HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

savingsPossible

445 karma · joined August 19, 2010

submissionscomments
savingsPossible··on YouTube’s rules are used to silence human rights activists
It is also trivially the case that "due process is good, but not the highest good". Or, to take a less charged example, freedom of contracts

I don't mean to be snarky, but to try to draw a line. There are goods and rights that are intrinsically important (say food, water, social life, freedom from crime) and some that are important for the maintaining of a society (contracts are a good example here).

One of these "to maintain a society" freedoms is due process. Another, free speech. Both are important for their own sake, but also to check and control power.

You can say, and it is reasonable to say, that not suffering the ill effects of crime is more important than having good due process. But, given that due process is an important check on those in power, whenever they say "we need to reduce due process to get better law enforcement", you should be wary.

To sum up: some seemingly rational trades between values are dangerous, especially since they reduce our ability to influence society/to undo those trades.

savingsPossible··on John McAfee found dead in Spanish jail after court approves extradition to US
To clarify:

What do you think the highest and lowest standards of evidence should be for "social opprobium"?

And what is the maximum damage to ones life that "social opprobium" should ideally entail?

savingsPossible··on John McAfee found dead in Spanish jail after court approves extradition to US
Did you mean to say "social opprobium" (aka, lets get this guy fired and kicked out of places) should have a lower standard of proof than "beyond a reasonable doubt"? Because reading your post I understood that it should be lower then the civil standard (i.e.: "preponderance of evidence")

Which I believe it *has*, but absolutely should not have

savingsPossible··on John McAfee found dead in Spanish jail after court approves extradition to US
1) Lower than preponderance of evidence?

I believe you about it having such a standard (we can call it presence of evidence or presence of suspicion), but not on it being right.

2) Preponderance of evidence makes sense on civil suits because they are kinda inherently simmetrical. Either A loses or B loses. We would probably do better in using the standard of evidence for, say, a traffic violation, in the case of social "lets get this guy fired and try to make sure he never gets a job again" -- might not be enough of a standard, but better

savingsPossible··on Japan's government plans to encourage 4-day workweek, but experts split
Apparently not?

The cost can come from the margin for the gas station, not the consumer

savingsPossible··on The Schindler of Japan, Chihune Sugihara
He/She may

1) Think Sugihara was right 2) Believe that taking refugees into europe is worse on average/bad

All it takes is a different reason for Sugihara to be right

savingsPossible··on As religious faith has declined, ideological intensity has risen
Correct.

There is no such thing as "secular ideology". There are many. Just as there are many religions.

There is materialism+work ethic, there is materialism without work ethic, there is "wokeism" (to pin a definition, the belief that oppression is a fundamental societal force and clearly directional based on some enumerated characteristics), there is nationalism. There's even "startups" :P

But perhaps you have a grain of truth in that rarely is a "secular ideologist" a "monotheistic" (monoidealistic?) one. Usually one's identity holds a plurality of those identifications.

Also, people can have a strong identification to ideas without a community to back it up (another grain of truth, and the saddest part)

savingsPossible··on As religious faith has declined, ideological intensity has risen
This was interesting, but also somewhat paradoxical.

A belief that does not affect your actions, but implies or causes a belief that does affect your actions. Well, that does affect your actions. :)

But serioulsly, joke aside, that was an interesting concept

savingsPossible··on ProPublica's tax story
You are equating morality with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utilitarianism. With "optimizing the integral of happiness"

You can be a perfectly moral denteologian (that is, a person that believes in moral rules, not in moral objective functions) and be a billionaire.

A second possibility: you can be a utilitarian, and believe that positive sum trades should always be taken (untenable position as this is (1)) and think you are taking one such trade. That is the claim Elon Musk seems to be making: This money today will save human lifes (electric cars reducing climate change) and increase the future number of lifes worth living in the cosmos (spacex)

(1) On the untenability and self-destructiveness of "always take positive sum choices, even if they harm you"

1) living an American middle class life while children starve might be similarly morally reprehensible

2) Not killing oneself and donating ones organs (saves what? 10 lives?) might be similarly morally reprehensible

savingsPossible··on The Dangers of Low Head Dams (2019)
Surprised by how low that is!

What is EROI for hidro/thermo/nuclear?

savingsPossible··on Offload Mental Simulation
> I think the halting problem only tells you that you cannot, in general, opinionate on what the program does, without expending an amount of computational effort equivalent to running that program. A better counterpoint is that you can't know ahead of time what values will be returned by IO calls.

One corolary of the non-computability of the halting problem is that the problem "does this line ever run" is also non-computable

savingsPossible··on Reddit is banning any Aimee Challenor mention. UK public figure and Reddit admin
No, but you get a pass because he was not yet convicted.

that is what a conviction means -- we should not punish people before it, nor should we punish people that associate with them

savingsPossible··on Google is apparently taking down all/most Fediverse apps from the Play Store
Does that matter?

If op is lying, he or she is lying.

But are some groups ok to threaten? Are some people ok to threaten?

savingsPossible··on Moving from YouTube to PeerTube
If you are watching on a browser, ublock origin fixes that

If on android, you can download newpipe (first download and install f-droid, a "google play for free/open source", and then download newpipe from there)

savingsPossible··on Ask HN: Anyone a social entrepreneur, i.e. placing social impact above profit?
This is an interesting perspective, that I sometimes have as well.

But you did miss the important nuance of the externalities as another post also comments.

And you did list subsidies, but some subsidies are hard to notice.

Cars, for example, are heavily subsidised (think of road maintenance+the rent of all that space) and cause negative externalities (noise, pollution and congestion).

So it is more than possible to make a profit and not be socially beneficial (I think that cars are a good example, but we can disagree on that, they stand mostly as an example of subsidies and externalities, the balance of good and harm is harder to access).

savingsPossible··on PDF: Still unfit for human consumption, 20 years later
thanks! really cool
savingsPossible··on You may finally use JSHint for evil
Do we need to consider only intent, or can we extrapolate probable futures?

Because then I worry about deepfakes making actors obsolete (as we have made obsolete so many other professions)

savingsPossible··on US to ban transactions with ByteDance and WeChat in 45 days
And then we fix this next problem, right?

That is no argument to avoid a policy. That is an argument to prepare for the next steps.

savingsPossible··on US to ban transactions with ByteDance and WeChat in 45 days
Your reply makes sense, but you are buying into the notion that there is 'hate' and 'racism' involved.

This is a spurious comparison. Every time someone accuses someone else of racism in this thread, there should be the same answer: The US (after a looong while!) is doing to Chinese companies the same China does to US companies. To ensure the benefits of globalization are not concentrated by China's protectionist policies

savingsPossible··on US to ban transactions with ByteDance and WeChat in 45 days
> Or you hate the Chinese fifth of the World population?

This is a spurious comparison. Every time someone accuses someone else of racism in this thread, there should be the same answer: The US (after a looong while!) is doing to Chinese companies the same China does to US companies. To ensure the benefits of globalization are not concentrated by China's protectionist policies

savingsPossible··on Facebook hate-speech boycott had little effect on revenue
Not in the USA, no
savingsPossible··on ‘Success Addicts’ Choose Being Special over Being Happy
Only a partial control. Some bad effect @50 can cause both the divorce and the problems at @80
savingsPossible··on Friendly Feudalism: The Tibet Myth (2003)
I have, apparently.

Can you substantiate that claim? I never saw the death count per population of each religion and to know that one is higher than the other. Or the slave count per population.

Was Christianity worse, or just larger?

savingsPossible··on Men Are Waiting to Share Some Feelings (2018)
That is the thing, though. Violence had social norms around it. It was not the case that you could escalate forever.

I remember one message from a father to a son, for example, that said "never throw the first punch unless he is X inches taller than you". Of course, this might have been a tad to noble for the time, but still, there were norms.

savingsPossible··on Men Are Waiting to Share Some Feelings (2018)
Before people had a firm idea of homosexuality, men did show affection for other men as well.

It went like this: it is ok to hold hands with a man (because no one will think you are gay/because no one thinks anyone is gay) -> it is not ok to hold hands (because people will think you are gay) -> it is ok to hold hands (because it would not be a problem if you were gay)

and the last step is still ongoing...

← PreviousPage 6 of 6