HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sgt101

7,940 karma · joined January 24, 2012

nothing to see here, move along, move along.
submissionscomments
sgt101··on OpenAI O3 breakthrough high score on ARC-AGI-PUB
I thought that AlphaZero could play three games? Go, Chess and Shogi?
sgt101··on Early Bronze Age Butchered Human Remains from Charterhouse Warren, Somerset, UK
If you've ever been to a rural Somerset pub after 9pm this should come as no surprise.
sgt101··on The Bering Land Bridge was more like a swamp
that's what I think a lot of early humans probably did, shorelines are good places to get food.
sgt101··on The Bering Land Bridge was more like a swamp
My experience of virgin forest is that it's totally impassible - fallen trees and dense understory everywhere - really really difficult to move through, but perhaps I've just got a biased view due to low samples.

On the other hand I definitely don't think that humans would have had an easy time going through a swamp - but instead round the edges with access into the land up rivers for trapping and camping.

sgt101··on The Bering Land Bridge was more like a swamp
Super easy for humans to get around - much better than a forest. If you have canoes, fishtraps, fire and portable shelters as technology then a pretty good environment to live in as well. I should imagine that over a period of time people will have simply colonised the whole area and then colonised over into NA rather than migrating to follow game or for some other reason.
sgt101··on Always go to the funeral (2005)
It was my failure that hurt me, I think.
sgt101··on Always go to the funeral (2005)
I had a friend who died young, I was young as well. I went to his funeral and there was an opportunity to speak about him and our memories of him. No one stood up to speak.

It was awful. I wanted to stand up and say he was a good friend, and to say I would miss him, but I didn't.

I've regretted that ever since - 30 years now, and I think about it frequently.

sgt101··on Ask HN: Examples of agentic LLM systems in production?
LLM agents: not so much.

Actual real Intelligent Autonomous Agents - go to Mars, kick a rover... there's one. Go try front running on the markets, you'll meet about 6000 other ones trying to out run you.

sgt101··on The Antikythera mechanism – 254:19 ratio
https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0024x0g

Up to date and with a very good discussion of the 254:19 gearing.

Also much more detail on the history of the mechanism.

sgt101··on Amid cuts to basic research, New Zealand scraps all support for social sciences
I just can't find any reference to Thatcher cutting Russia studies, it's quite a strange thing to imagine given that she presided over the peak of the cold war. Could you help? I know that Blair closed great chunks of the foreign office and that has seriously impacted the UK's ability to represent its interested abroad, but that's not just Russia.

I find it hard to imagine what the UK could have done in terms of taking advantage at the end of the cold war. I mean maybe if we had all moved to Germany then we would have been well placed to get the benefits that those folks got. On the other hand we did, eventually, get to shut down the British Army of the Rhine which saved a lot of money, and a bunch of skilled labour from eastern europe migrated to the UK as well. What potential benefits from a Russian engagment could the UK have realised?

sgt101··on The case against Google's claims of "quantum supremacy"
There's a specific view (as I understand it) that QFT's don't scale https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10072 but some folks seem to dismiss this for reasons I just don't grok at all.
sgt101··on The Case Against Google's Claims of "Quantum Supremacy"
I think Shor's scales lineally, if it's possible to do the fine grain control of the most significant bits. Some people don't think that's a problem, but if it is then growing keys will be an effective defense.
sgt101··on The Case Against Google's Claims of "Quantum Supremacy"
Thank you for your work and perspective - it's important that science is carefully reviewed and that doing the review is well regarded.
sgt101··on The Google Willow Thing
I think this shows how bad the definitions for computing are, there's a big rethink needed, but unfortunately it needs a galaxy brain to do it!
sgt101··on The Google Willow Thing
I think the record for Shor's remains at 15.
sgt101··on The Google Willow Thing
I think that the big challenge is to recast any classical computations as quantum computations with a superpolynomial speedup.

I think that all classical problems can be cast as quantum computations because quantum computation is just computation - I believe that one can implement a turning machine using quantum gates, so arbitrary computation is possible with quantum gates.

The superpolynomial speedups are the thing.. I wonder if these will be limited to a class of computations that have no physical realization - just pure maths.

sgt101··on The Google Willow Thing
Will AI take that use case though?
sgt101··on The Google Willow Thing
Qualification: Quantum Algorithms that provide superpolynomial speedup, have an application, and don't need quantum memory or rely on quantum data.
sgt101··on The Google Willow Thing
no

not for the next 5 years for sure.

sgt101··on Google says AI weather model masters 15-day forecast
whelp...

Ok, how would you articulate an understanding of how the weather works?

Let's face it, it's not going to be easy to frame in natural language...

sgt101··on Willow, Our Quantum Chip
I think that this is now a very fringe position - the accumulation of reported evidence is such that if folks were/are fooling themselves it would now be a case of an entire community conspiring to keep things quiet. I mean, it's not impossible that could happen, but I think it would be extraordinary.

On the other hand the question is what does "real QC" mean? The current QC's perform very limited and small computations, they lack things like quantum memory. The large versions are extremely impractical to use in the sense that they run for 1000ths of a second and take many hours to setup for a run. But that doesn't mean that the physical effects that they use/capture aren't real.

Just a long long way from practical.

sgt101··on What Arm's CEO makes of the Intel debacle
Having visibility across the value chain should be very helpful - you can avoid committing to undeliverable products and at the same time anticipate demand from your customers. Overall you should be able to run the same thing on much lower margins and be in a position to out compete anyone who doesn't have the same advantage.

Unfortunately I think that the temptation is to give in to the "faster horse that eats less" requests and to accept "we just can't do that boz" on the other end. China seems to be moving to a model that couples integration with bouts of intimidatory violence and so far that seems to be working well, but it does have costs.

sgt101··on A transport protocol's view of Starlink
I wonder how they could do that if they are on 8 250MHz bearers?
sgt101··on A transport protocol's view of Starlink
Fascinating that the throughput is about 250mbs. Presumably that's over the area served by one satellite? I wonder how much cache they put in each one... I vaguely remember a stat that 90% of requests (in data terms) are served from a TB of cache on the consumer internet, perhaps having the satellites gossip for cache hits would work to preserve uplink bandwidth as well. Maybe downlink bandwidth is the thing for this network though and caches just won't work.
sgt101··on Boeing plea deal over fatal 737 MAX crashes rejected by judge
Unfortunately I think that's a hard yes - because these people don't have to accept these positions. I think that this kind of high stakes gambling is part of the problem here...

Much better to defuse responsibility in the executive suite and pressure shareholders in general to ensure good governance.

sgt101··on Boeing plea deal over fatal 737 MAX crashes rejected by judge
I think you are onto something. There's often a threat to make companies pay 4% of their global turn over or something, but it would be more effective to make them issue voting shares with a value of 4% of their equity to the goverment - who could then sell them. If stockholders were threatened with a 4% dilution then they'd be much more vigilant than if the company has to pay a fine - which in the end shareholders will pass on to customers.

Also I think that governments are wary of destabalising companies with big fines - especially banks. A shareholder dilution will not threaten the finances of structurally important entities.

sgt101··on Procedural Knowledge in Pretraining Drives Reasoning in Large Language Models
drives retrieval of patterns of procedure?

I mean - like for arithmetic?

sgt101··on Noise-canceling single-layer woven silk and cotton fabric
Why wouldn't you just quilt them up in lots of pockets and then attach them like wall paper?
sgt101··on Personality Basins
>Your personality is formed by a process conceptually similar to RLHF. You are first born with a set of traits in a given environment. After this, you perform many interactions with your environment. If an interaction goes well, you’re likely to do it more often, and if it goes poorly, you’ll probably do less of it.

first off 0 evidence presented, second off what about the kids that grew up stealing food in concentration camps or due to abusive parents. Do they grow up to be liars and thieves? Nope. What about all the kids that get nothing but positive vibes and turn into total arseholes...

I gave up reading immediately - just dumb.

sgt101··on Britain is building one of the world’s most expensive railways
I say again, we can either have a social democracy where we decide what the rule of law is with a plebiscite or we can have a libertarian rights based society where whoever has capital can decide what happens and no one can stop them.

If we run things based on voting then part of that is accepting that other people don't agree with you about what is and isn't a priority. They like their quiet lives and there are enough of them to influence elections.

← PreviousPage 13 of 34Next →