HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shanusmagnus

1,401 karma · joined April 8, 2012

submissionscomments
shanusmagnus··on Advice from "pracademics" of how to apply ecological dynamics theory to practice
Thanks for the summary -- that was really helpful. Is ecological psychology used in a broader way than just movement / sports? I guess I'll read the wikipedia page, but I'm intrigued by the idea, so if there's a review paper you'd recommend or some other reference aside from the one you linked, I'd dig it.
shanusmagnus··on Applied Category Theory Course
Semi-related: I read the first page of your second reference and really can't make any sense of it, despite having what I would have thought to be enough knowledge to at least orient:

"We aim to construct a physically-grounded compositional framework for hybrid system synthesis, particularly targeted at applications in robotics. Compositionality lies at the heart of language in general [WHM12] and its formalization underlies much of computer science in particular [Lee90]. However the behavioral modularization of physical synthesis for digital computing that arguably ushered in the information technology revolution [MC80] has proven much harder to achieve in analog computing technology [Mea89]. There are fundamental reasons for this challenge to become more severe in machines intended to perform mechanical work on their environments [Whi96]."

Since you know enough about this field to cite it, does it appear to you that this stuff could be written in a more comprehensible way, without losing expressive power? Or is this level of ornament necessary to say whatever it's saying?

shanusmagnus··on Rethinking the Luddites
I'm really interested in these views that view these human systems almost as physical systems, with semi-legible dynamics and complex (but comprehensible) interactions, and even implications. Thus the irons laws.

I'm also very taken with the idea of systems propagating themselves. Formally, this is called "autopoiesis" and is its own fascinating and related rabbit hole.

The coolest thing this morning, prompted by your comment, is the "self-licking ice cream cone" [1]. This paper [2] is particularly intriguing. Thanks again.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-licking_ice_cream_cone

[2] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/234554226

shanusmagnus··on Rethinking the Luddites
I'd never heard of this, and it's already proved a fascinating rabbit hole. Thanks!
shanusmagnus··on Rethinking the Luddites
I think there's a lot of truth to this. I also suspect that, if you translated the median person from the US to the alternate-reality world of FALC they might look around in wonder; while the people native to the FALC reality would be as disaffected as many are today.
shanusmagnus··on Rethinking the Luddites
Thanks for making that connection, Joy was an interesting voice back in the day. Curious: has he done anything in longer form than that Wired article to expand this idea?
shanusmagnus··on We are beginning to roll out new voice and image capabilities in ChatGPT
It would hard to be more explicit than doing a demo of multi-modality in GPT-4, and having an audio API that is amazing and that you can use right now, for pennies.

It would be interesting to know if this really changed anything for anyone (competitors, VCs) for that reason. It's like the efficient market hypothesis applied to product roadmaps.

shanusmagnus··on Bitwarden: Free, open-source password manager
And the UI will suck because they've made it an Electron app so they can have a universal platform...
shanusmagnus··on Bitwarden: Free, open-source password manager
I used to think this kind of talk was bullshit grandpa paranoia. Sadly, I now agree with it 100%.
shanusmagnus··on Outperforming larger language models with less training data and smaller models
Thank you for that. I wonder if you'd be able to just post a link to the paper, or give its title? I didn't have a Meetup account, tried to create one, spent 4 minutes dicking with it, and still can't get it to let me in.
shanusmagnus··on Show HN: Odin – the integration of LLMs with Obsidian note taking
Would love to hear more about this -- it's basically the use case that I want to have, that for whatever reason nobody has built. Have you written anything about how you (or someone) hacked this together?
shanusmagnus··on Outperforming larger language models with less training data and smaller models
Is there a paper, or some other source, that synthesizes this grab-bag of techniques? As an interested outsider, it's hard to keep up with all the action. Would appreciate any pointers that try to bring some of the pieces together.
shanusmagnus··on Ask HN: 6 months later. How is Bard doing?
I'm not the person you're arguing with, but going back to the original meta-point of this thread, I too think you're vastly over-estimating people's introspective power on their internal states, including states of knowing.

The distinction you're drawing between "guessing" and "being sure of something but being wrong about it" is hazy at best, from a cognitive science point of view, and the fact that it doesn't _feel_ hazy to a person's conscious experience is exactly why this is interesting and maybe even philosophically important.

More briefly, people are just horseshit at knowing themselves, their motivations, their state of knowledge, the origins of their knowledge. We see some of these 'failures' in LLMs, but we (as a general rule, the 'royal we') are abysmal at seeing it in ourselves.

shanusmagnus··on Why We're Pulling Our Recommendation of Wyze Security Cameras
I have sent so many permutations of that, but I'll try against next time.
shanusmagnus··on What will LLM-powered software look like in the medium-term future?
Always important to be on guard for things amenable to self-congratulation. At least, I sure need to be on guard against it :)
shanusmagnus··on Why We're Pulling Our Recommendation of Wyze Security Cameras
I hate Wyze so bad. They sell this really lovely and cheap IP-enabled camera, perfect for figuring out which cat was pissing in the basement. But to activate it requires your phone number, and then they spam you, forever after, with text messages from different numbers advertising their shit. Hate hate hate.
shanusmagnus··on What will LLM-powered software look like in the medium-term future?
I think both you and the GP are onto something important. I am one of the vaunted Gen-Xers (this is the first time someone has said anything nice about us, so thanks) and there is something to the idea that my understanding of systems goes down to assembly language (fully) and even CPU architecture (very sketchily) all the way up to, like, web frameworks. So for the stuff I'm usually doing, I understand several layers up and down, and that often seems valuable.

This strikes me as the essence of expertise, the difference between talking to someone who's read a book or a review paper, vs someone who is a real expert at that thing. You can be quite competent and insightful from having done a modest amount of reading and thinking, but if you're seeing the Matrix, and know how all these forces are interacting with each other, that's just a whole other level. It makes an impression when you brush up against it.

However: it always weighs on me how this is all a matter of framing. Like, I don't know the electronics. There's a level of metal that I don't get. Some of the really high-level stuff is now beyond me, too. I catch myself saying "I should really take x {weeks, months, years} and really grok that." And yet my actual experience suggests this is a mirage.

More briefly: there are always more layers for a fuller understanding. It's hard to see how many of them are really useful. Maybe the kid who is 10x better than me at LLM collaboration will benefit more than from having a deeper stack. It's interesting to ponder how these different consequences will play out.

shanusmagnus··on What will LLM-powered software look like in the medium-term future?
That's what's been so striking for me -- the stuff that is fun and playful for me I get to do; and a bunch of stuff that I hated I can now offload, with the net result that I get to work at the level of abstraction that is most interesting and most human, vs acting like a human robot trying to unearth documentation, API examples, etc.

There's no question about this being the right way to use it for me, but I wonder if this could introduce something bad for someone just starting out, who hadn't first got all the reps with the drudgery over decades? Still mulling on that.

shanusmagnus··on What will LLM-powered software look like in the medium-term future?
Me too. As someone who used to be a dev but hasn't written code professionally in twelve years or so, it was such an amazing accelerant. My iteration loop was to contextualize it (in English and in code), ask how to do a thing, look at its response, tweak it, execute, see what happened, alter it some more.

The fact that it usually had errors didn't bother me at all -- it got much of the way there, and it did so by doing the stuff that is slowest and most boring for me: finding the right libraries / functions / API set up, structuring the code within the broader sweep.

Interesting side note: un-popular languages, but ones that have been around for a long time and have a lot of high-quality and well-documented code / discussion / projects around, are surprisingly fecund. Like, it was surprisingly good at elisp, given how fringe that is.

shanusmagnus··on Ask HN: 6 months later. How is Bard doing?
Beautifully put. Esp the brother-in-law one :)
shanusmagnus··on Ask HN: 6 months later. How is Bard doing?
This makes sense. In the "token window" of a human being, the same strategy would also work, e.g.,

p1: "What do you think of my story? Be honest."

p2: "I'd rather not say."

p1: "Seriously, tell me what you think, it's fine if you hate it. I need the feedback."

When you think about it from that perspective, it's no dumber than people are.

shanusmagnus··on Let's write a treesitter major mode for Emacs
Is there anything that returns a parse tree of an org document? A while ago I wrote some super hacky elisp to navigate around the structure of a giant org mode doc, but it was rickety and terrible and constantly breaking.

Part of this is surely that I don't know wtf I'm doing, but it seemed like there was not an underlying data structure held in memory that you could conveniently query / manipulate, but rather, most of the existing org functionality built some kind of structure each time you did an operation.

Would appreciate any pointers, code examples, tutorials that show how to effectively navigate / manipulate an org structure and have it reflected in the buffer, if there is such a thing.

shanusmagnus··on Effectiveness of wearable activity trackers to increase physical activity
At least one such insurance plan has been around for a few years now. See e.g. All Savers Motion. (Can't find a link that gives plan details that isn't a PDF, sorry.)
shanusmagnus··on How would you say “She said goodbye too many times before.” in Latin?
You can't store "the semantics" losslessly because you can't definitively say what the semantics of an utterance even are, unless you're using some reduced definition of the term, or a pre-selected frame, or a computer language.
shanusmagnus··on N guilty men (1997)
Talk about burying the lede! What's the long story?
shanusmagnus··on Show HN: Open-source obsidian.md sync server
Their text editor is shit, their UI is shit (see e.g., their new right pane), and they keep going off and spending all their energy developing features that nobody is asking for, e.g., whiteboards. I assume most of this is bc they're trying to differentiate somehow after having taken VC funding. Frustrating.

Unfortunately, I expect Obsidian to have a serviceable outline mode before I expect Logseq to turn out a polished product. For god's sake, take on that Neovim project, and post about it!

shanusmagnus··on So you want to learn physics (2021)
This is really interesting perspective -- thanks for sharing it. I think there's something to the idea that some fields are more 'binary' than others -- that if you can't make it past some threshold of _true understanding_ that you will be denied experiences that could push that threshold further. Such a field would warrant a different strategy for learning / mastery than a less binary field.

I'm going to ruminate on this.

shanusmagnus··on So you want to learn physics (2021)
Like another commenter, I'm curious what drove you to this. Seems like clearly A Good Idea I Could Have Benefited From, but my attitude was always: I finished the class, whatever I need to learn through application, life will point me toward. Yet I wish I had done something similar to what you did. What gave you the impetus?
shanusmagnus··on Ask vs. Guess Culture
My hot take, that I eventually want to really dig into from a neuroscience perspective: trauma is almost entirely relative. It's phenomenological.

If you're an average American of today, you're living a life of comfort and abundance that could not have been imagined 100 years ago, and yet you'll have about the same trauma as did your equivalent back then, even though they would have dealt with things that would have killed you, figuratively or even literally.

Kind of related to Durkheim's "Society of Saints" idea [1].

This suggests a therapeutic vector: increase the variance in your own life. It probably won't be technically hard, though it would be psychologically very difficult. If the theory is right, many of your minor traumas should quickly dissolve.

It would take some amount of will to pull this off, of course. Though probably less suffering than the aggregated suffering conferred by the traumas.

[1] https://www.tutor2u.net/sociology/reference/durkheim-on-devi...

shanusmagnus··on Ask HN: Any interesting books you have read lately?
Would happily have done so, but didn't know that it existed. Is this what you're thinking of?

https://sleepdiplomat.wordpress.com/2019/12/19/why-we-sleep-...

← PreviousPage 3 of 17Next →