HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

saulpw

3,890 karma · joined August 6, 2021

You can email me at hackernews@saul.pw.
submissionscomments
saulpw··on Hear Me Out: If We Find Life Out There Maybe We Should Kill It
Because your neighbor is the same species and so you have some idea of what it's like inside their head.

When your neighbor is a different species, this is pretty much exactly what humans do: kill it. The more unfamiliar, the faster it gets killed.

Is it bad for the ecosystems, biodiversity, your soul? Yes on all counts. But it's pretty consistent human behavior.

saulpw··on Compute-efficient pretraining and scaling to trillion-parameter models
Note that addition that's "trillion times faster" is purely an optimization, not greater intelligence.

And a society of humans does not increase our overall intelligence. It allows all of humanity to access the accomplishments of our most intelligent members throughout history (which is huge, don't get me wrong!) but it seems almost self-evident that our civilization as a whole is not smarter than Newton/Einstein/von Neumann/etc.

saulpw··on One resignation turned the embers of AI fear into a wildfire
"They" don't care about "fixing" the DMV. It's nice to think that "they would if they could" but in fact, the anti-government party actively cripples and dismantles government services so that people lose faith in government's ability to improve lives. And what would "fixing" it look like, anyway? Lower cost to operate or lower time-in-queue? Those are in conflict and as much as I would appreciate a better experience there when I have to go (once every 5 years), I think few people would be willing to pay $X/year for that.

On the other hand, my personal computer setup is better than it's been in a long time. Other peoples' software that I run has not improved much, but I've managed to fix several long-standing issues by just giving Fable access to my configuration and telling it my intent.

I've also vibe-coded several applications which are lighter-weight versions of things like Pinboard, Descript, and Weechat. I'm not releasing them because I've been doing OSS for 10 years and I've felt first-hand how the economics of open-source is skewed. And in this day and age where anyone can vibe up their own custom app, it doesn't feel worth it anymore.

What this tells me is that there's not proper incentive for the software you use to get "better" according to your values. You have implicit metrics of "cleanliness", "minimalism", "anticipatory design", and I share those values, but having worked as a SWE for 30 years, I have never worked for a corporation which encouraged those values. If I managed to inflict them on the corporate software I created, it was a "yes and" situation and I only did it because I (or other engineers) cared, never because management wanted it.

So the problem is not "AI is failing us" but rather "the system is failing to use these awesome tools to improve our lives". We can use AI to try to improve the system itself, but our system is not a github repo you can deploy to prod. It's a bit trickier to vibe up the improvements to our incentive structure (though I am trying to do it a bit myself).

saulpw··on Compute-efficient pretraining and scaling to trillion-parameter models
I think there's an intelligence limit, or at least asymptote. It may be above human intelligence, but I don't think it's miles above it (at least not the kind of intelligence humans can create, recognize, or use). For example in Go, most estimates place God or "perfect play" three ranks above top professionals[0]. In the latest human-AI Go match, the human got a 2 stone handicap. So it's not like we have a lot more frontier to push there.

[0]https://senseis.xmp.net/?HandOfGod

saulpw··on I want a data center job
claude fix it
saulpw··on A Tesla ran a stop sign and killed a man, Full Self-Driving/Autopilot was on
If fewer people die, there is only less liability to assign. Remember that the original argument was "FSD needs to have 0 fatalities before we adopt it". And it's not valid to argue that some traffic fatalities are unavoidable; I know people who work at the DOT and "Vision Zero"[0] is a thing, and already implemented in some European countries/cities. Without FSD. So FSD needs to clear this bar.

[0] https://visionzeronetwork.org/about/what-is-vision-zero/

saulpw··on The Education of a Doomer
I can think of several billionaires who would be quite fine ruling over a devastated and machine-led earth. Their families are chosen or bred to agree with their amorality, and they and their dynastic families would rule with pleasure.
saulpw··on The Education of a Doomer
Reducing inflation is indeed one of the reasons, but what I was getting at is that the government doesn't "need" people for tax revenue to pay for its services, contrary to popular belief. It needs taxes to make its money valuable.

L. Randall Wray, "What Are Taxes For? The MMT Approach" (2014):

> Sovereign government does not really need revenue in its own currency in order to spend. It is the tax that 'drives' the currency. If we eliminated the tax, people probably would not immediately abandon use of the currency, but the main driver for its use would be gone.

saulpw··on A Tesla ran a stop sign and killed a man, Full Self-Driving/Autopilot was on
No, because you can punish bad drivers, remove them from the driving pool, put them in jail, or in some way achieve justice (this may not always happen, but at least it's posible). There is no way for FSD to have any accountability, and so no justice can be served. "Sorry, your son was just unlucky that he was killed by the AI, but we can't do anything about it" is an intolerable breakdown of justice. Same problem we have with qualified immunity.
saulpw··on The Education of a Doomer
National governments which can print their own currency don't require people for tax revenue. They use taxes to compel people to acquire their currency to give it value. If they can instead compel AIs to acquire their currency, they won't need humans for that either.
saulpw··on AI, Tools and Transformation
I have a friend who writes, she has certain needs, I've shown her how to start building tools, she has no interest in building tools. She's focused on writing and does not think about her personal process that way. Not every is a tool-builder, in fact most aren't!
saulpw··on There Gonna Be a Shortage of Everything
They paved paradise, put up a parking lot.
saulpw··on There Gonna Be a Shortage of Everything
If the wealthy control the substrate (the server farms) and can restrict access to the machine, then it would be basically a truism that the machine would be only usable by the wealthy? Unless somehow the AI is secretly on the side of the common person and can't be trained away from that, which seems quite unlikely.
saulpw··on Porting my 1993 Amiga game to Godot, with an LLM reading the 68000 assembly
Yeah I'm working on a C64 game myself (Below The Root). Are yours a secret?
saulpw··on Porting my 1993 Amiga game to Godot, with an LLM reading the 68000 assembly
Which game are you planning to do? We all should coordinate so we're not doing the same games repeatedly.
saulpw··on Apple used to be weirder and maybe more fun
> October 17, 1988

> The typical Apple engineer’s office contains [...] about a gigabyte of hard disk space

A gigabyte?! In 1988?? Am I misremembering, or was that about 10-20x what we consumers had in our computers?

saulpw··on The Rise and Fall of Agent Civilizations
Even if they all become corrupt eventually, which one takes the longest to get there? Better to squeeze a few decades of decency out of it than a few years, or not get anything at all by handing it over directly to the already corrupted.
saulpw··on “I just chose words carefully”
A natural descriptivist.
saulpw··on The Rise and Fall of Agent Civilizations
Libraries, universities; institutions which have shown themselves to be devoted to the public good over centuries.
saulpw··on Nobody Told Me People Still Code New Games for a 1982 Computer
and then why would you use an LLM to write a forum post about it?
saulpw··on Bye, Bye GitHub
https://microsoft.ai/news/building-a-hillclimbing-machine-la...
saulpw··on You've heard of CSV files, but have you heard of CCSV files?
This is generally called ASV for ASCII-separated values, or USV for Unicode-separated values (e.g. U+241E, which is different from the ASCII U+001E equivalent).

Also, as wonderful as this would be, as other comments say, no one uses it because no one uses it.

saulpw··on Bye, Bye GitHub
Microsoft owns GitHub.
saulpw··on Tim Curry has died
Death comes in threes and they were both 80, could be a party soon
saulpw··on More than half of adults in U.S. say they lack basic statistical understanding
After all the average human has one breast and one testicle.
saulpw··on Peppermint oil reduces blood pressure by 8.48 mmHg in small study
Maybe we can add some licorice root to balance the effect.
saulpw··on Ask HN: How do you host your vibe coded tools/sites?
It's for a personal link bookmark site[0]. And I guess I had made the repo[1] public after all. It's been working well for about 6 months now.

[1] https://github.com/saulpw/trove/

[0] https://trove.saul.pw/

saulpw··on Ask HN: How do you host your vibe coded tools/sites?
I'm actually using Github issues as a low-volume/high-latency DB for a project right now. I use a Netlify function to do extremely simple auth and then open an issue on Github, which triggers a CI action, which appends to a .jsonl file in the repo (different branch), which triggers a Netlify build, which then serves the new jsonl file. (If the repo were public, this wouldn't even have to trigger a rebuild of the website, it could just get the .jsonl from Github directly).

It's totally hack-a-licious but it also totally works for my N<10 users.

saulpw··on Ask HN: How do you host your vibe coded tools/sites?
I use Netlify connected to Github/Gitlab, which does a build on every commit to the main branch. For low-volume static sites (which all of mine are) this is free, fast, and convenient.
saulpw··on I'm Done Using AI
I mean I'm constantly saying things like 'wtf bro', that's pretty much talking to it like a friend. At least he's still using 'it' pronouns for it.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →