HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shirakawasuna

265 karma · joined February 16, 2017

submissionscomments
shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
> Without trying to pick sides, the argument would be that these redistributive programs will not enhance public safety but instead will make things worse.

The police spend relatively little of their time doing what anyone would consider essential police work: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/19/upshot/unrest-police-time...

I see no reason that redistributing their duties related to things like traffic infractions, non-criminal calls, property crime, medical emergencies, etc. would do anything but help public safety, as cops are not particularly good at most of those things. They lack the training and professional culture to handle them appropriately. Rather than give them yet more money to train in such a wide variety of situations, we should have actual professionals that know how to handle, say, mental health crises respond to them, and only involve police as a backup to them at most.

Also, the vast majority of crime is related to poverty. Even gang violence is a product of poverty and the drug war, both of which can be addressed through policy and reallocation of funds.

> For those who can afford it, the safety "gap" will be addressed by private security forces, gated communities, or simply re-locating (and taking their tax dollars with them).

I wouldn't mind this much, as anyone interested in using their capital to do such things are also meddling unhelpfully in local politics.

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
SPD routinely started firing into crowds prior to making any such announcements, including the first time I was hit. The second time, they announced it and then immediately started firing at the crowd.

Announcing an unlawful assembly is not carte blanche to dole out collective punishment or violence, either.

There's already lawsuits ongoing. They won't go anywhere in terms of reforms because individual cops are virtually always indemnified, difficult to identify in these situations (many covered their badge numbers and nametags with tape), and the city will absorb the cost without the department taking any real hits.

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
Previous commenter is correct. I'm just saying I had first hand experience being targeted.
shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
> No, she didn’t lie

I watched her lie about something of which I have personal direct knowledge. Her claims have also been repeatedly contradicted by video evidence.

> and yes, it was a screaming mob. A mob that literally showed up on city council members doorsteps, among others.

Ah, the charged language. What's the difference between a "mob" and a protest making demands? This language reveals the sources you've been using for such information and they ain't great.

> I see you’re siding with the anarchists though, so this won’t be a productive conversation.

I would be curious to know what you think anarchists are.

> Accusing a black woman of racial profiling.

1. If this seems impossible to you, you should check out the actions of black cops. Profiling doesn't require the individual to be a white supremacist, e.g.

2. I didn't even claim that. I referred to the department.

> Good lord. You people are more racist than anyone.

In what way is anything I said racist?

> The consent decree did not recommend against hiring her (I just read it).

Ah, I misremembered which group it ran afoul of. Best's hiring was a mess. There was supposed to be a process: search committee finds options, Mayor makes a suggestion / selection, council confirms. What actually happened: search committee finds options, suggests hiring outside the department as the whole point was to institute reforms, and an outside hire would have no baggage in the department. The police union raises a ruckus about Best not being in the final 3 (she was already at SPD), this becomes news, and Durkan personally puts her on the finalist list, then selects her and council confirms.

> It’s also over 8 years old, long before her time, and they have since found them compliant.

The consent decree is a very low bar and the civilian oversight board has repeatedly stated that SPD is not following their recommendations or ready for end the consent decree. Despite this, Durkan and Best had applied for release from the consent decree in April. Part of that decree were issues regarding excessive force. As a reminder, SPD has been routinely beating protesters and indiscriminately teargassing protesters for nearly three months.

> The data says they use force in only 0.3% of encounters, and significant force likely to cause injury is only a small fraction of that:

> Further, the use of serious levels of force – force that causes or may be reasonably expected to cause substantial bodily injury – remained extraordinarily low, occurring in 21 of nearly 870,000 (0.0024% - or less than one quarter of one hundredth of a percent) of officer dispatches.

Based on police reporting. And remember, the vast majority of situations police are deployed to are in no way violent nor involve an arrest.

> Considering how unwilling many perps are, 21 out of 870,000 is shockingly low. Well done on the reform!

Uncritically accepting police number is going to lead you astray.

> There may be evidence of racism, but probably not the kind you think you are protesting. 42% of this force was used against white people, including 2 officer involved shootings, while 28% was against black people, including 0 officer involved shootings.

Those numbers imply a disproportionate racial impact already. Look at Seattle's demographics.

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
By cops and their lawyer who are trying to make a buck off of this.

The third precinct was abandoned when the fences started coming down. That's a full 30 minutes before any fires were started.

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
> You say the protests have achieved their goals. To me, that means they are an organized campaign of some sort.

As in there are various demands by various groups and you can identify the core where they overlap.

> The fact is, BLM is a national organization with nearly universal name recognition at this point. They have funding. They have PR teams. They are directing messaging.

BLM is decentralized. They don't have most of that.

> And the fact remains that I think "Defund the Police" is terrible messaging.

Okay. But it's not PR. It's not some campaign crafted by an overpaid consultant. It's a decentralized protest movement. I don't want it to be that, either. That's part of the problem in politics - caring far too much about this kind of thing. Focus on the realities, the people dying. The violent and aggressive and frequently racist police.

> > Please treat them like people.

> As I said at the beginning, I think we're talking past each other.

I think the attempt to infantilize was nearly dehumanizing.

> I never meant to dehumanize the protesters.

Then stop calling protests in response to murders by police a tantrum by oversized children.

> The main point I am trying to make is that as someone with no horse in this race (i.e. I am neither pro-BLM nor pro-police)

We all have a horse in this race. We live together in a society that has some level of control over things like policing, equity, violence, crime, poverty. The "neutral" position is implicit support for the status quo, much as being a "moderate" in politics indicates the same.

> if I were forced to pick a side on the issue based on my current view of what is and has happened over the past couple months, I would come down on the side of the police. I'd rather just stay out of it.

As I said before, ha.

> All this said, as much as I think our politics differ, I really do respect the way you've responded to people in this thread, and I hope there are more people like you among the protesters because then maybe you've got an actual shot at achieving your goals.

The vast majority of people in the protests are like me. You should go to one.

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
> So you weren't personally targeted.

I think I've clarified what I meant. I was targeted. I can't specify the exact degree to which anyone was skipped over to get to me.

> In what way were you targeted?

First time, it was indiscriminate use of teargas. Second time, indiscriminate use of teargas and a flashbang shot at my feet.

> Were you doing nothing to arouse police attention?

I was standing in a protest.

> I think most first world countries have a gas they can use for riot control. Are you insisting that most first world countries are regularly engaging in what you would call war crimes... that are worse than other countries?

It would be a war crime if it were a foreign military force using it against the exact same crowd, but not if it's cops. War crimes have a way of being selectively (un)enforced when it comes to those in power, in any case.

Police are fairly atrocious in most countries, so I don't think there's much point in trying to figure out exactly where I'd rank the police in the US. It wouldn't make it right if it were average or not.

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
> With reduced policing and increased chaos and rioting it seems logical that those with means will employ private security forces.

Why do you believe chaos and rioting will be the outcome of reworking policing? That "chaos" and riots are a direct result of the status quo of violent and often racist policing.

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
I think people's lives matter more than critiquing a slogan.
shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
> So regular riot control equipment in 95% of the world...

Yes, militarization of the police is normalized in many countries. That doesn't make it acceptable. They're trigger-happy and violent. It's part of the culture.

> The only other stuff they mention are semi-auto rifles which are not militarization. Us civilians have the same rifles which are way more accurate than a standard handgun. I dont want an officer using a handgun at 50-100 yards trying to stop an active shooter, I want them to have the best tool for the job which would be a patrol rifle. That's safer for everyone, especially bystanders.

Do you believe that there needs to be a line of officers wielding rifles behind a line of riot cops with flashbangs and tear gas launchers (used liberally and indiscriminately) behind a line of shielded riot cops grabbing things from protesters and generally trying to provoke a reaction? These things all work in tandem, in this context. That line of cops is part of their show of force, as they take anti-cop protests very personally. It's a form of intimidation and escalation.

> How is riot control pads / shields and an armored vehicle to stop bullets and rocks being thrown militarization?

Half of that is literally military equipment and US police departments are frequently under a "warrior" mindset. It's been heavily exported to various different PDs. They treat confrontations as a fight between them and the "bad guys", not public safety or law enforcement. Having a bunch of military or tacticool gear is part of that mindset.

> I don't see any offensive weapons used other than crowd control agents which last I checked are used in most of the world for the same purpose.

Normalization is not the same as moral or acceptable. Plus, this isn't quite a consistent take when it comes to these kinds of things. When Soviet bloc countries used far less serious responses to color revolutions, they were decried as totalitarian, antidemocratic monsters. But we do worse here and it's just normal business as usual.

And those "crowd control" agents are chemical weapons, explosives, and "less lethal" weapons causing permanent disability and injury. I watched a woman get shot with a grenade (either flashbang or teargas) and she went into cardiac arrest, only living because medics rushed her to the hospital. She was forward but still 30 feet from any officers. She was shot straight in the chest. She was just standing there and yelling.

> Judging how the protests have turned to riots over the past few months in major cities, they are completely justified in doing so.

They absolutely are not. It's a form of escalation and the cops have frequently provoked these responses with theses "shows of force".

> Getting rocks, molotov cocktails and everything else under the sun thrown at you when you're trying to stop people from burning down communities would make me want the best protection too.

The cops aren't trying to stop people from burning down communities. They don't actually do that, they don't deescalate, they don't actually even defend the private property (which is usually much of their function) so much as blast through and hurt people indiscriminately.

> But even in those cases the vehicles are used as transport and command / observation platforms. You mostly have a problem with crowd control tactics it sounds like which are pretty standard when dealing with a declared riot. Here is a good video on the tactics with explanations: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yT9bit2-1pg

I'm very familiar with their tactics, they used them against me.

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
I mean I was targeted. By personally I meant that I had that personal experience. It was as part of a group - the cops tend to use "collective punishment" when it comes to protests, after all.

The use of tear gas is the use of a chemical weapon and a war crime, but when you turn it against civilians in your own country we give it a pass.

shirakawasuna··on Global Mass Surveillance – The Fourteen Eyes
My general sense is that offensive capabilities are much better than defensive ones when it comes to security / surveillance. e.g., even using a VPN and a vanilla browser with no history and arbitrary window size is nearly worthless when it comes to many forms of surveillance.

Are there any guides out there that consider all the means by which you can attempt to shield yourself from these intrusions, including a description of the attack vectors?

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
> Then they are utterly useless

They've achieved many, though far from all, of their goals in various municipalities.

Why do you believe that a PR campaign is the only protest of value?

> The way you phrased it, the protests are nothing more than tantrums by oversized children.

That is in no way implied from how I phrased it. Pain and weariness from racialized murders and intimidation by cops is not a childish tantrum and I hope you never have to endure that pain yourself. I do hope that you find the empathy to consider their position.

> Tantrums should not be rewarded.

Please treat them like people.

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
I mean, they buy all kinds of military surplus or "tacticool" gear. Here's a random article going over a bit of it: https://www.tampabay.com/news/crime/2020/08/03/police-in-tam...

My police department should not be anywhere near militarized. It's inappropriate, wrong, and is a waste of funds because they should not be kitted out that way.

They bring out those vehicles during protests, among other things. People standing around chanting. Then they wait until curfew is over, maybe declare the assembly unlawful, and start using chemical weapons and intimidation on the crowd.

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
How many people were in that Minneapolis precinct?
shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
Why do you say that? The calls are for redistributing the funds to other municipal forces or programs.
shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
I've seen cops get downright giddy over having an excuse to gas and beat a protest. One of them had a little smiley face on the end of their baton and was fully kitted in riot gear.
shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
There's no irony there and it was not a "screaming mob". I'm concerned about your sources of information.

Chief Best stepped down after constantly lying about the police actions and the protesters for months. Best was hired against the recommendations of the federal consent decree that SPD is under because of repeated excessive force and racial profiling issues, hand-picked by the mayor. The reasons given for her stepping down are relatively boring and unlikely to be the real reason, which probably involves political calculus and the mayor.

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
As someone who was personally targeted by violent police for kneeling and holding my hands up, let me assure you that they are correct.

Have you gone to any protests where the police used chemical weapons?

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
That usually means that the police used fairly extreme violence and chemical weapons on protesters and received maybe a handful of water bottles thrown at them after doing so.

Your news sources have an agenda and tend to get these things wrong. Go to a protest and see for yourself if you want to viscerally watch them lie in real time.

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
Have you gone to any protests?

I got teargassed holding my hands up and chanting. Twice.

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
I would consider them a vehicle of capital that tends to do a terrible job covering these things. Conservative-adjascent.
shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
This is not a PR campaign and the protests and riots are not a public outreach effort. They are a demand coming from a position of pain and weariness.
shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
It's not a PR campaign. It wasn't planned for maximum effect or focus grouped. It's just what caught on.
shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
Defund also means balkanization of police duties. The police spend about 5% of their time on violent crime. They're also highly resistant to reforms and oversight. If we reduced police budgets by 80%, restricting their duties to those we consider necessary police work, they would be much smaller and easier to manage. The excess budget could go both to funding social services and to paying social workers, etc to do the other jobs that police currently do (and do badly).
shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
We can argue about the marginal benefit of investing in late-stage interventions, but it's certainly doing more than cops buying Humvees and LARPING as tacticool warriors.
shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
Defunding is a two-part task:

1. Balkanize police into distinct departments with different training and oversight. The police are tasked with far too many jobs at once and don't do a very good job at any of them.

2. Redirect some portion of funding to community development and fighting poverty, i.e. crime prevention. Instead of buying military surplus equipment, create after-school programs, ensure that kids get fed, etc.

If a police department is stretched thin, balkanizing should help with that. Having police doing too many things is a big part of the problem.

The police resist reforms constantly. They protect themselves and lie brazenly with little consequence. While morale is certainly something to consider, it's not the elephant in the room. There must be real consequences, and for that there must be real mechanisms of oversight, firing, and prosecution of cops and those who act in bad faith to protect fellow cops.

shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
Defunding is a solution because reform has never worked.
shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
None of that was a slogan.
shirakawasuna··on Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence
The goal of the defund movements is to balkanize police duties so that the people tasked with these duties have appropriate training, weaponry (if any), etc, to place more money into community development and fighting poverty, and to increase civilian oversight, since there have been decades and decades of attempts to reform the police and it does not work.
← PreviousPage 5 of 8Next →