HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

scoofy

6,393 karma · joined December 24, 2011

submissionscomments
scoofy··on A city-building game in which the city would prefer you didn't
I like that the game used real sites of building proposals. The "historic laundromat" is one I immediately spotted.
scoofy··on I would like the value of my home to rise, while my property taxes fall
Yea, the point of property taxes is to stop that from happening.

Austin has been begrudgingly growing up, not without a raft of complaints from locals, because the property taxes are high enough to make selling to a developer tempting. In return, Austin has remained relatively affordable in comparison to other tech hubs.

scoofy··on I would like the value of my home to rise, while my property taxes fall
I feel like people don't realize that this is how aristocracy happens.

Like, yea, property taxes suck... but the point is you're wealthy even if you want to pretend you're not. Passing the tax burden onto others, just because you can, is exactly how we end up in a world where wealthy landowners live like literally nobility while the people renting their land pay the taxes for their infrastructure.

scoofy··on Imposing Sanctions on the International Criminal Court
The hubris of the party machine being wielded to prevent a challenger to Biden was the problem. There were many of us screaming that a new candidate was necessary, but nobody listened. They stayed lock step in line with the party machine.

I voted for Dean Phillips in the primary. He was blackballed. Local party officials even tried to keep him of ballots.

It even got to the point where Ezra Klein was loudly complaining about what was happening, and even he was criticized.

If you want to understand why the Dems keep losing, you have to understand the party machine. Looking at how the Phillips campaign was treated, and the Sanders campaign before that, show exactly how someone can run on exactly the issues people care about but be shut down before it ever comes to a vote, because it harms the political interests of the higher ups in the party: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dean_Phillips#2024_presidentia...

The Democratic Party's electorate aren't really paying attention.

scoofy··on You're saving one minute and now I can't know if I'm talking a human
I have no idea if it’s spam or engagement farming. One of the messages was about how great my recent articles were and if I wanted to interview this guy to basically us my “podcast” as an advertisement for this guys vaguely related golf platform. Note: I don’t have a podcast.

Does he like my articles or does he have a spam agent emailing everyone writing about golf? I can’t know.

The other was like, a guy in the comments who was asking bizarre leading questions, basically trying to get me to explain how my product works, where if he’d actually read the series, I literally wrote an article about it. His account on the forum was just bizarre.

Maybe someone interested? Maybe an engagement bot. I literally can’t tell.

I agree shouting into the void isn’t particularly helpful, but if it’s happening now, we need to prepare for a future where nobody wants to communicate online anymore. I sure don’t want to.

scoofy··on You're saving one minute and now I can't know if I'm talking a human
I suspect there are just nontrivial amounts of people out there that do not consider the second-order effects of their actions.

I'm not even and LLM hater. I just really think that the interconnectedness of the internet has caused the death of etiquette, simply because there is no culture when every culture in the world is all participating all the time. Etiquette is useful, even when it's effectively arbitrary.

scoofy··on Peter Thiel's new Antichrist warnings
It's always a very short walk from "serious concern about religious prophesy" to "why is anyone taking this person seriously." The answer is, of course, huge piles of money.
scoofy··on California closed the Montana license plate loophole
I think that could be actually illegal. The fact that you can do it, and also avoid taxes is different than doing specifically to avoid taxes.
scoofy··on California closed the Montana license plate loophole
Why would there ever be a “no reason to assume evidence could be destroyed”?

The evidence of knowingly evading taxes is likely in encrypted text messages and emails that can be trivially destroyed.

scoofy··on California closed the Montana license plate loophole
No
scoofy··on Don't be fooled–LLMs don't reason
>Consciousness is the what-it's-like of sensation you have as an organism

>Each sentient organism has their own sensations

This does not follow besides feeling like it should.

scoofy··on Don't be fooled–LLMs don't reason
> Based on what?

Based on the face that we have zero explanation for consciousness. Based on the face that biologically neural networks are exactly a kind of neural network.

My point isn’t that we’re able to explain consciousness as an illusion. It’s that we’re able to explain consciousness-like behavior presumably without consciousness, and the infrastructure look uncomfortably like we do.

scoofy··on Don't be fooled–LLMs don't reason
Philosophy isn’t “western,” it’s reason. The “non-western” traditions you reference are effectively religious and are not based in rationality.
scoofy··on Don't be fooled–LLMs don't reason
I’m not so sure. While I completely agree on pure transformation, I continue to believe that the most concerning aspect of neural networks is that they really strengthen the argument that consciousness is the illusion.

The interplay between deductive frameworks and inductive frameworks is still always buoyed by the black swan problem… which is a the heart of Hume’s solipsism. Kant’s pure reason never considered instinctual logical gates that come prepackaged in the mind. That seems frighteningly close to a prediction algorithm, no matter how much we wrap it in a concept of understanding. In the end, we’re just building a model with a minimal error rate.

scoofy··on AI needs $6T in annual revenue to justify data centre boom
I wrote a golf simulator that helps visualize golf architecture with help from Gemini. When I published my first piece, I got an email from Tom Doak and the head of data science at Arccos. An absolutely insane response for my dumb blog. I was invited to the Renaissance Cup this year, almost certainly because of that post; golf nerds can tell you what a huge deal that is.

The blog post is here for anyone interested: https://golfcoursewiki.substack.com/p/i-spent-the-last-month...

Things are happening… and quickly, even if we are not quite to the point where VC’s are ready fund prototypes of robots to fold your laundry. Most of what’s happening is nerds finally building the project they’ve always dreamed of outside the traditional funding pathways.

scoofy··on California farmers are struggling to sell grapes as demand for wine drops
>The vast majority of people on this planet are teetotal.

A citation would be nice. The WHO seems to suggest this is incorrect: https://ourworldindata.org/alcohol-consumption

scoofy··on California farmers are struggling to sell grapes as demand for wine drops
Yes but if you look at, I dunno, the entire history of the human race, for some darn reason alcohol is strongly associated with socializing.

Maybe that's a coincidence though.

scoofy··on War may be coming. Are we psychologically ready?
Just leave it. There are so many Russian apologists on this forum it’s exhausting. You’d think the fact that Russia is in the middle of an unwise and unnecessary war of aggression wouldn’t itself be an argument for concerns of more attacks on NATO countries and allies.

But to prebut whataboutism, I also don’t like American imperialism.

scoofy··on Europe's summer drought is so extreme that desertification is a growing threat
This is not correct. LA gets its water from hundred of miles away. So does the Bay Area. So does the central valley.
scoofy··on Lake Ontario ("Lake America")
Mostly crying.
scoofy··on Europe's summer drought is so extreme that desertification is a growing threat
Trees that evolved to survive wildfires because of the near year-long dry periods.
scoofy··on Norway Shrugged (2024)
Most modern wealth alternative-minimum tax proposals allow individuals to effectively give the taxed percentage of the difficult to value asset to the state to be converted to a tax payment upon a liquidation event.

This is being used as a corner case to thwart wealth taxes that in the vast majority of cases involve well valued, liquid, publicly traded securities.

scoofy··on Europe's summer drought is so extreme that desertification is a growing threat
California is naturally a desert. It is only unnaturally green and lush.
scoofy··on Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
>Do not presume to understand other people's concerns based on one or two sentences.

Expecting to be taken seriously in a good-faith conversation while walking in throwing entirely unargued bombs like OP's comment is asinine. The idea that you should be able to skip the "arguing" part of an intellectual discussion because "I mean come on..." is the sentiment you hold is sophomoric bullshit. It doesn't care about truth, much less considering the person such a claim might actually be wrong.

scoofy··on Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
>The Economist pontificating about morality is like a vampire complaining blood tastes funny

This statement is no where close to a statement that matches your concerns. It implies “we all know the Economist is an inherently unserious rag… which it is obviously not.

scoofy··on Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
I don't think this kind of comment is helpful at all. We should treat these arguments on their merits, rather than with some ad hominum prejudice. If your (I presume anti-liberal) views are compelling, you wouldn't need to trot them out in as a flippant quip.

I would hope I didn't have to regurgitate that kind of basic intro to logic copy in a forum named after a combinatory logic.

scoofy··on Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
>The cogito argument is about thinking, not qualia.

I generally agree with the thrust of your argument -- the article is a mess and borderline unintelligible to this former philosophy postgraduate -- but I might nitpick this. Two points: (1) I do not think there is a substantial difference between whether the cogito is about thinking or perceiving. And (2) I'm not entirely sure the sensation that is thinking is independent from qualia.

I'm in less disagreement, but I'm not entirely sure what you mean by:

>Whether or not something is a moral patient (an entity worthy of consideration by moral agents) is independent of both human care and consciousness.

Moral frameworks are exactly deductive frameworks with arbitrary axioms. Like mathematics, they don't actually exist outside of a mind. Thus, I'm not entirely sure what "human care" means here, but absent humanity (or at least some conscious entity), I'm not sure any conception of morality is sensible.

---

An unrelated comment, but I just don't want to double post:

To me the most interesting thing to fall out of starting to understanding intelligence -- and we're definitely not there yet -- is that it is entirely possible that the 'consciousness is an illusion' argument ends up as significantly more serious. Ultimately, solipsism means it sort of doesn't matter, but it could be a kind of Darwin-style "we aren't special" result in thinking going forward.

scoofy··on The Hugging Face incident and the road ahead
I remember when Open AI was a not-for-profit trying to stop companies from doing exactly what the for-profit Open AI is doing now.

We live in the worst timeline.

scoofy··on U.S. State Department pauses immigrant visa applications
I’m not arguing policy here. My point is Trump is an absolutely terrible person who should be removed from office. It’s not the “I don’t like this policy” it’s “maybe do the policy without being an absurdly cruel person who treats others like garbage”
scoofy··on U.S. State Department pauses immigrant visa applications
Right, the point isn't that "Leave to renew" is some kind of horrible policy. Such bad-fucking-faith on display everywhere.

The point is maybe signal to people that we will soon be pausing all visa renewals so people who trivially have good jobs and good records know they ought to literally just plan on moving out of their apartment rather than have to deal with paying thousands of dollars to have someone else move their shit overseas, just to maybe get their visa renewed right when their shit arrives and they have to do the same thing all over again.

This would literally just helping law-abiding folks follow the law. But no, the cruelty is the point.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →