HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sgt101

7,940 karma · joined January 24, 2012

nothing to see here, move along, move along.
submissionscomments
sgt101··on AI and globalisation are shaking up software developers' world
I'm a managing consultant, so I don't have much time to do actual work (due to having to chat up clients and tell other people what to do). With cursor I can do what would have taken me an afternoon, previously, in an hour.

This is huge for me, because I can realise ideas and show people how to solve problems whereas bc (before cursor) I was reduced to saying "I'm sure that will work if we do it that way" and hoping that my folks would follow through on the thinking themselves.

Cursor supports me in two ways.

1) It gets things moving - I can put all the boilerplate and infrastructure to build something in place in a few minutes.

2) It removes road blocks. When I get stuck it gives me fixes.

Now I recognise it's all from Stack Exchange, basically, but it's a terrific interface for that knowledge.

What it doesn't do is provide new knowledge or ideas for fixing things. That has to come from upstairs still, but that's never been an issue for me.

sgt101··on AI and globalisation are shaking up software developers' world
I think Cursor is great, it's really boosted what I can do.

I think it's made me 3 -> 5x more valuable.

Now, maybe it's done the same for other people as well, but I think my co-efficient was high, and I continue to insist that I've never worked anywhere that had enough resource focused on software development. The demand has always massively exceeded the organisations ability to fund supply.

And, as many have noted lower costs can also boost demand.

Finally, off shore devs are on a longer cycle time for many reasons. If cost onshore are reduced then that cycle time will crush offshore competitive advantage. I don't see any prospect of me getting work from India or Indonesia, but I do see AI as a driver that will reduce work leaving the UK for other places.

sgt101··on AI and globalisation are shaking up software developers' world
What if you want to make things that are new?
sgt101··on Two new Gemini models, reduced 1.5 Pro pricing, increased rate limits, and more
We might see that with the inference ASICs later this year I guess?
sgt101··on Foundations: Why Britain Has Stagnated
"It may have been the greatest rapid expansion in a given economic sector in British history, and it was the key reason we didn’t experience a Great Depression while Germany, the USA, and France did. "

But Great Britain (as it was then) did experience a great depression. 3.5 million people were unemployed in 1932.

Ok - one could say that the depression in GB was less pronouced vs. the situation from 1918 on, but I think that there is a lot of cherry picking & spin in this article. Comparisons are not made consistently and the context from history mean some things matter less in the UK and matter more, and have happened for particular reasons. For example folks often talk about reservoirs, but fundamentally the UK's reservoirs were largely built to support an industrial demand that is simply not there - and this capacity remains despite the loss of demand.

There are some good points, but I think they are obscured by the polemic.

sgt101··on Terence Tao on O1
Super spreadsheet - very useful. Thank you for doing the work and sharing.
sgt101··on Craig Wright said he invented Bitcoin – lawyers proved him wrong
Well, you make it a capital office, or less draconian... make it an offense punishable by 10 years of hard labour in a dire penal camp somewhere cold.

In addition you make it an offense to fail to disclose knowledge of the use of such capabilities, and you institute a system of rewards to positively encourage disclosure.

Perhaps you call it social credit.

You are correct that there are a few people who would defy such a system, a very few.

sgt101··on Craig Wright said he invented Bitcoin – lawyers proved him wrong
The one fundamental that you have to understand about all government is that it is essentially a monopoly on violence. That monopoly enables things like taxation and broad social consensus and consent.

But, it's there, and if Bitcoin began to chip away at the core of any state you can expect it to be used.

Some people say that they can't take my gold. Some people say that they can't take my guns. But history says that they can and will and have.

sgt101··on Terence Tao on O1
Is there a list of discoveries or siginficant works/constructions made by people collaborating with LLM's? I mean as opposed to specific deep networks like Alphafold or Graphcast?
sgt101··on Effects of Gen AI on High Skilled Work: Experiments with Software Developers
Some say NIMBY's other say water supply.

"Water supply issues are already holding back housing development around the city. In its previous draft water resources management plan, Cambridge Water failed to demonstrate that there was enough to supply all of the new properties in the emerging local plan without risk of deterioration.

The Environment Agency recently confirmed that it had formally objected to five large housing developments in the south of the county because of fears they could not sustainably supply water. It has warned that planning permission for more than 10,000 homes in the Greater Cambridge area and 300,000 square metres of research space at Cambridge University are in jeopardy if solutions cannot be found.

A document published alongside the Case for Cambridge outlines the government’s plan for a two-pronged approach to solving the water scarcity issue, to be led by Dr Paul Leinster, former chief of the Environment Agency, who will chair the Water Scarcity Group.

In the long term, supply will be increased, initially through two new pieces of infrastructure: a new reservoir in the Fens will delivery 43.5 megalitres per day, while a new pipeline will transfer 26 megalitres per day from Grafham Water, currently used by Affinity Water.

But, according to Kelly, a new reservoir would only solve supply requirements for the existing local plan and is “not sufficient if you start to go beyond that” – a point that is conceded in the water scarcity document. "

https://www.building.co.uk/focus/a-vision-for-150000-homes-b...

sgt101··on Effects of Gen AI on High Skilled Work: Experiments with Software Developers
And yet we are told that competition will determine that capital and talent will flow towards that most efficient organisations over time. Thus, surely organisations that eschewed this practice would emerge and dominate?

So, either capitalism doesn't work, or your thesis isn't quite right...

I have two other counters to offer, first we have seen GDP per capita gradually increasing in major economies for the last 50 years (while the IT revolution has played out). There have been other technical innovations over this time, but I believe that GDP per capita has more than quadrupled in G8 economies. The USA and Canada have, at the same time, enjoyed a clear extra boost from fracking and shale extraction, and the USA has arguably enjoyed an extra extra boost from world dominance - but arguably.

The second one is simple anecdote. Hour for hour I now can do far more in terms of development than I did when I was a hard core techie in the 90's and 2000's. In addition I can manage and administer systems that are far more complex than those it took teams of people to run at that time (try running a 10gb size db under load on oracle 7 sitting on top of spinning rust and 64mb ram store for fun) I can also manage a team of 30's expenses, timesheets, travel requests and so on that again would have taken a person to do. I can just do these things and my job as well and I do it mostly in about 50 hrs a week. If I wasn't involved in my people's lives and happy to argue with customers to get things better I could do it in 40 hrs regularally, for sure. But I put some discretion in.

My point is - we are just more productive. It is hard to measure, and anecdote / "lived experience" is a bad type of evidence, but I think it's clearly there. This is why then accountants have been able to reorganise modern business organisations to use fewer people to do more. Have they destroyed value while doing this - totally - but they have managed to get away with it because 7/10 they have been right.

Personally I've suffered from the 3/10 errors. I know many of us on here have, but we shouldn't shut our eyes because of that.

sgt101··on How immigration remade the U.S. labor force
The people who used to live in the USA disagreed with you.

“A long time ago, this land belonged to our fathers, but when I go up to the river, I see camps of soldiers on its banks. These soldiers cut down my timber, they kill my buffalo, and when I see that, my heart feels like bursting.” – Satanta, Kiowa Chief

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Native_American_genocide_in_th...

But almost all of them have been killed and those that remain seem to lack a distinct political voice that's in any way relevant to the national discourse of the USA. All of those nation states that pre-existed "America" were, as you say, fucked.

sgt101··on Telephone Line Rural Outside Plant
uhmmm ok....
sgt101··on Telephone Line Rural Outside Plant
Yeah - there are colour codes you can use to find the pair that you want to connect, they are arranged in a mystical system of binders. It's like a map.
sgt101··on Telephone Line Rural Outside Plant
That used to be the case - but it's rapidly becoming standard to be directly connected to fibre. I believe that something like 60% of UK premises have a fibre connection available and I expect that all the providers will push folks off copper as fast as they can.

Because copper is a pain in the arse compared to fibre (for the provider). For the consumer copper has one key positive that fibre just doesn't - it works in a power cut.

sgt101··on Stonebraker Seeks to Invert the Computing Paradigm with DBOS
I think that they are more radical - it seems like they have implemented a unikernel that supports the database service and their claim is that that's all you need for app dev.

I think it looks rather similar (as a component) to something like snowflake - lots of data optimised services, but lower level with more app capability. The problem they will have is that a lot of the benefit that they are pushing is created by the big cloud data warehouses already, and the pain of a total re-implementation rather than re-architect or lift-and-shift completely terrifies most CIO's

sgt101··on OpenAI is good at unminifying code
I was with you until:

>If an LLM can interact with a browser and figure out how a UI works and take code hints from un-mimified code I think we could see all SAAS apps be commoditized. The backend would be proprietary, but it could figure out API formats and suggest a backend architecture.

whoooha! that's a lot of probing and testing of the SAAS that would be required in order to see how it behaved. SAAS aren't algorithms, they operate over data that's unseen on the front end as well...

>All this makes me think AI's are going to be a strong deflationary force in the future.

I don't get this. I've literally never worked anywhere which had enough software engineers, we've been going on about software crisis for about 50 years and things are arguably worse than ever. The gap between the demand for good software (in the sense that allocating capital to producing it would be sensible) and the fulfillment of that demand is bigger than ever. We just don't have the mechanisms to make this work and to make it work at an economically viable level.

Then we get AI to help us and everyone thinks that the economy will shrink?

sgt101··on Confessions of a Theoretical Physicist
This is at the heart of it.
sgt101··on King John's Lost Treasure
The law is clear - Treasure Act 1996. They'd get 1/2 the value and the other 1/2 goes to the landowner.

But - no, they wouldn't get to keep the items or dispose of them as they wished.

sgt101··on Confessions of a Theoretical Physicist
Really - to state otherwise is just a play on words.

Think carefully. Think friend, think.

sgt101··on Confessions of a Theoretical Physicist
I choose thoughts - I can conjour images, or scenes into my mind. I can choose not to think about things.

In fact, this is a proof of free will. If you were compelled to consider the consequences of your actions then evil would be impossible. The fact that we see evil means that people can choose not to think about what will happen when they do evil things.

sgt101··on Artificial intelligence is losing hype
maybe there's a term confusion here - GenAI has come to mean Generative AI (LLM's, Diffusion models..) rather than General-AI. People call that AIG, now people also talk about AIS which I take to mean "human level on a narrow domain only" while AIG is "generally intelligent at roughly human level".

My personal belief is that AIS is not a real thing (in the sense I wrote above) because narrow domain competence is tightly coupled to general domain competence . Even very autistic people that are functional in some domain actually have a staggering range of competences that we tend to ignore because we expect them in humans. I think machines will be similar.

Anyway, AIG or AIS is not round the corner at all. But that doesn't mean that there isn't a lot of value to be had from generative AI in the near future or now. Will this be a small fraction of the value from Web1.0 and Web2.0? Will it be approximately the same? Will it be a multiple? I think that's the question. I think it's clear that assistants for software engineers are somewhat valuable now (evidence: I get value out of them) how valuable? Well, more than stackexchange, less than a good editor. That's still alot, for me. I won't pay for it though...

And this points to the killer issue: there isn't a good way to monetize this. There isn't a good way to monetize the web, so we got adverts (a bad way). What will be the equivalent for LLM's? We just don't know right now. Interestingly there seems to be very little focus on this! Instead folks are studying the second order value. Using this "free thing" we can drive productivity... or quality... increase opportunities... create a new business?

sgt101··on Against the advice of my superintelligence
Issac Asimov wrote a classic that always makes me smile in this context [0]. A bit dated to say the least, but short and pointed.

[0] https://mcraenglish.weebly.com/uploads/1/5/8/7/15876062/the_...

sgt101··on Mike Lynch among missing after yacht sinks off Sicily
co-defendant now announced to be dead :(
sgt101··on UK launches its first Earth-imaging military satellite
no - high resolution target-able telescopes on taskable satellites don't go on low cost microsats.
sgt101··on UK launches its first Earth-imaging military satellite
The UK gov is a shareholder in the oneweb satellite constellation.
sgt101··on NASA acknowledges it cannot quantify risk of Starliner propulsion issues
PRINCE-2 and other methodologies used in these kinds of programs make ample provision for doing this - but like all methodologies the benefits only come from proper application. If the program manager is subjected to political pressure from different stakeholders then the processes and approaches that should catch division and misapprehensions may simply not run.
sgt101··on Does Reasoning Emerge? Probabilities of Causation in Large Language Models
Our brains have effects that proceeded language. Look at lions for an example.

We are much more (and a little less) than lions in terms of mind.

sgt101··on Rodney Brooks’s Three Laws of Robotics
I do not think Rodney Brooks has ever made any assertion that he is free of commercial interest!
sgt101··on Rodney Brooks’s Three Laws of Robotics
Simulations are closed, the real world is open.

Weird things happen in the real world. They happen all the time and we expect them to happen and hardly notice when they do. Simulations approximate the model that humans use to reason about the world, but we just ignore all the oddness and can't articulate the oddness until it's made explicit by some failure.

← PreviousPage 15 of 34Next →