HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sedawkgrep

279 karma · joined July 19, 2011

submissionscomments
sedawkgrep··on IPv6 is not insecure because it lacks a NAT
Who exactly is going to route/send an RFC1918 address to an Internet gateway?

Are you implying your ISP itself is going to do this? Because the Internet at-large doesn't have routes for your internal address space.

sedawkgrep··on IPv6 is not insecure because it lacks a NAT
It's absolutely common in enterprise networks.
sedawkgrep··on IPv6 is not insecure because it lacks a NAT
> Do you have any examples of NAT that isn't implemented in a more general firewall subsystem?

When I was a network engineer, we did NAT on edge routers for B2B connections all the time. Like literally hundreds of thousands of them. I am 100% serious on this.

sedawkgrep··on IPv6 is not insecure because it lacks a NAT
> Except in the real world everyone

...and goes on to ignore enterprise businesses, which consume most of the v4 space and are among the biggest resisters of v6.

sedawkgrep··on Ford F-150 Lightning outsold the Cybertruck and was then canceled for poor sales
Nonsense in how they approached things. Clinton-era we had govt. cut backs all over the place. It was done according to a plan and according to the law.

This was just a hatchet job, aimed and cutting and gutting any and every agency they thought they could get away with.

sedawkgrep··on IPv6 just turned 30 and still hasn't taken over the world
> I get all of that... but it just sounds like you're arguing that either using RFC1918, or someone's inability to route to your router, is a firewall.

Yes and no. The effect is the same; packets are dropped. If you have no path to a target and no way to create one, it's a security barrier.

> Neither of these things are NAT!

You're right. They're a *result* of having a NAT boundary.

> They can run `ip route add 10.5.5.5 dev vpn`/`via <next-hop>` just fine if they happen to be in the right place to do it, and your NAT won't help you.

'If they happen to be in the right place to do it' is doing a LOT of heavy lifting here. You'd have to have root access on a compromised host, e.g., a linux system, immediately adjacent to the router/firewall/VPN doing NAT. And boy would that be a stupid design for an enterprise, and it would never happen at the Internet edge. So we're talking about the edgiest of edge case unicorns.

Even if you had all that go right, return packets are going to be addressed wrong (NAT) so you'd have to figure out how to deal with that.

Your stance seems to boil down to security being an active security measure - e.g. packet filter policy. My stance is that NAT and the reality of network design naturally results in preventing unwanted traffic flows, effectively producing the same result.

I'm not saying firewalls aren't critical, just that NAT does create a barrier, and v6 advocates always blare on that it doesn't.

sedawkgrep··on The virtual AmigaOS runtime (a.k.a. Wine for Amiga:)
Literally the first line in the description:

> vamos is a tool that allows to run AmigaOS m68k CLI binaries directly on your Mac or PC.

sedawkgrep··on IPv6 just turned 30 and still hasn't taken over the world
Look I get where you're going with this. I do. All things being equal, a device that routes packets will route packets whether or not a NAT is in place. That's not the issue at hand.

The situation is simply that except in the rarest of cases, you're not going to be able to manipulate routing to achieve getting a packet with a RFC1918 (let's be real here, this is what we're talking about 99.9% of the time) destination address to go anywhere, much less to the target. Or more broadly, getting a packet addressed for a target behind a NAT to route TO a NAT gateway. Not to mention that if somehow it did get through, return packets are almost guaranteed to end up NAT'd, preventing traffic flow. So there's that.

On the Internet, even if your ISP didn't drop your packets outright, the routers wouldn't have the faintest idea how to route your packets to your victim.

Not Internet? Ok, let's say you're on a corporate network. You're a user and not a network admin.

Your company has a VPN to a partner company, and you're both using various subnets in 10/8. The partner has provided 192.168.1.0/24 of 1:1 NAT addresses so your two companies can share data, etc.

But there is no route in the IGP to the partner company's 10/8 network, only a block of 192.168.1.x addresses, none of which you are able to use. A magic fairy tells you that partner's payroll server has admin/admin credentials at 10.5.5.5. How are you going to get across the VPN to that address?

You won't, because you can't. Because there's no route, and in the case of a VPN, the interesting traffic probably doesn't include that IP even if you got a packet that far.

It's all simply a question of routing. Whether your traffic is being dropped by a firewall or dropped by a router, it's still being dropped.

FWIW I was a network engineer and architect at a massive enterprise for almost 15 years, and my team had management over all our Internet circuits, NAT, our WAN, etc. At the time I left we probably had >200k 1:1 NAT addresses; mostly across B2B links for management access of our devices on customer premises. It was an enormous PITA.

sedawkgrep··on IPv6 just turned 30 and still hasn't taken over the world
NAT effectively stops inbound connectivity at the NAT edge. A system could be a dozen hops beyond that and no inbound traffic can reach it.

IPv6 (without any NAT) means that the source and destination are fully routable.

How folks DON'T see this as a functional component of security is beyond me.

sedawkgrep··on IPv6 just turned 30 and still hasn't taken over the world
I left my job as a NE/architect over a 15 years ago, but the show stopper back then revolved around how to handle routing with firewalling. Firewalling being biggest roadblock due to needing traffic symmetry. I'm doing my best to remember why we stopped at just providing v6 at the edge for site-specific Internet hosted services and never pushed it further.

Mind you, our team discussed this numerous times over a few years and never came up with a solution that didn't look like it would require us to completely fork-lift what we were doing. The whole team was FOR getting us to v6, so there was no dogmatic opposition.

Consider this:

25k employee company. Four main datacenter hubs spread out across the USA with 200 remote offices evenly dual-homed into any two of the four.

All four of the DCs had multi-ISP Internet access advertising their separate v4 blocks and hosting Internet services. The default-route was redistributed into the IGP from only two locations, site A and B. e.g. two of the four DCs were egress for Internet traffic from the population of users and all non-internet-facing servers. IGP metrics were gently massaged as to fairly equally use of both sites.

All outbound traffic flowed naturally out of the eastern or western sites based on IGP metrics. This afforded us a tertiary failover for outbound traffic in the event that both of the Internet links into one of the two egress sites was down. e.g., if both of site A's links (say, level-3 and att) were down, the route through site A was lost, and all the egress traffic was then routed out site B (and vice-versa). This worked well with ipv4 because we used NAT to masquerade all the internal v4 space as site X's public egress block. Therefore all the return traffic was routed appropriately.

BGP advertisements were either as-path prepended or supernetted (don't remember which) such that if site A went down, site B, C, or D would get its traffic, and tunnel it via GRE to the appropriate DC hub's external segment.

The difficulty was that traffic absolutely had to flow symmetrically because of the firewalls in place, and easily could for v4 because NAT was happening at every edge.

With v6 it just didn't seem like there was any way to achieve the same routing architecture / flexibility, particularly with multi-homing into geographically disparate sites.

I'm not sure anymore where we landed, but I remember it being effectively insurmountable. I don't think it was difficult for Internet-hosted services, but the effort seemed absolutely not worth it for everything on the inside of the network.

sedawkgrep··on IPv6 just turned 30 and still hasn't taken over the world
Dude.

The difficulty of setting IPv6 up at your house vs. the needs of a multi-homed, geographically diverse enterprise couldn't be more dissimilar.

I'd lay off the judgment a bit.

sedawkgrep··on IPv6 just turned 30 and still hasn't taken over the world
It would've been even easier and lasted longer to use two bytes of hex at the start. That would've expanded the Internet to 65536x its current space.

Something like aaff:a.b.c.d

Leaving off the prefix: could just mean strictly IPv4.

sedawkgrep··on Rep Ro Khanna faces Silicon Valley backlash after embracing wealth tax
shrug

Well, between you and her, I'll take the senator, former Harvard Law professor, and architect of the CFPB.

sedawkgrep··on Rep Ro Khanna faces Silicon Valley backlash after embracing wealth tax
Elizabeth Warren, who has been a champion of financial reforms - specifically to assist in helping the middle and lower classes - is a proponent of wealth taxes.

That means a lot more to me than your grumpy, politically charged anecdote.

sedawkgrep··on Deliberate Internet Shutdowns
> accept I am a somewhat horrible person to even be able to articulate those thoughts.

No, you’re simply thoughtful and a realist. To acknowledge something doesn’t mean you agree with or endorse it.

sedawkgrep··on GPT-5.2-Codex
This is an interesting thread to me and my experience as a total hack programmer has been both awesome and pathetic with regards to AI.

Recently I tried working with both ChatGPT and Gemini (AI Studio) to take a really badly written PHP website and refactor it into MVC components. I've worked strictly through the web UI as this only involved a few files.

While both provided great guidance around how to approach disentangling this monolithic code, GPT failed miserably, generating code that was syntactically incorrect, and then doubling-down on it by insisting that it was correct and that errors were faults lying elsewhere. It literally generated code that lacked closing parenthesis and brackets.

In contrast, Gemini generated a perfectly working MVC version from the start. In both instances I did intentionally keep it on track to only separate the code into MVC and NOT to optimize anything, but it worked the first try. I've then taken it through subsequent refactorings and it's done superbly in that role.

So I can't speak to how well this works for large code bases, much less agentically. (my initial, very focused MVC refactor was about 1300 lines.) But when giving it a very specific task with strict guidance and rules, my results with Gemini were fantastic.

sedawkgrep··on Umbrel – Personal Cloud
Well the parent did say this:

> Details are extremely thin on the site, so let me know if I'm wrong.

sedawkgrep··on Japanese four-cylinder engine is so reliable still in production after 25 years
Thanks for the link. Like you, it really helped me understand what's going on with all three of the designs shown.
sedawkgrep··on Self-hosting a NAT Gateway
I don't think source routing is a thing anymore. At least if you're talking about the ability of a source to specify a path to its destination.

The last time I heard about source routing actually being a useful feature or a vulnerability used by hackers was the 1990's.

sedawkgrep··on Static Web Hosting on the Intel N150
For mini pcs, Beelink probably has the best support. I've owned a few and had one replaced under warranty.
sedawkgrep··on Cloudflare Global Network experiencing issues
> pop out a more specific BGP prefix from a backup path or secondary router so you can pull production away from the burning IP.

This won't help against carpet bombing.

The only workable solution for enterprises is a combination of on-prem and cloud mitigation. Cloud to get all the big swaths of mitigation and to keep your pipe flowing, and on-prem to mitigate specific attack vectors like state exhaustion.

sedawkgrep··on Why use OpenBSD?
> The firewall on OpenBSD is miles better to configure than iptables.

That's understating the matter by a huge amount.

pf is easier to read and understand, easier to adjust, more dynamic, and works like every other firewall in the world not based on iptables.

sedawkgrep··on [dead]
Thanks for the summary.

This:

> shutdown has a 50% chance of rebooting.

…gave me a good laugh.

sedawkgrep··on Ask HN: Why are certain communities like Reddit so anti-AI?
I think most of the hate and resistance is due to the erosion of trust that comes with AI. We’re already at the point where you have to question the authenticity of A/V media you see on social media. Soon we may not be able to trust even news outlets.

Nobody* wants this to happen, yet it’s charging forward.

* yes of course there are some, but they’re already the ones with the power and money.

sedawkgrep··on OpenBSD 7.8
Yeah I suppose.

But OpenBSD forked from NetBSD like, what, 30 years ago?

sedawkgrep··on OpenBSD 7.8
Yeah isn’t netbsd the BSD focused on portability and platform support?
sedawkgrep··on Magisterium AI
> how are you different from other llms ?

  Magisterium AI differs from generic large‑language models in several concrete ways that flow directly from the Church’s own teaching and from the way the system has been built.

  1. A Catholic‑only knowledge base

  All of the textual material that trains Magisterium AI comes from authentic Catholic sources—official magisterial documents, the Catechism, papal writings, the Church Fathers and Doctors—so the model never draws on secular or contradictory material. The Church itself reserves the interpretation of the Word of God to the magisterium, and Magisterium AI respects that boundary by limiting its corpus to those very sources.
sedawkgrep··on OpenAI Needs $400B In The Next 12 Months
Not to mention it would assume that number wouldn't change...but of course it depends entirely on what type of compute is there as well as the fact that every few years truckloads of hardware gets replaced and the compute goes up.
sedawkgrep··on Nightmare Fuel: Skibidi Toilet and the Monstrous Digital
I tend to view the world through a psychoanalytical lens. I'm always curious about the unconscious drives of individuals and the collective, and how we interpret and interact with the world we live in.

I thought the article was interesting and thoughtful. It did a marvelous job of making sense of something that, at first blush, is seemingly senseless, and I do not think for a moment the paper is a prank.

Quite the contrary. One of the main characteristics of today's world is the devaluation (or utter disregard) of meaning. Even in this thread the term "brain rot" implies that it's not only valueless, but harmful. The article is not only about finding meaning in the content, but that its ambiguous narrative can be a good thing, as it opens the mind up to multiple possibilities and perspectives.

I find that to be quite hopeful.

sedawkgrep··on Ask HN: Abandoned/dead projects you think died before their time and why?
> - Ford Crown Victoria

You can't just drop that and not say why...

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →