HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shail

148 karma · joined February 12, 2011

CoFounder at Hmpgr, http://hmpgr.com, Invite Code: HN shail2@live.com
submissionscomments
shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
Well, I have worked on mostly very early stage startups. Very rarely in a big corporation except my last employment. After that I have been working on my own startup.

As you know things change a lot in startups. Statistics show >95% of them fail. Hence the jump. I am not saying I jumped because they fail. But you work in a startup not because you want it to be next run of the mill company. You work in a startup so that it becomes the next Google.

But if my senses say that a company is not going to become next Google, I move on instead of wasting my time and companies time and money. I am not sure whether I answered your question but its more philosophical than anything else.

shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
I am seeing lots of comments about candidates feeling bad about it. Just to clarify on that end.

Do you speak to outside recruiters. Do they ask you questions about your skills before fwding you resume? If the answer is yes, then I am just another recruiter who happens to be actually technical and instead of asking you "Whether you know this tech? or How many years of experience you have with this tech?" kind of questions, I am actually taking proper tech interviews before fwding your resume.

Thoughts?

shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
But what if they lack the basic tech skills? I am not talking about tech as in knowing a language but someone whose CS fundamentals are weak.

Would you still consider? Obviously I am not talking about roles which do not require CS fundamentals to be strong.

edit: obviously again I am taking just round one.

shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
I agree that there is a value proposition for the recruiters but its difficult to make a service for them.

I think I have a value proposition for companies as well. I am reducing their filtering time (the time where technical folks from the company itself in involved).

Again, for candidates, if you speak to outside recruiters and judged by them before your resume get fwded, so you can see me as another recruiter who is actually technical and I am testing on your tech skills.

shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
I do not think its tied to the ratio. Its just tied to the absolute hits value. Yeah, if the recruiter is sending tons of unqualified resumes, then a company would end up changing it. But that does not happen often.
shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
From company perspective: Again, what is more important, money (which I am not charging a hell lot, if incase I am, correct me) or developers time. I am just reducing your cost on those interviews which would have failed already.

From candidate perspective: Do you talk to recruiters from hiring agencies? If yes, then you can see me as another recruiter who is much more technical. On answering the candidate's questions, I can obviously do part of the work. I am only taking one round so you have tons of more rounds to ask your questions.

shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
Hi eshvk

Thanks a lot for responding. I agree with few points but my argument against the rest is that I am not hijacking the whole interview process. I am just doing that round one which a junior person from the company would have done and I am hoping that if you clear you would have tons of chances to ask your questions and know the company well.

According to me, taking interview is an art. In fact, many times I have seen the person getting rejected by a company because someone inexperienced from the team took the first round and rejected him. I agree that companies should not do this. They should give another chance, but in real world when you have tons of resumes pouring in, companies end up doing this.

How about think along these lines, that if I really find you good. I will definitely make sure that your strengths are played in front of the employer really well and you are given due chance.

shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
I think you are right. The turnover is high and hence little incentive to change the status quo. But if a recruiting company takes this approach, it will definitely have an edge. About the big IF, yes it is and I do not like to boast but I think I can do this very very well if not excellent.
shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
I love this fact about this idea that I am getting paid either ways so I do not have any conflict of interest. About the results shown online idea, I think candidates would not like that for the interviews gone bad. Correct me if I got it wrong.
shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
Yep, Thats the idea. Make it consistent.
shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
Thanks a lot for this insight. This gives me another thing to try. Yep, if someone can put technology in lay man terms to recruiter they will be able to pick it up and be much better at their work. That will be win for everyone. Great idea.
shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
I am saving lots of developers hours. I am saving critical developer hours during, say a launch, when you had to keep your candidate search on hold. It has happened to me multiple times. I was waiting to hear back from companies while they were busy launching a product. In real world it happens a lot. I know I cannot do later rounds and they should be done by the team themselves but initial round can definitely be done by me. And finally, I am reducing their misses which results in saved developer time.
shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
Yes, its a service offered to employers right now so beneficiary is the employer. But I do not completely agree that candidate is at a loss. If the candidate is good enough, he will meet the employer eventually.
shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
Valid points for sure. This is one of the downsides. But if you clear this round you are definitely going to talk to them. Its just that instead of answering those initial filtering questions to them, you would answer to me and I will convey that to them.

But I see your point and its a good point to consider before considering my idea.

shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
Absolutely agree with that. A few rounds of practice before appearing will not hurt and will definitely increase your chances. But I am guessing selling it to fellow developers will be difficult. So I am starting with companies. But I agree with your idea and will give your idea a try as well.
shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
Sorry if I miscommunicated. I think you should go through my resume.
shail··on Ask HN: Interview as a Service – Any interest?
I would also like to know if anyone has tried this before. What was the experience? Thoughts?
shail··on Ask HN: How do you protect your children?
Loved your responses.
shail··on Ask HN: Who should succeed Balmer as CEO of Microsoft?
sinofsky
shail··on What are your most common reasons for rejecting candidates after a job interview
what if he can still type faster than you?
shail··on Ask HN: Is there evidence that artificial sweetener is bad for you?
Stevia?
shail··on Show HN: Display OS X notifications from your terminal easily
amazing thing. life saver.
shail··on I've lost interest in myself
Take a vacation.
shail··on Help with Rails?
Could you describe the problems you are facing in more detail?

I guess you would not have to pay to get directions. One-on-one help might need payment.

shail··on Show HN: Stocks+ a 1-for-1 replacement for the Apple Stocks app
The question is how is it free? They must be pulling the data from some free source else these real time stock quotes cost a lot.
shail··on High costs and negative value of pair programming
I think the best way to compare individual programmer vs pair programmers is to look at it this way:

When you work yourself on implementing something, how will compare these two:

YOU (60% of your capacity) vs YOU (>90% of your capacity)

My philosophy is that pair programming is just like individual programming but just increase the output efficiency of one of the member in the pair by 30% or so (if the pair is a good pair). Thats it.

An individual programmer at his >90% capacity will outweigh (in terms of output/cost) two programmers at 60% capacity.

So, if you have to pair them to get a single programmer with 90% capacity, do it.

shail··on Show HN: Linux server skills for newbies - a new online course
If you don't mind, I would be curious to know how many signed up? Want to know the traction level of such a concept.
shail··on Ask HN: Is Twitter being a useful tool to anyone here?
the two responses I have got until now demostrate only marketing kind of use cases. What else?

Are people really microblogging on twitter?

shail··on Show HN: Too busy for online dating? Try Wednesday Night
How will they ever start to exists in a new neighborhood?
shail··on Ask HN: Why should you ship fast?
I agree to this absolutely.
← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →