Look at one of their examples of an initial prompt: https://github.com/openai/math/blob/main/reasoning_traces/re...
7,219 karma · joined January 30, 2017
◮ Website @ www.sebmellen.com
◮ Blog @ www.sebastianmellen.com
◮ Email @ hn [ a t ] sebastianmellen [ d o t ] com // corp email is first name at mycompanysite
——————————
There is a tide in the affairs of men. Which, taken at the flood, leads on to fortune; Omitted, all the voyage of their life Is bound in shallows and in miseries. On such a full sea are we now afloat, And we must take the current when it serves, Or lose our ventures.
——————————
[ my public key: https://keybase.io/sebmellen; my proof: https://keybase.io/sebmellen/sigs/iwp1glP0DaEmYMDaW9pg2Syr_Kq5YULKX7AU68ovLCQ ]
iWIkiiKk7w
Look at one of their examples of an initial prompt: https://github.com/openai/math/blob/main/reasoning_traces/re...
Thanks for the heads up!
[0]: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q6711174
[1]: https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/tools/sbdb_lookup.html#/?sstr=20031...
The only appropriate response to this is "What the fuck?"
Thank you for providing more details. The originally linked article was very light on information, so based purely on the comments that Albany's made, I think my conclusion was a fair one :)
Edit: I see I've been downvoted for this in light of another commenter providing more detailed information. I'm leaving my comment unedited so that the responses to it are not confusing, but please don't downvote just for the sake of disagreement. I would love to engage with you further if you provide substantive information in the comments. The originally linked article on this post was very light on details.
The issue is that the AI is at best what's in papers and medical records, which often forgoes the core thing that might lead a physician to uncover something or take a different approach with the patient.
The only thing that gets around that is StealthGPT, but it mangles your intent in the output so badly that it's easier to just write the thing yourself.
The worst thing about AI is endless complexity slopification.
But the core problem still exists based on the clarity of the prompt and the prompter.
Seeing my wife's depth of intuition and expertise as a physician, compared to my comparatively caveman-like prompts when asking for health advice, there's a massive delta in accuracy.
Have you ever had a significant health issue and tried to get help from a model? Even something like GPT 6 Pro? The firehose and confusion you will generate trying to figure out answers are far less helpful than having directed interaction with a physician.
If the prompt is an expert-written board question! Not so with inferior prompts [0]. Critically, you need deep medical knowledge to interact correctly with the agent.
What you're asking is basically: "If we take someone out of a three month dev bootcamp, and have them prompt Claude, why can't they be as good as a four year CS grad?"
I doubt that you would feel similarly about expertise in your own field.
Out of respect for you as a fellow intelligent HN commenter — you are deeply misinformed, and I would urge you to reconsider your perspectives on this.
Every study shows that utilization of APPs and nurse practitioners Leads to decreased quality of care and a significant increase in utilization of other healthcare resources, like the emergency department and imaging, that better-trained physicians don't need.
Less-trained providers misdiagnose cancers, refer patients to the wrong specialists, overprescribe antibiotics, and generally cost the system significantly more in overall health load than if we had better-paid general practitioners.
There is an argument that not enough physicians go into general practice, which is true, but it's because subspecialties are in such high demand that they're generally better paid. The unfortunate fix is that we need to find a way to better compensate primary care, even though Medicare physician reimbursement rates continually decline and our health insurance system is not well structured to support this kind of primary care model.
I've left a few links below if you'd like to read them:
General burden of NPs higher than physicians even with lower appointment cost: https://static1.squarespace.com/static/615326dd2c363f1e2a5c8...
Skin cancer misdiagnosis: https://www.ovid.com/journals/jaderm/abstract/10.1001/jamade...
Antibiotics overprescribed: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5047413/
It would be the same as someone from Hacker News going to read a medical forum where people are discussing AI, and the takes would feel similarly juvenile and uninformed, simply due to lack of exposure.
You are right, of course… but unfortunately I don't think it's worth arguing too much here.
> “Better examination performance was linked to improved adherence to mammography screening recommendations, appropriate prescribing practices, improved care of patients with diabetes, lower patient morbidity and mortality, fewer complaints to regulatory bodies, and lower malpractice payments. The association was observed across examination formats and medical specialties.”
https://academic.oup.com/academicmedicine/article-abstract/1...
Unfortunately, it’s very clear.
Come to think of it, who needs communally regulated safety services like jails, prisons, and law enforcement? In addition to having a private guard, every company should have their own in-house holding pen and justice system :)
But we can separate the financial inanity of his empire from the question, which is whether Elon is a capable engineering mind or simply an ‘Isaacson puff piece recipient’.