unusable for me.

sarjann··on 'People are going to get screwed' Pennsylvania voters unite against data centres
And if they can't give capacity, they should maybe be required to give a kind of "call option" or hedge locals energy prices linked to regular inflation.
sarjann··on Protecting Engineers' Skills in the AI Era
"It is the training apparatus of your future senior staff, and you should protect it the way you’d protect any other piece of critical infrastructure."

I think a problem is that especially with the culture of job hopping a lot and high turnover you can't be sure that you're not just training staff that'll go elsewhere. It's like an industry wide prisoners dilemna.

sarjann··on LLMs: Intelligence vs. Cost
Why use electricity alone for open models? Surely you’d want to spread the cost of hardware over the period too?
sarjann··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
What are you actually trying to get at? Had you even bothered to watch the 2nd (short) yet?

My point was that he’s willing to acknowledge that he was wrong, that is what the clip shows. Also can you read minds now?

‘He's also just saying what he thinks people (the general population) want to hear’

sarjann··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
I can't find a counter to every statement they have made and not sure about your specific AGI claim but.

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/QMhtTO3u61A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L_ueDUrkOlQ

Examples of acknowledging he was wrong

sarjann··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
Not sure about being early when it comes to points about models reaching the peak of their capability. Honestly, I don't understand how he's qualified (in terms of knowledge) to make such claims.
sarjann··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
Circular financing is an issue if the wealth accumulation stays in the chip -> model provider ecosystem. However it seems like the labs are making quite a lot of revenue from the chips (customers).
sarjann··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
I think one important distinction is at least they have some humility to admit they were wrong. I think Ed Zitron has rarely, if ever acknowledged he was wrong.
sarjann··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
I've always been suprised with the amount people take him seriously. I think he's someone who makes people who dislike AI "feel good". I don't blame someone who doesn't understand AI or have read what he's written.

But for the bloombergs and other podcasts I would have expected them to do a bit of research. I honestly think with the amount of doubling down he's been doing that he's a grifter.

sarjann··on Anthropic's best AI model struggles to attract users as cheaper tools thrive
I think an important part is communication, so many of these issue could be fixed by saying "Hey we're seeing our utilisation go over x% over the weekdays so we need to implement "surge usage" during this period starting in 2 weeks.

Instead often it feels like they make a change, then wait for someone to figure it out. Then Anthropic ends up being reactive as opposed to proactive in communication.

It is kind of funny because surprises from OpenAI tends to be positive (Tibo resets), on the Anthropc side I dread them.

sarjann··on I gave Qwen 3.8 27B a reverse-engineering job and it finished in 30 minutes
I guess the Riemann Hypothesis is an easy task then.
sarjann··on Kagi added a setting for removing paywalled links from search results
That's why it's a choice. If you weren't going to sign up to a site then it's just a pure degradation of experience to see links you can't use.
sarjann··on Kagi added a setting for removing paywalled links from search results
I would like to be able to whitelist some paywall sites, e.g. I have an FT subscription and would like to have that bypass the block.
sarjann··on DFlash 2: Keep Drafting Parallel
Great news, has made low memory bandwidth model usage so much nicer.
sarjann··on Incident with Github.com
Except he tries justifying it.

"Github’s servers are constantly on fire as their usage increased something like 50x due to LLM sloppers pushing large amounts of trash code"

"Unless you have a emergency hotfix (you don’t), go hit the gym or walk outside." with assumptions like above.

If it was, "hey they f*ed up but there's no point having an overly emotional reaction" that would be fine. But he seems to be justifying this. Especially with Github's record up to now of unreliability I think it's completely fair to be annoyed.

sarjann··on Incident with Github.com
This has to be rage bait, this is a critical piece of infrastructure for many people. Stuff going down can lead to deployments failing and as you mentioned in many cases emergency hotfix's.

The idea that we should be fine with this unreliability is just amazing. It's not a mental health issue to have problems when important infra fails.

sarjann··on Incident with Github.com
You would think for a company that has close to a monopoly of developer mind share wrt git that they'd maybe put in the bair minimum to get several 9s.
sarjann··on Google is making private AI practical with homomorphic encryption
I think at 1000x it's probably way cheaper to do an "AWS outpost" style thing. Although not sure if it's a fundamental constraint or something that could be optimised.
sarjann··on Gemini 3.7 Flash
Introductory price seems a bit weird as it expires at the end of the year and by then it’s going to be significantly outdated.
sarjann··on DeepSeek Harness
Might be easier to do cross platform.
sarjann··on Mark Zuckerberg attacks 'closed' AI rivals as Meta returns to open models
Fundamentally I always try to look at incentives. It's not that they are good or bad but that incentives favour certain behaviours.

Google is incentivised to collect a bunch of data (like FB) to improve their ad serving etc. Apple does not have that incentive as they don't make as much off advertising as hardware / app revenue.

NVIDIA is friendly with open source as they want to commoditise the model layer and take the gains in the hardware / data center layer.

I am trying to think what the incentive is here.

sarjann··on London Underground begins scanning passengers' faces
If I were to guess, they may have some "test" users (people who are involved in this) who are on the watchlist, they do their regular commutes and see if the system picks them up each time.

For this system there is no requirement that criminals faces are used to test it.

sarjann··on Mistral Patent for "Code implemented tool calls"
Google + Motorola aquisition vs Apple is a prime example.
sarjann··on Mistral Patent for “Code implemented tool calls”
I do wonder if we need a charitable foundation that does software patents and makes them freely available just to stop cockroaches abusing patents.

Another step (although governance would need to be super good for this). Would be for this charity to withold access to these patents from companies that decide to abuse stupid patents.

sarjann··on Muse Code and Muse Spark 1.2
I do think some of features in their harness seem interesting (workers in separate worktrees at once), recovery from crashes seem interesting.
sarjann··on Jeff Dean leaving Alphabet
I don't see how not? A theoretical physicist can do all the thinking they want but if they can't test an idea against nature it's not super useful.
sarjann··on Qwen3.8-Max: A New Bar for Coding and Cowork
dgx spark, nvfp4 so I have spare room for KV cache (context)
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →