HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shermantanktop

5,227 karma · joined July 10, 2023

submissionscomments
shermantanktop··on Nitter and XCancel receive cease and desist notices
Personally I have zero interest. If it's a big enough deal, it'll get to me somehow. Knowing about it 15s after it happened and then seeing a flood of uninformed speculation would be stressful.

Others do value that, no judgment, but for me it's be a net negative.

shermantanktop··on How Universities Should Prepare Founders
Is it too late to get zuck back to whatever he was doing before his current activities?
shermantanktop··on Where did all the public bathrooms go?
I had to stop and think, but I follow your mathematical reasoning. Although 1:1 is not a realistic number; i'd think more like 4:1 or more? and if men over 60 are around, it's going higher for sure.
shermantanktop··on A Kantian Critique of "Sorry" by Justin Bieber
I had a coworker who talked all the time about their improv activities outside of work. They also dropped “yes, and” into business meetings with execs, and would then explain why.

They asked me if I thought it would be a fun team-building exercise to bring in their improv coach and do a class with a bunch of VPs and directors. I said no.

I understand the concept but sometimes people can be overzealous about their passions.

EDIT: I understand the concept and sometimes people can be overzealous about their passions.

shermantanktop··on Paul Atkins misreads Adam Smith and the American founding
Is there someone who could be convinced by this article, but who doesn't already agree with it?

I'm discouraged that public discourse about ideas has become so partisan that it ends up being partisan to express an opinion that touches on the most important things that are happening.

shermantanktop··on Why aren't smart people happier? (2022)
That's what makes us so smart!
shermantanktop··on Why aren't smart people happier? (2022)
And then the void wraps a cold clammy tentacle around your leg, just to show you that two can play that game.
shermantanktop··on Harvest hikes bills by 1500% after purchased by Bending Spoons
What is newsworthy here? Price goes up, customers leave.
shermantanktop··on I spent twenty years becoming good at the wrong game
I came to a similar conclusion during my masters, with less data and a less well-articulated rationale. I realized that I already had a talent for intellectual bullshittery, and grad school was encouraging it rather than giving me core skills. Looking around at fellow students, the same was true of them, and the competitive environment reinforced this tendency in all of us.

I learned to be more self-critical of my thinking than others were, and to recognize when others weren’t holding me to a higher standard. And I left.

shermantanktop··on Companies promote incompetent employees to management to limit damage they do
If you were suffering from Dunning-Krueger, how would you know?
shermantanktop··on Companies promote incompetent employees to management to limit damage they do
I've never seen this happen as a reaction to actual incompetence, where the person is a net negative and a drag on everyone.

I have seen something similar, though: a valued employee doesn't have balanced functional skills at their current position, and yet is a net positive due to other factors. They are good at problem solving but bad at coding; they are great at oncall operations but bad at design; they are good at making others better but not great by themselves.

They can either acquire the skills to be functionally competent alongside their peers, or management can give them responsibilities that allow them to contribute without actually having them be good at their current job.

That's definitely flunking upward but it's not necessarily a bad thing.

shermantanktop··on Spaghettifying DRAM
I just told my boss to remove a line in a doc because it sounded too AI-y. He then said that he had written it himself.
shermantanktop··on 'The Cheese and the Worms' by Carlo Ginzburg Review
He did both! Along with The Great Chain of Being by Lovejoy. We also studied the Divine Comedy (all three ugh), the librettos for the Magic Flute and the Barber of Seville, Frankenstein, and lots more. I took multiple courses with him, so this is across several years.
shermantanktop··on 'The Cheese and the Worms' by Carlo Ginzburg Review
I read this in college, with a fantastic professor (RIP) who also assigned Huizinga's "Homo Ludens." I loved it ...if only the rest of academic history was so free-thinking and human-centric, I might have stayed.

"Night Battles" is amazing too. And the fact that some of the scholarship in both books is contested adds to the interest - he really rattled some cages and wasn't afraid to take an idea and run with it.

shermantanktop··on Ethical Cold Outreach
Advertisers always say they are educating and informing, so that their "audience" is "learning" about their product.

And there's a bit of truth to that, for new products - people don't know about it yet. But it quickly goes from awareness to persuasion, then lies, and finally mindless repetition of a logo and tagline.

The endgame of ads is not information flow, it is programming the emotions and memory of the "audience."

shermantanktop··on France to ban unsolicited telemarketing calls
Never done anything directly. But large-scale protests can move the Overton window.
shermantanktop··on Tl;dv: Over 180k meetings left wide open
I just did this - i took notes by hand during a meeting, but also took the AI summary and compared the two. I did miss one item. My hand notes were far better though.
shermantanktop··on Defending my own brain against enshittification
Dissing Biscoff cookies in the opening paragraph? Not sure I can read the rest...
shermantanktop··on I made tinnitus my friend, then it disappeared [video]
Interesting. Summarizing: pineapples contain a compound which breaks up collagen. No proof it does that to the human body, or floaters specifically.

But if it did, I’ve got terrible collagen and so I won’t be eating pineapple everyday, regardless of what the Taiwanese pineapple council would like me to do.

shermantanktop··on What Happened to HackerOne?
Often preceded by the waning of the passion and self sacrifice that enables things to happen without money.

It’s sad when it’s asymmetric - founders lose their idealism and sell out while early employees fail to notice the game has changed.

But dreams are rarely enough to keep things going. And VCs know just what to say to make it seem like the dream and the money can coexist.

shermantanktop··on Georgia police officers fired after Flock camera misuse
To paraphrase Homer: the cause of, and solution to, a problem! In this case police misconduct.

It does make me wonder whether electronic evidence of police behavior will materially impact actual behavior over time. But given that the normal reaction is to deny access to evidence, I doubt it.

The people who want to be police officers tend not to be the people everyone else would want to be police officers.

shermantanktop··on I made tinnitus my friend, then it disappeared [video]
Interesting. This is from personal experience? Has anyone else eaten pineapple and had a similar experience?
shermantanktop··on New Mexico court orders Meta to pay $567m over harms to children’s mental health
The inverse incentive is what's in place today: a platform actively harming the users who signed up for it, in pursuit of ad dollars. The incentive is to extract maximum revenue while disregarding the real-world effects of actions, including driving children to self-harm or mental illness.

That's bizarre. But I know for some people, it doesn't seem bizarre, and just seems like "capitalism."

shermantanktop··on Pareto Front
They don’t cut the visible scope. They cut the monitoring, failover, automated patching, test coverage, deployment improvements, documentation, etc.
shermantanktop··on Pareto Front
I’m sadly twitchy when I hear “Pareto” - having endured numerous middle managers suggesting they can deliver 80% of the scope in 20% of the time (unrelated to the frontier topic here). Do that at each level of an org and the nonsense multiples rapidly.

The 80/20 “rule,” as far as I know, is meant to be descriptive after the fact. It can’t be used as a planning assumption. To be fair to those managers, they don’t really mean to be rigorous. They are just trying to justify cutting scope.

shermantanktop··on I'll be stepping back from leading product for X
Chesterton’s login?
shermantanktop··on The title cards in Blade Runner are amazing
Probably because non-type-nerds would not be amazed. They also wouldn’t switch between six different monospace fonts, or talk at length about how fonts generate feelings.

I’m glad there are people obsessed with fonts. But writing for people exactly like yourself is often limiting.

shermantanktop··on I’m leaving OpenAI to build telepathy
“meaning” emerges from a mental process. That mental process can consume things which were built to convey meaning (e.g. a novel) or were not (a waterfall).

Just because an AI bot says things that are meaningful, that doesn’t mean you need to assume it is intentional, sentient, or intelligent. It could vomit out a random Rorschach test and if you found meaning for yourself, you can still understand it was random.

I talk to a bot to sharpen my thinking, not to adopt its thinking.

shermantanktop··on Stateless MCP has recaptured my interest
Okay, here’s one I’m working through. When the workload consists of compound elements in multiple domains, agents work best when they see that as a flat surface of detailed resources. Traditional APIs work best when they hide the implementation details behind an ergonomic api.

So service API developers want to abstract and hide, over and over, and this means agents have less and less context and do more guessing.

shermantanktop··on Stateless MCP has recaptured my interest
I keep encountering mistakes by people who are convinced that agentic interactions are nothing new, that all the decades of hard-won lessons about service API design are 100% relevant and nothing more is needed, that agents can be relegated to the role of just-another-caller and left to the dismal domain of client developers.

It’s not true. It’s not totally untrue, but don’t hide your head in the sand.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →