64 karma · joined December 29, 2011
Not sure where you get the idea that the cost of limiting firearms is low or that the cost of limiting cars is high. Mass transportation, tele-communication etc. seem like viable solutions and because "for the children."
> That's why we should stop at firearms.
That's why we should stop giving our rights and freedoms away.
[0] www.census.gov/compendia/statab/2012/tables/12s1103.pdf
If there's one argument I cannot tolerate it's a "for the children" argument. Yes great lets have less children die. How do we do that? Killing sprees in China show that you can kill several children with just knives and gasoline. So after the guns we ban knives, we regulate gasoline, we restrict the press and instill a curfew because "for the children." Better yet, while we're just naming stuff that will make us feel better, why not a TSA-like agency for all public places, a Patriot Act to protect us from killing-spree and more warrant-less wiretapping because "for the children." Pedofiles on Facebook; regulate the Internet "because for the children." Can we please find a solution that does not strip freedoms from the sane and law-abiding among us?
It won't solve the problem because we are not other countries. I don't say this out of hubris. Without addressing things like the gun-culture we have here or the irrational fear of crimes we have here people will find a way to procure firearms. I'm pretty sure in 10 years 3D-printing will have advanced enough for us to make upper-receivers. What then? Do we regulate computers "for the children?"
2. It focuses the conversation on, what I think is, the actual problem rather than something that is achievable but clearly does not solve the problem.
Maybe it comes down to where you stand on Apple products and Gruber but I'd say he was spot-on. The things that he mentions also stood-out when I read the article.
"The analogy of an Apple tax might sound facetious, but think about it. Median U.S. household income was $50,054 in 2011, according to the Census Bureau. That means a sizable chunk of that is getting diverted to Apple headquarters in Cupertino." Before reading the article and just Gruber's post I would've agreed with you that Gruber is niggling but it appears that the author is actually semi serious about there being an Apple tax.
"I think lots of people are too obsessive about their media consumption for their own good. The prevalence of torrents is symptomatic."
I'm not sure I'm following you. If I do understand you then I think you're wrong here. It's a bit like saying people are too picky about the music they listen to; the Billboard's top 50 should be enough for them etc.
N.B. I don't like the use of "right" here I think it's ambiguous. Are we talking about laws, morals etc.? For simplicities sake I'll use "right" in my reply.
I also don't like the idea of trying to force digital goods to act like physical goods.
If $500 isn't hard for you to swallow I say you should get one.
Also, the question is do you think this is a marginal improvement and if so what would they have to do to make this more than a marginal improvement?