HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sepositus

527 karma · joined February 4, 2025

Often present the minority view on HN (and pay the karma price).
submissionscomments
sepositus··on First American pope elected and will be known as Pope Leo XIV
I don't think that's a fair statement. For example, a large majority of denominations (I'd say >80%) agree on something like the Apostle's Creed [1]. But yes, for less core doctrines, there are sometimes dozens of flavors.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostles%27_Creed

sepositus··on First American pope elected and will be known as Pope Leo XIV
Yes, this is accurate, they have a whole element of "tradition" that gets encompassed into teachings. However, I may be wrong, but these "traditions" mostly came out of areas where the Bible wasn't super clear. I suppose that's where the debate is, then, because it seems to be a minority view that the Bible doesn't have a clear definition of marriage.
sepositus··on First American pope elected and will be known as Pope Leo XIV
What do you mean? There are plenty of "modern" interpretations. New scholarly commentaries come out almost every year. My point is that, among these, the prevailing assumption continues to be one that doesn't support same-sex marriages in the church.

What is lacking, from my perspective, are scholarly interpretations that swing the discussion the other way. The best I've seen simply just exclude the problematic scriptures which really isn't within the Catholic tradition (inerrancy of scripture and all).

contexnt: I've studied religions (and still follow the topic) and have a basic understanding of where things are, but take it with a grain of salt.

sepositus··on First American pope elected and will be known as Pope Leo XIV
Curious, do you think he's wrong that it's at odds with what was taught by the apostles? It's obviously unpopular, but I have yet to see a convincing argument (based in the teachings of the Bible) that promotes same-sex marriages.

If I were in his position, and part of my duty is to interpret and lead via "the holy scriptures," then I would probably want to be as accurate as possible.

sepositus··on Ask HN: How much better are AI IDEs vs. copy pasting into chat apps?
This is exactly how I use agent mode in Cursor. I’ve never understood why I would use aider. Am I missing something else?
sepositus··on Show HN: eInk optimized manga with Kindle Comic Converter (+Kobo/ReMarkable)
Has anyone tried this on a Remarkable? It always seemed like the perfect size for reading comic books/magna.
sepositus··on Mississippi Can't Possibly Have Good Schools
I'm still trying to pinpoint exactly why Oregon has some of the worst scores in the country (I believe it ranked dead-last this year when adjusted for socio-economic factors). When I see what's going on around me, I can only think it's somewhat related to broken family's and undisciplined kids. The stuff that my kids come home and tell me is happening in school is pretty mind blowing.

I've also noticed a complete reversal on any form of discipline. There's not even detention anymore. It seems in the name of acceptance we're taking in all kids, even ones exhibiting extremely aggressive behaviors, and then doing absolutely nothing to curb those behaviors.

sepositus··on Gemini 2.5 Pro Preview
> Asking one to make changes to such a code set, and you will get whatever branch the dice told the tree to go down that day.

Has anyone come close to solving this? I keep seeing all of this "cluster of agents" designs that promise to solve all of our problems but I can't help but wonder how it works out in the first place given they're not deterministic.

sepositus··on Replacing Kubernetes with systemd (2024)
Ha, I figured someone was going to come with a retort like that. Fair, but it would be better to compare it to running a distributed postgres cluster on your local mac.
sepositus··on Replacing Kubernetes with systemd (2024)
To suggest that Kubernetes doesn't fall under the scope of "battle tested" is a bit misleading. As much as systemd? Of course not. But it's not 2016 anymore and we have billions of collective operational hours with Kubernetes.

Just the other day I found a cluster I had inadvertently left running on my macBook using Kind. It literally had three weeks of uptime (running a full stack of services) and everything was still working, even with the system getting suspended repeatedly.

sepositus··on You sent the message, but did you write it?
> I believe we are wired like this

Absolutely, and I think because of this we'll never see the desire go away completely. However, I'm imagining some dystopian future where human touch is so rare that people _forget_ how much it means to them. It's like scrolling through the endless slop of Netflix and then coming to some rare gem of a film where you're reminded what genuine art is.

sepositus··on Burning Mao
Yes, it was indeed a shameful war. Bloodier though? Not from my understanding. Happy to be corrected, though.
sepositus··on Burning Mao
Thanks, but I was looking for an explanation of the "hardly more bloody" comment. I briefly looked up casualties for the things you listed and it's not even remotely close to the deaths attribute to Mao.
sepositus··on You sent the message, but did you write it?
I just had an interesting experience this morning with my oldest child. He wanted to write a letter to the Splatoon development team to show his appreciation for the game. He printed it out and brought it to me with a proud expression on his face. It took about five seconds to catch the AI smell.

We then proceeded to have a conversation about how some people might feel if an appreciation letter was given to them that was clearly written by AI. I had to explain how it feels sort of cold and impersonal which leads to losing the effect he's looking to have.

To be honest, though, it really got me thinking about what the future is going to look like. What do I know? Maybe people will just stop caring about the human touch. It seems like a massive loss to me, but I'm also getting older.

I let him send the letter anyways. Maybe in an ironic twist an AI will respond to it.

sepositus··on Burning Mao
> Yes, it was messy, but hardly bloodier than what the West was doing in the country at the time.

Can you expand on this?

sepositus··on How to live an intellectually rich life
I would say that material decay, neglect, economic collapse, war, and changing cultural priorities played a far greater role in the loss of these texts rather than the ones lost to zealous Christians. It's just weird to single that group out when their actions represent a minority in the overall loss of these ancient texts.
sepositus··on How to live an intellectually rich life
I appreciate this perspective as it matches mine and I think comes from experience. I imagine myself sitting on my peak and seeing millions, maybe billions, of other peaks and the desire to traverse them propels me forward. However, as soon as I'm a quarter of the way up one, I start to think, what am I missing on the other peaks? That's the FOMO. Then I spend the next five years of my life partially breaching a thousand ideas and never experiencing satisfaction.
sepositus··on How to live an intellectually rich life
> But yes, European countries were heavily influenced by communist ideology, which continues to shape our values today, about well-regulated free markets, fair taxation, public service, and so on

So this is the first time I've seen well-regulated free markets and fair taxation as being associated with communist ideology. Granted, I'm not well-studied here, but I recall being taught quite the opposite.

I did some preliminary research uisng Gemini Research to see if I could surface anything that might suggest this has been universally regarded as true and it came back with the opposite on the first (well-regulated free markets) and ambiguity on the second (not universally associated with communism).

Would you be able to reference a place where I can learn more about these relationships?

sepositus··on How to live an intellectually rich life
Wasn't communism influenced heavily by being anti-capitalist? They fundamentally disagreed with the tenants that the United States stood on. Your comment, if I'm understanding it correctly, makes it look like the communists were just trying to do their own thing in their own countries and the big bad U.S came in and bullied them out of existence.

I'm not defending either sides here. I'm not a Reaganot. But to think most communist regimes were not hellbent on the destruction of western capitalism would seem a bit misleading to me.

sepositus··on How to live an intellectually rich life
I didn't realize Early Christianity had a monopoly on the destruction of books? As far as I know the burning of rival civilizations has been happening for thousands of years.
sepositus··on Claude Integrations
Yeah, this was my first thought. I was watching the video of it creating all of these Jira tickets just thinking in my head: "I hope it just did all that correctly." I think the level of patience with my team would be very low if I started running an LLM that accidentally deleted a bunch of really important tickets.
sepositus··on Apple violated antitrust ruling, judge finds
> All while their tools that developers _have_ to use are buggy and often nigh unsusable (Apple Connect....).

I'm moving to a job where I don't have to be the build/devops engineer for a product with an iOS app. To say I'm relieved wouldn't even be the half of it. What made it particularly worse was that our release cycle was every two months which is just enough time for Apple to completely wreck the build.

Absolutely terrible experience.

sepositus··on The coming knowledge-work supply-chain crisis
I see a whole new future of cyber warfare being created. It'll be like the reverse of a prompt engineer: an injection engineer. Someone who can tamper with the model just enough to sway a specific output that causes <X>.
sepositus··on TmuxAI: AI-Powered, Non-Intrusive Terminal Assistant
So I have yet to use any tool that needs an API key because I am concerned about costs. Does anyone have any idea what the daily usage of something like this would cost?
sepositus··on The coming knowledge-work supply-chain crisis
> But humans often write things which are false.

Not to mention, humans say things that make sense for humans to say and not a machine. For example, one recent case I saw was where the LLM hallucinated having a Macbook available that it was using to answer a question. In the context of a human, it was a totally viable response, but was total nonsense coming from an LLM.

sepositus··on What Porn Did to American Culture?
Sure, another common one would be a warped view of sex. A lot of these young men get into relationships and often want to do some "things" that the other party is usually not comfortable with. The problem is they become less capable of "getting off" with the less risqué acts and it's usually then that they realize how porn has altered their perspective on reality.
sepositus··on What Porn Did to American Culture
I had no intentions for people to take my view as objective reality, and no where in my comment did I assert my take was purely objective. I think people are just used to others putting their thoughts out as facts and make the wrong assumption. But that's not my fault :)
sepositus··on Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for repeat speeders
Personally, I tend to get irritated when someone swings 10-15 mph over/under the current speed limit. I often have to speed around them to avoid them. I probably would care less if the car just followed their erratic behavior for me.
sepositus··on What Porn Did to American Culture
Yeah, I agree that the statement, "porn has molded the world we live in," is problematic. Based on my experience, it certainly does affect a subset of the world negatively, but how much do those people go on to shape the world? It's plausible some do, but without more evidence, it's hard to discern by _how much_.
sepositus··on What Porn Did to American Culture
I'm sure there have been studies done, but I don't know them off the top of my head. I'm speaking from personal experience here (since apparently I need to spell this out in my comments): I would say that violent video games _may_ play a role in someone who then proceeds to go down the path of "violence porn." But usually, there are other factors drawing them to that place (i.e., bullying).

Likewise, I've often seen porn used as a tool to deal with other subsurface issues. The high of the hormone rush brings temporary relief, but like most highs, it requires more and more for it to stay the same.

Interestingly, no one in any of the comments so far has provided any anecdotal experiences of porn resulting in the opposite effect on someone. I don't doubt it happens, but it seems more people are focused on attacking my statement rather than engaging in a conversation. I'm happy to hear more stories.

← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →