HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shapenamer

95 karma · joined May 17, 2023

submissionscomments
shapenamer··on Gun-related deaths and suicides among American children soar to all-time high
Well they have the rights of adults. Should 19 year old people not have the rights of adults?
shapenamer··on The American Illusion of Freedom
>One common misconception among some Americans is that other western nations lack freedom of speech. ... >When people say X or Y nation lacks free speech, what they’re usually referring to is the lack of protections for hate-speech. The US stands entirely alone in its consideration of hate as a form of protected speech.

OP explicitly refutes specific claims made in the article and your response is "whataboutism". You either didn't read the article or I'm correct that you simply don't like the hypocrisy being pointed out. Perhaps both?

shapenamer··on The American Illusion of Freedom
Pointing out hypocrisy is always whataboutism to people that don't like it being pointed out.
shapenamer··on Helicopter Footage Reveals State Trooper Surveillance Capabilities
This seems to contradict statements like the one below that even a single laser, "...is no different than shooting a firearm at the helicopter."
shapenamer··on ‘I’m not wanted’: Florida universities hit by brain drain as academics flee
I still don't understand. The person you originally replied to was celebrating "politically motivated academics" not interested in the truth being purged and you replied, vaguely, that there's an objective truth and then insulted the user's intelligence for celebrating a politically motivated purge.

Something tells me you wouldn't have made the same post if the politics were the other way around.

shapenamer··on ‘I’m not wanted’: Florida universities hit by brain drain as academics flee
I'm still super curious what the "objective truth" is in this case.
shapenamer··on In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021)
Well then lets apply the same standard to the statement that there were no lockdowns. Some countries like New Zealand wouldn't even let their own citizens fly home, and there were stories about people in China having their doors nailed shut by the police. You don't get to make a blanket statement that, "there were no lockdowns" and then downvote everyone that replies because they weren't specific enough.
shapenamer··on In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021)
No replies with the downvotes, as impressive as usual.

Looking back at this thread it seems every post disagreeing with the ridiculous statement that there were no lockdowns has been downvoted. Amazing.

shapenamer··on You're So Vain, You Probably Think This App Is About You: On Meta and Mastodon
It's extremely normal https://www.virtua.org/articles/turn-your-head-and-cough-the...

You clearly didn't play any sports, or you're female, I suppose.

shapenamer··on In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021)
Always blows my mind when people suggest the only reason someone wouldn't trust the US government is because they've fallen for some misinformation. The US government does a great job of destroying trust all by itself.
shapenamer··on In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021)
half my friends lost their jobs because of the not-a-lockdown. The fact that we could still buy FOOD doesn't mean we weren't locked down. What a terrible take.

Well guys, we weren't physically barred in our homes and starved so we weren't locked down. Brilliant.

shapenamer··on You're So Vain, You Probably Think This App Is About You: On Meta and Mastodon
weird take imo, I played multiple sports in highschool and every year I had to go have a doctor (always female, but I'm supposed to be ok with this I guess, but I wasn't) handle my genitals or I wouldn't be allowed to compete.
shapenamer··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
> implying that the 1940's weren't modern times or that the concept of citizenship has radically changed since then.

nope

shapenamer··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
But what about the Jews that were German?
shapenamer··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
"...men and boys were systematically executed..." huh?
shapenamer··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
Ummm what? This is maybe the dumbest thing I've ever read.

    The Massacre of the Bani Qurayza (627 AD): According to Islamic sources, during the siege of Medina in the aftermath of the Battle of the Trench, the Jewish tribe of Bani Qurayza was accused of conspiring with the attacking Meccans against the Muslim community. After the Meccans retreated, Prophet Muhammad's followers turned against the Bani Qurayza. The men were executed en masse, while the women and children were enslaved.

    The Sack of Isfahan (1387): Timur, the Turko-Mongol conqueror, laid siege to the city of Isfahan, which was then part of the Jalayirid Sultanate. When the city finally fell, Timur reportedly ordered that every soldier in his army should return with at least two severed human heads. The total number of people killed is estimated to have been about 200,000. Women and children were often spared to be taken as slaves.

    The Massacre of Nanking (1937): Also known as the Nanking Massacre or the Rape of Nanking, this atrocity was committed during the Sino-Japanese War when the Imperial Japanese Army captured the city of Nanking. Over a period of six weeks, mass killings, rapes, and looting were perpetrated against the city's residents. While not every man was killed, the death toll was incredibly high, with estimates ranging from tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands. Many women were raped, and some were killed or taken away.

    Srebrenica Massacre (1995): This was the largest mass murder in Europe since World War II, perpetrated during the Bosnian War. Over 8,000 Bosniak men and boys were systematically executed by units of the Bosnian Serb Army. Women, children, and some elderly men were forcibly transferred and deported, making it an example of ethnic cleansing.

    The Assyrian Empire: The Assyrians, who built a powerful empire in ancient Mesopotamia, were notorious for their brutal military tactics. Their treatment of conquered peoples often included mass killings, forced deportations, and enslavement. However, it's important to note that not every city they conquered was subjected to this treatment; it was often employed as a form of psychological warfare, to intimidate other cities into surrendering without a fight.

    The Mongol Empire: While not exactly "ancient" by some definitions, the Mongols under Genghis Khan and his successors in the 13th and 14th centuries were known for their ruthless conquests. Cities that resisted Mongol rule could expect no mercy; the men would often be killed and the women taken as slaves or wives. This strategy was also a form of psychological warfare, encouraging other cities to surrender without a fight to avoid a similar fate.

    The Roman Empire: The Romans are known for their tactic of "decimation", which involved killing one in every ten men in a unit as punishment for serious infractions, like desertion or cowardice. But when it came to conquered peoples, the Romans were sometimes ruthlessly thorough. For example, after the Third Punic War, the Romans reportedly killed or enslaved the entire population of Carthage.
shapenamer··on Turning Joe Rogan down was the right thing to do
if there's no evidence of it being harmful, why has it's use mostly been stopped? Why did the UNEP consider banning it, specifically to reduce mercury exposure? Why do they label it with a skull and crossbones?

I don't really care if it's the least toxic of the possible alternatives, it's still toxic and shouldn't be ingested in any way.

They imply, without directly stating, that because it's cleared from the human brain (they believe but don't know for sure, they tested on monkeys but not humans of course) faster than it's sibling compound, Methylmercury, that it's simply safe to ingest. However, it also states that ethylmercury breaks down into inorganic mercury, which is both toxic, and has a half-life of AT LEAST 120 days. So you end up with inorganic mercury in your brain and it may stay there for years.

The wiki page literally states in plain English that health organizations have considered banning it, but it would just cost too much damn money. That's not science, that's something else.

Edit: "...because it sounds bad and someone once told you mercury is bad." Mercury is bad for you and there's literally no question about it. Here's the first result from google: https://www.vdh.virginia.gov/epidemiology/epidemiology-fact-...

You keep acting like I'm some kinda of science denier but I'm literally reading the wiki page YOU linked, and it says it's extremely toxic, in multiple ways. If anyone is sticking there head in the sand, it's you.

Second edit: To address your confident statement of "NO" to your own questions: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3096006/

"Acute or chronic mercury exposure can cause adverse effects during any period of development. Mercury is a highly toxic element; there is no known safe level of exposure." You're so confident that "there's no evidence" it's bad for you, and you're just plain wrong. You accuse me of simply receiving my opinions/beliefs with no evidence and it's looking more and more that it's the other way around. Looking forward to more condescending yet horribly wrong and uninformed responses from you.

shapenamer··on Turning Joe Rogan down was the right thing to do
Wow how rapidly you went from "read this" to "I'm not going to respond and just downvote everyone that disagrees with me"

Edit: Oh ya another great part of this wiki page is when it states, "The United Nations Environment Program backed away from an earlier proposal of putting thiomersal on the list of banned vaccine compounds as part of its campaign to reduce mercury exposure.[18] It stated that eliminating it in multi-dose vaccines, primarily used in developing countries, would lead to high cost and a refrigeration requirement that developing countries could ill afford."

So they were considering banning it to reduce mercury exposure, which we know is bad for us, but they didn't because.... drumroll please.... money. Shocking. The fears are completely unfounded though.

shapenamer··on Turning Joe Rogan down was the right thing to do
This wiki article is super weaselly and just plain gross. The first paragraph states that "In spite of the scientific consensus that fears about its safety are unsubstantiated,[6][7][8][9]..." If you actually check those sources they're all about specifically autism. But the paragraph says nothing about autism and simply states that fears about it's safety are unsubstantiated. Later on it goes into detail about how toxic it is and that it's mechanism of toxicity is not known. Basically it's very toxic, it will damage your brain and your kidneys, but don't worry about it because it for sure doesn't cause autism. It later breaks down into inorganic mercury which is also toxic.

It also says, "Later it was reported that ethylmercury is eliminated from the body and the brain significantly faster than methylmercury, so the late-1990s risk assessments turned out to be overly conservative."

I'm not a doctor, but I think I'll shoot for 0 toxic mercury in my brain, regardless of it's rate of removal relative to other extremely toxic substances, thank you very much.

I suspect if I told you that I have a substance that is significantly less lethal than cyanide, you still wouldn't take it. I sure wouldn't.

It also kinda implies that multiple governments have banned it's use, mostly just to shut up those crazy anti-vaxxers, which is just ridiculous.

Edit: Downvotes without replies are always so impressive.

shapenamer··on Turning Joe Rogan down was the right thing to do
I read the wiki page you linked and I came out with more questions. If you read the toxicology section it says pretty plainly that it's extremely toxic, moves freely about the body, distributes to all body tissue, crosses the blood-brain barrier, stays in the brain for (probably) two weeks, and "The mechanisms of toxic action are unknown." It says that the link to autism has been debunked, that's fine, and yet it's use in vaccines has been mostly stopped in the US, and completely banned in Europe.

I'm just even more convinced I don't want it in my body.

shapenamer··on Turning Joe Rogan down was the right thing to do
While you're imagining things, imagine having your life ruined by addiction and hearing the people responsible will not be HELD responsible because they're rich, from ruining people's lives.

Or imagine getting cancer from a product that was fraudulently tested by the company that makes it and then being told to "trust the science" regarding a product from the same damn company. Only a "loon" wouldn't trust these people, for sure.

shapenamer··on Texas governor signs law shutting diversity offices at public universities
Why poll when you could actually vote and elect! Oh they do.
shapenamer··on Texas governor signs law shutting diversity offices at public universities
"You're not arguing in good faith". You clearly didn't even read the headline, much less the article. Is that "good faith"? Set a good example for us lmao.
shapenamer··on 21st-century editors should keep their hands off of 20th-century books
"Careful, sir. I think you've had too much to think. Any more comments like that and the thought police may be alerted. We wouldn't want that, would we?"
shapenamer··on The effect of deplatforming hate organizations on their online audience
Ok, that's fair. Just to be clear I was not trying to insult you or your government. Just pointing out that the people that make up your government are very normal people with the same weaknesses and blind-spots as the rest of us.

At the risk of seeming like I need the last word and further risk of sounding very cliche, there is a quote by a man named Martin Niemöller, a German man, about a German government, that I believe, tells us in no uncertain terms, that the slippery slope fallacy is not a fallacy AT ALL, and that we should take government powers and limits extremely seriously.

shapenamer··on The effect of deplatforming hate organizations on their online audience
I think it's very strange to say it's uniquely American when there have been, historically, far more tyrannical governments in Europe than just about anywhere else in the world and countries like Germany have criminalized basically any positive display/speech about their past tyrannical government. Your views may not be uncommon, but they're certainly not universal, and even if they were, that wouldn't make them correct, or even well thought out.

>I'm saying that people shouldn't discuss immigration policy through inciting to violence and racism. And I'm saying that Elon Musk is absolutely the last person I'd want to be the arbiter of what speech is legal or not.

Yes and I still think I'd rather be kicked off twitter by Musk than locked in a jail for saying the wrong thing. I honestly have no idea why you believe that the members of your government are more fair/just/whatever than anyone else, including Musk. They're not, and that's why they should have limited power.

shapenamer··on The effect of deplatforming hate organizations on their online audience
Making death threats is already illegal and is not a "hate crime". You're advocating for governments to make more speech illegal, speech that you don't agree with.

As far as your government turning to tyranny. I can't think of many governments that turned to tyranny multiple times. They are usually removed, or stay in power. "My government is not currently tyrannical so I'm confident it will stay that way", is a strange way to think if you've read much history, imo.

shapenamer··on The effect of deplatforming hate organizations on their online audience
I'm not European but I find it incredibly bizarre that you would prefer such a thing. The worst Elon Musk can do to you is kick you off his platform. As soon as a government gets involved you're looking at being potentially locked in a cage like an animal for expressing your opinion.

They say the people get the government they deserve though.

shapenamer··on ChatGPT is not ‘artificial intelligence.’ It’s theft
They might even name the shape. Perhaps "cube".
← PreviousPage 2 of 2