HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

short_sells_poo

2,257 karma · joined July 19, 2013

submissionscomments
short_sells_poo··on Transformers Can Do Arithmetic with the Right Embeddings
This is such a strawman. Do you have to really stoop to this level? There are a billion useless things people pay for, is that a measure of the intelligence behind it? People routinely pay $1000 dollars for a dog, does that mean a dog is 50x more intelligent than ChatGPT? All I'm saying is that we should be a bit more humble about intelligence when we understand so little about it.

Just because LLMs are useful, it doesn't mean they exhibit more intelligence than a mouse. A mouse probably also doesn't reason about anything, but it is an agent capable of independent behavior, something that is still very far removed from current AI models.

short_sells_poo··on Transformers Can Do Arithmetic with the Right Embeddings
Oh I'm very much with you. In fact I get irked by people here breathlessly parroting that human level AGI is upon us any day now. I'd be impressed if an AI had mouse level capabilities any time soon. I think the current models are very impressive, but they are parlor tricks compared to what a true AGI should be capable of.
short_sells_poo··on Show HN: Sum (algebraic) types for C in one 100 line header
I think parent means simple as in the language has very few facilities and the ones it gives you are very barebones (hence simple). C is simple in the sense that a screwdriver is simple compared to a power tool.

It doesn't mean that it is simple to use correctly. An expert might be able to accurately judge the torque achieved by hand, but a beginner can easily under- or over-torque things. Etc...

short_sells_poo··on Transformers Can Do Arithmetic with the Right Embeddings
Well, 99% of day to day life is mundane for much of living beings on earth. A bee is able to get through it's entire life without showing signs that it deeply ponders about anything.

However, humans have the ability to reason about things (whether most people use this ability is a different question). So then we must ask the question: is this ability just a more advanced form of probabilistic pattern matching, or is it a different architecture altogether? Will current AI models be able to develop this ability, or will we need new models?

short_sells_poo··on Transformers Can Do Arithmetic with the Right Embeddings
Of course there are cases like this, nobody is perfect. But we are talking about mathematics here, not everyday subconscious decision making. I agree that 99% of daily life is trivial pattern recognition. That's not what distinguishes humans though is it? Because animals, down to single celled organisms do just fine without higher order mental capabilities. But we are talking about reasoning here - and specifically about structured one like math.
short_sells_poo··on Transformers Can Do Arithmetic with the Right Embeddings
I suppose it's a question whether what we call "reasoning" is an emergent phenomenon from having enough connections in a graph, or whether it's some other special sauce which we simply don't have in our current models yet. E.g. humans follow a deductive process to answer questions which they haven't encountered yet. Do we gain this ability purely from a denser/larger graph of knowledge, or from a completely different architecture?

I think until we know the answer to this, we can't make predictions about how to build true AGI.

short_sells_poo··on Autonomous AI Robot Creates a Shock-Absorbing Shape No Human Ever Could
Unfortunately the moment you get dollar bills attached to particular words, everyone starts using them. AI sells. Evolutionary algorithms do not. So everyone chasing the sweet dollar will say AI and other buzzwords.
short_sells_poo··on Meteor seen in Portugal
Any space expert able to explain the very vivid blue colour please? I distinctly remember most meteors are either white or greenish tinted. Was it just the composition, or was it down to higher temperatures reached due to the higher speed?
short_sells_poo··on Fastest rate of natural carbon dioxide rise over the last 50k years
Consciousness appears to be a form of intelligence. Is it required for general intelligence (whatever that means)? We don't know. Would humans be classified as having general intelligence if we weren't conscious? In any case, I perhaps worded that poorly. I wasn't saying that consciousness is the same as intelligence, it was just an example of how little we actually understand intelligence.

> AGI simply means that we can create a type of machine that can do any kind of mental task that a human can, at least at a human level.

What does this even mean? What is human level? The ability to write a symphony? Or the ability to calculate 2+2=4? These are such poorly defined metrics that I don't understand how can we then start throwing around very precise (and short!) timelines for attaining it.

The statement: "we'll send a human mission to Mars in the next 5 years" is 10x more believable than this breathless AGI hype, because at least the former is well defined.

short_sells_poo··on Fastest rate of natural carbon dioxide rise over the last 50k years
I didn't say that AGI requires consciousness, just that we don't understand what intelligence truly is, along with consciousness (which appears to be a form of intelligence).

And I'm not particularly keen of the reasoning: "it is solving novel problems that humans struggle with", because a pocket calculator can solve problems that humans struggle with. A computer can play chess better than a human can, does it mean it's an AGI?

short_sells_poo··on Fastest rate of natural carbon dioxide rise over the last 50k years
I'm loving this absolutely breathless parroting of "AGI in the next 5 years" and yet: we don't even know what general intelligence is. We don't know how/why/where consciousness arises. It's not even a clearly defined concept. But here we have "Workaccount2" prophesizing the rise of general intelligence :D

Please enlighten us sensei, what is actually General Intelligence, and how will you know it's here?

I realize my reply is a bit flippant, but it's tiring to see how certain are people about something that nobody truly understands.

short_sells_poo··on GPT-4o
> I am routinely getting zero useful results on the first page or two of Google searches, but AI is answering or giving me guidance quickly.

To me, this just sounds like Google Search has become shit, and since Google simply isn't going to give up the precious ad $$$ that the current format is generating, the next best thing is ChatGPT. But this is different from saying that ChatGPT is a similar step up like Search was.

For what it's worth, I agree with you that Google Search has become unusable. Google basically destroyed it's best product (for users), by turning it into an ad riddles shovelware cesspit.

That ChatGPT is similarly good like Google Search used to be, is a tragedy. Basically we had a conceptually simple product that functioned very well, and we are replacing it with a significantly more complex product.

short_sells_poo··on Attackers can decloak routing-based VPNs
People confuse Switzerland and Swaziland and those two aren't even on the same continent :)
short_sells_poo··on Tougher rules for sellers of internet-enabled devices in the UK
Your first point was addressed by my sibling comment.

> Which implies being happy with the status quo.

At this point it feels like you are trolling. By your logic, I hope you are out in Angola distributing food, because otherwise you are obviously happy about people dying of starvation. See what I did there?

Brexit built it's entire campaign on "taking back control of the borders and restricting immigration". For Remain, the issue with Brexit was losing access to the EU single market and Schengen free movement zone, which were the focal points of their campaign. None of the sides campaigned against hunger in Angola, therefore by your logic everyone in the UK - including you - is positively happy about the status quo of Angolans starving?

short_sells_poo··on Tougher rules for sellers of internet-enabled devices in the UK
It's likely down to the fact that once the proverbial Polish Plumbers left, a lot of people realized that there's nobody here who actually wants to do that work, no matter the price. So we have no nurses, we have no truck drivers, we have no electricians. And the list goes on.

And it's impossible to import these people anymore, because a) the wages in the UK are low - lower than in most of the EU and much lower than in the US, and b) many of these professions are not really classified as high skill, even if they take a lot of practice.

short_sells_poo··on Tougher rules for sellers of internet-enabled devices in the UK
You keep pushing this strawman. Just because someone wasn't for something, it doesn't mean they were against it. Immigration was simply not an issue on the Remainers' minds. Immigration was the main Brexiter point.
short_sells_poo··on Tougher rules for sellers of internet-enabled devices in the UK
I can promise you that if you anonymously asked the majority of the rural Brexit voters (rural areas being where the majority of Brexit votes came from), they'll all say that they are culturally closer to white Europeans than to dark skinned non-Europeans.

The UK shares much more and much longer of it's history with Europe than with it's former colonies. We are talking about thousands of years going back to Roman times, instead the less than hundred that the general British colonial rule lasted. The Royal family has Danish and German blood.

Does this mean anything? Not really. It's all semantics.

The actual outcome is very simple: the UK demolished it's ties with it's closest neighbours and biggest single economic block, for some questionable ties with very far away countries. In doing so, it now has very little negotiating power on it's own and has to build many relationships from scratch, from a very weak starting position.

The financial situation of much of the population is dire. The only real reason why one would want to immigrate to the UK is the financial sector, which is still hanging on. If you voted for Brexit, I'd like to say "good luck, I hope you like the taste of the meal you cooked".

short_sells_poo··on Tougher rules for sellers of internet-enabled devices in the UK
I don't remember seeing any emphasis on immigration from the remainers. The remainers simply wanted to stay part of the EU for the economic and travel benefits. The Brexit campaign made immigration a focus point, and of course both Johnson and Farage had to provide some reasoning about replacing EU immigration. Once out of the EU, the only other immigration to replace it with was non-EU. So their argument was: we don't want to be in the EU, we still need immigration, so we'll replace it with skilled non-EU immigration.

Basically the UK replaced the culturally and economically close immigration from EU with culturally and economically far immigration from other countries, while also kneekapping itself economically...

And finally: "This is one reason a lot of us Brown people voted for Brexit. not my main reason, which was mostly opposition to further integration (the commitment to "ever closer integration") and some aspects of EU decision making, legislation and regulation."

Perhaps. Or perhaps it is the very common pattern of immigrants voting against further immigrants coming in. Notably, a very significant LatAm immigrant continent in the US are staunch Republican voters against immigration. Sure, they might come up with a variety of excuses why they are voting against their fellow countrymen being able to immigrate like they did, but ultimately it's quite clearly an attempt to burn the bridge behind them to close off further competiton for their own jobs.

short_sells_poo··on Carl Sagan, nuking the moon, and not nuking the moon
I agree that civilizations (including humans) are unlikely to completely wipe themselves out, but it is not at all certain that we could recover to our present technology after a cataclysmic event.

Once we mine out all easily accessible fossil fuels, we'll cross a certain point of no return. After that point, a 19th century type industrial revolution will no longer be (easily) possible. Let's say a truly cataclysmic war happens and we just lose access to modern technology. Would we be able to regain it at some point? Could we rebuild a modern civilization without having access to the most energy dense and convenient fuel known to us even today?

Sure, we wouldn't go extinct, but if we are no longer able to travel beyond our own planet, we may as well have filtered ourselves out from the galactic stage.

short_sells_poo··on The emotional trial of clinical trials: like online dating with death risk
I'm sorry for what your wife and you have gone through and I cannot imagine the frustration caused when being at the mercy of a seemingly uncaring bureaucracy and having little power to do anything.

I do think that more often than not, the doctors appear uncaring because they're under a very similar feeling that you experienced - but all the time. If they don't build emotional barriers, they wouldn't be able to cope. I feel this is doubly true for areas like oncology where death is a much more regular occurrence and can happen even when everyone has done everything right.

I cannot fathom the feeling of having to see people wither away, to see family after family lose their loved ones. Any doctor who doesn't learn to completely distance themselves from it all is probably not going to last.

short_sells_poo··on Yes, social media is a cause of the epidemic of teenage mental illness
I agree with you. It feels like some people here never interact with kids. It really is a very difficult problem to solve. You ban your kids from participating in social media, and you might end up hurting them much more by isolating them and getting them ostracized. In the end your cure ends up doing more damage than the illness would've. I absolutely agree that we should do something, and I'm trying my best. However, as long as a critical mass of young people are partaking, I cannot in good conscience force kids to stay off, because I know how bad that would make their life. So it's all about education and drilling the dangers into them as much as I can. Ultimately, this is a new world, with new rules and new dangers. The generation of millenials, boomers, etc - we are on the way out. We can advise the new generation, but they will have to find their own way to handle the dangers.
short_sells_poo··on Supreme Commander Graphics Study (2015)
If you are a sweaty tryhard I agree. But I personally want cool powerfantasies and big explosions while gaming, otherwise I could just as well play chess or go.

To be clear, I'm not arguing against clear silhouettes, but the general unit design. The robots often just look wacky. Like the sumo thing is this lumbering trashcan that could as well be accompanied by a tuba soundtrack.

short_sells_poo··on Supreme Commander Graphics Study (2015)
I want to like BAR because it is so obviously made with passion and attention to detail but I can't get over how wonky the units look. I don't mean the quality, but the design. They don't look at all cool and I can't get the power fantasy of leading an army of killer robots. I feel like leading some random hodgepodge of guns mounted on trash cans.
short_sells_poo··on Santa Barbara's collective memory, sold for kindling
It's grotesque that this is not even the direct effect of the advertising industry, it is the side effect of Google's algo to sort results.

Being ranked higher in the Goog results is sadly worth more than a town's historical records.

I wonder if things were different if Google wasn't allowed to monopolize search.

short_sells_poo··on "She's bouncing the ball" – the uncanny way octopuses play
Animals receive and give very little mercy or kindness in nature. In fact, nature is capable of stunning brutality - eg newly "crowned" male lions kill off the cubs of the old male.

Humans have a capacity of reasoning about their actions, which places a certain responsibility on us to do better than nature. But where do you draw the line?

Ultimately we shouldn't eat animals at all - we should eat lab grown meat. But lab grown meat is still far away. So what do we do in the mean time? Ban all meat consumption? Is that even realistic?

short_sells_poo··on "She's bouncing the ball" – the uncanny way octopuses play
Are there bad actors in farming even in Switzerland? Sure. But the majority of the farms I've been to have treated their animals with respect and kindness. The cows actually spend most of their time out on the pastures grazing freely. They are only taken indoors when the weather gets too cold for them in winter. It's very far from what people picture when talking about industrial farming in the US. It is true that there's an ultimate cruelty to keeping farm animals: we do it so eventually we can kill and eat them.

So if you argue against all meat consumption by humans, then it is true: no keeper of animals can be considered "fit for keeping humans". Even a small farm purely for the owner's own consumption places restrictions on the livestock's freedom and ultimately keeps them so they can be eaten. Even animals that we keep as pets could be considered to live in inhuman conditions, because we restrict their freedoms.

short_sells_poo··on Swept away: $500k sand dune built to protect US homes disappears in days
There's definitely a significant amount of "leopards ate my face" going on here, but I think a fair few people simply don't know better. They see a beautiful beachfront property and when the weather is good, it's all hunky dory.

But then a hurricane moves in and levels everything to the ground, and the real estate agents neglect to mention that this will happen on a regular basis.

short_sells_poo··on AWS building 414 exaflops AI computer exclusively for Nvidia's internal research
I wonder what is NVidia's play here. Do they want to build their own models and compete with the likes of MS and GOOG?

Elsewhere the CEO was saying that NVidia wants to build it's own platform (whatever that means), so I'd have expected they'd build an SC like this on their own.

short_sells_poo··on Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right
My point is that with the current VR implementation the problem is not about rudeness, but fundamentally hampering personal communication.

If I go and meet with someone in person, I generally do it because I want to see them up close, face to face. If we are both wearing VR headsets that hide our faces, the whole premise goes out the window.

Eventually, VR headsets might overcome this problem by accurately portraying the other person's face in some way, but we are nowhere there yet.

short_sells_poo··on Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right
There's an important difference: the subtle face mimicry is extremely important for sub-conscious (and conscious) communication. Having headphones on is rude because it indicates that the other person is not interested in hearing what you have to say. The problem with having an opaque visor covering your face is not that it's rude, it's that you completely lose the non-verbal part of communication. This is why email and phone communication can be so easy to misunderstand. Without seeing the face and body languages of the other person, your mind will have a tendency to overlay biases and prejudices on what is being communicated. A simple "sure, whatever" can be interpreted as obnoxiously dismissive, as a surrender, or friendly banter. If you can see the body language of the other person, the intent is usually clear. If you can't, it isn't.
← PreviousPage 11 of 29Next →