HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sbuttgereit

6,901 karma · joined June 14, 2015

Business systems implementation and development consultant Muse Systems (https://muse.systems) about me: https://buttgereit.com
submissionscomments
sbuttgereit··on Judge finalizes order for Greenpeace to pay $345M in ND oil pipeline case
Based on their "Meet the Committee" page, they look a bit more like they have a dog in this fight beyond simply adjudicating the case.

https://www.trialmonitors.org/meet-the-committee

Plenty of accomplished people there, but as a group "unbiased observers" isn't the first phrase that comes to mind.

sbuttgereit··on Long Range E-Bike (2021)
As a pedestrian I find your analysis a bit myopic... but on par for far too many cyclists.
sbuttgereit··on Are the Mysteries of Quantum Mechanics Beginning to Dissolve?
This was a good discussion on the topics involved as well; between Jacob Barandes & Tim Maudlin. Though I don't recommend watching this without first getting some familiarity with Barandes's ideas... while there's some explanatory dialog in this video I'm posting, mostly is a discussion. It's nice to see the ideas (politely) challenged and answered.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8xPvxAdmhKM

sbuttgereit··on Fixing retail with land value capture
It's just market value.

> *SECTION 1. (a) The maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property shall not exceed One percent (1%) of the full cash value of such property. The one percent (1%) tax to be collected by the counties and apportioned according to law to the districts within the counties.*

(https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displayText.x...)

At sales time basically the sales price establishes the assessed value for taxes.

Again, this isn't a precise reading, but the general idea.

sbuttgereit··on Fixing retail with land value capture
This doesn't sound like it's the same thing as what happens in California.

> second year of home ownership as they adjust to meet the sales price.

This sounds like the reassessment is triggered when a nearby sale or comparable happens. In California, the triggering event is the sale of the property itself only. So, for the entire time you own the property in California, the Prop 13 rules limit the allowed assessment to increase only up to 2% annually, assuming that the increase is supported by market price increases. Again, this isn't exactly precise legal reading, but is enough for the gist. There are limits to things like total taxation relative to market value and certain ways local governments can (in practice) tax property in excess of the limits. But the idea is to prevent an owner seeing sudden increases of 300% anytime after the initial sale.

Now when you sell your property, the new owner will face the fully assessed market value of the property for property taxes. So the new buyer could face 100's of percent taxation differences compared to what you're paying.

sbuttgereit··on Fixing retail with land value capture
I think you may have replied to the wrong comment.
sbuttgereit··on Fixing retail with land value capture
This is in California.

The hand-wavy explanation is that in the late 70's when this initiative passed (Prop 13), home values were rising rapidly due to an influx of people moving to the state and higher inflation rates of the times. Many people that owned homes, including those that had purchased their homes and retired, were getting priced out of their homes on the property tax rates. There are other rationales or rationalizations depending on where you come down on it. But Prop 13 was intended to slow property tax growth while you owned the property, with assessment reset to full market value at sale time.

sbuttgereit··on We mourn our craft
> "I didn’t ask for a robot to consume every blog post and piece of code I ever wrote and parrot it back so that some hack could make money off of it."

I have to say this reads a bit hollow to me, and perhaps a little bit shallow.

If the content this guy created could be scraped and usefully regurgitated by an LLM, that same hack, before LLMs, could have simply searched, found the content and still profited off of it nonetheless. And probably could have done so without much more thought than that required to use the LLM. The only real difference introduced by the LLM is that the purpose of the scraping is different than that done by a search engine.

But let's get rid of the loaded term "hack" and be a little less emotional and the complaint. Really the author had published some works and presumably did so that people could consume that content: without first knowing who was going to consume it and for what purpose.

It seems to me what the author is really complaining about is that the reward from the consuming party has been displaced from himself to whoever owns the LLM. The outcome of consumption and use hasn't changed... only who got credit for the original work has.

Now I'm not suggesting that this is an invalid complaint, but trying to avoid saying, "I posted this for my benefit"... be that commercial (ads?) or even just for public recognition...is a bit disingenuous.

If you poured you knowledge, experience, and creativity into some content for others to consume and someone else took that content as their own... just be forthright about what you really lost and don't disparage the consumer. Just because they aren't your "hacks" anymore, but that middlemen are now reaping your rewards.

sbuttgereit··on Flock CEO calls Deflock a “terrorist organization” (2025) [video]
Well then... let's eliminate any due process and fourth amendment protections, maybe requiring something sensible like "officer suspicion", or maybe just a program of "random" searches.. you know keep everybody on their toes. I also bet that real crimes (whatever that means) goes down...

Just because something works doesn't make it right. Personally, giving up what the law is suppose to protect (individual rights) in the name of the law is something I can only see as a fool's bargain.

sbuttgereit··on Flock CEO calls Deflock a “terrorist organization” (2025) [video]
Probably worth posting some links to the Institute for Justice's "Project on the Fourth Amendment":

https://ij.org/issues/ijs-project-on-the-4th-amendment/

This Project includes work to fight technologies such as Flock's in the courts:

https://ij.org/issues/ijs-project-on-the-4th-amendment/licen...

I've always felt good contributing to IJ and the topic and takes in the posted video are precisely why I do so.

sbuttgereit··on Ubisoft cancels six games including Prince of Persia and closes studios
It's interesting. I wonder how much large-company disfunction is derailing these things.

Recently Hytale, a would-be Minecraft successor, released early access. That project started around a decade ago as something of an indie project, was purchased by Riot, then cancelled by Riot, then recently sold back to the original project people... who basically undid a lot of fruitless work done by Riot and... as I said... now released as early access. A well received early access as far as I can tell.

I wonder why we don't see more indie games and new developers that are more able rising to challenge what look like dysfunctional incumbents?

I'll be the first to admit that I don't know anything about that industry, but it seems like there's space to make progress for newcomers.

sbuttgereit··on European lawmakers suspend U.S. trade deal
That the current US administration is behaving today not terribly unlike the UK regime of the late 18th century is not a convincing argument for the UK reasserting its historic imperial ambitions in North America or elsewhere.

Furthermore, the native populations of those western territories would probably like to have a word over UK & European rights to assert such privileges in the first place.

sbuttgereit··on Fossil versus Git
Tried jj several weeks ago... and absolutely love it.

A life non-goal for me is becoming proficient in a version control system and Git, insofar as I've been able to tell, demands that you become proficient in an uncomfortably large subset of its features in order to get through any workload, even in the simplest realistic cases.

jj did take some getting use to, but after a couple days it was all sorted and actions which terrified me in Git felt natural and safe using jj. The kind of things that required me to go back to the git documentation (or stackoverflow, or some blog posts) to be sure I was holding it right... in jj it comes easily and naturally.

That jj offers sufficient power under a simple interface to get through the day ... while being compatible with those that use Git... make it a no-brainer for me.

sbuttgereit··on Maybe comments should explain 'what' (2017)
Until someone changes the test to be four days, or two, but doesn't update the test name.

Ultimately disciplined practice requirements rely on disciplined practices to succeed. You can move the place where the diligence needs to taken, but at the end the idea that comments can lose their meaning isn't that different to other non-functional, communicative elements also being subject to neglect. I don't mean to suggest that a longish test title wouldn't be more likely to be maintained, but even with that long name you are losing some context that is better expressed, person-to-person, using sentences or even paragraphs.

I had first hand experiences with this, oddly enough, also working on an accounting system (OK, ERP system... working the accounting bits). I was hired to bring certain deficient/neglected accounting methodologies up to a reasonable standard and implement a specialized inventory tracking capability. But the system was 20 years old and the original people behind the design and development had left the building. I have a pretty strong understanding of accounting and inventory management practices, and ERP norms in general, but there were instances where the what the system was doing didn't make sense, but there was no explanations (i.e. comments) as to why those choices had been taken. The accounting rules written in code were easier to deal with, but when we got to certain record life-cycle decisions, like the life-cycle evolution of credit memo transactions, the domain begins to shift from, "what does this mean from an accounting perspective", where generally accepted rules are likely to apply, to what did the designers of the application have in mind related to the controls of the application. Sure I could see what the code did and could duplicate it, but I couldn't understand it... not without doing a significant amount of detective work and speculation. The software developers that worked for the company that made this software were in the same boat: they had no idea why certain decisions were taken, if those decisions were right or wrong, or the consequences of changes... nor did they care really (part of the reason I was brought in). Even an out-of-date comment, one that didn't reflect the code has it evolved, would still have provided insight into the original intents. I know as well as you that code comments are often neglected as things change and I don't take it for granted that understanding the comments are sufficient for knowing what a piece of code does.... but understanding the mind of the author or last authors does have value and would have helped multiple times during that project.

When I see these kinds of discussions I'm always reminded of one of my favorite papers. By Peter Naur, "Programming As Theory Building" (https://pages.cs.wisc.edu/~remzi/Naur.pdf). In my mind, comments that were at least good and right at one time can give me a sense of the theory behind the application, even if they cannot tell me exactly how things work today.

sbuttgereit··on Mistral OCR 3
Yep. I saw the title and got excited.... this is a particular problem area where I think these things can be very effective. There are so many data entry class tasks which don't require huge knowledge or judgement... just clear parsing and putting that into a more machine digestible form.

I don't know... feels like this sort of area, while not nearly so sexy as video production or coding or (etc.)... but seems like reaching a better-than-human performance level should be easier for these kinds of workloads.

sbuttgereit··on The Scottish Highlands, the Appalachians, Atlas are the same mountain range
Nick Zentner, a geology lecturer at Central Washington University, takes a particular subject and does a relatively deep, discussion oriented, dive into it over the course of 26 sub-topics... his "A to Z" series. In these he does a couple streamed shows a week and includes links to relevant papers and resources. At the end of each session is a viewer Q&A for those watching live. Almost an online continuing education course....

He did "Baja-BC A to Z" 3 years ago:

https://www.nickzentner.com/#/baja-bc-a-to-z/

With the associated reading list: https://www.geology.cwu.edu/facstaff/nick/gBAJA/

Currently he's about halfway through another "A to Z" called "Alaska A to Z" which covers some of that same territory

https://www.nickzentner.com/#/livestream-series-26-episodes/

And the so-far-posted reading list: https://www.geology.cwu.edu/facstaff/nick/gALASKA/

Of central importance to the first half of the current Alaska series is recent paper by geologist Robert S. Hildebrand titled: "The enigmatic Tintina–Rocky Mountain Trench fault:a hidden solution to the BajaBC controversy?"

What's great about these series is that he'll get a number of the geologists writing these papers involved in one way or another. Either contributing interviews or talks specifically for the video series, or like in the case of this Hildebrand centric work in the current series, Hildebrand himself is watching the stream and participating in the live chat with the other viewers, answer questions and the like.

sbuttgereit··on Avoid UUID Version 4 Primary Keys in Postgres
OK... but that concern seems a bit artificial.. if bigints are appropriate: use them. If the table won't get to bigint sizes: don't. I've even used smallint for some tables I knew were going to be very limited in size. But I wouldn't worry about smallint's very limited number of values for those tables that required a larger size for more records: I'd just use int or bigint for those other tables as appropriate. The reality is that, unless I'm doing something very specific where being worried about the number of bytes will matter... I just use bigint. Yes, I'm probably being wasteful, but in the cases where those several extra bytes per record are going to really add up.... I probably need bigint anyway and in cases where bigint isn't going to matter the extra bytes are relatively small in aggregate. The consistency of simply using one type itself has value.

And for those using ints as keys... you'd be surprised how many databases in the wild won't come close to consuming that many IDs or are for workloads where that sort of volume isn't even aspirational.

Now, to be fair, I'm usually in the UUID camp and am using UUIDv7 in my current designs. I think the parent article makes good points, but I'm after a different set of trade-offs where UUIDs are worth their overhead. Your mileage and use-cases may vary.

sbuttgereit··on Avoid UUID Version 4 Primary Keys in Postgres
You might have missed the big H2 section in the article:

"Recommendation: Stick with sequences, integers, and big integers"

After that then, yes, UUIDv7 over UUIDv4.

This article is a little older. PostgreSQL didn't have native support so, yeah, you needed an extension. Today, PostgreSQL 18 is released with UUIDv7 support... so the extension isn't necessary, though the extension does make the claim:

"[!NOTE] As of Postgres 18, there is a built in uuidv7() function, however it does not include all of the functionality below."

What those features are and if this extension adds more cruft in PostgreSQL 18 than value, I can't tell. But I expect that the vast majority of users just won't need it any more.

sbuttgereit··on I tried Gleam for Advent of Code
Fair enough, but to be fair to my statements, the quotes I chose were largely from gleam-lang.org or the Gleam OTP library.

Take for example this section of the Gleam website FAQ section:

https://gleam.run/frequently-asked-questions/#how-does-gleam...

"Elixir has better support for the OTP actor framework. Gleam has its own version of OTP which is type safe, but has a smaller feature set."

At least on the surface, "but has a smaller feature set" suggests that there are features left of the table: which I think it would be fair to read as a subset of support.

If I look at this statement from the Gleam OTP Library `readme.md`:

"Not all Erlang/OTP functionality is included in this library. Some is not possible to represent in a type safe way, so it is not included. Other features are still in development, such as further process supervision strategies."

That quote leaves the impression that OTP is not fully supported and therefore only a subset is. It doesn't expound further to say unsupported OTP functionality is alternatively available by accessing the Erlang modules/functions directly or through other mechanisms.

In all of this I'll take your word for it over the website and readme files; these things are often not written directly by the principals and are often not kept as up-to-date as you'd probably like. Still even taking that at face value, I think it leaves some questions open. What is meant by supporting all of OTP? Where the documentation and library readme equivocates to full OTP support, are there trade-offs? Is "usable as normal" usable as normal for Erlang or as normal for Gleam? For example, are the parts left out of the library available via directly accessing the Erlang modules/functions, but only at the cost of abandoning the Gleam type safety guarantees for those of Erlang? How does this hold for Gleam's JavaScript compilation target?

As you know, Elixir also provides for much OTP functionality via direct access to the Erlang libraries. However, there I expect the distinction between Elixir support and the Erlang functionality to be substantially more seamless than with Gleam: Elixir integrates the Erlang concepts of typing (etc.) much more directly than does Gleam. If, however, we're really talking about full OTP support in Gleam while not losing the reasons you might choose Gleam over Elixir or Erlang, which I think is mostly going to be about the static typing... then yes, I'm very wrong. If not... I could see how strictly speaking I'm wrong, but perhaps not completely wrong in spirit.

sbuttgereit··on I tried Gleam for Advent of Code
> For those that don't know its also built upon OTP, the erlang vm

This isn't correct. It can compile to run on the BEAM: that is the Erlang VM. OTP isn't the Erlang VM; rather, "OTP is set of Erlang libraries and design principles providing middle-ware to develop [concurrent/distributed/fault tolerant] systems."

Gleam itself provides what I believe is a substantial subset of OTP support via a library: https://github.com/gleam-lang/otp

Importantly: "Gleam has its own version of OTP which is type safe, but has a smaller feature set. [vs. Elixir, another BEAM language with OTP support]"

sbuttgereit··on America's betting craze has spread to its news networks
This is a new issue for sure, but what trust is left to erode in the first place?

We already are regularly asked to accept mere emotionally motivated opinion as information. Of course its relayed as "fact-based reporting", wrapped in mostly tidy narratives which wear the makeup of a journalistic endeavor. But look at which facts are amplified, suppressed, or omitted; or the adjectives used around the facts or which facts are only ever spoken by the journalists and which facts are allowed to be conveyed directly by the participants. Even the choice of which stories are newsworthy and which aren't plays a role.

Modern journalism is already largely a call to action for adopting a particular worldview rather than an effort to ensure that you have the best information in formulating opinions. The press, the government, and activists already have taken the stand that you are a fool that is better manipulated into "correct thinking" by your betters than left to your own devices.

Given all that, I would contend that most reporting is not there to inform you in the first place: its there to manipulate your emotions on a subject while convincing you that somehow you are now "informed". I would say under those circumstances that any trust that still exists in the media is already misplaced. The betting question is just another avenue exacerbating an already unreliable journalistic landscape.

sbuttgereit··on Is it a bubble?
I think your experience matches well with mine. There are certain workloads and use cases where these tools really do well and legitimately save time; these tend to be more concise tasks and well defined with good context from which to draw from. The wrong tasking and the results can be pretty bad and a time sink.

I think the difficulty is exercising the judgement to know where that productive boundary sits. That's more difficult than it sounds because we're not use to adjudicating machine reasoning which can appear human-like ... So we tend to treat it like a human which is, of course, an error.

sbuttgereit··on The closer we look at time, the stranger it gets
I think I like Tim Maudlin's approach to the question. Time isn't all that mysterious: it's simply fundamental meaning it cannot be explained has being the sum of some things more fundamental. The argument is that's where the difficulty lies for many is they want to express time as though it's a composite, and it just isn't. So the best you can do is explain time by referencing those other aspects of existence which incorporate time.

Here's a much longer take from Tim Maudlin, "Tim Maudlin: A Masterclass on the Philosophy of Time" (https://youtu.be/3riyyEmWwoY?si=9aI-bETWcNpdjMW9), Tim Maudlin is Professor of Philosophy at NYU and Founder and Director of the John Bell Institute for the Foundations of Physics. The podcast is Robinson Erhardt's.

sbuttgereit··on The closer we look at time, the stranger it gets
I guess I have to ask what more you're looking for, perhaps hoping for, than: 1 second per second?
sbuttgereit··on Homeschooling hits record numbers
You know, I'm relatively social and I don't even go to school let alone a public school! How do I manage it? I engage with social groups in other ways.

Homeschooling doesn't necessitate going into a dark room somewhere and closing/locking the door. Sure, some may do that... but majority simply don't. Suggesting that there aren't paths to good socialization outside of public school is just rationalizing a position and ignoring the reality that many home schoolers don't operate in isolation. We're a social species and we tend to seek out others. This is even true for homeschoolers who can collaborate or engage in all manner of social opportunities that exist amongst a coalition of homeschoolers or they can take advantage of the social activities which are available in most communities of any size. Again, we're social creatures and we'll give into that impulse. To suggest that has to be nurtured by a public institution or is somehow unavailable outside of a public school just isn't credible on its face.

As others have said all up and down the thread, you take measures to build that social circle and interaction. And I can tell you from direct personal experience... a public school offers positive interaction opportunities to some, but wholly negative and even damaging to others... public schools absolutely offer a social experience. Whether that's good or bad in my experience is at best a case-by-case call.

sbuttgereit··on California DMV approves map increase in Waymo driverless operations
More of the state is not allowed than is... at least by geography.

Also, there's a practical element. If I have to specify where they can't go, the default position is they can go anywhere... if I inadvertently leave an area out of my black-list where it really ought to exist: the default is "permission granted". With a white-list, the worst case is a forgotten or neglected area can't be operated in as a default and the AV provider will have an interest in correcting.

But also politics. It's a very different message to say we're going to white-list a given AV operator to exist in different areas vs. black-listing them from certain areas.

sbuttgereit··on Homeschooling hits record numbers
You think avoiding these things are why people are thinking about homeschooling?!

In San Francisco where I live the public school system made the decision to not offer algebra until later for egalitarian reasons. Basically since they couldn't bring up the students that faired poorly in math, they delayed the subject for everybody. Along the same lines, they took the one high school dedicated to the highest achieving students and turned it into a lottery system rather than something earned.

Yes, of course you're right, kids will be competing on all those subjects. But the idea that public institutions are somehow the safeguards of fundamental academic achievement is just out of touch.

Of course, San Francisco public school's embrace of socialist/egalitarian drive identity politics is just one example of public education failure. Elsewhere in the US in these times, other school districts are being turned effectively into seminaries because the other political side has other doctrinal objectives. In neither case is learning how to think or how the world really works is important.

sbuttgereit··on How Cops Are Using Flock's ALPR Network to Surveil Protesters and Activists
Yes, the "Damned if you don't" faction is polling well against the "Damned if you do" faction currently.

Either way, we're still just making a shit sandwich and arguing over the condiments.

sbuttgereit··on Republican push to make U.S. census surveys voluntary alarms statisticians
From the article...

"Language in a pending 2026 spending bill written by the Republican-led U.S. House of Representatives goes further. It would make both the ACS and the regular 10-year census voluntary, and would also prohibit the agency from reaching out more than once to anyone who doesn’t initially respond."

That text included a link to the bill: https://docs.house.gov/meetings/AP/AP00/20250910/118544/BILL...

From that bill I imagine they mean (page 146)

"SEC. 605. None of the funds in this Act may be used to enforce involuntary compliance, or to inquire more than twice for voluntary compliance with any survey conducted by the Bureau of the Census."

sbuttgereit··on Dissecting Flock Safety: The Cameras Tracking You Are a Security Nightmare [video]
This is the most serious effort I've seen:

https://ij.org/press-release/judge-rules-lawsuit-challenging...

Not exactly trying to get new legislation passed but working within the courts to set some boundaries.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →