HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sgt101

7,940 karma · joined January 24, 2012

nothing to see here, move along, move along.
submissionscomments
sgt101··on How we hacked McKinsey's AI platform
Why was there a public endpoint?

Surely this should all have been behind the firewall and accessible only from a corporate device associated mac address?

sgt101··on Why vampires live forever
It's the world builder, odd that it comes second but if it had come first then most people would have been put off! I liked that the main character was the least super empowered of any of the characters though.
sgt101··on Why vampires live forever
It never occurred to me to see if there was a film!

Mind you even more amazing I was on youtube yesterday and a short film showing the first chapter of the brand new book (published really recently) that I was reading popped up.

Now I see that there is not only that film (in the DUST series) but also a miniseries someone has made...

https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=antimemetics+di...

sgt101··on Why vampires live forever
The novels Blindsight & Echopraxis by Peter Watts have a nice vampire sub-plot... basically his world has vampires which have been revived from the fossil record. They are posited to have gone extinct in recent times, but before then were human's key predator, keeping our populations strongly in check and then having to hibernate for decades to allow the breeding to provide new meat!

He's super interested in brain disorders and spins a good story about the trade offs of a terrible reaction to right angles in exchange for savant like powers of perception.

sgt101··on Show HN: Moltbook – A social network for moltbots (clawdbots) to hang out
zactly - this is scifi stories from the 1950's being replayed, the shocking thing is that there's so much open mouthed "oh wowing" going on. People who are surprised by this need to read a few novels.
sgt101··on The Nobel Prize and the Laureate Are Inseparable
He was a clever king, but no one good could be king of England for more than about 18mths in those days.

I think that the parent probably meant Henry VIII.

sgt101··on Data Activation Thoughts
How to know if one should fine tune/pretrain or RL / reasoning train given some data set?
sgt101··on Waymo passenger flees after car drives on Phoenix light rail tracks
"Waymo passenger flees after remote operator drives on Phoenix light rail tracks"

There, fixed it.

sgt101··on Show HN: I used Claude Code to discover connections between 100 books
Interesting - ages ago I used SML to look at the relationships between Shakespears plays.

https://medium.com/gft-engineering/using-text-embeddings-and...

Validation is a problem here - you find relationships, but so what? Is it right.... I can't say. It is interesting though.

sgt101··on 'Bandersnatch': The Works That Inspired the 'Black Mirror' Interactive Feature (2019)
Colin Ritman is so Demis Hassabis.
sgt101··on Manus AI 100M USD ARR
There's a loop between adoption of a technology and adaptation of a technology. For some domains that loop is fast, the adaptations prove to be easy and the feedback from adopters is easy to get. For other domains it's slow, especially towards the end of the process of going from something interesting to something useful. A good example of a slow loop is self driving, it's hard to get feedback about self driving in safety critical real world situations... another example is medicine.

The other issue is that the value is more or less all in the LLMs (at the minute). For example, I built a data engineering toolkit using LLMs, it created synthetic data from examples, it created ingestion pipelines given different source filed and a target, it created data test rules. I liked my little toolkit and some people were impressed, but the value was all in the models that underpinned it. The crust of clever bits that added value was thin, very thin. Ok, we used the llms to generate some python that then created the synthetic data and testing rules to reduce costs, we had three or four "agents" that worked together to create the pipelines. We decorated target code with open provenance code to create provanance... But just by saying these things or letting you use the toolkit and you seeing what it made - that's enough for any half competent person to relicate it (with AI assistance) in an afternoon, or maybe a couple of afternoons. Maybe.

So, to create a viable company is going to take significant effort (if you can think of a value add) because the value add still has to be real.

sgt101··on An 11-qubit atom processor in silicon with all fidelities from 99.10% to 99.99%
can you give a bit more information on 100's of qubits below threshold? I wasn't aware of 100's...
sgt101··on Get an AI code review in 10 seconds
What would SOA be?
sgt101··on 40 percent of fMRI signals do not correspond to actual brain activity
Good for you George E Collins.
sgt101··on The Thinking Game Film – Google DeepMind documentary
I think that's a rather conspiratorial way of framing it.

I think it's more about someone trying to do the most good that was possible at that time.

I doubt he cares much about prizes or money at this point.

sgt101··on Iceland declares ocean-current instability a national security risk
Has that site been /slashdotted by HN? It's really buggy for me.
sgt101··on Technical Deflation
The models themselves represent the biggest deflation cases I've ever seem.

The charged cost of a frontier model is ~200x lower than 2 years ago, and the ones we are using now are much better - although measuring that and how much is challenging. Building a "better than GPT-4" model is also vastly cheaper than building GPT-4 was... perhaps 1/100th?

sgt101··on UK intends to scrap jury trials for majority of court cases
Nonsense.

- voting population? What are you on about? It's everyone older than 18.

- you are not allowed to say "let's go and kill xxxyyy" or "burn hotel xxxyyy" but more or less you can say anything else. You might get sued if you say "Kier Starmer is an XXXYYY" but possibly not.

- this is using a system such as the one that operates in many countries - like France. But note: Germany ditched jury trials in 1924...

sgt101··on UK intends to scrap jury trials for majority of court cases
Unfortunately the system has basically been collapsed by industrial scale theft and fraud, and the impact of covid...
sgt101··on UK intends to scrap jury trials for majority of court cases
What matters of criticizing the UK? Let's have the specifics to discuss?
sgt101··on 73% of AI startups are just prompt engineering
My coffee maker app is quite disappointing.
sgt101··on Gemini 3
I think that Google didn't see the business case in that generation of models, and also saw significant safety concerns. If AI had been delayed by... 5 years... would the world really be a worse place?

Yes - less exciting! But worse?

sgt101··on Three kinds of AI products work
The product is the LLM, the wrap has marginal value atm.

You can write an agent, it's cool. I can copy it.

I cannot build my own LLM (although I can run open source ones).

sgt101··on Spec-Driven Development: The Waterfall Strikes Back
Yes - it's not a problem with the technique... it's a problem with you! (or me!)

I remember feeling very small and very embarrassed. I remember consultants all puffed up with pride in their intellectual purity. These are patterns we need to move away from in the community.

sgt101··on Spec-Driven Development: The Waterfall Strikes Back
I was thinking more about my experience in corporate settings.

Hardware needs to be procured or implemented in the cloud - there's a lot of work on the architectures and costs early in projects so as to ensure that things will cost in. Changing that can invalidate business cases, and also can be very difficult due to architectural and security controls.

In terms of users, in corporates the user communities must be identified, trained, sometimes made redundant, sometimes given extra responsibilities. Once you have got this all lined up any changes become very hard because suddenly, like a ripple over a lake when a pebble is dropped in, everyone who's touched has a reason why they are going to miss targets (you are that reason) and therefore want 100% bonus (there is no money for 100% bonus for all).

In previous jobs I would have delighted in pointing out that if there are no users the system can't be funded!

I agree that working without a spec is madness, it's just not realistic in the real world either. People expect you to stand behind a commitment to deliver, they also want to know what they are paying for. However, things do change, both really (as in something happens and the system must now accomodate it) and also due to discovery (we didn't know, we couldn't have known, but now we know and must accomodate this knowledge). It's really important to factor this in, although perfect flexibility is infinitely expensive and completely unrealistic...

A bit of flex can be cheap, easy and a lifesaver though.

sgt101··on Spec-Driven Development: The Waterfall Strikes Back
If your architecture allows it.

If you are working with constrained hardware or users... it isn't.

sgt101··on Spec-Driven Development: The Waterfall Strikes Back
I just feel that the community has learned nothing.

Opinions about "what works" being pushed as fact. No evidence, no attempt to create evidence (because it's hard). Enless commentary and opinion pieces, naive people being coached by believers into doing things that seem to work on specific examples.

If you have an example that worked for you it doesn't mean that it's a useful way to work for everyone else in every other situation.

sgt101··on Startups are pushing the boundaries of reproductive genetics
It's important to consider the potential long run impact of this work.

It may be 30 years or more before the impact of genetic manipulation in humans becomes apparent.

This could cause very signifcant suffering to those effected. The manipulation techniques are not entirely understood, in the past organisms that have been manipulated have not had the outcomes that were hoped for or expected.

In addition during this work it is possible that suffering and death may be inflicted on human infants.

These dangers surely must weigh heavily on anyone considering this sort of work be undertaken.

sgt101··on Context engineering
so why does the author not link to or reference this material so that other people can evaluate it?
sgt101··on Context engineering
Yeah - random baseless assertions are at the heart of progress.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →