HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sgeisler

263 karma · joined January 8, 2018

submissionscomments
sgeisler··on An Alternative to the American Way of Innovation [video]
> But artisanal hardware is an intellectual dead end.

I agree that this model of iterative improvement won't yield the next big technological breakthrough. But the big consumer electronics manufacturers aren't really innovating either. They might make a product a little bit flatter or give it another camera, but I can't think of a real game changer in the last five years.

Once all the technology is there and just improves iteratively the described model seems to be better suited to find as many local optima in the possible product space as possible (and not just a few big ones).

I could see how a lack of patents would lead to more secrecy in R&D labs. If what you are doing is truly novel and complicated (like developing a smaller node type in processor manufacturing) keeping the research secret would keep you as safe from competitors as patents. And if you aren't (like inventing rounded corners on smartphones) then you shouldn't have gotten the patent in the first place imho.

sgeisler··on An Alternative to the American Way of Innovation [video]
This model is definitely better at serving niche markets.

For example there are phone manufacturers in China that don't follow the silly trend of making phones slimmer, more fragile and with smaller batteries. Another example are mini notebooks like the GPD Pocket and its many clones which you can (could? haven't looked in a while) only get from china.

I'm a happy user of both product categories and don't think any western company could have been convinced to build these. The market is just too small.

Since I find myself in these small markets quite often (I love robust/rugged devices, phones with hardware keyboards, open hardware, ...) that's a super useful development for me. And I think there are more people like me, maybe with different wishes, but in similarly small markets, that would profit from more product diversity and easier customization of products.

sgeisler··on You Do Not Need Blockchain: Popular Use Cases and Why They Do Not Work
> If you put 20 BTC into an exchange (in promise for 550 ETH or whatever), but the exchange goes bankrupt... you lose both your BTC and your ETH. You have to go through the courts to try to get your money back.

That's actually solvable with atomic swaps [1]. They anable you to trustlessly exchange crypto currencies at an agreed on price.

[1] https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Atomic_swap

sgeisler··on A faster, more efficient cryptocurrency
@root_axis (since I can't reply directly):

> PoW systems are the only ones where "higher value transactions" need security proportional to their size.

Every other currency is either backed by men with guns and transactions are reversible (fiat) or you have to spend a roughly proportional amount of resources securing it (e.g. gold). I didn't look at the data, but judging by US military spending I'd guess that the strongest economies also have to spend the most to keep their system safe.

You can still argue that the assumption of pseudonymous actors in bitcoin makes the proportion factor larger (=system less efficient) than for systems that can use identities and attribution and I'd agree with that. But that's only because it can operate with less assumptions (no identities), which I see as a feature.

sgeisler··on A faster, more efficient cryptocurrency
> sufficiently trustworthy

Trustworthiness always depends on your use case.

If you are transacting small amounts of money (less than is spent on mining a block) then waiting for 3 confirmations is probably sufficient to consider the transaction settled. But what if you send a transaction with a 100 times higher value than goes into mining a block then you will need to wait for over 100 confirmations till you can be sure it doesn't make economical sense for anyone to try to double spend your transaction by orphaning the first block your transaction was in (with a very simplified incentive model not taking into account other transactions in these blocks).

Thus the money spent on mining blocks determines how much value can be transferred in one block. Allowing for higher value transactions is good thing imo, is necessary for its success as digital gold and therefore justifies the higher energy consumption (especially since there don't seem to be any alternatives with similarly good or better robustness against attacks yet, proof of stake can't work under the same assumptions bitcoin does [1]).

[1] https://download.wpsoftware.net/bitcoin/new-pos.pdf

sgeisler··on Distributed web not ready for Runet cutoff from the Internet
At least bitcoin will be mostly unaffected since you can receive blocks via satellite [1] and if even one satellite connected node is inside Runet then you can at least keep up with the blockchain. Sending transactions can be done via sms [2]. The main problem would be mining in Russia, but if miners know about the shutdown in advance and it's economically feasible then they can get satellite internet to upload found blocks.

[1] https://blockstream.com/satellite/

[2] https://twitter.com/SamouraiWallet/status/954271930365947904

sgeisler··on Volt: Fast native desktop client for Slack and Skype
> not every closed source stuff is evil, really

But how do you know that this closed source software isn't evil? You can't distinguish without an audit by a competent person you trust. Most closed source software isn't audited to a level that I'd deem sufficient for my security.

The problem is even worse: proprietary software has a single owner that can be coerced into including (even targeted) backdoors by state level attackers.

If I really want to run proprietary software I typically try to containerize it or even run it in VMs.

sgeisler··on Librem 5 Hardware Update
If "tools" meant some sort of screw driver I'd welcome that. If there are any parts that have to bend to open the case these will break in the long run and are less reliable in my experience (e.g. the phone's back would slide off when pulling it out of the pocket, experienced that with my old BB Q10).

Some really small torx screws that can't fall out of their holes even when loose would be optimal. If they also shipped a little screwdriver that fits onto one's key chain I'd be more than happy with that solution.

sgeisler··on No Tuition, but You Pay a Percentage of Your Income if You Find a Job
> But then such schools that predominantly work on ISAs, will pre-select for good students, who are most likely to succeed and also for industries where the compensation is higher.

That actually sounds like a good incentive structure to me. Most people shouldn't study something that will not give them some advantage (which these schools would select for).

If you struggle to make ends meet it wouldn't be a reasonable decision to study something unprofitable in the first place. I wish it was different and everybody could invest an infinite amount of time to learn what they are interested in, but in a resource constrained reality that's not possible and individuals have to make decisions that are advantageous for them.

sgeisler··on We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on Ethereum Classic
* Trustless time stamping to proof that you had certain information at a certain point in time without revealing it https://opentimestamps.org/

* (depending on your stance on personal liberty) censorship resistant, pseudonymous e-cash/e-gold (Bitcoin)

sgeisler··on Crev: dependency vetting with a web of trust
I guess you will trust coworkers, people you know irl, well known developers, companies you pay for review subscriptions. You don't have to trust all of them 100%if you require multiple reviews per dependency.
sgeisler··on Crev: dependency vetting with a web of trust
It doesn't, but now both the original author and some number of independent reviewers have to do stupid things in order to cause harm. That's an improvement to the current situation where you mainly trust the author in most cases.

A review is only valid for a specific version/hash of a set of files, so if you only upgrade your dependencies once they have enough trusted reviews you should be safe.

sgeisler··on Crev: dependency vetting with a web of trust
Imo this is the missing puzzle piece (and the more important one for me personally) for software supply chain security, the other ones being deterministic builds and signed binaries.

And the real problem aren't even people trying to steal your bitcoins [1], you notice that and hopefully had not all your eggs in one basket, it's a (sometimes expensive) lesson in IT security. The much more serious threat are state level actors trying to backdoor secure communication channels, the breach will happen without your knowledge. One shouldn't expect that every nation will take the obvious and public route like the Australian government [2], simply demanding access. With enough resources it seems totally viable to backdoor just one deep dependency of some UI framework and circumvent all end to end encryption used by affected apps.

I hope distributed code review will get some traction not only in the Rust world, but in the whole open source universe.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18534392

[2] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/12/signal-to-austra...

sgeisler··on 12 Factor CLI Apps
I imagine this to be a little bit over the top in most cases. A standard flag like --complete-rahyeiB1 (with a sufficiently long random string to avoid collisions with existing flags) which takes the already written argument list as an argument and prints possible completions would be nice though.
sgeisler··on Bitcoin's Use in Commerce Keeps Falling
> Another fork of bitcoin.

That's factually wrong. Lightning is a protocol on top of Bitcoin (like HTTP is built on TCP) and not a fork.

It has a different set of trade offs: transactions on it are instant, but one should only store small amounts on it (like what you would carry in your purse) since your money on it can be stolen if you are offline for too long (and you did not pay someone to monitor the network for you). But as long as you are online often enough your funds are secure.

If someone is curious how it works: https://lightning.network/

sgeisler··on [dead]
The original article [1] referenced is interesting, but I'm not sure if the proposed algorithm is useful in a completely unauthenticated and decentralized network, since it makes assumptions about identity of nodes and the latency between them. Are these chosen "observer" Nodes doing any PoW? Otherwise I assume this is a nice vector for a sybil attack.

PS: Could the link be changed to the original paper [1]? The linked article doesn't add much and shows ads.

[1] https://vitalik.ca/general/2018/08/07/99_fault_tolerant.html

sgeisler··on Amazon Charges Couple More Than $1,000 to Ship Paper Plates
> but I don't see how this case would have gone differently

If you have to make a conscious decision to transfer money first before they ship anything I guess you would notice that $1000 for some plates is a bit much.

A good example for this is paypal (even though I don't like them as a middleman): whenever I pay something using it I am redirected to their website and am shown what I will pay to whom in return for what and money only leaves my account if I confirm the transfer.

> 1-click to purchase

Well, 1-click buying is an anti-feature for me: it promotes impulsive, non-batched and probably quite often unnecessary buying and makes the whole process less transparent (what lead to this incident).

sgeisler··on Amazon Charges Couple More Than $1,000 to Ship Paper Plates
This also highlights one of the most ridiculous properties of many payment methods/how we handle money in general. Both credit cards and bank accounts allow others to just "pull" money from them [0]. To me this is such a silly feature (bug): it's like letting anyone send emails in your name if you don't regularly check your sent folder to cancel fraudulent outgoing mails.

The story described in the article would not have happened if our payment methods were all "push"-based. E.g. if you want to protect buyer and seller, a protocol could look like this:

1. select items to buy

2. send money to a trusted 3rd party (e.g. amazon)

3. the vendor ships the items or you can claim back your money in a predefined time frame

This could even be done without a trusted third party if the used money was programmable [1].

[0] having grown up in Germany where cash and debit cards are the main payment methods (and knowing much securer systems), finding out about this was quite a shock back then

[1] https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Multisignature

sgeisler··on The crypto alternative
For example "irrevocability of transactions" is fixable by introducing arbitrators. This has the huge benefit of making the trade off explicit and still allowing for irrevocable transactions. With 2-of-3 multi-sig escrow services can be implemented in a decentralized and trust less way (if both parties agree no escrow agent has to be involved).

Handling private keys has also become much simpler in the past years due to hardware wallets and hierarchical deterministic keys. But I can see why someone could not want to be responsible for the safekeeping of their savings.

sgeisler··on Facebook to change user terms, limiting effect of EU privacy law
I'd be interested if you could ask your users if they are _not_ a EU resident. Only if they click yes go ahead, otherwise show that you will not serve them. Probably 90% would learn to click the "Not from EU" button. Who should hold you accountable for false user input in that case?
sgeisler··on Cockpit – Administer Linux servers via a web browser
Thank you very much for clearing this up.

Since I'm not familiar with networkmanager in combination with other config: what happens if I configure some network interface using Cockpit that is already defined in /etc/network/interfaces.d/*? Will it just throw an error or could it bring my system into a broken/undefined state so that it wouldn't be reachable after the next reboot?

If the latter is the case it would probably be unwise to install/use Cockpit on an already configured system.

sgeisler··on Cockpit – Administer Linux servers via a web browser
I've just watched a presentation [0] linked by someone else in this thread and am quite impressed by the architecture and UX shown.

But it seems to me that Cockpit is more about monitoring and doing ad-hoc changes and not permanent configuration. I base that assumption on the fact that for example there are multiple places where one can configure network interfaces in debian and there is no cli tool or api to persist network configuration created with ip (at least to my knowledge). I can imagine parsing and editing fstab automatically and 100% correctly to be tricky too.

On the other hand enabling or disabling systemd services is permanent by default and there are probably more cli tools that automatically persist changes done through them.

Can anybody more familiar to Cockpit shed some light on the persistence of most of the configuration options?

[0] https://media.ccc.de/v/ASG2017-99-cockpit_a_linux_sysadmin_s...

← PreviousPage 3 of 3