HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

seaorg

172 karma · joined June 3, 2021

submissionscomments
seaorg··on DeepMind says reinforcement learning is ‘enough’ to reach general AI
Yes, programs are Turing machines that use memory. I’m a little insulted. No method of containment is good enough for something like that. But we agree that sandboxing as a basis to claim that AGI won’t be a danger is totally unsound.
seaorg··on DeepMind says reinforcement learning is ‘enough’ to reach general AI
The entire sandbox thing is foolish. Obviously it won’t be sandboxed anyway because of what you’ve pointed out. But any sandbox we design won’t be good enough.

GTP is not supposed to exist according to computer science and machine learning experts in 2017. They were all wrong. Same with deep dream, styleGAN. And it will be true with the next thing.

The mental gymnastics refers to the fact that people have cognitive dissonance about GTP. They have amnesia about the decades of stagnant progress in text generation. All anyone can do is point out that it’s definitely not sentient and it’s not AGI so what’s the big deal? All of a sudden the goal posts have been moved… this is the single biggest quantum leap in text generation ever, a mind-boggling level of lucidity with grammar, punctuation and more all without ever being given a single deliberate instruction from a human being. It is objectively amazing. Objectively. And people have no reaction. Because they are not emotionally ready for it. It’s cognitive dissonance, mental gymnastics, whatever you want to call it.

seaorg··on DeepMind says reinforcement learning is ‘enough’ to reach general AI
The layman and the AI expert have both written off the possibility of creating AGI for the entirety of this latest AI spring. In the past decade I have basically never encountered anyone who thought that AGI was going to happen in our lifetimes or even anyone who believed that it would be a problem if it did.

One time I discussed AGI with a good friend. And I gently pressured him to play through the scenario of the advent of AGI. And he made a guilty confession to me. I could tell he was embarrassed to share his opinion. He said “can’t we just unplug it?” This is a microcosm of the entire issue. It’s something a child might say. For global warming, can’t we just turn on the air conditioning? No, we can’t just unplug it.

Here is how you can understand what is happening. An AI model is just a program. A program that is written by another program.

Consider a list of programs that contains every possible program. It is infinite. Make it finite by limiting the size of the programs based on some practical consideration. It’s still a very long list.

What is in this list? Pong. StyleGAN. AGI? Almost certainly. How small might AGI be? It probably appears more than once on the list — how many are there? But let’s ask the real question here and boil this down. How many items on the list are something we will regret having discovered? A great, great many.

Every day, people are exploring the list. They are using primitive methods to sift through all these programs and find the ones that have interesting behavior. The process of program discovery is automated with things called “training algorithms.” As our computers get faster and capital allocation grows larger we mine this list more and more quickly. The problem is that we keep finding things that surprise us. And that is the core and substance of the entire issue. We have demonstrated to ourselves over and over again that our own intuition about the contents of this list is completely wrong. Despite the mind-boggling level of mental gymnastics performed in the wake of GTP-3, enough to constitute a three ring circus, the fact of the matter is that GTP-3 and soon to be 4 is not supposed to exist according to every single AI expert. Compute is only getting cheaper and capital is only getting bigger and the list is only getting shorter and it’s not going to stop surprising everyone including the “experts.” Just because we don’t know how to make something we will truly regret doesn’t mean we aren’t capable of creating it.

seaorg··on A walk in nature is better than microdosing
Microdosing is important for people in Kansas and Mars.
seaorg··on Frozen in Siberian Permafrost for 24,000 Years, Microscopic Animal Comes to Life
This is wild. Absolutely wild. And I think it says a lot about what we might find on Mars. The only thing cooler than reviving an ancient microorganism is reviving an ancient Martian life form.
seaorg··on The Human Body in Space: Distinguishing Fact from Fiction (2013)
What’s the minimum radius?
seaorg··on The Human Body in Space: Distinguishing Fact from Fiction (2013)
Actually, assemble multiple water-filled cylinders in earth orbit and then put those in staggered cycle orbits. Power requirements are low so all you’d need is a regular engine with a large fuel tank.

Once those are in cycle orbit you now have giant water cylinders that you can catch every once in a while to ride to earth/Mars. Forever. With a tiny energy budget for corrections. Just wait till one passes by and slip your vessel inside it. Man I am good.

seaorg··on The Human Body in Space: Distinguishing Fact from Fiction (2013)
It’s just money.
seaorg··on The Human Body in Space: Distinguishing Fact from Fiction (2013)
Multiple launches. Assemble and fuel a big spinning water bottle in orbit. Maybe tether maybe not. Spin up and establish cycle orbit. Done. Basic physics and orbital mechanics.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_cycler

seaorg··on The Human Body in Space: Distinguishing Fact from Fiction (2013)
You should learn basic physics before you presume to know it...

It’s not a question of power. You could could get it spinning quickly or slowly with high or low power respectively but the question you are trying to ask it how much energy is required. The amount of energy to get the thing spinning is the same no matter what. And once you get it spinning, you’re done. It will keep spinning. I think there is a certain law that pertains to that. Something to do with fig newtons.

The amount of energy that is required is trivial compared to the other energy budgets. And it would be spun up at low power over the course of hours or days.

seaorg··on The Human Body in Space: Distinguishing Fact from Fiction (2013)
I’m not a Scientologist.
seaorg··on The Human Body in Space: Distinguishing Fact from Fiction (2013)
The problem isn’t the smart people who look at these problems. It’s the collective behavior of the masses to have amnesia about basic physics.
seaorg··on The Human Body in Space: Distinguishing Fact from Fiction (2013)
Imagine if they tried to cram a bunch of people in a literal metal tube with no windows and send them to the bottom of the ocean for months as a time. How could anyone be stupid enough to think that would work?
seaorg··on The Human Body in Space: Distinguishing Fact from Fiction (2013)
Make the transit ship spin. Surround the habitable parts with water and other materials. It’s so simple but nobody seems to be aware that these are solved problems.
← PreviousPage 3 of 3