HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shakna

16,025 karma · joined August 20, 2016

https://jamesmilne.org

@shaknais@mastodon.social

submissionscomments
shakna··on Writing Parquet files using Haskell
Depends what you're doing, but it really can have C-comparable speed. [0]

Unoptimised/naive Haskell might be that slow. But that's true of a lot of languages and isn't particularly interesting to me. Java is slow if you do everything the naive way, too.

[0] https://entropicthoughts.com/on-competing-with-c-using-haske...

shakna··on OpenAI breaches Medicare, Albanese reveals
Most government contractors are onshore, for Australia. SDP was only rolled out this year.
shakna··on Resident Evil 4 (GameCube) – complete byte-identical decompilation to C/C++
> Reverse engineering would have to be illegal if what you say is true, because the source code you obtained from a copyrighted work is "tainted".

Yes. It often is. Hence why we have "clean room" practices to avoid the taint.

There's a reason "legality" is one of the headlines on the reverse engineering wiki page.

The headliner legal case in the US being Sega v. Accolade, which said that reverse-engineering to discover functions is fine if no documentation exists, but almost all other options are not fair use.

As for Nintendo, I guess you missed that they throw gigantic DCMAs at GitHub all the time? [1]

https://github.com/github/dmca/blob/master/2025/02/2025-02-2...

shakna··on Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in all subscriptions
This is the same terms of service that were stretched to indemnify against theme park accidents. [0]

Why would anyone give them the benefit of the doubt?

[0] https://lawcouncil.au/international-law/ils-insights/tangled...

shakna··on Resident Evil 4 (GameCube) – complete byte-identical decompilation to C/C++
Be wonderful if you approached a translated piece, by first considering the time and culture that produced it. Understanding the intent, rather than quoting it out of place.

This is a political critique, on the rule of law (writing) over attempting to treat things on a case by case basis (philosophy).

Quoting it, without understanding it, is part of that author's complaint.

shakna··on Resident Evil 4 (GameCube) – complete byte-identical decompilation to C/C++
If what you committed was piracy, then no. It doesn't matter how creative you were. You only get rights, were first you had a right to use.

If you are "significantly similar", you are probably infringing.

Feel free to explore the myriad of precedent setting cases in the music remix community.

shakna··on Resident Evil 4 (GameCube) – complete byte-identical decompilation to C/C++
CC0, on the decompilation of a copyrighted work? That's... Not the way it works.

You inherit the copyright from the original, as this is derivative.

There's a reason decompilation has always been a grey area of seeing whether or not the copyright holder cares.

shakna··on Deodands put a price on objects that caused death
Recidivism in the USA is higher than almost every other nation [0], at about 65-70%.

You're absolutely right that they don't stop, the first time, in the US. However, the cause of that same recidivism, is overwhelmingly correlated to a lack of support on leaving. Rehabilitation is in the name - habeo, to have or possess.

Why do people reoffend? Because currently, they're fucked. Background checks in everything, screw them over. They can't get work, they can't rent, and so, when all other options are off the table, is it actually a surprise, that they reoffend?

It'd be a hell of a lot cheaper, not to lock them up, and not expose a first-time offender to a black hole where everyone says the world would be better off with them dead.

See for example, Norway, with the lowest recidivism rate in the world [1], where it actually is true, that most do not reoffend.

[0] https://bjs.ojp.gov/topics/recidivism-and-reentry

[1] https://digitalcommons.coastal.edu/bridges/vol10/iss10/2/

shakna··on Deodands put a price on objects that caused death
> decline of superstition from roughly the second half of the 18th century on

I'm sorry, but no. Superstition absolutely did not decline during that period. It did change shape, but it was not declining.

You're talking about a period which saw the resurgence of spiritualism - 1840s to 1920s. Revival of old faiths, creations of new ones. Every single person buzzing with ideas on magic.

shakna··on CrowdSec Source Code Leak
Well, as it wouldn't be a script, congrats on already losing the skills you would need, to assess whether or not what you set out to do is actually accomplished.

And as we're discussing a security tool... Love to see how you judge it as something that doesn't matter in your stack. Incidentally, mind offering me your IP range?

shakna··on CrowdSec Source Code Leak
Our current models and harnesses have not been doing a fantastic job, of keeping things confined... The harness defaults to approving random commands, meaning if the model goes for the data, it tends to find the data. And a delete all before replacing it is fine, right?
shakna··on CrowdSec Source Code Leak
Did you take that time into your account of costs as well?

You're already using automation tools. Seems like you just don't... Want to learn... The tool that would save you hours of frustration, tomorrow or the day after.

shakna··on CrowdSec Source Code Leak
Well, it'd cost me about 10 minutes, and it wouldn't delete half my data. So... How much is your infrastructure worth?
shakna··on Bend – a language that blocks AI mistakes via proof and runs on GPUs
You mean t-shirts of this comic, from 2016?

[0] https://www.commitstrip.com/en/2016/08/25/a-very-comprehensi...

shakna··on CrowdSec Source Code Leak
Which means it'd be a lot cheaper, to use tools, and public sources, and just automate it the traditional way...
shakna··on Suspected sabotage causes major Netherlands rail disruption
Today is also Prinsjesdag. So pissed off Dutch is more likely. As it has been, for the last three years running with highways getting blocked on this day...
shakna··on OpenAI bots knew about the RubyGems caching vulnerability
Well I suppose no one has ever been charged under that paragraph of the law then. And the courts have never interpreted it that way.
shakna··on OpenAI bots knew about the RubyGems caching vulnerability
The first count is "or any restricted data", not classified material. A technological restriction, is enough.

"Knowingly accessed" has never meant you personally. Operators of a botnet don't know directly what they access. They know that the autonomous software is built to access restricted things.

shakna··on OpenAI bots knew about the RubyGems caching vulnerability
> There are no negligent or stochastic hacking laws

I'm sure that Andrew Auernheimer would be pleased to hear that. [0] For accessing a publicly accessible endpoint, that was completely undefended and didn't actually require "hacking", he was convicted of "exceeding authorised access".

You _don't_ have to show intent under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, for the first count.

> knowingly accesses a computer without authorization or exceeds authorized access [1]

"Knowingly", not "intentionally", as in the other counts.

You only have to show that:

a) They trained a system to access without authorization (hacking)

b) The system that was trained exceeded authorized access

As responsibility falls to the operator with automated systems, the company becomes liable.

[0] https://techcrunch.com/2013/01/21/ipad-hack-statement-of-res...

[1] https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/cioprod/documents/Co...

shakna··on Mullenweg has returned as CEO after attempted board ouster
Some Wordpress clients are government, with all the scale and always-on-call requirements that entails.
shakna··on Revolut confirms customer data breach through fake government requests
Trying to find a way to tip toe around KYC, whilst keeping their customers safe, has also turned out to only use insanely stupid methods, though. So why did they already do that?
shakna··on P(doom)
xAI v. Ellison [1], where xAI argue that the right to denudify people is a First Amendment right, and therefore fine, regardless of the person it is depicting.

> HF 1606’s principal sponsor stated that this was an “intentional” drafting decision, explaining there is no way to distinguish between images that are nudified with and without consent.22 But any interest that Minnesota has in preventing nonconsensual “nudification” cannot sustain a prohibition on consensual“ nudification

Doe v. xAI [0], where it seems Grok was intentionally trained on CSAM, as part of the "denudification" tooling.

Currently... It very much seems that Musk believes that if a kid says 'yes', then that is consent. Despite them being a kid.

But, from a guy who tried fairly hard to get to Epstein's island, that's not exactly surprising. [2]

[1] https://www.plainsite.org/courts/minnesota-district-court/xa...

[0] https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Doe-v...

[2] https://time.com/7362868/elon-musk-epstein-emails/

shakna··on P(doom)
Sociopathic nerd, putting an awful lot of money into legalising CSAM, and interfering in elections domestic and foreign.

Dunno if I'd rank Musk's danger down - he screams a certain ideology these days. He might well believe he is doing the right thing.

shakna··on LG denies TV spying claims, says tracking and snooping concerns 'not true'
Whilst most around me do expect voice control to exist... Most expect it not to function. "Hey Siri/Google" was always more of an exercise in frustration than success.

It seems the Australian accent still befuddles most STT with about 1/8 words confused (said as someone who uses STT to use their computer at all).

It would not shock me, if outside of North America and Great Britain, these systems are as effective as the original autocorrect algo.

shakna··on LRU is harder to beat than the KV-cache papers suggest
In that quote, Adams doesn't repeat himself, before making an assertion. He realises the audience has more of a context window than three words.

The same is not true, of the token generation that... Mostly Claude models... Have taken to.

shakna··on Navier-Stokes Announcement
Formalized in Lean, just five months ago [0], resulted in discovery of bugs.

Just because Lean can compile it, does not mean it is safely proven. It is the start of a process to check whether something actually holds, not the end.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47759709

shakna··on NTSB issues investigative update on B-767 runway excursion accident in Miami
Isn't it? Pretty sure its actually the drilled and trained commandment. If you doubt, speak up, and if that fails, take control. [0]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crew_resource_management

shakna··on Macbeth and His Problems
Random and unrelated things. Things that could have happened anytime, but didn't. Just all at once during one run. And haven't really happened since.

Ones I remember:

- Opening night, actress slipped on a stair, and fractured her ankle.

- Mirror in the changerooms had its hook break (warden said internal manufacturing defect, could not be seen ahead of time), and smashes an actor in the head. Concussion.

- A door jammed after the weather changed. Someone tried to open it without realising, and dislocated their shoulder. (200 year old building.)

shakna··on Bespoke: A programming language for people who say please
Not verbose enough. Needs to repeat the same information twice or thrice.
shakna··on Automattic's board forces CEO Matt Mullenweg into leave of absence
But when the same person was extremely professional, kind and helpful, six months before a sudden shift in behaviour?
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →