HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sellyme

1,751 karma · joined August 4, 2014

submissionscomments
sellyme··on Larry Page: “I think we should look into acquiring YouTube” (2005)
> What is the value proposition exactly

Having a career.

It's very rare for someone to last decades as a performer in the entertainment industry, and online content moves faster than most. You don't want to suddenly have no audience age 35 with zero skills or experience outside making potentially niche YouTube videos.

sellyme··on Climate activist arrested after ProtonMail provided his IP address
I'm not sure what you're trying to get at with the word "scan" here, so hopefully this abstraction will be useful.

Imagine you have a message written on a piece of paper. You intentionally show this message to two people, Alice and Bob, and are fully aware that they have both read and can perfectly remember the entire contents of the message.

Now imagine that Alice thought about the message independently (not recalling it, but actually thinking new thoughts), and that Bob did not do this.

Are you claiming that Alice violated your privacy by thinking about something you showed her and asked her to remember? Or perhaps would it only be a violation of privacy if she then subsequently told you one of those thoughts?

sellyme··on Climate activist arrested after ProtonMail provided his IP address
In both cases exactly the same entities read your email: you, the sender, and Gmail.

I don't see how you could go "yeah, this is a privacy improvement" if your information is still visible to exactly the same entities, but one of them isn't really mentioning it.

sellyme··on Today Sci-Hub is 10 years old. I'll publish 2M new articles to celebrate
> Someone needs to rent and service the servers, update the software, bandwidth costs money, etc..

Scientific papers use approximately zero bandwidth.

As a point of reference, if I hosted such a website on my home internet connection I would be paying approximately 0.00013 cents per upload. Even users downloading millions of papers would cost me less than a coffee.

Setting up and managing a proportionate payment system would cost more than just eating the bandwidth costs would.

sellyme··on Climate activist arrested after ProtonMail provided his IP address
The scanning of email contents that Gmail does is, from a privacy standpoint, indistinguishable from them simply sending you the email. Their server has to know the contents of that email either way.
sellyme··on The red warning light on Richard Branson’s space flight
> You honestly believe that the NBA has never [...]

I've never watched the NBA, so I'd have no idea.

> You think no officials of any sport did or didn't make a call because of some bet somewhere?

Just so you're aware, there are numbers between 0% and 100%.

sellyme··on The red warning light on Richard Branson’s space flight
You literally said "100%".
sellyme··on Super Follows
> see content in chronological order without other bullshit

This is called "Lists" and has been a free feature of Twitter since 2009.

sellyme··on NP Complete 3rd Grade Math Problems (2018)
> I'm pretty confident anyone can become really good at anything, given enough motivation and time.

And I'm pretty confident that some people can become really good at said thing faster, due to some form of innate talent. And as we all have finite time, that's a pretty important trait.

sellyme··on Esperanto Champions the Efficiency of Its 1,092-Core RISC-V Chip
You've misread it. Here's those lines with a bit more context:

> But if, instead, they followed the peak of the energy efficiency graph, the entire chip would consume just 8.5 watts [...] and operating at about 0.4 volts, Ditzel said, one chip would take about 20 watts.

"the peak of the energy efficiency graph" isn't stated explicitly, but is at around 0.32 volts.

Basically they want to use up all 120W of a PCIe slot, at the highest efficiency possible. They could have gotten higher efficiency (at 8.5W per chip), but that would have resulted in not being able to use the full 120W and thus actually having worse performance overall, even though it's more efficient.

sellyme··on Discord has won over gamers. Now it wants everybody else
> The gifting button is only beside the upload button on mobile, and personally I've never hit it accidentally. To me it just seems like they've made it more prominent, I don't see any intent to trick people into mis-clicking.

Perhaps you don't remember what that UI used to look like. For most of Discord's existence, there were two buttons to the left of the chatbox in the mobile app. The leftmost of these was a camera icon (for taking a photo and immediately uploading it), and the rightmost was the gallery icon, for uploading an existing image. For the vast majority of users, the gallery icon would have been the most commonly used.

In 2020 they got rid of the camera icon entirely (now requiring an additional menu to get to it), moved the gallery icon, and then where the gallery icon used to be they added the Gift Nitro icon. Instead of using the empty space vacated by the camera icon they moved a feature used >10,000x more so that the Nitro button could benefit from everyone's muscle memory.

At the time it happened misclicks and feeling tricked was an extremely common complaint [1], to the extent that I do not believe for a second that a team of people competent enough to build such an otherwise excellent piece of software could possibly have not foreseen it occurring. That this is not an isolated incident but rather part of a pattern helps cement that judgment.

> Like I've said, I have no problem with them trying to make more money, they need to make a profit to keep providing a free service.

I do have a problem with it, because they're trying to make money by tricking their users. I'm perfectly happy to go back to IRC if the only way they can think of to keep their company afloat is to deliberately make their product worse to use.

[1]: https://www.google.com/search?q=discord+gift+nitro+button+im...

sellyme··on Discord has won over gamers. Now it wants everybody else
> I don't think tricking is the word for this.

Tricking is 100% the right word for it. They are putting those Nitro buttons there with the clear intent that a user will click it by accident while attempting to access a different feature that used to be there.

> You're not going to click something by accident and be immediately billed for something.

If it didn't work, they wouldn't be doing it. I'm not claiming that they're outright scamming people out of money, but that they're using actively hostile UI/UX to profit by serving advertisements for Nitro when someone was trying to upload a photo. That's absolutely worthy of criticism.

sellyme··on Discord has won over gamers. Now it wants everybody else
> Every single Discord-related post here I see comments about the "bad ux". I'm a heavy Discord user and I have no complaints with the UX

Since I started using Discord, they have on three separate occasions moved a button I used frequently, and in its place added a button that attempts to extract money from me.

They've established a pattern of trying to monetise the application by tricking the user into doing something that they didn't want to do. That isn't just bad UX, it's actively hostile.

sellyme··on Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents
> Who the hell installs a random app and then uses it to transfer millions of $$ in bitcoin?!?

It's not like there's a huge wealth of stable reputable ecosystems that could have been used as an alternative.

Look at any crypto forums from just 5 years ago and just about every single website or tool mentioned has either been hacked or run off with users' money in the intervening period.

sellyme··on Joe Rogan, confined to Spotify, is losing influence
Yep. Exclusivity deals are a great way to push me, someone who would ordinarily happy pay for content, into piracy.

I already have software that can play MP3s. I like it. Stop trying to make me use someone else's.

sellyme··on Joe Rogan, confined to Spotify, is losing influence
Yes.

See also: about half of the rap tracks on the platform, where every third line is product placement.

sellyme··on Sweden must repay $1.6M in Bitcoin to convicted drug dealer
> They seem mad because they missed an opportunity to make 1.6M then.

I think it's more that they're mad because someone managed to make and keep 7 figures profit from a crime that they were caught doing purely because the justice system screwed up.

It's hard to keep the "crime doesn't pay" messaging when stuff like that happens.

sellyme··on The Bullshit
Yes, generally speaking when I'm reading something I'd hope that my mind is doing some interpretation. It would be a rather difficult activity otherwise.
sellyme··on Hire for slope, not Y-Intercept
> and then in a few years be getting intermediate value for that same entry level rate.

If you're expecting to pay someone an entry-level rate ~3 years into their career you're going to be getting exactly zero value out of them as they will get a job at a company that pays them what they're worth.

sellyme··on The Bullshit
You're still missing the point that people tell almost identical stories for just about every profession in existence. The user that replied to you wasn't even doubting you, they were just saying that it's not special.
sellyme··on Nerds don't respond to marketing; try technical documentation instead
> When was the last time you bought something because of ads?

The last major purchase (>$100) I've made because of an advertisement was a ROG Phone 3 (two of them, actually) late last year. I had not ever heard of it before seeing an advertisement for it, and upon looking it up it seemed like a really good option.

The last one full stop was a billboard advertisement for a block of chocolate with a flavour that I know I like from a brand I don't normally purchase. Decided to try it out, liked it a lot. That was about three weeks ago.

> Would a fancy jingle convince you to sit 40 mins in traffic for the same crappy burger with slightly different sauce from the same Sysco truck?

I don't think it's possible to sit in traffic for 40 minutes on my continent, so that's going to be a pretty tough sale.

sellyme··on Fishdraw: Procedurally Generated Fish Drawings
Oh cool, I've used his Rush Hour solver before! Small world.
sellyme··on Nerds don't respond to marketing; try technical documentation instead
I think the more prevailing opinion is just that marketing follows Sturgeon's Law. McDonald's is a good example - their marketing (at least in my region) is excellent, and I'm consciously aware of the fact that it leads me to having a higher opinion of them as a company. On the other hand, KFC's marketing is absolutely horrible (do other countries get those insanely out of touch "shut up and take my money" ads?), and I occasionally choose not to eat there solely because their marketing pisses me off so much.

I'd say that fewer than ~5% of the adverts I see increase my opinion of the advertised product/brand, and around 80% of them actively reduce it. Based on my other interactions with people who can be described as "nerds", this seems like a reasonably common sentiment.

In short, it's not that people think they're invulnerable to marketing, they just think that they're invulnerable to shoddy marketing aimed at the lowest common denominator with no thought beyond "let's just yell at them every 5 minutes until they buy our product". Which could very well be true.

sellyme··on The Bullshit
Here's the quote with a tiny bit more context:

> Go read more bullshit. Immerse yourself in news of Russian plots [...]

Seems pretty clear-cut to me. The original comment did muddy the waters a bit by taking the inverse of that statement, but the author isn't being ambiguous on their beliefs in that regard.

sellyme··on The Bullshit
I don't think anyone is under the delusion that domestic terrorists in the US are being secretive any more. That ship somewhat sails after an attempted insurrection.
sellyme··on The Bullshit
It depends on what you mean by "these behaviours". I'm suggesting that the author is claiming some great injustice but conveniently trying to avoid letting anyone judge for themselves, and in my experience the people doing that usually aren't the world's most upstanding citizens.

I'm certainly not suggesting that the author is prone to outbursts of racial slurs - that was just an example of something I encounter regularly, and typically that type of person is far less literate - but I am extremely doubtful that the content they're complaining about removal of is as "anti-bullshit" as they'd like to claim.

sellyme··on The Bullshit
I'm assuming it's a satire in response to the following line, which claims that banned Facebook pages are "the anti-bullshit universe":

> One option, more popular each day, is to retreat to the anti-bullshit universe of alternative media sources. These are the podcasts, videos, Twitter threads, newsletters, and Facebook pages that regularly vanish from circulation for violating “community standards” and other ineffable codes of conduct, oft-times after failing “fact-checks” by the friendly people at Good Thoughtkeeping.

I also like that the author explicitly refuses to provide any examples of these "anti-bullshit alternative media sources". Very common tactic amongst this ilk - complain about aggressive censorship and how George Orwell was specifically warning us about Twitter, all the while doing everything you can to avoid people seeing what was actually incurring bans.

I see it all the time in communities I run, people start trying to spin off alternative sites and talk about how <insert community here> impinges on free speech, and then when you check what they were banned for there's a tirade of racial slurs directed at other members of the community.

It's insanely hard to get your content consistently removed from Twitter or Facebook, they do everything they can to avoid having to hire more moderators. It can happen, but then providing the examples will get everyone on your side immediately. Anyone who claims that they're being unfairly censored and yet refuses to show the content that actually got removed is trying to hide something.

sellyme··on The Bullshit
I don't see why you think "I worked around a newsroom for 13 years" is a good rebuttal to the fairly trivial claim that most professionals chose said profession because they wanted to do it.
sellyme··on The time Pepsi got sued for a $33M fighter jet
So you've established that there's some kind of hierarchy here, where the value of 1 pizza to a certain entity depends on their place in the hierarchy. The higher up on the hierarchy you are, the less 1 pizza matters to you. Furthermore, you've stated that it's "categorically worse" to get a free pizza from a family business than from Domino's, because a net loss of 1 pizza matters less to Domino's than it does to a family business.

I agree with this assessment. However, I would posit that a single university-aged individual is even lower on this hierarchy than a family business is, so unless Domino's had the same promotion going on and they chose to target a family business instead, the logic seems to defend their action.

It's probably also worth pointing out that the original commenter only said "local pizza place", which isn't always used synonymously with "family business", and additionally that describing an explicit instruction ("you [can] enter as many times as you like") as a loophole is somewhat of a stretch.

sellyme··on San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2019)
What does the person who wrote the post lose by having a small subset of people ordinarily unable to view their original public post get to see the contents nonetheless?
← PreviousPage 4 of 19Next →