HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shalmanese

13,028 karma · joined October 8, 2008

shalmanese@gmail.com

I've done so much startup stuff I'm equally bad at all of it.

I currently work coaching Founders globally from a base in Singapore: https://coaching.figuringshitout.com/

I formerly was a 3x Founder and have worked in Engineering, Design, Product & Growth.

I also have a background in Computer Vision (designed a single camera 3D tracking algorithm), Augmented Reality (Designed a AR prototype for FEMA to manage disaster response workers), Tabletop/Touch Computing (Studied how people's collaborative behaviors change when put under time pressure), HCI (Studied it for 4 years), Interaction Design (ditto) and am well read in Psychology (esp. Social Psych), Economics, & other random trivia.

I also cook... a lot.

submissionscomments
shalmanese··on Ex-Facebook diversity manager pleads guilty to bilking $4M from company
One gamble he ultimately won.
shalmanese··on Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10?
How much would it have cost back then to buy a broken, used FP3 with a cracked screen as a donor phone?
shalmanese··on Crush Your Interviews with the Power of Storytelling
People on both sides of the table have the common misconception that coding challenges are about solving the problem. They're not, coding challenges are there for me to gain an insight into how you think through problems and the questions you ask are 100x more important to me than the code you write.

I have a colleague who, every coding challenge, immediately started by writing a bunch of tests and asking questions around the edge cases so that he could clarify the exact specs of the task he was being asked to perform. Any interviewer who didn't roll with that was a sign to him that there probably wasn't an engineering maturity culture fit and helped eliminate a lot of companies.

The story he was trying to tell was that he was an engineer that considered understanding the problem to be a much more important task than understanding the solution and he managed to tell it via the way he approached whiteboard coding.

shalmanese··on Crush Your Interviews with the Power of Storytelling
The absolutely low hangingest fruit, highest ROI activity I recommend every candidate do as they're gearing up for a job search is to meticulously go through their past work history month by month or even week by week and dredge up the memories of all the things they've actually done leading up to this point in their career and then find another person and do the physical act of explaining each of the things so they know if they can even tell the story in a way that makes sense or not.

The reason I believe it's the highest ROI activity is because I keep on suggesting it to people and most people think it's a great idea and then they don't do it. It's gotten to the point where, for the people I really care about, I have to schedule a 3 hour block with them on a weekend and sit down with them just to actually have them do it and after it happens, everyone agrees the result is transformative but people have a weirdly high activation friction to actually doing this.

It should get to the point where I can quiz you on a "tell me of an example where you X" and they should be able to rapid fire answer back to me what example they would pick and we can do a round of 30 of these in 10 minutes. If they find themselves having an esprit de l'escalier moment of wishing they had picked different examples, that's a sign they should go back and revise more.

I have so many friends who have done so many awesome things in their career but then freeze up in the interview and just plain forget to mention the perfect relevant anecdote and they think it's some defect on them but, surprise, all of our recall is terrible and we all constantly forget details of things that happened years ago and the only way to get good is with discipline and practice.

Another technique I encourage every candidate to master is the classic politician technique of transforming every question into the question you wished the interviewer had asked in a seamless enough way that they don't notice. eg: One of my close friends who I coached was absolutely terrible at hypothetical scenarios, she would totally freeze up because that's not how her brain worked. I trained her so that whenever an interviewer asked:

"How would you design this theoretical feature for this made up example"

Her templated reply would go something along the lines of:

"Oh yeah, we faced quite a similar problem when I was working on [...] at [...]. The way I approached it was [...] because [...] and it meant that [...] for [...] stakeholders. So I guess in this scenario, I would apply those same techniques [...] to make sure that [...] met [...]'s requirements.

At the end of the day, we're generally all in denial about how much interviews come down to vibes and how vibes is a very trainable skill that it's very possible to reduce the error rate through practice (note: this is different from presenting a different vibe from how you actually are IRL which I generally advise people is long term counter productive). Engineers especially have a lot of emotion invested in how interviews "should" be that isn't at all concordant with any version of reality and they have hangups about investing skillpoints in things that empirically improve their interview performance because it goes against their mental model of what should improve their interview performance.

shalmanese··on X is now licensed for payment processing in a dozen U.S. states
> The guys who are trying to make Messenger an everything app are probably some random MBA grads who have done nothing of significance in their life and real world.

The head of Messenger when this happened was literally the ex-president of PayPal.

https://time.com/2850224/paypal-david-marcus-facebook-messen...

shalmanese··on Before OpenAI, Sam Altman was fired from Y Combinator by his mentor
This feels like a wild misreading of the situation based on a simplistic good/bad dichotomy. People were mostly stunned at how poorly the board handled things and that sama probably wasn't as bad as the board was trying to make him out to be which is wildly different from him being good.

Even the worst criminal in the world should be declared "not guilty" if they were caught for a crime they did not commit for which the prosecution did not make a convincing case. In law, there no "innocent", only "not guilty" and most people surmised that sama is not guilty in this context irrelevant of a larger backstory.

shalmanese··on Before OpenAI, Sam Altman was fired from Y Combinator by his mentor
I think OPs point was that this was sama finding the line of what was the most egregious thing that is acceptable to admit in public which is almost certainly not the most egregious thing he's done and could be a large part of the explaination of why people's opinion of him knowing certain private actions diverges so much from everyone else.
shalmanese··on A door at a Swedish library was accidentally left open
This has been tested by researchers: https://www.npr.org/2019/06/20/734141432/what-dropping-17-00...
shalmanese··on Quake Brutalist Jam II
If you haven't seen it yet, I highly recommend checking out the story of MyHouse.wad: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5wAo54DHDY0

If you want to go in spoiler free, I'd recommend downloading the WAD and playing it through blind. But if you don't have the time for that, there's a ton of great youtube videos that covered the topic.

shalmanese··on Technology holy wars are coordination problems (2020)
The F-35A was fine, it was mostly the B that clusterfucked the project. Again, if we're talking about incentive problems, those are just straightforwardly co-ordination problems.
shalmanese··on What does and doesn't matter about Apple shooting their October event on iPhone
The iPhone 15 doesn't have 3.0 USB-C because the silicon was only introduced in the A17. Hardware revs are set in stone many moons before so being able to push USB3 support a generation later allows engineers to focus on other tasks.

Again, all speculation but the point is how a defined end point allowed teams to receive clarity over tradeoffs and move quickly. It's very typical of how Apple works (which you can see in Vision 1.0 where certain things were wildly overspecified and other were wildly under for that reason). The exact details may be wrong but the logic of how they got to this place feels right.

shalmanese··on What does and doesn't matter about Apple shooting their October event on iPhone
Prior launches had more important priorities to include so it was easy for teams to push this feature back knowing that the only mandatory launch date for it to hit was the iPhone 15 Pro launch.

Having the clarity over what's important allows teams to perform rather than endlessly debate over tradeoffs.

shalmanese··on What does and doesn't matter about Apple shooting their October event on iPhone
I'm almost certain that everyone has this story entirely backwards because people are used to thinking in a linear sequence of this happened, then that happened. Apple famously works backward from that process.

Reading the story behind the story, I think what happened is that several years ago, Apple execs were looking at a range of plausible technologies that were becoming feasible and were trying to find some kind of coherence among them through the story they wanted to tell. The story that was really speaking to them, as Gruber identified [1], was that finally the professional and consumer market were about to merge in really interesting ways.

I think what happened was at that point in time, they decided that the iPhone 15 Pro was going to be used to film the keynote for the iPhone 15 Pro and that this was the target given to all teams to give them clarity and focus to deliver a coherent end product.

Even tiny things like, why did they delay the introduction of USB-C for so long? Start making sense under this framework. If you're not used to this mode of thinking, a lot of the things I'm saying can sound like a stretch but if you adopt the framework, a lot of tiny things they mention suddenly make sense.

People are focusing on the specific output which is a single video but the power comes not from the output but from understanding the process that resulted in that output. Apple knows that other companies will always struggle to reproduce their exact process which is the core source of a durable sustaining advantage.

[1] https://daringfireball.net/linked/2023/10/31/downplaying-sho...

shalmanese··on Ask HN: What are you passionate about at the moment?
Not stupid at all! There are many things I help others do that I explicitly want others to do if it were me. eg: I am really good at helping other people build websites but every personal website I have tried to build, I've floundered at until I've brought in outside help. I assume lawyers have figured out it works the same way as the common saying goes "Any lawyer that represents himself has a fool for a client".
shalmanese··on Ask HN: What are you passionate about at the moment?
As an experiment, I just went to ChatGPT and tried to solve the problem as if I were OP and here's the result: https://chat.openai.com/share/3f0fe9cd-76ff-44ac-956f-cfb332...

I certainly found it helpful, even as a basic refresher of the field and I learnt a new thing which is apparently there is no single book that explicitly focuses on helping founders move on which feels like a business opportunity?

But also, you can see how I got to a useful place from first principles with the help of an AI. I stopped where I felt I was sufficiently interested that if I were in OPs shoes, I would have just bought the whole book and read it through and I did it in about 15 minutes although I admit I was cheating since I had an end goal in mind already.

I've left it for anyone else to go further in whatever direction and close the gap between where I ended and specific advice like you have provided.

shalmanese··on Technology holy wars are coordination problems (2020)
There's 3 seperate aircrafts in the F35 program which, if we designed any 2 of them, could have been coherent, well designed, well executed single aircrafts. It doesn't matter which 2, pick any 2 of the 3 missions and we could have gotten 2 great aircrafts.

But planners looked at the costs and said we simultaneously can't justify 3 seperate programs and also we can't simplify it down to one program, hence the ungainly mess that resulted.

Like I said before, if someone could have convinced any 2 of the branches of the military to knife the other one, we could have reached a much better place than we are now. That we didn't was a co-ordination problem.

shalmanese··on Ask HN: What are you passionate about at the moment?
The books will tell you to do all that!

They're not ready for me to tell them that, they need to be guided on the path to the path to the path.

shalmanese··on Ask HN: What are you passionate about at the moment?
> And I devoted the last decade of my life to that. Now that's fallen apart and I'm a little lost and it hurts me alot.

You have no contact in your bio but I've run into this with founders a lot and you need to recognize that what you're going through is a period of grief and mourning. I recommend you look up some books on how grief is processed in breakups or deaths and see if you find points of similarity.

Kubler-Ross' "On Death and Dying" is a classic place to start, it's where the "five stages of grief" model was first introduced. Her version of it is a lot more complex than the pop culture, linear understanding that most people have. She mostly talks about the interplay between the five stages and how we ping pong back and forth in interesting ways.

Also, FWIW, I've found ChatGPT a remarkably efficient tool to "read" books in an area you're totally unfamiliar with and want a quick download. You start by asking it to give you a broad overview of a book/set of books and then dive into the areas you find the most interesting until you arrive at an actionable framework.

shalmanese··on Technology holy wars are coordination problems (2020)
"The few that aren’t come to mind much easier because they’re much more legible than coordination problems."

How much of the world is spent working on truly greenfield R&D vs how much attention do we pay to it in the media, in our discussions and as examples that we use when we try and convey abstract concepts?

shalmanese··on Technology holy wars are coordination problems (2020)
I really like the example gwern provided:

Should array indices start at 0 or 1? My compromise of 0.5 was rejected without, I thought, proper consideration. - Stan Kelly-Bootle

The examples you listed above are what I would call 0.5 solutions. To me, these are straightforward co-ordination problems that failed to find a solution and then devolved into optimization problems that failed to find the right local minima because the problem formulation was flawed in the first place.

Co-ordination problems aren't fuzzy and nice almost all the time. A lot of solving co-ordination problems is getting two people to agree to knife the third to make the problem go away.

shalmanese··on Technology holy wars are coordination problems (2020)
People who optimize for effort look for truth. People who optimize for impact look for effectiveness. Unless your need is to predict to an individual level to high resolution, this is wasted effort.

People are largely a statistically predictable bag of attributes in many areas that matter for impact. The small amount of areas where humans are wildly unpredictable is what makes us beautiful and we focus on that as the "soul" of a human but they're also not usually the ones that intersect with how we care about impact.

There will be a statistical prediction of all the ways people will choose to get to a train station based on distance, weather, percentage car ownership, quality of sidewalk etc. Something as simple as improving the lighting of the right road to the train station can increase the ridership to a significant degree because it helps people feel safe walking home in the evening which means they also feel safe heading to work in the morning.

You spend enough time with a sensitive enough radar in a large organization and you see the same statistical patterns. People are milling around and impacted by their environment and things you want to make happen aren't happening until you notice the corporate equivalent of the unsafe road and you put down a couple of lights and rapid change occurs. You do it enough times consistently and you get promoted and the patterns become subtler.

shalmanese··on Technology holy wars are coordination problems (2020)
Thanks for providing a concrete example of

a) what a relatively mundane value-add via co-ordination looks like. Something like this is impossible to communicate without so much context but these stories are happening in every single pocket of a giant org.

b) What the artistry of it is. It's not easy and can take years to understand a single co-ordination problem well enough that you push single pebble and cause the right avalanche of change

c) Why anyone who is looking for impact inevitably gets drawn into it, independent of their feelings of whether they personally enjoy it or not (spoiler alert: I have never met anyone who has told me this was their true passion from birth. All of us wade into it reluctantly and eventually develop the internal motivation to make it satisfying).

shalmanese··on You don't need to work on hard problems (2020)
As I just said in another thread, “amateurs talk about effort, professional talk about impact”. Unravelling the puzzle of how impact happens is the hardest problem.
shalmanese··on Technology holy wars are coordination problems (2020)
It’s sad because they’re all just systems. People in a particular circumstance behave in a statistically predictable way given a system of incentives. If a behavior is unexpected, you’ve encountered a bug in your mental model and you should just chase it down like any software bug. Making a change to the system requires the same set of programming and analytical skills of navigating any complex code base.

There’s a reason why nerds who grokked this became masters of the universe for a few solid decades.

shalmanese··on WeWork Goes Bankrupt
I mean, if he fails his own test, that’s his problem but the test is the correct one.
shalmanese··on Technology holy wars are coordination problems (2020)
You can tell from this that gwern has never spent any time climbing up the ranks of a large organization.

Almost all of the hard problems in the world are straightforward coordination problems. The few that aren’t come to mind much easier because they’re much more legible than coordination problems.

To paraphrase a saying, amateurs discuss effort and professionals discuss impact and in whatever field you’re in, with a few tiny notable exceptions, once you reach beyond a certain magnitude of impact it becomes 95% about solving coordination problems.

shalmanese··on WeWork Goes Bankrupt
I mean, Ben Horowitz is correct here. In a VC interview context, crapping on Adam Neumann is boring and zero information value which is a negative signal. Being able to fairly evaluate people you have strong emotions for, positive or negative is a key VC trait.
shalmanese··on AI fake nudes are booming. It's ruining real teens' lives
Oh gee, it’s not helpful, thanks! Do you also explain to people who have recently been dumped that wallowing is not a productive activity and they should simply be in good relationships instead?
shalmanese··on I accidentally saved my company half a million dollars
But there are still things you need to avoid that would get you fired if your performance dropped and there are still things you can do that would improve or decrease your job prospects on the open market if the company ever goes under or is forced to let you go. I'm using "promotion" in a more abstract sense than literal promotions.
shalmanese··on I accidentally saved my company half a million dollars
Client work is its own unique hell of misaligned incentives. You've just replaced one boss with a dozen bosses, all of which have the power to "promote" or fire you.

I'm not saying that any one individual can't find a job that is the unique perfect blend of incentives for them, indeed, the entire point of this framework is that alignment between your goals and the incentives of your job is the most powerful lever an employee can pull. But that incentive structure will necessarily make others working there deeply unhappy as its unique choice of tradeoffs is just shitty in a way invisible to you.

← PreviousPage 9 of 34Next →