HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

seesthruya

135 karma · joined May 14, 2025

submissionscomments
seesthruya··on Demand for human radiologists is at an all-time high
I'm a diagnostic radiologist with 20 years clinical experience, and I have been programming computers since 1979. I need to challenge one of your core assumptions.

> Can AI read diagnostic images better than a radiologist? Almost certainly the answer is (or will be) yes.

I'm sorry, but I disagree, and I think you are making a wild assumption here. I am up to date on the latest AI products in radiology, use several of the, and none of them are even in the ballpark on this. That vast majority are non-contributory.

It is my strong belief that there is an almost infinite variation in both human anatomy and pathology. Given this variation, I believe that in order for your above assumption to be correct, the development of "AGI" will need to happen.

When I interpret a study I am not just matching patterns of pixels on the screen with my memory. I am thinking, puzzling, gathering and synthesizing new information. Every day I see something I have never seen before, and maybe no one has ever seen before. Things that can't and don't exist in a training data set.

I'm on the back end of my career now and I am financially secure. I mention that because people will assume I'm a greedy and ignorant Luddite doctor trying to protect my way of life. On the contrary, if someone developed a good replacement for what I don, I would gladly lay down my microphone and move on.

But I don't think we are there yet, in fact I don't think we're even close.

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
Agreed, and from what I understand radiation oncology treatment planning has benefited from this.
seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
For what it's worth, I almost dropped out of medical school in my second year to go back to a career in tech. It was a close thing.

Still, I have enjoyed my time in radiology. It is insanely challenging to do well, and has been very rewarding.

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
This is illegal, and you will go to jail if you do this with a Medicare or Medicaid patient and it is discovered.
seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
When you get a medical test like an MRI, there is both a technical fee and a professional fee that is paid.

For a shoulder MRI, the technical fee, which goes to the facility that performs the scan, maybe $1,500.

The professional fee, that goes to the radiologist that interprets the scan, maybe $80.

Patients often only see a global fee.

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
Basically, the ABR needs to approve a residency program for the residents that graduate from the program to be eligible to sit for the boards.

I don't think they would ever do it, but technically the ABR could stop them.

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
You cannot bill for a resident's work, without an attending signing off on it.

I like residents, I actually started a new radiology residency program.

They are a net drain on productivity in radiology, due to the teaching obligations

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
I'm a radiologist that can program!

I've authored and contributed to several open source projects over the years, and I'm currently doing a deep dive in CAD/CAM after buying a CNC machine.

I help my practice where I can, and have written a little utility to make generating reports easier, but I would have to quit my job if I was trying to take on the absolutely enormous task of radiology computer aides diagnosis. And I need my job!

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
Ok, I should have been more clear.

A radiologist practicing in the USA can live anywhere in the world, but they must be trained in the USA, licensed in the state(s) where they read from, credentialed at the hospitals or facilities they read from, and carry medical malpractice insurance.

The point being, hospitals can't throw cheap Indian or Filipino radiologists at the worklist.

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
Basically, they are all currently hot garbage.

In my practice we have:

1. Mammography CAD

2. Pulmonary nodule CAD

3. Intracranial hemorrhage CAD

4. Intracranial vessel CAD

They all stink! I would love it if they were useful, radiology is insanely difficult and I could use the help!

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
There's a reason they can't.
seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
This is 100% true and very insightful, but not obvious to people who don't work in healthcare.
seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
You are correct!

I should have said when an AI can do my job it can do anyone's job.

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
This is true!
seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
IMHO the ABR isn't quite as powerful as you're indicating, but in general I agree.

For what it's worth, I started a new residency program to train more radiologist, so I do have some skin in the game.

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
Are you aware of any states in the US that have made it harder to sue doctors for malpractice?

My point, which I made poorly, is this: There's a reason doctors that went to medical school in India and trained as Radiologists in India can't read US cases remotely for a fraction of the cost of US trained and licensed radiologists.

It's not because the systems to read remotely don't exist.

It's not because they're poorly trained or bad doctors.

Itsty because they can't be sued.

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
All good points! Nobody knows the future!

I jumped into this thread to share my thoughts, and my thoughts alone, because I'm not sure there are a lot of radiologists on HN. I certainly don't speak for all radiologists.

But, I would submit to you, that rapid, radical changes to the practice of medicine are rare, if not impossible.

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
I agree with you on all points. The only question is how long will it take?
seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
Agreed
seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
I agree with you, but here is where things get tricky:

Everyday I see something on a scan yhat I've never seen before. And, possibly, no one has ever seen before. There is tremendous variation in human anatomy and pathology.

So what do I do? I use general intelligence. I talk to the patient. I talk to the referring doctor. I compare with other studies, across modalities and time.

I reason. I synthesize. I think.

So my point is, basically, radiology takes AGI.

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
I have a fairly strong background in tech, and I've been programming computers since 1979 when my dad bought me a TRS-80. Tape drives FTW!

I agree with almost everything you've said here.

Except 'not in my lifetime', because I plan on living for a very long time, and who knows what those computer nerds will come up with eventually ;-)

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
100%
seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
There's nothing special about radiology. And I do believe inertia will carry me through the end of my career, which has approximately 10 years left.

However, it's my opinion that my job takes general intelligence, not just pattern matching.

Therefore, when I lose my job to AI, so does everyone else.

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
I agree with you fully.

And, I didn't say I would never be replaced. I said I would finish my career, which is approximately 10 more years at this point.

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
There is a national shortage of radiologists in the US, with many hospital systems facing a backlog of unread cases measuring in the thousands. And, the baby boomers are starting to retire, it's only going to get worse. We aren't training enough new radiologists, which is a different discussion.

Askl to your question on where my confidence stems from, there are both legal reasons and 'not being able to do the work' reasons.

Legal is easy, the most powerful lobby in most states are trial attorneys. They simply won't allow a situation where liability cannot be attached to medical practice. Somebody is getting sued.

As to what I do day to day, I don't think I'm just matching patterns. I believe what I do takes general intelligence. Therefore, when AI can do my job, it can do everyone else's job as well.

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
Depends on what you mean by 'see'.

For example, let's say I'm looking at a chest x-ray. There is a pneumonia at the left lung base and I am clever enough to notice it. 'Aha', I think, congratulating myself at making the diagnosis and figuring out why the patient is short of breath.

But, in this example, I stop looking closely at the X-ray after noticing the pneumonia, so I miss a pneumothorax at the right lung apex.

I have made a mistake radiologists call 'satisfaction of search'.

My 'search' for the patient's problem was 'satisfied' by finding the pneumonia, and because I am human and therefore fundamentally flawed, I stopped looking for a second clinically relevant diagnosis.

An AI module that detects a pneumothorax is not prone to this type of error. So it sees something I did not. But it doesn't see something that I can't see. I just didn't look.

seesthruya··on The A.I. Radiologist Will Not Be with You Soon
Working radiologist here, 20 years experience.

This article is surprisingly accurate. I fully expect to finish my career without being 'replaced' by AI.

Happy to debate/answer questions :-)

← PreviousPage 2 of 2