5,227 karma · joined July 10, 2023
Of course it’s got quirks and unfortunate relics of its long history, but I reach for it willingly, and I can’t say that about the rest of the Office suite.
In any case I feel the paper is interesting but almost begging to be misinterpreted.
What I'd like to see is if the LLM would exhibit the same behavior wrt other types of predictive selections. For example, rather than choosing people from four tribes, choosing flower seeds from four packets, or choosing lottery tickets from four machines.
Please just go read the abstract; your first reactions to the headline may not be relevant.
If the formed bias was against HN usernames that started with “r,” would it still seem daft?
I was just in a stall where the inside of door had a pictogram forbidding users from standing on the edge of the bowl and squatting. I assume this might be for visitors from countries where squatting is common.
Point being, you just never know what random members of the public will do with a door to hide behind.
The same debates happen about early games made with far less intention and artistry. For those games I’d be surprised if there was much care about canon at all.
Especially when the studio which made game v1 was fired and a new studio was asked to take some random game in development and update the sprite to look like v1’s box art. And 40 years later people are arguing about timelines and character arcs?
The more you look like a high-status leader, the longer it will take, and the more likely it arrives as a fine or a suspended sentence followed by an eventual redemption story published in the New Yorker or equivalent.
But targeting other high-status people ejects you from the white glove treatment.
Some people are very invested in making sense of things that just don’t have a ton of intention and meaning behind them.
Human learning is slow, AI production is fast. Very hard to steer a middle path.
So sure, there are introspective AI scientists. I fear their role in the history of this period will be a footnote about cautionary voices.
I’d like the author to describe how they knew what specific applications these many people were using on their phones, all around them at a baseball game.
Many of them were actually on social media, which itself is a form of algorithmically driven mass influence. But because the content was typed in by other people, we’re ok with it, while the robotic token producer we call AI is an evil force?
If we get the worst outcomes from AGI, the scientists who worked so hard to enable it are unlikely to reflect deeply about it. If they had that capacity, they might do it ahead of time. And some do…but not enough to stop the inevitable tide.
Ironic, given the role that chance and statistical prediction plays in the mechanisms of AI. Free will is in fact a thing, and moral choices have moral consequences.
Ultimately, the symptoms are what people experience, and treatments often center on mitigating symptoms. Having an insight into the underlying genetics may or may not help anyone live with a disease, especially not in the near term.
It appears now we can get along with just a single “artificial.”
I can’t say that’s true for me and my company. It’s not all lies or anything, it’s a fragmented view that emphasizes conflict and the most visible 10% of what the company actually does.