HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sgt101

7,940 karma · joined January 24, 2012

nothing to see here, move along, move along.
submissionscomments
sgt101··on GPT-6 Astra
so like a novel or a working paper? Or notes?
sgt101··on GPT-6 Astra
That's approximated by the portals - the people building these go and look at Expedia for their flow and design ideas... so the information permeates across.
sgt101··on GPT-6 Astra
In what way do you think it learns?
sgt101··on GPT-6 Astra
I don't think it can learn from context, otherwise we could write Jane Eyre into it and it would be the novel? It's not learning as we conceive of it - it's another thing that we have labelled as "in context learning".

I have feelings, it needs to be able to empathise with me, or another driver, or a client...

sgt101··on GPT-6 Astra
Does it learn?

Does it experience?

Can it connect with other agents, understand them, come to empathise with them and find a way to work with them better?

The answer is no to all of these, and there are other problems as well. Yes, this model is trained to use a domain specific language to reason and plan over puzzle problems, and so it's programmers have cracked arc-agi-3 and that's a great achievement, but there is an asymmetry here. The arc team are well funded but are charged with providing a target for the vast ocean of funding, compute and talent everywhere else.

Most importantly, arc-agi-3 and the other benchmarks are all verifiable. The model can check if it's succeeded or not. They are not A* of course, but long horizon problems where you have to overcome minima to get the solution are not alien to AI either.

sgt101··on GPT-6 Astra
And the reason why there are 10 clicks is that that is the number of decisions that is required to get people to hand over their money.

There will have been an A-B test with 9 clicks -> less sales, less revenue.

There will have been an A-B test with 11 clicks -> less sales, less revenue.

The people making these sites are not dumb. They are also sitting on thin margins nowadays, and mostly from the airlines and hotels rather than from the users.

sgt101··on GPT-6 Astra
But, like, isn't that what Expedia does and has done for 20 years?
sgt101··on Nvidia agrees to acquire Hugging Face for $13B
There's a herding effect with torrents where popular things are quick to get, unpopular things may be very difficult to get, because the majority of users delete files to save space.

I might host 3 or 4 models that I've downloaded recently, but I won't be hosting the 50 or so that I've tried in the last two years.

sgt101··on Nvidia agrees to acquire Hugging Face for $13B
DISASTER.
sgt101··on My Friend Aaron
Good story, write more. You have a good NO AI style.
sgt101··on Beware the Permanent Periphery
There are problems with this analysis.

First it discounts the debt and financial load on the frontier labs to 0. The costs of developing this technology may well not be borne by those who reap the benefits. This is not like the Amazon distribution network.

Second it assumes that, like nuclear weapons, the technologies of frontier AI will not proliferate. I would argue that we have seen orders of magnitude reduction in compute requirements enabling sub linear improvement of scale driven AI in the last 24 months. Meanwhile 27bn param models do what trillion model parameters couldn't 12 mths ago. I think we're seeing a diversification of approach now, and it's not clear that the winners will be scale driven.

Third, and the most fatal, it assumes that AI will be the driver of power in the future geopolitical landscape. But frankly if I nuke you what will your clever machines do then?

This is not 1945 and this essay is essentially a note from a USA in the middle of an existential crisis channelling the 1950's.

sgt101··on CEO who fired 900 people on Zoom just before Christmas wants his job back
Apologise and donate his fortune to homeless charities?
sgt101··on The USSR in 100 Photographs
Worth watching Star City on Apple TV for a perspective on Soviet life. Now, Star City is definitely propaganda but it makes you think!
sgt101··on Muse Code and Muse Spark 1.2
Do you know a good place for accessing the full sized chinese models but hosted not in China?
sgt101··on Muse Code and Muse Spark 1.2
What I love is the idea that this is more likely to happen at Meta than at Anthropic, Google, Microsoft or OpenAI... or in the PRC!

There's contractual cover, there are lawyers all over the USA ready to make themselves very rich by creating a class action over it... you don't have to worry! Or, you do, but frankly, only MI6/CIA/Mossad can save you now.

sgt101··on Tiny black holes may be exploding stars across the Milky Way
Could this kind of trigger effect the standard candle application of Type 1a's? For example, if a black hole triggers a type 1a and that perturbs the type 1a light curve in some way (possibly because less mass could be consumed in the explosion than you would get if one was triggered by mass accretion) and the rate of triggering of this kind changed over time as the universe aged and somehow the population of primordial black holes changed, or the distributions of white dwarf candidates and pbhs changed...
sgt101··on Intelligence Is Not the Main Bottleneck
In what way do you mean iterations - what's your model for iteration as a mechanism for iterating intelligence? Do you mean that intelligence improves with every generation?
sgt101··on It's not a fear of "AI communism"; it's a fear of competitive market capitalism
Where are you subscribing ? z.ai?
sgt101··on Intelligence Is Not the Main Bottleneck
I hope you're joking about...

I think we both know the answer, but the answer very definitely isn't intelligence.

sgt101··on Intelligence Is Not the Main Bottleneck
As far as I know humans with the same sort of brains as your brain and my brain have existed for 100,000's of years, perhaps as long as 2 million years.

They did not go to the moon. They did not make mechanisms, they did not make pottery, they did not smelt iron, they did not press shapes onto clay and leave it in houses that burned down, they did not have houses.

All of that has come in the last 12,000 years. I think that there are people in the Amazon today who could not write or read a word, could not drive a car or solve an equation or argue a case or compose an algorithm who are as intelligent as me, or you, or more. I think that people like that have existed for more than a million years.

So if they were so smart, why didn't they go to the moon?

sgt101··on The next chapter of our AI momentum
"Onwards!"

These guys...

sgt101··on It's not a fear of "AI communism"; it's a fear of competitive market capitalism
>It's not wish casting whatever that means. The crux of the argument isn't as much of a capability one as it is an economic one. If China can release open source models like these to displace demand for frontier models so can American companies. It's just that it's not profitable enough for them to do so at this time.

I would back you if:

1) The American companies had not run up debts in the $100bn range. 2) If there was an open source business model that could create $100bn companies or pay down $100bn of debt. 3) There was a convincing moat such as a social media network effect - I mean that lasted 10 years or so for Meta - or ways for them to create a supplier based monopoly like MS did with IBM, Dell, Compaq,.. or Google has with Samsung and Apple. I think that it might be that the consumer use case could yet be tied to Samsung and Apple, so Google might do it again, but ATM I dunno if consumer use cases are the thing here.

>Do I believe you, or do I believe the people with trillions at stake. I believe the folks actually doing the work and with money at stake. I have yet to find a convincing argument otherwise.

Go look at SpaceX's shareprice.

You are being taken for a ride.

sgt101··on Linux desktop market share has hit over 10% in North America
I guess almost all laptops/desktops are corporate, student, gaming or own business use.

I have never, ever, seen a corporate linux desktop outside of devs.

I have never, ever, seen a student using a linux desktop apart from CS students and a few physics/maths.

Linux is not for gaming.

See above answers for Linux in own business.

sgt101··on The Silurian Hypothesis (2020)
Agree - although I think the records we have rule out a previous *Human* "civilisation", not to say that Humans with thousands and thousands of years of culture along with ideas we have no inkling of and would find fascinating have come and gone and bloomed and faded many many times.
sgt101··on The Silurian Hypothesis (2020)
My thoughts:

Civilisation implies large scale agriculture.

Large scale agriculture implies specific pollen signatures.

We don't see any of these signatures in the pollen records dredged up from lakes and seas.

There was no previous civilisation in the last 1.4m years (this is the depth of the pollen records we have I think).

sgt101··on How Do We Stop Vibe Coding?
This is what happens when you swap gatekeepers for drug pushers.
sgt101··on Why Software Factories Fail (or: harness engineering is not enough)
It's just he's qualified himself as an unreliable witness. This is not someone who deeply understands and thinks about what he does or what he advises.

The things that I know about, that he writes about, where I know he's got it a bit wrong.... I find myself questioning if he's right or not. Because he's a persuasive writer. But winning arguments doesn't make you right. This isn't a supported, balanced discussion it's a self aggrandising mismash of commonplace ideas and issues.

He's learned how to grab the mic, he believes he has the right to the mic, people are listening to him.. all three of these are wrong and until we call this out and put a stop to people like this shooting their mouths off damage is going to carry on being done.

sgt101··on Why Software Factories Fail (or: harness engineering is not enough)
This is interesting and all, but why should we believe any of it?

1) This guy has a track record (confessed) of making shit up, yapping on about it, and pushing it on the innocent. He's done a bunch of damage with his bullshit and now wants us to pay attention again. I mean - something something off fella.

2) There is NO EVIDENCE AT ALL that his ideas are good. He's just making stuff up.

Give me a reason. Also shouldn't he be ostracised and stripped of his wealth for his previous rubbish?

sgt101··on Inkling: Our Open-Weights Model
I think...

we will see!

sgt101··on Nativ: Run frontier open models locally on your Mac
converting a model to MLX is trivially easy as well - just a couple of lines of code and a few minutes wait.

I do find that it reliably crashes on the first try, but then it picks up from where it finishes and completes the conversion reliably.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →