HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sgillen

1,829 karma · joined February 16, 2016

Robotics engineer at NVIDIA. https://github.com/sgillen
submissionscomments
sgillen··on Skip: A programming language to skip the things you have already computed
I too would prefer := or even =!
sgillen··on Sci-Hub statistics and database
I would imagine it depends on the particular paper, the more experimental ones in CS, the more theory ones in math.

Do note though that most math and ML practitioners use arxiv over sci-hub.

sgillen··on OpenAI Chief Scientist Says Advanced AI May Already Be Conscious
Not sure why everyone is being so negative. Taken charitably the scientist is saying

"We don't currently have a mathematical definition for what consciousness is, but if we do develop one in the future, I would not be totally surprised if we learned that todays large neural networks (I assume here he is talking mostly about the recent gigantic language models) turn out to be conscious in some sense."

Maybe that's overly charitable, but that statement doesn't seem too unreasonable.

sgillen··on Why isn't there a replication crisis in math?
Yes but it's famous because it's the exception to the rule. It's definitely a failure to replicate, but that does not necessarily mean that math has a replication crises in the same way the social sciences do.
sgillen··on Why isn't there a replication crisis in math?
Did you read the article? This saga is explicitly mentioned and does not detract from the authors point IMO.
sgillen··on Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11k per article
Who is the target audience here? And who exactly is paying for this?

Researchers who care about open access can and do already upload their work to arxiv and/ or scihub in addition to publishing their work in formal venues.

sgillen··on Oh, 2022
How? In the fine print for most of these contracts it says something like “up to 1Gb, actual rates may vary based on network load” or something similar.
sgillen··on Launching Version 13.0 of Wolfram Language and Mathematica
Symbolic math in matlab is vastly inferior to Mathematica, and the deep learning and reinforcement learning toolboxes are vastly inferior to the offerings in python.

However for control system design or digital signal processing I think matlab is superior to both, I also think the matlab IDE is severely underated.

These are just from my experiences, I’m sure each of these languages have other applications where they are superior to the other too.

I also speak with privilege as someone who has access to all these packages for free so..

sgillen··on Launching Version 13.0 of Wolfram Language and Mathematica
I think Matlab is starting to realize this, at least at the institutional level they are starting to offer all the toolboxes for a fixed price (much much lower than buying all the boxes individually)
sgillen··on Better, cheaper, more abundant random numbers
Though I agree we have good solutions to this, I also think it's a more nuanced problem than it seems at first glance. See for example this stack overflow post: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/75677/converting-a-unifo.... To convert uniform to a Gaussian there are at least four different competing methods, all with subtle tradeoffs. Besides that there are certainly other continuous distributions we might be interested in transforming to, which are useful but not as nice as a Gaussian.
sgillen··on Revisiting the “Tsar Bomba” nuclear test
True, but the airplane still needs to leave the blast radius before the bomb impacts the ground, the 50MT version still needed a large parachute to meet that requirement.
sgillen··on Stephen Wolfram – re:Clojure Keynote [video]
I would bet most techy people my age (mid 20's) are aware of Wolfram Alpha, but maybe not Mathematica.
sgillen··on Ask HN: No diversity at university: how to make life more interesting?
I recommend trying to befriend some of the graduate students at your field. Maybe try to get involved with research with your professors. In my experience those who go for a PhD tend to be from a wider variety of backgrounds, and more intellectually curious.

I’m sure you can find these sorts of people in the regular student body as well, but they may be harder to find!

sgillen··on Ask HN: As an outsider, how could I publish a white paper?
Ah, I see what you are saying now. Have you seen this https://stackoverflow.com/questions/2819347/dijkstras-algori... stack overflow post yet? It seems to be provide a way to modify Dijkstra's to do what you want?

I'm not sure this is what you are looking for, but if that variant of Dijkstra's can be made to work you should probably include it as a comparison in any white paper you make!

sgillen··on Ask HN: As an outsider, how could I publish a white paper?
Are you certain you have not rediscovered a previously known algorithm? a common variant of Dijkstra's algorithm finds the shortest path from one node to all other nodes in a graph, using in O((V + E)log v) time and O(V + E) space (and can actually get a better big O with a Fibonacci heap, but no one uses this in practice).

So from reading your post, I'm not entirely sure what sets your algorithm apart!

If you do want to make claims about your algorithm being state of the art, I recommend trying to come up with a formal proof for the run time, and type up a manuscript in latex presenting the algorithm, a proof of correctness / runtime, and placing the algorithm into the existing literature. You can then try to send that to academics to read over, or submit to a conference as a solo author, if the work is good I don't think they will ignore you.

sgillen··on Web4 Should Run on LaTeX
Well the article title is clickbait, the author wants the web to move to plaintext, but doesn’t actually seem to suggest moving away from plain html and css.

(Still a bit silly though since the author does mention latex as an alternative too).

sgillen··on An ultra-precise clock shows how to link the quantum world with gravity
Yes but I think the idea of this new paper is to measure the effect of gravity on time dilation for a system that is also subject to quantum effects.
sgillen··on Why I Hate Frameworks (2005)
The closest analogy I can think of are just basic data structures. Dictionaries, lists, tuples, sets etc.
sgillen··on Ask HN: Is there a point to HN points?
At a certain number of points you can change the color of the banner at the top, so that’s pretty huge.
sgillen··on Smart kids should skip high school (2015)
I think the college experience in the US varies pretty widely depending on what sort of college you are at what you are studying, and your own attitude. An average state school, a small liberal arts college, an MIT/caltech, business school at Yale or Harvard. These will all be vastly different experiences.
sgillen··on Blaze: High Performance Vector/Matrix Arithmetic Library For C++
From the end of the article:

>> Blaze is certainly more tuned for performance and uses nefty techniques under the hood like padding, explicit loop-unrolling and turning divisions to multiplications to create more opportunities for FMA. However, aggressively tuning for performance implies more specialisations, more overloads, more “SFINAE” and so on and as result compiles slower than Eigen.

sgillen··on If You’re So Successful, Why Are You Still Working 70 Hours a Week?
True, but this article is about "insecure overachievers" who work at "elite professional organizations". I think there's a decent argument that these people are largely driven by prestige AKA social relevance.
sgillen··on Too much of a good thing: Mourning the slow death of the retail game store
Maybe the problem is that it’s much easier to make a game now than it was back then. But as a result people who maybe don’t really know what they are doing can make games using huge tech stack.
sgillen··on Y Combinator's Demo Day loses luster
Well raising money early is likely appealing to the founders of the companies, which may help YC attract better talent, creating a virtuous cycle.
sgillen··on How Computationally Complex Is a Single Neuron?
Do you believe that using a biological computer for research is ethically any different than an animal analogous intelligence in silicon?
sgillen··on The Assault on Empiricism
I don’t know, the article says people today are just ignoring “the data”, but you can make “the data” support almost any story you want.

You can (as this article does) point to crime statistics and say “see look, black people commit more crimes that’s why they are arrested by the police more”. Or you can say “look, the police are more likely to arrest black people even for minor offenses, which accounts for a difference in arrest statistics.” Same data, different story.

I also take issue with how some of the data in the article is presented. It claims with certainty that exactly 17 unarmed black men were killed by the police last year, but data on police shootings are notoriously unreliable. The article doesn’t even address this issue.

sgillen··on Ask HN: Best (not crippled) laptop configuration for AI/ML/RL?
Honestly for AI/ML/RL I would recommend spending your budget on a nice desktop workstation and remoting into it with whatever cheaper laptop you prefer.
sgillen··on Atlantic Ocean currents weaken, signalling big weather changes: study
Well I believe the droughts and wildfires are not really occurring in Siberia, which is the area I think some are speculating will become a breadbasket.

Edit: I was wrong.

sgillen··on The problem with reinforced concrete (2016)
Maybe if you want to invalidate those studies you can try leaving the knives out in the rain 10-100 days in a row!
sgillen··on Ask HN: What are some thought-terminating clichés in the software industry?
I would say this does not have to be thought terminating.
← PreviousPage 4 of 23Next →