HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sgeisler

263 karma · joined January 8, 2018

submissionscomments
sgeisler··on The new Clang _ExtInt feature provides exact bitwidth integer types
Since I had to implement something like that in rust for a base32 codec [1] a few years ago I really like the idea. Although my main concern was ensuring that invariants are checked by the type system, which might not be as much a concern in c with its implicit conversions?

[1] https://github.com/rust-bitcoin/rust-bech32/blob/master/src/...

sgeisler··on Surge of virus misinformation stumps Facebook and Twitter
If you make it sound as if they didn't help on an individual level that's clearly misinformation (intentional or unintentional). That due to shortages there might be adverse societal effects is another matter.

I'd argue that it's intentional misinformation so that people make potentially[1] suboptimal personal decisions that lead to better outcomes for society at large. But that's not their call to make. Give me the facts and I'll decide for myself. Otherwise prepare to be called out.

[1] That might or might not be the case depending on personal risk profiles and dependence on a functioning society. Also: a functioning society is worth little to a dead rational actor.

sgeisler··on Verizon/Yahoo Blocking Attempts to Archive Yahoo Groups – Deletion: Dec. 14
It's actually not totally insane anymore. If you could afford a Tesla Roadster you can build yourself a 4PB storage solution. With some high density top loading storage servers (4HE for 90 HDDs), 6TB HDDs and some SSDs thrown in for caching you can build that in 36HE for less than 300k$ (not counting time needed to assemble and configure). So if that's your hobby, go ahead :D If one takes more than 5 minutes to research this I'm pretty sure that it's possible to push that number below 250k$.
sgeisler··on The evolution of the web, and a eulogy for XHTML2
I'm aware of this workaround, but it's still a sad state of affairs, especially since POSTs have to be handled with more care because they aren't idempotent. So the browser will warn the user if they really want to resend the query if something goes wrong the first time.
sgeisler··on The evolution of the web, and a eulogy for XHTML2
I once searched for a way to send PUT requests using HTML forms because I despise using JS for core functionality but still wanted to build a nice REST API. Somehow I stumbled across XForms which was part of XHTML2 and supports PUT and DELETE only to find out that no browser supports it.

Now I hope that the form extensions proposal [1] will gain some traction.

[1] http://cameronjones.github.io/form-http-extensions/index.htm...

sgeisler··on Open Libra: An open platform for financial inclusion
My main disappointment was that it's synchronous. Synchronous BFT algorithms seem like an old and already solved problem, with many already existing implementations. So I don't see exactly why you'd develop your own, especially since it's quite hard to get right. Maybe I missed some revolutionary performance increases back when I read the paper.

Imo async BFT algos are much more interesting since they can actually fit the attacker model of an open network like the internet. Nobody can give you any guarantees (in an absolute sense) about message delivery times and hops can arbitrarily delay your messages.

sgeisler··on Open Libra: An open platform for financial inclusion
> But that's affected mostly by factors other than money supply?

That's a good point. I think the "mostly" is highly dependent on the rate of "money printing" and where exactly this money goes. But the Libra/Fiat rate might not be necessary anymore as an indicator once it becomes a useful indicator because of rising consumer good prices.

> BTC does not provide price stability.

If bitcoin gets adopted more widely and has a bigger market cap the volatility should go down. The supply shocks every ~4y due to the block reward halving are getting smaller too. But sure, a free market money will never be as stable as a currency with central bank interference. For me that's not a bug but a feature, it doesn't shield market participants from economic realities, so they can actually adapt.

sgeisler··on Open Libra: An open platform for financial inclusion
The value in libra isn't in some novel technical concept. From what I have seen they made some ugly trade-offs to make the whole thing scale, invented their own not-state-of-the-art BFT algorithm and invented a new programming language for smart contracts that looks a bit saner than the EVM stuff.

The real selling point is the partnership with major payment services, CC companies etc. If it succeeds you might be able to pay with libra at every POS terminal and that would be huge. If the base layer is as permissionless as advertised that could even be used to build proxies that allow Bitcoin payments at every POS terminal.

The second interesting idea is the monetary basket backing it. That would take some control out of government's hands and would discourage overly reckless money printing since people would have a damn easy way of both detecting it (e.g. looking at the Libra/€ price) and opting out (buying Libra). If all big fiat currencies aren't stable enough even gold or BTC could be chosen as a backing asset.

If OpenLibra can't replicate this they have a totally worthless project, not much different from all the other altcoins out there.

sgeisler··on Why We Hate Taxes, and Why Some People Want Us To
Yeah, but that only works if you view your citizens as your "property" that works for you and doesn't move in and out of your country. If you view them as autonomous agents that move between jurisdictions to optimize their benefits in their current situation it doesn't.

For example (as a German citizen) you can go to university in Germany for free and move to a low tax country afterwards for work. When you are old and fragile you come back and use the healthcare system since your foreign insurance becomes too expensive (I'm not entirely sure about that loophole, but I heard it existed).

Of course there is some friction involved (friends, family in the home country). But which percentage of the population has to act rationally for the system to become unsustainable in the long run?

Most countries haven't adapted their policies to the reality of globalization yet. I fear some might go the way of the former GDR and try to keep their citizens from leaving. I heard even the US is doing something like that, it's said to be quite hard to get rid of a US citizenship (and the IRS).

sgeisler··on Advertising Is a Cancer on Society
That's only a problem if healthcare is taxpayer-funded. Otherwise it's your and your insurer's problem to price this in somehow, maybe even offering cheaper plans for people living healthy (e.g. meeting weight goals).
sgeisler··on Librem 5 Smartphone Final Specs
I think this first model is for enthusiasts who can afford it and want to fund the development. It won't be perfect yet. If you think about it as a donation it makes a lot more sense.
sgeisler··on Librem 5 Smartphone Final Specs
As someone who backed them in 2017 I'm so happy to finally see the specs. It's amazing to follow their progress, I love what they are doing with Gnome/Phosh, that gives me hope that there will be many native apps for the most important tasks and not just some web-app mess.

For the people complaining about the price/specs ratio: this phone is no standard off-the-shelve system, it had to be designed with user privacy and openness in mind while having a ridiculously small market. I'm amazed they did it so cheaply.

Personally I hope that they will be able to sell enough to continue development. Maybe this will lead to a second generation with multiple models for different market segments. I'd love a librem phone with a good old blackberry keyboard in the <1500$ price range with a little more RAM/CPU power and screws holding the back plate.

sgeisler··on The human body is already close to thermal limits in many regions
These green interventionist policies proposed to deal with the problem are a greater threat to the lifestyle of many people than the problem itself.
sgeisler··on The human body is already close to thermal limits in many regions
From my perspective the biggest thread to western lifestyle is the reliance on cheap labor in Asia (production) and Africa (mining). Their minimum livable pay might rise due to food shortages, need for AC etc. That could have a major ripple effect on many product and service prices. But maybe we will have even better automation by then so we can trade opex for capex.

But I only have shallow knowledge of the major supply chains, maybe someone with a deeper understanding can chime in.

sgeisler··on Adblocking: How about Nah?
> There's a massive drive to consolidation: people don't want to have a lot of subscriptions to manage.

Imo subscriptions aren't viable at all. For me to subscribe to something I need strong evidence that I will use it enough.

Automatic micropayments with a daily allowance seem like a much superior solution. They remove the friction of making the subscribe decision and keep the content creators in check by only paying for interesting content. Subscriptions can be easily forgotten or aren't annoying enough to bother to cancel them even if the provided content isn't worth it anymore.

sgeisler··on Calibra – Digital Wallet for Libra
Let's see if they will allow non-custodial wallets for libra, that might make them the catalyst that enables real world bitcoin payments. There could be a service that pays libra invoices for you if you send them bitcoins. If this happens automated/transparently in wallets that would be a big step forward. Let the POS terminal tell you which currency it wants and your wallet will send it. If they want USD send libra, if they want BTC send BTC via lightning. Switching from accepting USD to BTC would become seamless (e.g. in case of increasing inflation).
sgeisler··on Calibra – Digital Wallet for Libra
As I understand it Calibra is a custodial wallet. I'd guess that transactions between Calibra users never hit the libra blockchain, so reverting them should be possible.
sgeisler··on Asian countries take a stand against the rich world’s plastic waste
As a counterpoint: I live in Germany where we have such a system in place. When I went to the US for a few months not having such a system in place actually felt liberating. Suddenly I didn't have to worry about storing bottles, how to get them back to the store, etc. I just threw them into the recycling bin.

This might not be a problem for families or people that actually plan their grocery shopping and go there by car to buy for a whole week. But for me as someone who just stops at the store every day on the way home to get whatever I need it's really hard to bring empty bottles back to the store (I won't carry around empty bottles all day).

sgeisler··on Linux support on Lenovo personal systems
Maybe that will give them a reason to publish an official linux driver for the fingerprint reader.

Currently there only seems to be a reverse engineered prototype: https://github.com/nmikhailov/Validity90

sgeisler··on Blendle ditches pay-per-article service
The concept of micro transactions isn't the problem imo. The lack of automation is.

If there was a browser plugin that automatically paid up to x$ if an authorized website asks for it, but never more than y$ per month that would be a good compromise between subscription model and single article purchases. There would be the initial authorization, but after that no further interactions. The news website, instead of displaying a paywall, could talk to the plugin to facilitate the payment.

As long as you'd be fine of loosing up to y$ in case of a bug/hack/whatever this should work fine. If publishers were to increase prices they had to fear to cross the yolo-line of x$ and the user being explicitly asked for consent, that should keep them in check too.

sgeisler··on Buyer's Remorse: High Debt and Low Pay Leave Some College Grads Rueful
German student here: sure, university is mostly free, but that leads to people taking their time, resulting in regulations about how long you are allowed to study, leading to all kinds of bureaucratic tricks like switching majors, getting your semester counter decremented for work in the student council, etc. But generally my life as a student is quite pleasant (didn't fail exams, so I'm still on track time wise).

The thing that I'm worried about is the reaction of these all-inclusive countries once they see a rise in "education arbitrage": get your degree in Germany, then move to the US to pay less taxes (and make more money in case of CS) and optionally move back once you want/have children. On a long time scale that could bleed a country of resources. And I fear they could get the idea of making people stay somehow.

sgeisler··on Show HN: Rust Library to check your Internet connectivity
That could even be used to return an enum instead of bool: Online, CaptivePortal with the URL as member and Offline.
sgeisler··on An experiment shows how to rebuild human compassion
> Imagine telling someone they have the chance to spend an hour inside the world of a refugee. Who would agree, and who would avoid it? Chances are, people who don’t want to empathize wouldn’t want to enter an “empathy machine” at all.

Isn't avoiding such unpleasant situations one of the main reasons why people try to make more money, move into nicer neighborhoods, etc.? I'm not sure there is such a big market for "entertainment" that makes you feel bad.

Personally I see such devices as manipulative and a threat to rational thinking (like all dark patterns that prey on our instincts). Thus I'd try to avoid exposure to them.

sgeisler··on Germany proposes $2,800 fine for parents skipping measles vaccination
> Is it also cruel to let one unvaccinated child endanger the lives of thousands?

Right, that's immoral, but what I was getting at was that you can choose to not endanger anybody to a large extent even if you aren't vaccinated. The main problem are densely populated areas and public institutions. If you are just living on a farm in the middle of nowhere barely visiting the neighbor villages there is much less risk involved.

> I'm also fine with sequestering unvaccinated children and adults, but given Germany's history, that might not go over very well.

I know, I'm German, but the proposal itself bears some resemblance to forced sterilization during that time to "improve public health". It's one of the most tricky policy areas there are and should be handled with more care and consideration.

I totally agree that getting vaccinated is the right choice, but without consent it's abuse and if written as law it's tyrannic.

sgeisler··on Germany proposes $2,800 fine for parents skipping measles vaccination
That's just cruel, it takes away choice of people about their own bodies.

I totally see the point of this proposal, but you could achieve a better outcome with less authoritarian rules: just forbid non-vaccinated kids to go to public schools, kindergartens, to ride public transport, etc. That would still leave you with the choice of living away from other humans and taking care of your children at home without endangering anyone _and_ without taking away the right to control what happens to your body. In the end most people would choose to just get vaccinated.

I especially wonder what happens to people that just pay the fine, are their children still allowed to go to public schools? If yes you didn't really solve the problem, you just created another tax.

sgeisler··on Giving up on wlroots-rs
Not parent, but I'd think twice before contributing to a C code base I'm not completely familiar with in fear of causing some bug/CVE. Rust projects are much nicer for drive-by contributions to projects one uses but isn't generally interested in working on. If you are not working on a security critical part of a system you can be pretty sure not to cause severe bugs like RCEs.

Also for pure rust projects the development environment is easier to set up: cargo+rustc do everything vs. autotools+make+installing system wide libraries+ccache+gcc (just what I've seen in the wild).

sgeisler··on Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’
Why are people so concerned about autism, aren't there much worse conditions? I know many genius people that would probably fall into the spectrum if ever tested. They are typically obsessed with some field of research and develop deep insight, which is valuable in an increasingly specialized society.
sgeisler··on A Gazillion-Dollar Standoff over Two High-Frequency Trading Towers
From an outsider's point of view (still a CS student):

If you are a CS/Physics/Math person who loves to optimize systems then this is a good way to get paid for doing exactly that I guess. Many other problems/industries just require good enough solutions, with HFT it seems that most optimizations are worth it, which makes it so much more interesting.

sgeisler··on An Alternative to the American Way of Innovation [video]
Yes, I understand that, but if there weren't copyright laws we wouldn't need a CC0 license for example, because it would be the natural state of affairs: you can do whatever you want.

And afaik MIT, BSD and Apache just add the duty of mentioning the author, which has no practical implications on the usage of the software. At least I wouldn't care if someone actually writes my name somewhere. If someone asked me to relicense software I wrote as CC0 (and it was formerly MIT) I'd happily do so.

That means that the open source movement doesn't depend on IP laws. Some projects might still depend on it, like the linux kernel (because of GPL) but bitcoin for example doesn't (MIT). Both strategies work in practice.

ADDENDUM: What I want to say is: for many projects IP laws don't have any positive effects, they just add friction by requiring the author to add (and think about) a license.

sgeisler··on An Alternative to the American Way of Innovation [video]
You can make this argument when it comes to GPL software, since it forces you to open source your changes if you want to ship them. But does it hold for MIT licensed software (or if you are picky about attribution CC0)? Couldn't the existence of MIT or CC0 licensed open source projects disprove that

> that model only exists if you respect the rule of law and specifically conventional copyright

because these licenses are basically blank checks to do with the software whatever you want? They don't really depend on the existence of any IP laws.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →