HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sebastian_io

96 karma · joined January 30, 2021

submissionscomments
sebastian_io··on SnowFS – a fast, scalable version control file storage for graphic files
Thanks for listing out the points you disagree with! The project is still in early alpha, so is the Readme. Therefore anything that is ambiguous or not clear, is worth to address.

The main requirement is performance (a missing point in your list). If Git would be a good candidate as a versioning system for DCC software packages, it would have been picked up by now, but it didn't happen, among others because of the reasons listed above. Git addresses a completely different target audience and lifecycle than SnowFS. The commit hash integrity is a problem in CG/VFX productions, so is the 4GB limitation, as well as the I/O performance for large binary files. The fact that these issues are still there are fully understandable, given the responsibility and dependencies of this project. That's why SnowFS tries to address the niche requirements with its light implementation.

In terms of the license, this is intentionally the weakest argument of all. It doesn't prevent anyone under the GPL to ship Git as an external program with a commercial software, same counts for libgit2 with its linking exception. So there is not even a real benefit here. But the chosen MIT license is an open invitation for everyone.

P.S. Certain features and technical solutions will be feature-proposed to libgit2

sebastian_io··on SnowFS – a fast, scalable version control file storage for graphic files
That looks really cool! I will check the project out, thanks!
sebastian_io··on SnowFS – a fast, scalable version control file storage for graphic files
Most productions I've seen Perforce is still the way to go, sometimes PlasticSCM for Unity
sebastian_io··on SnowFS – a fast, scalable version control file storage for graphic files
You are absolutely right! A tool that can cover everyones needs is a great goal, and a pluggable or modularized approach might be even the best. SnowFS is not a one-way street, there are certain features that are currently investigated to be feature-proposed for libgit2. Means, this project is a great way to explore the possibilities without any historical or technical barriers because it is so lightweight. Best proof are the benchmarks
sebastian_io··on SnowFS – a fast, scalable version control file storage for graphic files
Programmers, game makers and 2D/3D artists are very different target audiences with very different needs. To name one example, the commit hash integrity which is a foundation of Git is a must-have for software projects, but might be not useful in environments like VFX or CG productions
sebastian_io··on SnowFS – a fast, scalable version control file storage for graphic files
Same here, the aimed goal is a C++ backport, bc I am a C++ dev. But Rust is on my radar and happy to learn
sebastian_io··on SnowFS – a fast, scalable version control file storage for graphic files
Indeed, TS/JS is great for its quick turnaround times for prototyping. But the I/O performance is executed by the underlying C/C++ layer. For the rest TS/JS is fast enough. But a full C++ backport is still on the horizon
sebastian_io··on SnowFS – a fast, scalable version control file storage for graphic files
SnowFS is still at the beginnings, so it will shape over time. For the benchmarks, these are the results on a MacBook-2019 with APFS for a 4GB file:

[git add texture.psd: 20164ms] [snow add texture.psd: 4596ms] [git rm texture.psd: 575ms] [snow rm texture.psd: 111ms] [git checkout HEAD~1: 9739ms] [snow checkout HEAD~1: 1ms]

You might get slightly slower speeds on NTFS for 'add' and 'checkout' but still very performant

← PreviousPage 2 of 2