HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

short_sells_poo

2,257 karma · joined July 19, 2013

submissionscomments
short_sells_poo··on Thermodynamics rules future orbital data centers
Because that's the next generation's problem, and we can do more to mortgage their future for our own luxury :)
short_sells_poo··on Job: Head of Stonehenge
What? No that will not allow you to buy "most houses in London in cash after saving for 5 years" unless you live far out of town in a tiny place and eat plain rice for 5 years, and even then it'll be long odds.

First, you'll take home slightly over half of that net of various taxes and deductions, but let's be generous and say your take-home is 200k. You live very frugally, don't go out, don't really buy anything and keep your costs at 50k a year, including rent (!). That leaves you with 150k a year, so after 5 years you have 750k. This allows you to buy a modest 2-3 bed row house with a postage stamp sized garden in one of the less desirable areas of the city.

If you want something that doesn't look like a shed, you are looking at 1 million pounds and up, more like 1.5 million. If you want in a nice area and large garden, make it 2 million.

short_sells_poo··on Dopamine Fracking
I think we are being got at, but I'll bite :D

To be clear: my objection is not at all about enjoying the finer side of life, there's nothing wrong with that. Harrods and a lot of the surrounding areas are not about that. By and large, the crowd who likes that area (and I'm not placing you among them) are there because they want to appear among the rich and flash their shitty LV or Gucci bag which they probably picked up somewhere at a discount.

There are two kinds of drivers of expensive cars:

1. Those who drive their Bentley Continental GT because they appreciate the craftsmanship and the smooth ride

2. Those who are inching along in traffic in Kensington because they want the world to see they have a Bentley.

One of these groups is genuinely wealthy and have class will be driving their grand tourer somewhere in France or Italy on nice roads to their villa, or if they don't like driving, they'll be driven by staff. If they aren't nepo babies, they'll be just as dismayed about the difficulties that 99% of the population lives under, because ultimately we are all in the same boat. If 99% of the crew are unhappy, eventually the captain and the officers will be thrown overboard to the sharks. If the captain wants to have a good time, they have to make sure the crew aren't unhappy at least.

short_sells_poo··on Dopamine Fracking
You have to be joking, right? So you are saying that it's all fine, because we can just go to Harrods to get quality food?

Nevermind that I hate Harrods and that entire area with a passion. It's a tasteless, glitzy tourist trap.

My post was all about the fact that barring a tiny percentile of people who a) live in an affluent area and b) are willing to pay 2-3x the regular supermarket prices, you cannot get good quality food. And you say "ah it's simples, just go to the most egregiously flashy beacon of division between the rich and poor and you can get good fruit"

Thank you, I can still get good fruit at my local grocer in Wimbledon, because it charges 2-3x over the regular high street prices and there are people around who can pay this. Doesn't help someone living in Croydon and having to go to Tesco, does it now.

short_sells_poo··on Zig by Example
Don't be ridiculous. Learning? That's for the dinosaurs. Just throw an llm at the problem!
short_sells_poo··on Dopamine Fracking
Living in London, I notice the same. Getting access to true quality produce is not even a question of money now, it's basically just impossible to get full stop. There are a few local shops in the more upmarket areas that survive on the fact that people are willing to pay the 2-3x premium over the prices at Waitrose.

Gone are the days when you could ask the grocer or farmer to give you a peach to taste. People got used to having 24/7/365 access to everything, and supermarkets optimized purely for looks instead of taste and nutrition, because you aren't allowed to taste anything there. The only thing you can go by is the looks. This means looks sell.

I'd hazard a guess the vast majority of brits don't even know what a proper strawberry tastes like, because the only thing they can buy are beautifully polished turds. Everything tastes watery and crap, or conversely just generic "sweet".

I wouldn't even blame farmers. Their life is hard enough. They are operating on razor thin margins in a very uncertain environment. The consumer (against their own interests) demands that they produce beautifully and cheap turds, so that's what they'll produce. And if you try to do the right thing, you simply run out of money because you can't compete with the turds at the supermarket.

I only have empirical evidence for this, but it got much worse since Brexit as well. The variety has gone down a lot, I see shelves routinely empty at supermarkets and they all seem to be focusing on the same ultraprocessed crap.

short_sells_poo··on Numexpr: Fast numerical array expression evaluator for Python, NumPy, Pandas
I understand what numexpr does, I don't understand why I'd use it.

Polars is able to lazy evaluate query plans without any unnecessary intermediate allocations, if I want to do algebra on dataframes, I'd use polars.

The narrow usecase seems to be that you have large matrices such that memory efficiency is a concern, but not so large that they don't fit into memory at all.

My point was that this seems like a very narrow niche to me, where I'd still rather use numba or taichi purely because I don't have to evaluate raw strings and can still rely on linters.

short_sells_poo··on AI is just unauthorised plagiarism at a bigger scale
Nobody said that it's useless, that's a straw man.

But it also isn't a free exchange of ideas. It's a concentration of capabilities in the hands of a few corporations.

short_sells_poo··on AI is just unauthorised plagiarism at a bigger scale
It's not hated because it impacts people's wages, although that perhaps factors into the hate. It's hated because AI is not a public good. The LLMS today are owned by megacorporations who harvested a public good for private gain.

This is not some altruistic entity striving for the betterment of humankind. Practically nothing that comes out of the techbro culture is. This is pure and simple greed and the chances that AI can be a vehicle of altruism when it is owned by megacorps is basically zero.

short_sells_poo··on AI is just unauthorised plagiarism at a bigger scale
There are two issues the author raises (as I understand it):

1. People copying others' work, made much easier by AI.

2. AI companies effectively harvesting all the accessible information on an industrial scale and completely sidestepping any permissioning or licensing questions.

I believe both of these are bad and saying "people copied each others' works before the advent of AI" is a poor cop out. It's tantamount to saying that there's no reason to regulate guns more than say knives, because people have used knives to kill each other before guns were invented. The capabilities matter.

The way LLMs empower wholesale "stealing" rather than collaboration is quite evident: why collaborate when you can just feed an entire existing project into the agent of your choice and tell it to spit out a new implementation based on the old one, with a few tweaks of your choice, and then publish it as your work? I put "steal" in quotes because it's perhaps not really stealing per-se, but there's a distinct wrongness here. The LLM operator often doesn't actually possess any expertise, hasn't done any of the hard work, but they can take someone else's work wholesale, repackage it and sell it as their own.

Then there's the second, and IMO much more egregious transgression, which is that the LLM companies have taken what is effectively a public good, but more specifically content that they haven't asked permission to use, and just blanket fed it into their models.

Legally speaking, it's perhaps A-OK because it's not copyright infringement (IANAL). But people on this site often hold the view that if something is a-priori legal, it is also moral (I'm not accusing you of this). What the LLM companies have done is profoundly immoral. They extracted a fortune of the goods and work made by others, without even bothering to ask for permission - or even considering this permission. And then they resell access to this treasure to the public.

Perhaps AI will bring an era of prosperity to humankind like we haven't seen before, perhaps it won't, but that changes nothing about the wrongness of how it started.

short_sells_poo··on Numexpr: Fast numerical array expression evaluator for Python, NumPy, Pandas
What is the advantage of using Numexpr instead of say Polars, Numba or Taichi?

Numexpr seems to sit in a sort of odd niche of having to do relatively simple arithmetic on in-core matrix data fast. For anything more complex, Polars seems more powerful and yet easier to understand, Numba and Taichi are both much more flexible in that they can be used to implement much more complex arithmetic (at the cost of writing lower level python code).

Numexpr basically evaluates raw strings, which makes any sort of heavy usage basically immune to linting, code inspection and refactoring.

Pandas has the eval() method on the Dataframe that uses numexpr as backend, but we generally never use it because of the upper mentioned maintenance issues and the availability of better alternatives.

short_sells_poo··on AI slop is killing online communities
Is SA still a thing? I had an account since... 2007? God I'm old. I miss the days when you could have a community that you could easily search for content. Nowadays everything is a discord black hole.
short_sells_poo··on "Parse, don't validate" through the years with C++
I hope this is not trolling so I'll bite. It is incredibly natural to represent an object, such as an email, as an Email class in object oriented languages like C++. It'd then have a constructor that accepts a string and constructs the email object from said string, or maybe a parse(string) -> Option<Email> thingy. The type system then ensures the checks are present whenever they have to be, and nowhere else.

Tl;dr: there's nothing extra that functional or OO programming give you here. Both allow you to represent the problem in a properly typed fashion. Why would you represent an email as a string unless you are a) deeply inexperienced or b) have some really good reason to drop all the benefits of a strongly typed language?

short_sells_poo··on Tangled – We need a federation of forges
I don't get the joke and I'm a bit too worried about googling this on my work pc, can you please enlighten me what's up with the word knot :D
short_sells_poo··on We need a federation of forges
Slight tangent: the post says that github is crumbling. Can someone get me up to date on what's going on please? Admittedly I'm not following tech drama particularly closely, but I thought I'd have heard if a major thing like github was going down the chute.
short_sells_poo··on Open Source Isn't Dead. Cal.com Just Learned the Wrong Lesson
This is happening quite a lot actually. People just feed an existing project into their agent harness and have it regenerate more or less the same with a few tweaks and then they publish it.

I'm not sure how this works in the legal sense. A human could ostensibly study an existing project and then rewrite it from scratch. The original work's license shouldn't apply as long as code wasn't copy & pasted, right?

What happens when an automated tool does the same? It's basically just a complicated copy & paste job.

short_sells_poo··on What being ripped off taught me
It's actually unbelievable that this would be taught as anything but a cautionary tale of survivorship bias.

The FedEx founder got lucky. The countless others who tried a similar gamble didn't and unfortunately their story doesn't seem to be taught because "desperate founder gambled the employees salary and lost" just doesn't have the same ring.

short_sells_poo··on Goodbye to Sora
I see where you are going with this, but IMO this is not a technical problem but a legal problem.

Who will be held responsible when an AI agent messes up the HR system and the company is exposed to losses due to a mistake? Who is going to be responsible when your SEO agent overspends?

Ultimately, it's going to be you most likely, because I can't see AI firms taking this responsibility.

You might argue that right now it also falls on the employer, since employees are rarely held responsible for genuine mistakes, even if it ends in disaster, however you have a lot of agency over what an employee is doing. Their motivation is generally correlated with doing well, because past success ensures future career growth.

An AI agent has no such incentives. The AI company will just charge you some minimal fee to provide the service, and if it messes up, will wash their hands of responsibility and tell you that you should've been more careful in using it.

I dislike Taleb for various reasons, but using AI agents is basically the definition of a fragile system. It works 99% of the time, lulling people into this sense of security where they can just offload all their work very conveniently. And then 1% of the time (or 0.01% of the time), it ends in utter disaster, which people are very bad at dealing with.

short_sells_poo··on Microsoft's "fix" for Windows 11
Parent is pointing at the fact that the relationship between our perception of MS products and their financial success is highly inelastic. The bottom line isn't impervious to bad product decisions, but there can be a large number of user hostile decisions that PMs push through that still increase revenue on the whole even at the cost of user satisfaction, before they move past the optimal point in the payoff curve.
short_sells_poo··on Show HN: Threadprocs – executables sharing one address space (0-copy pointers)
How would this really help python though? This doesn't solve the difficult problem, which is that python objects don't support parallel access by multiple threads/processes, no? Concurrent threads, yes, but only one thread can be operating on a python object at a time (I'm simplifying here for brevity).

There are already means of passing around bulk data with zero copy characteristics in python, but there's a lot of bureaucracy around it. A true solution must work with the GIL (or remove it altogether), no?

short_sells_poo··on Warranty Void If Regenerated
Ah sorry, fair enough. I guess you were, are and will have been getting this question quite frequently :D

I used dashes quite frequently in the past, but stopped using them to avoid being associated with llm generated text :(

It's a shame really, because it is a useful gramatical tool.

short_sells_poo··on Fyn: An uv fork with new features, bug fixes, stripped telemetry
I like it a lot :D.

Virtual environments have been always associated with projects in your use case I guess.

In my use case, they almost never are. Most people in my industry have 1-2 venvs that they use across all their projects, and uv forcing it into a single project directory made it quite inconvenient and unnecessary duplication of the same sets of libraries.

I dislike conda not because of the centralized venvs, but because it's bloated, poorly engineered, slow and inconvenient to use.

At the end of the day, this gives us choice. People can use uv or they can use fyn and have both use cases covered.

short_sells_poo··on I built an AI receptionist for a mechanic shop
Just how much effort even went into this? The project is LLM generated, the blog post is LLM generated. It produced something that is really annoying to deal with as a consumer. The last thing I want to talk with when calling a boutique garage is some AI receptionist.

Why should people be impressed by this?

short_sells_poo··on I built an AI receptionist for a mechanic shop
You are right, but this also isn't a luxury mechanic shop. A luxury mechanic shop would be a place that services and customizes Bentleys, RRs, vintage Ferraris and similar. And to your point, the clientele there will be extremely unimpressed if they are asked to speak with an AI. A place like that is as much about being pampered by staff as about the workmanship.

OP's brother is by all accounts running a successful boutique workshop, but the various luxury annotations were completely unnecessary and just detract from the actual project. If they do want to lean into the luxury segment, being cheap with AI receptionists is not the way to go. They need to hire actual staff who has experience with HNW individuals.

short_sells_poo··on Warranty Void If Regenerated
Are you an AI? This looks like it was at least ran through an LLM judging by the heaps of em dashes.
short_sells_poo··on Pandas Exercises for Data Analysis (Interactive)
You'll get a lot of responses saying Polars is better than Pandas. I argue those people are missing the point and don't understand Pandas' real strength or why people choose Pandas today.

Pandas was never meant to be a technologist's tool. It was meant to be a researcher's tool and was unfortunately coopted to be a technical solution as well. It has not well escaped it's roots.

Pandas is fantastic for doing iterative and interactive research on semi-structured data. It has a lot of QoL facilities and utility functions for seamlessly dealing with exploratory timeseries analytics for in-core data. Data that fits into memory.

For example, I can take two time series and calculate their product:

ts3 = ts1 * ts2

This one line does a huge amount of heavily lifting by automatically aligning the timestamps and columns between the two inputs so that I'm not accidentally multiplying two entries that have the same ordinal but not the same timestamp or column label.

Can I do the same with Polars? Yes, but it comes with exponentially more cognitive overhead. And this is just one example.

Pandas is ultimately a flawed product as it's origin's go back more than a decade where R's dataframe was cutting edge. A lot of innovation happened since then and the API and internals of Pandas mean that certain choices that were made early on are nontrivial to change.

This doesn't change the fact that Pandas is still immensely useful. Eventually perhaps Polars will come close to it, but so far the focus wasn't on interactive use ergonomics unfortunately.

As it stands, I use pandas for research and polars for production systems.

short_sells_poo··on Pandas Exercises for Data Analysis (Interactive)
For short scripts and interactive research work, pandas is still much better than polars. Polars works well when you know what you want.

When you are still figuring out things step by step, pandas does a lot of heavy lifting for you so you don't have to think about it.

E.g. I don't have to think about timeseries alignment, pandas handles that for me implicitly because dataframes can be indexed by timestamps. Polars has timeseries support, but I need to write a paragraph of extra code to deal with it.

short_sells_poo··on Claude now creates interactive charts, diagrams and visualizations
They clearly vibe code a lot (most? all?) of their stuff, and it shows. Elementary features are broken regularly and while I appreciate them trying new features, I'd appreciate it more if existing ones were reliable and promptly fixed if broken.
short_sells_poo··on Redox OS has adopted a Certificate of Origin policy and a strict no-LLM policy
For a human to be able to do any customization, they have to dive into the code and work with it, understand it, gain intuition for it. Engage with the maintainers and community. In the process, there's a good chance that they'll be encouraged to contribute improvements upstream even if they have their own fork.

Vibe coders don't have to do any of this. They don't have to understand anything, they can just have their LLMs do some modifications that are completely opaque to the vibe coder.

Perhaps the long term steady state will be a goldilocks renaissance of open source where lots of new ideas and contributors spring up, made capable with AI assistance. But so far what I've seen is the opposite. These people just feed existing work into their LLMs, produce derivative works and never bother to engage with the original authors or community.

short_sells_poo··on Redox OS has adopted a Certificate of Origin policy and a strict no-LLM policy
This is not even about capabilities but responsibility. In an open source context where the maintainers take no responsibility for the code, it's perhaps easier. In a professional context, ultimately it's the human who is responsible, and the human has to make the call whether they trust the LLM enough.

Imagine someone vibe codes the code for a radiotherapy machine and it fries a patient (humans have made these errors). The developer won't be able to point to OpenAI and blame them for this, the developer is personally responsible for this (well, their employer is most likely). Ergo, in any setting where there is significant monetary or health risk at stake, humans have to review the code at least to show that they've done their due diligence.

I'm sure we are going to have some epic cases around someone messing up this way.

← PreviousPage 2 of 29Next →