HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sdhgaiojfsa

662 karma · joined January 19, 2018

submissionscomments
sdhgaiojfsa··on Uber Self-Driving Car That Struck Pedestrian Wasn’t Set to Stop in an Emergency
They can't detect me slowing down before I start slowing down. So if it's t-4 until impact and I'm still moving at full speed, they would need to start braking now if they can't stop in 4s (assuming the worst case that I continue on my current trajectory).

That being said, I'm happy to find my assumptions about stopping time are incorrect and a car traveling at 25mph can stop in less than a second. So on busy NYC streets this wouldn't be an issue. Even at 50mph it appears that stopping time is sub 3s, so the vehicle could probably have avoided this collision if it were running a more intelligent program.

sdhgaiojfsa··on Uber Self-Driving Car That Struck Pedestrian Wasn’t Set to Stop in an Emergency
I don't know if you've been to New York or any other places where people walk, but vectors would absolutely be intersecting on a regular basis up until a fairly short time when the pedestrian would stop. Constantly I walk toward an intersection where, if I kept going for three more seconds, I would be pasted to the street by a passing car. But I stop at the end of the sidewalk, before the road begins, so the vector changes to zero in those last three seconds. It would be super weird if cars would brake at the intersection every time this happened. Cars would be braking at every major street on every major avenue, constantly.

What's actually needed here is some notion of whether the pedestrian is paying attention and will correctly stop and not intersect the path of the car. Humans are constantly making that assessment based on sometimes very subtle cues (is the person looking at/talking on a phone, or are they paying attention, for example).

sdhgaiojfsa··on Places in the U.S. Where Disaster Strikes Again and Again
That was not my takeaway. My takeaway was that these are places where no one is, and thus there is not a significant amount of damage.
sdhgaiojfsa··on Judge Rules Trump Can’t Block People on Twitter
Free speech rights apply to more than just those words one would say face to face.
sdhgaiojfsa··on Spend analysis of 6 years, 686 rides, and $12k spent on Uber (2017)
Big supporter of public transit, but this is apples to oranges. Nine times out of ten, the Uber is going to get you where you want to go a lot faster, unless embarkation and destination are both on the same public transit line.
sdhgaiojfsa··on Getting Google to ban our entire company
> It's insane . . .

Yes. So insane one suspects it may not be true.

sdhgaiojfsa··on I've Paid $18,000 to a $24,000 Student Loan, and I Still Owe $24,000
> The government could certainly choose to subsidize those students explicitly by providing loans on better terms itself. It's not like there are no other solutions.

Sorry if I gave the impression that I was trying to exhaustively enumerate the solution space. I was not! Thanks for the discussion.

sdhgaiojfsa··on I've Paid $18,000 to a $24,000 Student Loan, and I Still Owe $24,000
> A useful statement would be saying that by making it very difficult to discharge loans in bankruptcy (under certain specific terms), the number of loans increased by 15% and the terms changed by blah blah.

I'm afraid I don't have enough information to make such a specific statement. :(

> Yet you don't want to revisit why the government is effectively subsidizing them by removing their risk?

I don't object to the government stopping their subsidy. I'm just saying what I expect the result to be: either loans would stop being issued overall, or they would only be issued to certain majors, which the public would find unacceptable.

sdhgaiojfsa··on I've Paid $18,000 to a $24,000 Student Loan, and I Still Owe $24,000
I wouldn't say I am firmly against this approach, but I do feel that if you have that sort of system, you probably need some control over the types of studies that people can engage in. This is a somewhat unpopular opinion most places, but I do think it's possible for a major to be more or less useful to society. I think that (broad strokes) that is reflected by compensation and/or demand for the services offered by graduates of a given major (teachers and social workers notwithstanding). I think in general it's in the best interests of society to limit the number of people studying unproductive subjects.
sdhgaiojfsa··on I've Paid $18,000 to a $24,000 Student Loan, and I Still Owe $24,000
> Well, maybe it would have been better this way.

I don't deny it. There are considerations in both directions. You could also imagine a system of universal rate setting, where you can only offer loans to potential engineers if you do so to art students as well. You could imagine genuinely allowing a free market in student loans. There are a lot of possibilities, each of which would fall at different places on the multi-dimensional optimization problem that we've got in front of us.

But I argue that if you want folks to offer student loans, and don't want lenders to discriminate against certain majors, and don't want interest rates >10%, and want principles on the order of >$100k, you probably need to prevent discharging the loan in bankruptcy. You can't get all those other things and dischargeable loans at the same time.

sdhgaiojfsa··on I've Paid $18,000 to a $24,000 Student Loan, and I Still Owe $24,000
> This is literally an extremist statement (i.e. either you cannot get loans or you can) and as such an impossible oversimplification.

I find that most times when people say, "You cannot," or, "You can," what they're actually saying is, "The probability of you being able to is very low/very high." Surely this is the case for my claim. If it helps, please read it as such.

> Students received loans before they couldn't be discharged in bankruptcy.

Other variables were different then. Particularly, the variables of cost and expected compensation relative to the baseline. (Cost has, infamously, been rising, while the expected compensation of graduates relative to the baseline has been falling.) You may be right that under current circumstances banks would be equally willing to lend. That strikes me as absurd, but I've been wrong before. Shall we roll the dice and find out?

sdhgaiojfsa··on I've Paid $18,000 to a $24,000 Student Loan, and I Still Owe $24,000
In most other countries, student loans aren't even a thing, because university is subsidized to the extent that it is free or relatively inexpensive. The size of the bet is absolutely integral to whether giving the loan makes sense, because it affects the benefit of discharging the loan. If you're saying, "We should make uni cheap or free, and also make loans dischargable," well, sure, but now you're talking about changing a lot of variables rather than just one, and correspondingly increasing the difficulty of reform.
sdhgaiojfsa··on I've Paid $18,000 to a $24,000 Student Loan, and I Still Owe $24,000
We've been over this a thousand times: you would not be able to get loans for education if you could discharge them in bankruptcy. They would become a super-toxic bet. They would have to be conditioned on the ability of the student to make significant earnings, because otherwise the optimal play for many people would be to get the education, and then declare bankruptcy.
sdhgaiojfsa··on Why a Dutch court stopped high school students from swapping schools (2017)
Generally speaking, we're not trying to reduce random factors. We're trying to reduce hereditary factors. There are already plenty of intrinsic hereditary factors (intelligence, appearance, health). We want to limit the ability of extrinsic hereditary factors (wealth, connections) to influence egalitarian processes, and in some cases even correct for them.
sdhgaiojfsa··on Does Clean Laundry Have Germs?
Nobody knows the answer to these questions, and I'd question anyone who represents that they do. "Some time." "Maybe." "Somewhat, perhaps."

It would probably be wise for you to increase your washing frequency, nevertheless.

sdhgaiojfsa··on Does Clean Laundry Have Germs?
Don't most washing machines plug into a 240V circuit?
sdhgaiojfsa··on Tesla CEO Musk Says Company Is Flattening Management Structure in Reorganization
In a way that paywalls don't? I doubt it.
sdhgaiojfsa··on Tech Breakthroughs That Could Make People Love the Bus
The idea of a trackless train also appeals. If they had a separate right of way and could get integration with the stoplights the analogy could be extended in terms of utility as well.
sdhgaiojfsa··on NYC Renters Paid Extra $616M Thanks to Airbnb, Study Says
All passive investing is rent seeking under that interpretation of that sentence.
sdhgaiojfsa··on NYC Renters Paid Extra $616M Thanks to Airbnb, Study Says
I'm not commenting on the validity of the policy, only one whether rent-seeking is the correct term to describe lending one's property out on AirBnb.
sdhgaiojfsa··on NYC Renters Paid Extra $616M Thanks to Airbnb, Study Says
No, that is not the definition of rent seeking. The definition of rent seeking is:

"In economics and in public-choice theory, rent-seeking involves seeking to increase one's share of existing wealth without creating new wealth."

An example of rent-seeking would be lobbying against the construction of new housing to inflate the value of one's own home. A non-example of rent-seeking would be renting your house out to someone else. More from Wikipedia/economics 101:

"Rent-seeking is distinguished in theory from profit-seeking, in which entities seek to extract value by engaging in mutually beneficial transactions . . ." such as a transaction between a property owner and someone seeking to rent that property for temporary use.

sdhgaiojfsa··on Future sailors: what will ships look like in 30 years?
Anticipated by Paolo Bacigalupi in Ship Breaker. Great book if you're looking for some semi-dystopian SF.
sdhgaiojfsa··on NYC Renters Paid Extra $616M Thanks to Airbnb, Study Says
This is not what people traditionally think of as "rent-seeking." Rent-seeking behavior is doing something to get more money without providing any corresponding value. AirBnb hosts do provide value -- just not to the people who live in the neighborhood. But it is fine to argue that, based on their willingness to pay more, out of town visitors provide better utilization of the housing resource.

TL;DR: Extracting rents from things you own by providing economic value to a customer is not "rent-seeking."

sdhgaiojfsa··on Tesla is hit by $2B patent troll case from Nikola Motors
I think, for most people, the damages are all that matter. Whether you are theoretically infringing on something is not what you lose sleep at night over. It's whether you're going to be sued and lose a lot of money.
sdhgaiojfsa··on The Era of Very Low Inflation and Interest Rates May Be Near an End
Sure. I was only responding to the New York part.
sdhgaiojfsa··on The Era of Very Low Inflation and Interest Rates May Be Near an End
NY Case Schiller home price index is flat to slightly down over that period, actually. This is for the NYC metro area. I could be convinced that rent has doubled with housing price flat, but I'm guessing not?

https://us.spindices.com/indices/real-estate/sp-corelogic-ca...

sdhgaiojfsa··on High-Paying Trade Jobs Sit Empty, While High School Grads Line Up for University
For a 20 year old guy? What do you think people get paid?? :)

The median HH income in the US is 60k/y. So he is almost making the median, and that's as a newbie, and with no partner. If he had a partner making minimum wage, he'd be over the median. After he gets a few more years of experience, he'll be over the median. Yeah, I'd say that's pretty good.

sdhgaiojfsa··on Google's “Director of Engineering” Hiring Test (2016)
> OK, but incorrect/inflexible quizzing about tech questions is inappropriate full stop. If this was an interview for SWE summer intern it'd be a badly-run interview.

I would not ask the questions listed in this interview. But, I'm not a recruiter. I think it's safe to say that the average recruiter has a better understanding of their objectives and constraints than I do, and is better able to judge what types of questions to ask during an initial screen than I am. Those questions may not be optimize for the same thing any given candidate is optimizing for.

> You can't ensure that there will be no hurt feelings ever, but ideally the candidates you fail don't go around talking about how poor your interview process is.

People in the original thread in 2016 said much the same, arguing that people would no longer want to work for Google. It's 2018 and Google is still not having any trouble attracting engineering talent. Seems like offering high salaries and interesting work matters a lot more to the average candidate than whether the prescreen has a view suboptimal questions.

sdhgaiojfsa··on Don’t buy the MacBook Pros even on sale, in my opinion
I try to keep spares of anything mission critical. I get that computers are expensive, but you owe it to yourself to make sure that your productivity cannot be broken by a single object's destruction or absence.

(That doesn't mean you need a spare new macbook pro. An older device that is maintained, and a good environment setup process, is sufficient.)

sdhgaiojfsa··on Top Senate Democrat Endorses Decriminalizing Marijuana at the Federal Level
Some Republicans at the federal level want to stay out of the way. I don't see any evidence that the fraction is most. If most wanted it, it would be done.
← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →