HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sarvinc

64 karma · joined December 29, 2011

Former Airborne Ranger. Principal software engineer at DealerTrack. Father of a baby boy.
submissionscomments
sarvinc··on Fear of Amazon Pushes Retailers to Take On Risks of Same-Day Shipping
For some reason I don't want to like what you've written. I up voted because I agree with you.
sarvinc··on Journalists’ Addresses Posted In Revenge For Posting Of Gun Permit Owners
Surely not all adults are capable of handling the responsibility of several things; debt, firearms, a vehicle, alcohol etc. I don't want to live in a place where this is a justification for anything.
sarvinc··on Journalists’ Addresses Posted In Revenge For Posting Of Gun Permit Owners
Funny story; when I was in the Army we had shortened Remington 870s used for breaching. One of my friends was trying to convince everyone that the "shorty" would be ineffective when used in a hanger because of the potential distance between target and assaulter. Another friend offered to help test the theory out by being the one behind the shotgun. It turns out that the shotgun doesn't do much when shortened but there is a strong physical reaction that occurs when someone fires one in your direction.
sarvinc··on Expedia: Bad for the Traveler, Bad for the Hotel
I'm not sure this is what people usually mean when they say "cutting out the middle man." Here the hotel and you are actually using the services of a middleman without then paying.
sarvinc··on The 2nd Amendment should protect the Internet, not your AK47
I'm nitpicking, and/or don't understand what you've written, it appears that you're making an argument for repealing the second amendment rather than making an argument that it isn't clear what was meant by the second amendment.
sarvinc··on No, Really, Regulate the Bullets
> Costs (eg negative impact, not price) of limiting firearms: low, mostly political. Costs of limiting cars: catastrophic, economy-devastating.

Not sure where you get the idea that the cost of limiting firearms is low or that the cost of limiting cars is high. Mass transportation, tele-communication etc. seem like viable solutions and because "for the children."

> That's why we should stop at firearms.

That's why we should stop giving our rights and freedoms away.

sarvinc··on No, Really, Regulate the Bullets
I agree that if we limit firearms we limit harm from firearms. Tell me why we should stop at firearms? Fewer children would meet pedophiles online if we didn't have an Internet. Fewer people would die in car accidents if we didn't have cars. 35.9 million people died within a year of being in a car accident [0]. Lets revisit this discussion when as many people are dying of gunshot wounds in the US as die of a car accident.

[0] www.census.gov/compendia/statab/2012/tables/12s1103.pdf

sarvinc··on No, Really, Regulate the Bullets
To be clear you replyed to a previous poster who made two points. I defended those two points. These are two new points that I'll attempt to address.

If there's one argument I cannot tolerate it's a "for the children" argument. Yes great lets have less children die. How do we do that? Killing sprees in China show that you can kill several children with just knives and gasoline. So after the guns we ban knives, we regulate gasoline, we restrict the press and instill a curfew because "for the children." Better yet, while we're just naming stuff that will make us feel better, why not a TSA-like agency for all public places, a Patriot Act to protect us from killing-spree and more warrant-less wiretapping because "for the children." Pedofiles on Facebook; regulate the Internet "because for the children." Can we please find a solution that does not strip freedoms from the sane and law-abiding among us?

It won't solve the problem because we are not other countries. I don't say this out of hubris. Without addressing things like the gun-culture we have here or the irrational fear of crimes we have here people will find a way to procure firearms. I'm pretty sure in 10 years 3D-printing will have advanced enough for us to make upper-receivers. What then? Do we regulate computers "for the children?"

sarvinc··on No, Really, Regulate the Bullets
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shiguan_kindergarten_attack 12 killed. Knives and gasoline used. It's terrible stuff but let's not argue from positions of ignorance and fear.
sarvinc··on No, Really, Regulate the Bullets
1. I don't think the argument is that firearms are less lethal only that attacks and death will still occur.

2. It focuses the conversation on, what I think is, the actual problem rather than something that is achievable but clearly does not solve the problem.

sarvinc··on Jackass of the Week: Reuters
I'm with Gruber on this; this was a terrible article. I read the article I guess I missed the "clear message." The closest I could come to a point, besides the idea that buying Apple products has some sort of hidden tax, was that Apple products are more expensive (purchase price) than the equivalent competing product.

Maybe it comes down to where you stand on Apple products and Gruber but I'd say he was spot-on. The things that he mentions also stood-out when I read the article.

"The analogy of an Apple tax might sound facetious, but think about it. Median U.S. household income was $50,054 in 2011, according to the Census Bureau. That means a sizable chunk of that is getting diverted to Apple headquarters in Cupertino." Before reading the article and just Gruber's post I would've agreed with you that Gruber is niggling but it appears that the author is actually semi serious about there being an Apple tax.

sarvinc··on Cable companies aren’t “forcing” people into piracy
Sorry for the late reply. "Only if you're obsessed with watching something specific." I take issue with the word "obsessed" but I agree with you point. I'll even, try to, do you one better; if I want to watch something it's easier for me to turn on the T.V.

"I think lots of people are too obsessive about their media consumption for their own good. The prevalence of torrents is symptomatic."

I'm not sure I'm following you. If I do understand you then I think you're wrong here. It's a bit like saying people are too picky about the music they listen to; the Billboard's top 50 should be enough for them etc.

sarvinc··on Cable companies aren’t “forcing” people into piracy
I think I don't have the right to take your clothes, but I certainly have the right to copy your clothes and make my own. How do you think this scenario applies to digital goods/content?

N.B. I don't like the use of "right" here I think it's ambiguous. Are we talking about laws, morals etc.? For simplicities sake I'll use "right" in my reply.

I also don't like the idea of trying to force digital goods to act like physical goods.

sarvinc··on Cable companies aren’t “forcing” people into piracy
I imagine piracy stats are probably more accurate then Nielsen ratings.
sarvinc··on Cable companies aren’t “forcing” people into piracy
I'm not the original poster but I'm more interested in discussing Marco's post than the original. The original is attacking a straw-man.
sarvinc··on Cable companies aren’t “forcing” people into piracy
I'm not sure about moral failure but I agree that this is a hole in Marco's argument.
sarvinc··on Cable companies aren’t “forcing” people into piracy
I'm not sure I see the point in arguing that piracy is or isn't justifiable. It's happening and it seems to be increasing. The sad fact is that it's easier to pirate than it is to pay. I pay for cable, HBO, Showtime, etc. but exclusively use a Mac Mini and torrent everything. Do I feel that what I'm doing is justifiable, no. Is it easier for me, yes.
sarvinc··on Review: The ARM-powered Samsung Chromebook
I haven't read the article but I think it's important to point out that the comparison is between IE and Chrome not Windows 7 and Chrome. Put another way, if I had an OS specifically built to run a mail application. Then, regardless of hardware, it wouldn't surprise me that my mail application ran faster on that OS then on Windows 7, OS X, etc.
sarvinc··on In under 3 weeks, iPhone 5 overtakes Galaxy S III in mobile web traffic
In the past 6 months I gave up my iPhone 4S and tried out a few Windows Phones and a Samsung Galaxy S2 (with Gingerbread). I'm very happy with the iPhone but I thought that I would see what's out there before purchasing an iPhone 5. I have to say that by far the Galaxy S2 was my least favorite phone; I could barely stand to use it for a day. This isn't a comment on Android or even the S2. I'm willing to believe that my tastes are atypical and I believe that the phone was usable. I learned that people value certain things over others. Perhaps iPhone owners value something that you yourself do not.
sarvinc··on IPhone 5 is Exactly what Apple Should Release
Admittedly I know nothing of "business level productivity suites," but why would you think that WP8 holds the most promise? Judging by WP7, which I've been using for 2 months now, I would imagine WP8 hold no promise. I'd also imagine that apps like Glassboard hold the most promise.
sarvinc··on Dead Trigger for Android free due to high piracy rates
It probably has something to do with the fact that this game has in app purchases.
sarvinc··on Show HN: Stachify, Instagram for mustaches
I'm completely smashed and bought this!
sarvinc··on Stephen King: Raise My F***ing Taxes Already
I think he already does this http://www.stkfoundation.org/
sarvinc··on While Apple Is Criticized for Foxconn, Other Companies Are Silent
This gave me pause; because I'd never thought of things this way. Unfortunately this doesn't seem to fit with my own experience. I've worked jobs that paid overtime. I worked overtime when I could, not because I felt the wage was unfair, but because I wanted the extra money.
sarvinc··on Android Device Makers Are Mutinying, Says Insider
I disagree, I think not supporting other platforms would've been short sighted. Think music distribution and iTunes.
sarvinc··on "Linux switch saved city millions and reduced user complaints"
I imagine this is exactly how it would go down if I installed Linux on my parent's computers. I think the key here is administration (at least until Linux is supported by 3rd party consumer companies). You can't move a company to a different OS without great IT support.
sarvinc··on Mike Daisey: Some Thoughts After The Storm
Early on I wondered why he wouldn't just be properly contrite say "I lied" and get this over with. From his point of view it's better for him if he doesn't do this. Like a politician, who's been caught doing something wrong, if he can weather the storm long enough people forget what he's done. If he comes clean then he loses the last vestiges of his support. I don't think it's a matter of coming to terms with what he's done I think it's a matter of selfishness. He sought fame and money, received both and he wants more.
sarvinc··on Read this before you buy the new iPad
I just moved from the first generation to the third generation and I'm pretty happy with it. It's faster in every way, same great battery life and the screen is much nicer for reading. One unexpected benefit is that Siri's voice annotation works decently enough.

If $500 isn't hard for you to swallow I say you should get one.

sarvinc··on Read this before you buy the new iPad
It's safe to say that most developers will take advantage of the screen resolution. Just not three days after it's released.
sarvinc··on “Disappointing” iPad 3 speculation
You really can't say that about many other brands. If I had to guess I would say you have to make pretty great devices, for a while, before you get that kind of brand loyalty.

Also, the question is do you think this is a marginal improvement and if so what would they have to do to make this more than a marginal improvement?

← PreviousPage 3 of 3