HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

seanharper

256 karma · joined May 8, 2009

submissionscomments
seanharper··on Poll: How do you bill recurring payments?
Clarification -- as a gateway providers like Braintree, Linkpoint/FDGG, Auth.net, etc are perfectly fine, but their recurring functionality is not robust enough for most subscription or metered businesses. I must have written this before my coffee or something.

Sorry Bryan.

seanharper··on Poll: How do you bill recurring payments?
These results are very biased by the early-adopters that frequent hackernews.

There are WAY more people out there are using the recurring functionality of the gateways (ex. Auth.net, Braintree, Linkpoint / First Data Global Gateway) than one of the standalone recurring billing systems (recurly, chargify, etc).

However using those legacy solutions is a SHAME because they are in general quite horrible. They are certainly cheaper, and may seem like the path of least resistance, but they don't do the job well enough for serious companies.

You want something like Recurly, Chargify, Zuora, CheddarGetter, if you are doing either recurring or metered charging of your customers. It will make your life easier and is worth the expense.

seanharper··on Ask HN: Share your experience with a non YC or Techstars incubator.
Excelerate is good, most of the companies have raised money as a result.
seanharper··on Chargify New Pricing
The recurring payments capabilities of gateways, such as Braintree, Auth.net, etc. typically are not as robust as the recurring payments capabilities of the companies that specifically focused on that capability such as Chargify, Recurly, Zuora, etc.

If you just need to charge the same customers exactly the same amount on exactly the same timeframe, then the capabilities of gateways such as Braintree may be ok for you.

But typically SaaS companies and others with multiple plans, additions, features, extra one time payments, etc. need an additional layer of logic on top of those capabilities. You can either buy that logic or pay Chargify, et al for it.

seanharper··on Ask HN: How much do founders pay themselves?
I think 30% discount to what you would take in the open market.
seanharper··on [dead]
interchange is complicated!!
seanharper··on Square vs. Merchant Account Comparison Calculator
SMARTASS! :) Fair enough - that is admittedly not at all mathematically correct and we should have chosen a different way to graphically show which side was "winning". You got us - questionable design decision.
seanharper··on Square vs. Merchant Account Comparison Calculator
I was one of the guys that wrote it - it's not BS - its just a random starting point. Most people play with the bars to try a few different scenarios.
seanharper··on Square vs. Merchant Account Comparison Calculator
I think lots of people are waiting and they have come up with a few versions of them. They have been silent for a while but rumors are that they are working on something awesome.
seanharper··on Square vs. Merchant Account Comparison Calculator
Probably. ;) The whole point of making these things is because they are fun to show off and potentially useful to other people.

No sense in building something useful and not telling people about it.

seanharper··on PayPal Upgrade Calculator
The average monthly fee (including gateway) on the transfs marketplace is $16 / month, which is included in the calculation (try putting the volume slider to $0). Likewise, Paypal Pro (which you need if you want to accept payment without sending the user off-site) has a $30 / month fixed fee.

Of course there are certainly crooked merchant account providers that will hose you with bigger monthly fees, so it pays to be careful. The last thing a startup needs is extra fees.

seanharper··on PayPal Upgrade Calculator
Yah, getting a merchant account is a pain in the butt, but I think you are overstating it a little. The jury is out on whether merchant accounts or paypal have more onerous reserves.

There is a wide ecosystem of payment processors that like to sign up startup ecommerce businesses. Note, your local bank isn't included in that group, they probably won't want you as a customer.

If you use tokenization or recurring transactions and don't store the card data on your local server (same situation as paypal, btw) PCI requirements are very minimal and won't cost you anywhere near $2k.

seanharper··on PayPal Upgrade Calculator
Actually its not misleading. That 1.9% interchange fee is a blended average of the interchange fees that an online business is likely to encounter, including debit (which is less than 1.9%), standard credit (less than 1.9%) and rewards (more than 1.9%) and business (more than 1.9%). Its a reliable estimate based on a huge database of transaction history. In the "More info" we give you the ability to modify the assumptions and see the result.

Amex is a non-issue since it costs online businesses the same 3.5% whether you use paypal or not (note - this is new as of next week, previously Paypal always gave you the ordinary 2.2% rate for Amex and lost money doing it).

Paypal is a very competitively priced product, for a lot of transaction profiles it is cheaper than a traditional merchant account + gateway.

If you get a shitty deal on your merchant account then Paypal will always be cheaper.

seanharper··on PayPal Upgrade Calculator
This says "paypal upgrade calculator", which makes it sound more biased than it really is - it's actually a very fair comparison.
seanharper··on Need to process payments?
Chargify and Cheddargetter and Recurly are competitors and their products are pretty similar. I cannot speak to their specific benefits and disadvantages.
seanharper··on Need to process payments?
The issue that you describe where your prior merchant account provider billed you a downgrade rate for 90% of your transactions isn't really because they were "high-risk" (they weren't, you have no downgrades). It's an example of "marking up the downgrades" which is a strategy that unscrupulous merchant account providers use to increase their profit. http://transfs.com/blog/marking-up-downgrades/

What they really mean is that the interchange rate that your transaction qualified for is worse than the rate that they set to be your default or "qualified" rate. http://transfs.com/blog/what-is-interchange-again/

These billing tiers are a problem because there is no standard on what is "qualified" and what is "unqualified", it varies between processors and between customers within the same processor. http://transfs.com/blog/tiered-pricing-for-merchant-accounts...

There is a way to solve those billing tier ambiguities (which never are in the favor of the businessowner) - its called interchange plus pricing. Insist upon it, every processor can do it, for any size business.

Basically interchange is the wholesale rate that visa/mc charge the processor. In an interchange-plus pricing scheme the processor pass those charges on to you and explicitly disclose the markup you are paying above that wholesale rate. It's the best way to ensure no funny business is going on with your rates - http://transfs.com/blog/why-you-should-want-interchange-plus...

Only accept interchange plus or a no-downgrade flat percentage (like Paypal offers) - it will save you money and aggravation.

seanharper··on Need to process payments?
This is a shameless plug, but at http://transfs.com (transparent financial services) we have a free webservice that helps you compare various payments options.

It's strictly private and requires no commitment of any kind. Basically it's like Kayak for payments.

However, we don't do international yet, so probably can't help the original poster. International payments are really hard, there are many fewer options in most foreign countries.

Even in Canada and UK the number of merchant account providers is many fewer than in the US, giving the customer less choice and enabling the providers to maintain more of their archaic practices.

seanharper··on Greenspun: Let's stop investing in our kids
I paid out the ass for my undergrad and graduate degrees, for neither was the primary benefit economic.

What is the ROI on reading literature, or listening to music, or doing puzzles or making art?

He is right, though, education has inflated at a ridiculous rate, it is a giant bubble, in part fueled by cheap debt.

For those of us that spend most of our income on education and also live in hip urban areas that have seen so much inflation in real estate, our overall inflation rate has been >10% / year for the past decade.

seanharper··on Why are the east of cities usually poorer?
I would appreciate some evidence for whether that is actually true. Chicago and Milwaukee are both examples in the midwest for which that is not true - the east side is the nicest, very valuable waterfront property.
seanharper··on Introduction To Online Payments - TL;DR: It's A Total Bitch
Why not just do an ACH transaction? ACH is problematic because it is not very secure, but for subscription software can be a good solution since there is no cost of goods.
seanharper··on Introduction To Online Payments - TL;DR: It's A Total Bitch
Paypal has a pretty high per-item fee of 0.30 / transaction and a reasonably low (and fixed!!) percentage fee of 2.2%-2.9%.

Therefore, if you have an abnormally large average transactions size OR get paid mostly by other businesses, with their business cards OR have an abnormally large share of amex transactions, paypal will be more appealing from a cost perspective than it otherwise would be.

At TransFS.com we include them in the auction results because the answer of how paypal compares in price is actually different depending on your situation.

seanharper··on Introduction To Online Payments - TL;DR: It's A Total Bitch
Offsite checkout has a bad reputation for decreasing conversion rate. It would be interesting to have a really scientific a/b test, but the results will also differ between different customer bases.
seanharper··on Introduction To Online Payments - TL;DR: It's A Total Bitch
There are two philosophies:

1. Hire one provider, an expert, to handle everything for you - the merchant account, your billing logic (ex. recurring billing) and the payment gateway.

2. Get the best in breed for each layer in the stack. The Chargify/Recurly/Cheddargetter set is working to be the best in class at handling billing logic. For most online services the billing logic is quite complicated (and gets increasingly complicated over time) and something that the majority of merchant account providers / gateways are not historically good at handling.

seanharper··on Ask HN: Making money during college?
Supervise a computer lab, that was the best gig ever, i made $12 / hour (8 years ago) and could do homework and write code while I was working. It was a lot of fun too.
seanharper··on Ask HN: Merchant account and payment gateway for subscription-based web apps?
Braintree seem like good people, I went to grad school with Brian and he is sharp and seems honest.

I am really curious about how you compared the CHASE paymentech deal with the Braintree deal. Were they interchange-plus rates? Or were they qualified / midqualified / nonqualified? Did you know how the categories compared to each other?

Disclaimer - I have a startup in the space (transfs) so this is market research for me. :)

← PreviousPage 2 of 2