HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sceptic123

337 karma · joined September 23, 2024

submissionscomments
sceptic123··on Nobody knows how the whole system works
You're not going to be any good for hunting, farming or keeping warm if you have the shits though.
sceptic123··on Nobody knows how the whole system works
The existential crisis part for me is that no-one (or not enough people) have the skills or knowledge required to do these things. Getting people to work together only works if some people have those skills to begin with.

I also wasn't putting the focus is on cooking, the ability to hunt/gather/grow enough food and keep yourself warm are far more important.

And you are far more optimistic about people than me if you think people working together is the likely scenario here.

sceptic123··on Nobody knows how the whole system works
Even as a collective whole, engineers will likely only understand the parts of system that are engineering problems and solutions. Even if they could understand it all, there is still no _one_ person who understands how everything works.
sceptic123··on Nobody knows how the whole system works
I read it more as:

We already don't know how everything works, AI is steering us towards a destination where there is more of the everything.

I would also add it's also possible it will reduce the number people that are _capable_ of understanding the parts it is responsible for.

sceptic123··on Nobody knows how the whole system works
I don't think they're saying _you_ can't do those things, just that most people can't which I have to agree with.

They're not saying people can't learn those things either, but that's the practice you're talking about here. The real question is, can you learn to do it before you starve or freeze to death? Or perhaps poison yourself because you ate something you shouldn't or cooked it badly.

sceptic123··on The world is more equal than you think
The original article is literally focusing on a single metric to make a wider point about inequality — does that mean you agree that it's not a valid way to analyse the data. Particularly if the conclusion doesn't seem to be borne out by actual studies in the area.
sceptic123··on The world is more equal than you think
> … the main household survey used to estimate consumption in the UK has a low sample size, and there appears to be a growing problem of undercoverage of expenditure … the fact that undercoverage has grown over time means that it is not clear whether the relatively modest recorded changes in consumption inequality since 1991 are genuine, or just due to an increased inability to pick up the expenditure of high-spending households.

From: https://academic.oup.com/ooec/article/3/Supplement_1/i103/74...

sceptic123··on The world is more equal than you think
You cherry picked a line and didn't include the rest:

> But the gains for middle‑ and lower‑income households were less than the gains for upper‑income households

And you're making claims that are only talking about income (where the evidence suggests that inequality is increasing) to suggest that people are better off.

Where is the evidence that "all income levels are doing better"?

sceptic123··on The world is more equal than you think
Seems like you need these kind of overly simplistic takes to get people to engage with this topic

No-one's interested in a detailed report: https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=wid.world

sceptic123··on The world is more equal than you think
Given that this is about "global consumption spending" my take is that the richest people are finding new ways to hide their expenditure.

Doesn't help when the source data is not available to better understand what the claims made here are actually based on.

sceptic123··on The world is more equal than you think
can you provide evidence?
sceptic123··on From Tobacco to Ultraprocessed Food: How Industry Fuels Preventable Disease
Are you ignoring the "mostly" in mostly plants?
sceptic123··on How to choose colors for your CLI applications (2023)
unless you're colour blind
sceptic123··on Why do RSS readers look like email clients?
Google Reader, mentioned once in the text but not really explored, was a different experience. I pretty much stopped using RSS when that went away. Every other reader would either mangle the experience or add a paywall.

It had a magic simplicity that could be summed up as: "without me doing anything, give me the next thing I want".

Similar story with Google Podcasts IIRC, none of the current ones work the way that did either.

sceptic123··on Director Gore Verbinski: Unreal Engine is the greatest slip backwards for movie
Was going to make a joke about your typo, but my heart wasn't in it
sceptic123··on The Overcomplexity of the Shadcn Radio Button
Interestingly Radix has both `Radio Group` and `Radio` — The simple `Radio` input does use `<input type="radio">` but the `Radio Group` does not. Git history does not show _why_ though.
sceptic123··on Ask HN: What are your best purchases under $100?
I make two cups in one Aeropress, am I doing it wrong?
sceptic123··on How did TVs get so cheap?
Does Android TV not come with spyware?
sceptic123··on Most websites don't need cookie consent banners
There's no _need_ to use cookies for tracking purposes though, it's usually just easier/cheaper/quicker (or requested by the marketing department) to use off the shelf software than actually spend the time to implement these things.

But if you have a cart, you need a cookie banner regardless of any tracking you are doing.

sceptic123··on enclose.horse
But if you remember the best score isn't that approach still possible?
sceptic123··on enclose.horse
But you have no idea what the optimal solution is, are you 1,10,50 away from it. Would be nice to have some indicator of how close you are before you submit, though I guess that's intentional.
sceptic123··on Are Apple gift cards safe to redeem?
When money is concerned, any kind of suspected money laundering / fraud investigation generally requires you to pause that account until the check is complete. What happens afterwards will be down to the results of the investigation.

It's also unlikely there are just those two states. For many services there will be a number of factors involved, but it's purposely opaque to make it harder to circumvent.

sceptic123··on Are Apple gift cards safe to redeem?
It may be simple enough to prove, but that is an uncomfortable ask if those circumstances are genuine.
sceptic123··on Pricing Changes for GitHub Actions
Why are the self-hosted plans so expensive? Such a high bar to go from free to paid.
sceptic123··on I'm a Tech Lead, and nobody listens to me. What should I do?
No need to answer this person's question, they are not asking for help, they are promoting their upcoming book
sceptic123··on Stop Breaking TLS
I would still say that is loose — are connection issues caused by staff using streaming services generally considered to be DoS?

And on balance I'd say losing Integrity is a bad trade off to make here.

sceptic123··on Getting a Gemini API key is an exercise in frustration
That's my point, you need to be a specialist to understand it, but the specialists are incentivised to upsell you.

A simpler product would be better for consumers, but won't happen because there are industries (and a lot of lobbying) built up around keeping the money train rolling.

sceptic123··on South Korea – A cautionary tale for the rest of humanity
To try to remove the word motherly there, your comment could be written as:

Most men are worse parents than most women.

Do you think that is a good representation of what you are saying? Do you think it's true? Are men inherently worse at parenting, or is there something else at play?

And I would also like to know what your evidence is for that.

sceptic123··on South Korea – A cautionary tale for the rest of humanity
Because we're not mice. Because he was actually studying the effects of overcrowding and not population growth & decline.

You'd need to look at more than just the population numbers, the issues were around high infant mortality and bad parenting, those are the things you should look out for over low birth rates.

sceptic123··on Getting a Gemini API key is an exercise in frustration
I thought thees things were complex on purpose to make it hard for people to easily understand and compare so you have to speak to a sales person who can do the upselling
← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →