HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sepositus

527 karma · joined February 4, 2025

Often present the minority view on HN (and pay the karma price).
submissionscomments
sepositus··on Percentage of parents financially supporting adult children reaches 3-year high
In six years? We're talking pre-COVID graduations for both of us. I also started out making $1,200 a month in the U.S military. I chose the military precisely because I grew up in a very poor area where drug use and gang killings were rampant (my parents moved into a relatively affluent neighborhood shortly after I left).

So, your bullet points don't really describe my experience.

sepositus··on Percentage of parents financially supporting adult children reaches 3-year high
My sibling and I are about 6 years apart and the difference is astounding. They have no income, savings, and are still living with my parents. I have several kids, own my home, and have a large emergency fund. I still haven’t quite figured out what had created such a large difference.
sepositus··on Yale professor who studies fascism fleeing US to work in Canada
> Sounds like a good solution. Not having children then I should also have the choice to not pay any tax towards other people's children's education.

I'd certainly be in favor of that. I don't expect anyone to subsidize my children's education. Granted, as one commenter pointed out, some people believe it to be a societal good (like state-sponsored health care), so you're likely to get a lot of pushback.

But I think the current system lacks the correct incentives. My theory is that free market competition among public schools, similar to what we have in universities, will align the incentives more than they do now. The first step is introducing consumer choice back into the system.

sepositus··on Yale professor who studies fascism fleeing US to work in Canada
> Well you can take them there, you just need to move.

This is what I meant earlier. Since you don't see a problem here, we're basically just talking past each other. The fact that I can't register my child within any school in driving distance represents a problem to me.

> So other people in that district should disproportionately support your child's education compared to what you are?

This is a symptom of the broken system that I am trying to present here. There are many existing proposals to amend it. For example, allow parents to use the taxes they are paying with any school. If I pay $5k in taxes annually, and the school 20 miles away pays $10k annually, then I can make up the $5k myself. The point is that I have a choice.

sepositus··on Yale professor who studies fascism fleeing US to work in Canada
> Secondly, I am confused as to what you think should be done. Because it appears that you do not like paying a lot of tax money but expect there to be affordable quality education available?

I shouldn't be locked into a specific school based on where I live. If there's a school 20 miles away that I think would be a better fit for my children, I should be able to take them there. Basically, I'm arguing for a free market.

sepositus··on Yale professor who studies fascism fleeing US to work in Canada
Doesn't that feel a bit disingenuous? It sounds like you might be coming from a very privileged background and haven't been placed in a similar situation that is primarily outside of your control. It also seems to suggest that I haven't spent my years as a parent trying to do the best for my children (i.e., raising my income).

Besides all that, it seems like you simply disagree with the fact that this is a problem at all. If that's the case, we can agree to disagree.

sepositus··on Yale professor who studies fascism fleeing US to work in Canada
> Secularism is the principle of seeking to conduct human affairs based on naturalistic considerations, uninvolved with religion. It is most commonly thought of as the separation of religion from civil affairs and the state and may be broadened to a similar position seeking to remove or to minimize the role of religion in any public sphere.

That's the introduction from Wikipedia, which matches my understanding of the definition. It's not synonymous with atheism. However, given its stated mission of minimizing religion, it seems like it would be relatively unconcerned if atheism were to be treated more favorably.

sepositus··on Yale professor who studies fascism fleeing US to work in Canada
I'm not immediately aware of any studies, but I would be shocked if there wasn't a correlation. Low-income families have a higher probability of raising children in a dysfunctional home who then become a burden on the local school district. Respectable teachers then flee these schools for better opportunities. This part isn't conjecture, as I'm recounting personal testimonies of teachers who have come and gone from my town. Whether this is a widespread issue, or how much of the problem it represents, I cannot confirm.
sepositus··on Yale professor who studies fascism fleeing US to work in Canada
This completely ignores the problem. I shouldn't have to sell my house and move to go to a school I can drive my kids to.

But, to answer your confusion, the median house price almost doubles in this area. So it's economically infeasible.

sepositus··on Yale professor who studies fascism fleeing US to work in Canada
How about sending my children to the school 20 miles away that is doing orders of magnitude better than my local district? Not an option apparently. Even tried several routes, including appealing to the school board, and I'm effectively ignored on every attempt.

Anyways, moving is not an option for me, as I have local dependents that I am responsible for taking care of and who would be abandoned if I left.

sepositus··on Yale professor who studies fascism fleeing US to work in Canada
> Stanley said this order sets the country “on a path to educational authoritarianism”.

Paying large sums of taxes for a school that is unquestionably failing my children, with no option to attend another school (without shelling an unfathomable amount of money for private schooling), feels like educational authoritarianism to me.

sepositus··on Dagger: A shell for the container age
I happen to know Nix, but it’s from previous experience where I also learned to greatly dislike it. Anyways, did an interview yesterday where the company was using Nix to build and they were completely shocked I had Nix experience.

So yeah, no where near eating anyone’s lunch, let alone the behemoth that is Docker.

sepositus··on Building a Firecracker-Powered Course Platform to Learn Docker and Kubernetes
Cool platform. Really keen on seeing the Dagger course finished.
sepositus··on Sell yourself, sell your work
All of the places I've worked at that have come close to this style of self-promotion have been dominated by kingdom builders and professional bullshitters.
sepositus··on Project Operation Whitecoat (2010)
You might be interested in reading Walz vs New York [1] for some background on this subject. As with most things, it's nuanced, but you essentially have two choices here: tax the churches or don't. Most have agreed that the former has a much greater risk of violating separation of church vs state (excessive government entanglement) than the latter. You're free to disagree, of course.

[1]: https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/397/664/

sepositus··on Whose code am I running in GitHub Actions?
Yes, this is a crucial distinction to make. The fact of the matter is that you have to treat GitHub Actions like a compromised system. Sure, there's not a ton of steps you can take for protecting builds if it's your primary builder, but you can for example not hook up an AWS account with full admin privileges to it (which I've seen more times than I would have like to).
sepositus··on Project Operation Whitecoat (2010)
> These are women who wanted the baby

That's an interesting point. I haven't interviewed an extensive number of post-abortive mothers, so my view is, of course, not representative of the whole, but in those few cases I have (via my community work), this was universally true. In every case, there were external factors pressuring the mother to abort the baby despite her motherly instincts pushing back on it at every level. Sometimes, it was a controlling boyfriend, parents, or some other peer pressure. In each case, though, the mother was left scarred for life.

I wish more people would openly talk about this.

sepositus··on Project Operation Whitecoat (2010)
In general, I prefer not to impose my views on people via the government. If the majority of people feel having "in God we trust" on the currency is beneficial, then so be it. If they don't, I won't stand in their way.

The only place I will push back is removing tax exemptions from churches, as this breaks the fundamental separation of church and state the other way. It gives states power over churches via taxation.

sepositus··on Post Apocalyptic Computing
Or just get lucky and end up with a Dr. Stone [1] :)

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dr._Stone

sepositus··on Project Operation Whitecoat (2010)
I suppose this will surprise you, but I'm strictly against religion and government mixing. When Jesus said, "My Kingdom is not of this world," I take that very seriously. It's why I've never associated with the Republican party, which has increasingly high-jacked the evangelical vote.

I'm not sure why you're accusing me of trivializing anything. I'm simply commenting on the religious discussions on HN and how I usually find them sorely lacking. But I wouldn't expect any different, considering most "hackers" tend to be secular in my experience, which is fine.

sepositus··on Project Operation Whitecoat (2010)
I don’t usually expect nuanced theological discussions here. It’s usually the equivalent of bumper sticker comments.

The “appetite” for Young Earth Creationism amongst my Christian group is very low if nonexistent. In fact we often spend more times groaning at the antics this crowd gets into.

sepositus··on The Software Engineering Identity Crisis
I suspect a large part of the problem is a lack of experienced engineers with the capacity to do interviews. As someone who often gets stuck with them, I can attest to how draining they can be, especially if you're doing them correctly. The problem is that it's _these_ engineers we need running the interview because they can pretty quickly pick out a fraudulent candidate from an exceptional one while giving both the option to use AI. I generally only need about 30 minutes to confidently assess whether someone is worth pushing further in the process.

But while HR would love to make me a full-time interviewer, it rarely makes business sense. So we end up with unqualified people using what they were told are good signals for hiring talent.

sepositus··on The Software Engineering Identity Crisis
More than ever modern interviews are pointless. I just finished an SRE technical interview where I had to efficiently solve a problem around maximizing profit in a theoretical market setting. I’m guessing it was just a reframed leet code question. Yet not moments earlier they were talking about their needs with increasing visibility, improving deployment times, etc. At some point this has to break, right? If the article indicates anything, it’s exactly those high level analytical skills they should be testing. I almost think allowing AI would be even better because it allows a conversation about what it got wrong, where it can be improved or is not applicable, etc.
sepositus··on Meta pirated at least 101 of my books, and others
I’m not sure that’s the whole picture. Followed to the logical conclusion, everyone should have the right to pirate whatever books they want and then feed them into a local LLM. Which leads to less kickback to the author, which means they can’t sustainably write, and we end up in a worse off situation.
sepositus··on 'Dark oxygen': a deep-sea discovery that has split scientists
This is more or less my view. However, when I say the "humans are bad" group, I mean the people basing their decisions purely on emotion or virtue and who are usually incapable of coming up with such a nuanced view. The same goes for the other extreme.
sepositus··on I fear for the unauthenticated web
I understand where you're coming from, I'm just saying there's been many companies I've worked for where protecting the user _was_ the most profitable play. And that's what we did. Yes, you're less likely to see it in bigger corporations with ecosystem lock-in (like Apple) because the math begins to sway towards exploiting users being more profitable.
sepositus··on I fear for the unauthenticated web
The argument is that there's less profit in selling out user trust. Of course, this heavily depends on the context, especially if you have a regulatory lock-in where users can't leave. However, there are cases where keeping user trust _is_ the profitable route.
sepositus··on 'Dark oxygen': a deep-sea discovery that has split scientists
> I live in a city. Building it destroyed some wilderness to give half a million people somewhere to live. I think that was a very good thing.

This is likely going to be the point of disagreement. Depending on where someone falls in the spectrum, their beliefs can range anywhere from humans are bad and should die to protecting and growing human life at all costs.

sepositus··on Teaching a new way to prevent outages at Google
Exactly this.
sepositus··on Teaching a new way to prevent outages at Google
I'm not sure if things have changed over the past five years, but this is exactly the stuff you'd throw in a promotion packet or maybe in a performance (perf) review to hit that mythical "superb" rating.

The breaking point for me (and why I left after almost a decade) was when people started getting high ratings for fixing things they had an original hand in causing. Honestly, the comfiest job in the world if you're a professional bullshitter.

← PreviousPage 5 of 9Next →