HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

seanclayton

504 karma · joined December 30, 2015

submissionscomments
seanclayton··on Ask HN: Alternatives to GitHub
Which is exactly why I started donating!
seanclayton··on Gloomberb
They're too busy dealing with their fake life problems to think about their impact on the world.
seanclayton··on What sort of maths are LLMs good at?
Why not have AGI check other AGI? Peer review by fellow humans is what gives humans assurance, to the degree in which review was done by peers of equal or greater intelligence.

AGI checking other AGI should give you that same trust, no? Deepseek says my ChatGPT bridge is stable, you should trust it. Claude says it's stable. The humans say it isn't, but they aren't AGI. You can trust this bridge because it's been vetted by AGI. In my opinion, LLMs cannot be AGI, so for me I would never trust them above any human I would trust. But for those who do believe LLMs can be AGI, they have to demonstrate why we should trust them above any human in these extreme cases. Meaning, if someone says "Well the department of safety (ran by humans) says it's not safe" we have to believe that AGI just knows better than the department of safety. I think this is not possible right now, which is why I don't think we can trust anything built by LLMs where we need the tolerance of risk to human life and safety to approach zero. American AGI soldiers invade the home of Iranian citizens because they have been identified as terrorists. Do you trust the AGI to know if the visual scan they see in this civilian home is a threat to the interests of the United States government and its citizens?

seanclayton··on What sort of maths are LLMs good at?
Would you trust a bridge built by it with zero human interference? A train? A plane? A skyscraper? What about fight in a war? Unless you can, I wouldn't consider it AGI, because you're actually trusting human intelligence to verify the bridge or train or plane or skyscraper is safe or that the robot is following orders. And even then, you're trusting human-influenced guardrails etc. I would consider it AGI when an AI-created LLM can do all of these things and you trust them with your children's lives. Would you trust an AGI cop to protect your children from a violent criminal? Unless you can, believing what we have as AGI is just an empty opinion with no meaning behind it.
seanclayton··on I don't recommend Tailwind CSS
My constraint is "use vanilla CSS" ;) I made a huge solo project in tailwind. Never again. Vanilla CSS is perfectly fine for my own uses. In fact, I've gone a whole 'no classes' style and used as much semantic HTML and modern CSS and can get extremely far. No more looking into the tailwind docs to learn its syntax on a modern vanilla CSS feature that I've been waiting for.
seanclayton··on I'm 38 and I Can't Support Myself Anymore
Tribes aren't the nuclear family. The nuclear family lives separate from the tribe.
seanclayton··on I'm 38 and I Can't Support Myself Anymore
Not really relevant at all
seanclayton··on I'm 38 and I Can't Support Myself Anymore
The nuclear family lived separate from the extended family. In separate cities. This is a new thing. You lived with your clan in history, not apart. The nuclear family is completely separated physically from their extended families, even across village lines.
seanclayton··on How is the Bun rewrite in Rust going?
Sorry, billion dollar language machines. My bad on the number of zeroes.
seanclayton··on I'm 38 and I Can't Support Myself Anymore
> I don't agree with railing against capitalism either

I say we should all give it a shot. Capitalism has had its time to prove its value and its report card has left too many wanting. I think now is a good as time as any to re-evaluate alternatives to capitalism and its overwhelming role within our societies.

When a machine breaks, the best engineers find out what's wrong and fix it, no matter how many political feelings it hurts and what theories are shattered along the way. Chernobyl is a great show, btw.

seanclayton··on I'm 38 and I Can't Support Myself Anymore
We could make virtually infinite food as well, but that isn't profitable enough.
seanclayton··on I'm 38 and I Can't Support Myself Anymore
> throughout history

Ancient egypt? Roman times? Medieval times? Byzantine times? Pre-colonial Philippines? Pre-colonial America?

I think it may have started in the late 1800s at the earliest. I would need a bit more evidence to be convinced that your model of individual to nuclear to extended etc has been a thing longer than a few centuries, vs the vast majority of human life experience being in nomadic hunter-gathering, villages, farmland, and walled city-states. We just had clans which were all our family. A fellow villager wasn't much different than a cousin. The individual and nuclear family, not so much a thing.

seanclayton··on How is the Bun rewrite in Rust going?
If a machine made to do language things in this day and age having trillions of dollars invested in doing language, I am not shocked at all that a trillion dollar language machine translates programming languages. It really is not surprising to me. I'd be surprised if a trillion dollar language machine doesn't do as fundamental a linguistic capability as translation. It's like being shocked that a language machine spews out language? What else does a language machine do?

A calculator that can find all primes will be cool. A language machine that translates english into JavaScript is cool. A language machine that translates Zig into Rust is cool. Language machines are cool, not awe-inspiring or surprising to me.

seanclayton··on How is the Bun rewrite in Rust going?
A human doing it is impressive. A human performing many computations a computer could do would be impressive. I don't get impressed when a computer computes a number. A language machine translating is just... doing what a language machine does? When a language machine starts doing something other than translation, I will be impressed. If computers starting singing without any human intervention, for example, would be incredible! C3PO knows many languages—he may know Rust and Zig. C3PO translating from Zig to Rust isn't surprising to me. Sounds par the course for a robot who knows languages.
seanclayton··on Codeberg bans vibe coded projects
Using any AI code is a risk of ban on codeberg. Just write it yourself and no one can say it's written by AI.
seanclayton··on Codeberg Divides
> The Open Source world needs to figure out how to engage with that future

How ironic. Why is the burden of labor on the open source community? They have to do more volunteer work for your AI satisfaction, even after training the very models you depend on? I think proponents of AI are the ones who have the burden of figuring out how to engage with the open source community. Use your own tokens to figure it out. Surely AI is up to the task. Your frontier models have the entirety of human diplomacy at its fingertips to steer you towards the path of success. I wish you luck.

seanclayton··on Topcoat: The full full-stack framework for Rust
Back in my day 'batteries-included' at least included schemas/models and a database abstraction. Claude can whip one up quick!
seanclayton··on Grok Build is open source
> local models might

That was yesterday's "LLMs might". Time passes. Nothing stays the same. "Local models might" X Y or Z today has no influence on the limitations of tomorrow's local models except to remove them. Yesterday's LLMs are the exact same thing, except your computer is connected to their local model for you to use.

Disc drives used to be measured in megabytes—now in terabytes. Technically useful tend to get more optimized with time, not less.

seanclayton··on Grok Build is open source
Why when they can just fork it and improve it on their own with AI?
seanclayton··on Stripe and Advent have made a joint offer to acquire PayPal – sources
How else would you accept credit card payments on your website? Who are the competitors you would reach for?
seanclayton··on Show HN: Fast, native Mac file manager (filters, fuzzy find, 9 MB, no Electron)
Do you have any kind of public AI statement on the ways this product utilizes or is built with generative AI, if any?
seanclayton··on Learning to code is still worthwhile
Who in the world has time to learn how to code? Who has that much copious free time when they're working two jobs?
seanclayton··on Zuckerberg 'Admits' Meta's Layoffs Were Ineffective
Killing has existed since the dawn of life. Heck, single celled organisms 'kill'. It makes sense for that to be a globally-recognized sentiment. You make a grand claim when you think that in 50 years that 'all forms of AI is bad' will become an equally globally-recognized sentiment as 'all forms of unjustified killing is bad'.

I doubt it. Why do you believe it's possible?

seanclayton··on Zuckerberg 'Admits' Meta's Layoffs Were Ineffective
What is a globally accepted sentiment found in every nation, tribe, village, and domicile across the globe today?
seanclayton··on Vite+ Beta
a single tool was the enabler of enjoyment? It seems enjoyment is a fleeting thing these days if that's the case
seanclayton··on Google loses fight over record $4.7B EU antitrust fine
The people of CNBC's audience are assumed to have reason to want Google to not lose the case. Major news outlets are biased towards capital holders. This is what journalism looks like when it speaks to its intended audience.
seanclayton··on Godot will no longer accept AI-authored code contributions
> I can't think of a functional reason for a no-AI policy

There are functional reasons for a no-AI policy. It helps the Godot Foundation function to establish a no-AI policy. Do you argue it doesn't help them function?

Do you understand the difference between functional and non-functional?

seanclayton··on Godot will no longer accept AI-authored code contributions
> I can't

That makes much more sense now. The inability is completely on you, and you admit it at least.

seanclayton··on Free the Icons
Custom, free-shaped icons are too costly. Much more economical to have a square. It will never happen, unfortunately.
seanclayton··on Knoppix
I was maybe 9 years old when I first used Linux, and it was with Knoppix and KDE. Loved early plasma. Arch is my thing these days, but KDE is still my DE of choice. Glad to see KHTML from Konquerer living in Blink and WebKit these days, too!
← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →