HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

short_sells_poo

2,257 karma · joined July 19, 2013

submissionscomments
short_sells_poo··on Redox OS has adopted a Certificate of Origin policy and a strict no-LLM policy
> We, agentic coders, can easily enough fork their project

And this is why eventually you are likely to run the artisanal coders who tend to do most of the true innovation out of the room.

Because by and large, agentic coders don't contribute, they make their own fork which nobody else is interested in because it is personalized to them and the code quality is questionable at best.

Eventually, I'm sure LLM code quality will catch up, but the ease with which an existing codebase can be forked and slightly tuned, instead of contributing to the original, is a double edged sword.

short_sells_poo··on Redox OS has adopted a Certificate of Origin policy and a strict no-LLM policy
I find the fact that people can't even be bothered to put their own thoughts into text and communicate via an LLM to be the most grotesque and dystopian aspect of this new AI era.

It looks like we are going to have large numbers of people whose entire personality is projected via an AI rather than their own mind. Surely this will have an (likely deleterious) effect on people's emotional and social intelligence, no? People's language centers will atrophy because the AI does the heavy lifting of transforming their thoughts into text, and even worse, I'm not sure it'll be avoidable to have the AIs biases and start to leak into the text that people like this generate.

short_sells_poo··on Ireland shuts last coal plant, becomes 15th coal-free country in Europe (2025)
An LNG terminal would not help for the current high prices. Europe is experiencing a gas price shock precisely because LNG is easy to store and transport. Asia gets half it's gas through the Strait of Hormuz, which is currently experiencing troubles. This means Asia is willing to pay a lot of premium for LNG, which in turn means that Europe has to match this premium otherwise LNG will go to Asia and not Europe.

Being dependent on gas is equal to being exposed to global shocks, unless you can cover your domestic needs purely with domestic gas extraction.

short_sells_poo··on Ireland shuts last coal plant, becomes 15th coal-free country in Europe (2025)
> Ultimately though, the only way to fix this is to build a lot of wind (industrial scale) and solar (residential scale) as otherwise we're at the mercy of world events.

I'd add that this is only part of the equation because: what do you do on an overcast day with no wind?

You need significant storage capacity before you can become isolated from world events. Until then, you need power generation that you can bring online on short notice: coal, gas, hydro, etc. Traditionally, gas was used for this because it's easy to store, quick to get going and gas plants can also burn coal if needed.

Unfortunately, the nice properties of gas (easy to store and transport) mean that it's a global commodity. It will go where they pay the most, which means that far away events can cause a price in gas prices globally.

short_sells_poo··on US Court of Appeals: TOS may be updated by email, use can imply consent [pdf]
> Should the state just prohibit all agreements between two parties unless the state's adjudicator decides they are exactly equal in "power" and permits it.

This is a strawman and you know it. Please at least make an attempt to argue in good faith, otherwise there's no point.

Of course there should be a reasonable middle-ground. The current situation with completely bogus ToS is not it.

Let me turn it around: should the state just abandon it's duty of creating an fair and equal playing field between large corporations and clients and let society devolve into a corporatocracy where laws are enforced purely to further corporate interests? Because that's exactly what you seem to be suggesting.

See? Not particularly conductive to discourse, is it :D

short_sells_poo··on Show HN: Mcp2cli – One CLI for every API, 96-99% fewer tokens than native MCP
This is entirely predictable: we get an army of vibe coders, vibe coding up tools to make vibe coding easier.
short_sells_poo··on US Court of Appeals: TOS may be updated by email, use can imply consent [pdf]
Because the power is disproportionally concentrated with one party - the service provider. The users of the service are numerous, comparatively small and uncoordinated.

In a situation like that, users have no means of resisting egregious terms, and no you cannot pull up stuff like "if you don't like it, don't buy it". As I wrote, the users are uncoordinated, and would take a huge effort to coordinate. Boycotting services rarely works (if ever). So what we end up with is that legal teams employed by firms optimize to shove as much bullshit into ToS as they can, the users grind their teeth and bear the bullshit, and get shittier service. Nobody really wins, because I'd argue the marginal gain for the company is minimal at best from this.

The government is not there just to enforce laws, but also to legislate such that the scales are balanced. Otherwise we may as well live in a dictatorship.

short_sells_poo··on Claude Code Remote Control
A few weeks ago the github integration was completely broken on the claude website for multiple days. It's very clear they vibe code everything and while it's laudable that they eat their own dogfood, it really projects a very amateurish image about their infrastructure and implementation quality.
short_sells_poo··on AIs can't stop recommending nuclear strikes in war game simulations
Perhaps it was convenient for everyone involved to have an obvious enemy. Say the US wiped out the USSR... then what? Hegemonies are not known to work well without some bogeyman to conquer or rally against. The USSR was a very convenient enemy for the US, and vice versa.
short_sells_poo··on Intel XeSS 3: expanded support for Core Ultra/Core Ultra 2 and Arc A, B series
That's very individual. Particularly for games where twitch reflexes are irrelevant, I much prefer smoothness to minimizing input lag.
short_sells_poo··on Intel XeSS 3: expanded support for Core Ultra/Core Ultra 2 and Arc A, B series
At 30 fps you already have 30ms between frames so you aren't getting anything close to instant input.
short_sells_poo··on Is Show HN dead? No, but it's drowning
I actually came to this realization recently. I'm part of a modding community for a game, and we are seeing an influx of vibe coded mods. The one distinguishing feature of these is that they are entirely parasitic. They only take, they do not contribute.

In the past, new modders would often contribute to existing mods to get their feet wet and quite often they'd turn into maintainers when the original authors burnt out.

But vibe coders never do this. They basically unilaterally just take existing mods' source code, feed this into their LLM of choice and generate a derivative work. They don't contribute back anything, because they don't even try to understand what they are doing.

Their ideas might be novel, but they don't contribute in any way to the common good in terms of capabilities or infrastructure. It's becoming nigh impossible to police this, and I fear the endgame is a sea of AI generated slop which will inevitably implode once the truly innovative stuff dies and and people who actually do the work stop doing so.

short_sells_poo··on Expensively Quadratic: The LLM Agent Cost Curve
I'd absolutely want to review every single line of code made by a junior dev because their code quality is going to be atrocious. Just like with AI output.

Sure, you can go ahead and just stick your head in the sand and pretend all that detail doesn't exist, look only at the tests and the very high level structure. But, 2 years later you have an absolutely unmaintainable mess where the only solution is to nuke it from orbit and start from scratch, because not even AI models are able to untangle it.

I feel like there are really two camps of AI users: those who don't care about code quality and implementation, only intent. And those who care about both. And for the former camp, it's usually not because they are particularly pedantic personalities, but because they have to care about it. "Move fast and break things" webapps can easily be vibe coded without too much worry, but there are many systems which cannot. If you are personally responsible, in monetary and/or legal aspects, you cannot blame the AI for landing you in trouble, just as much as a carpenter cannot blame his hammer for doing a shit job.

short_sells_poo··on The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory
For a long time to come. The energy density of fossil fuels is very high (about 50x higher than that of lithium ion batteries), there's a ton of infrastructure for handling and transporting them and a ton of infrastructure for using them.

They get turned into plastics and energy, two things which civilization feeds on voraciously.

It's not just inertia that keeps them going.

short_sells_poo··on How London became the rest of the world’s startup capital
I see your point, but consider this: getting to and through a major airport is a huge pain the ass. Trains also tend to take you to city centers more often than airports, which almost always need to be a significant distance from anything interesting due to the noise.

Let's take a hypothetical scenario:

- 5 hours flight time (average for NY and LA), 2 hours on each side to get to and from the airport to the actual city. Total is 9 hours.

- 10 hours train time and 1 hour on each end (which is generous given the proximity of train stations to city centers), 12 hours.

The difference is not that much, and a train ride is so much less faff than a flight that it's not even funny. Little to no security theater, you don't get fondled by security agents, you don't have to stand hours in line with silly passport controls and luggage checkins/pickups. And the list goes on.

A good train infrastructure can be vastly more pleasant than a good air infrastructure. Where air wins out is intercontinental flights where trains are truly not an option anymore.

short_sells_poo··on How London became the rest of the world’s startup capital
To people who have to commute to London, particularly if it's not a mainline train, it's tragically bad and overpriced. Train outages happen on a daily basis, the fare is very expensive compared to mainland Europe and the quality is quite a bit worse.
short_sells_poo··on How London became the rest of the world’s startup capital
The issue is that wages in London are much lower for tech than in SF or NY. If you want to make good money in London, you have to work in finance, and preferably in the investment business.

London is a very expensive city, and the median income is actually very low compared to it. There is a high concentration of people who are very well off, but everyone else is struggling.

short_sells_poo··on FBI is investigating Minnesota Signal chats tracking ICE
The courts may (still) be independent, but it feels like they are pointless because the government just wholesale ignores them anyway. If the executive branch doesn't enforce, or selectively enforces court judgements, you may as well shutter the courts.
short_sells_poo··on Tesla fined for repeatedly failing to help UK police over driving offences
I just realized something: doesn't this allow the actual drivers to escape the non-monetary penalties?

In the UK, if a driver is caught speeding, they'll (generally) also get points on their license and after accumulating 12 points, they'll (generally) lose their license for a while. Points decay on some frequency which I forget.

Anyway, what's to stop someone from driving a company car and then just paying the fines via the company and refusing the name the driver?

short_sells_poo··on Furiosa: 3.5x efficiency over H100s
It's a soft version of money printing basically. These firms are clearly inflating each other's valuations by making huge promises of future business to each other. Naively, one would look at the headlines and draw the conclusion that much more money is going to flow into AI in the near future.

Of course, a rational investor looks at this and discounts the fact that most of those promises are predicated on insane growth that has no grounding in reality.

However, there are plenty of greedy or irrational investors, whose recklessness will affect everyone, not just them.

short_sells_poo··on Furiosa: 3.5x efficiency over H100s
Someone else mentioned it elsewhere in this thread, and I believe this is the crux of the issue: this is all predicated in the actual end users finding enough benefit in LLM services to keep the gravy train going. It's irrelevant how scalable and profitable the shovel makes are, to keep this business afloat long term, the shovelers - ie the end users - have to make money using the shovesl. Those expectations are currently ridiculously inflated. Far beyond anything in the past.

Invariably, there's going to be a collapse in the hype, the bubble will burst, and an investment deleveraging will remove a lot of money from the space in a short period of time. The bigger the bubble, the more painful and less survivable this event will be.

short_sells_poo··on Furiosa: 3.5x efficiency over H100s
The fact that there's an incestual circle between OpenAI, Microsoft, NVidia, AMD, etc.. where they provide massive promises to each other for future business is nothing short of hilarious.

The economics of the entire setup are laughable and it's obvious that it's a massive bubble. The profit that'd need to be delivered to justify the current valuations is far beyond what is actually realistic.

What moat does OpenAI have? I'd argue basically none. They make extremely lofty forecasts and project an image of crazy growth opportunities, but is that going to ever survive the bubble popping?

short_sells_poo··on The chess bot on Delta Air Lines will destroy you (2024) [video]
I never thought of it this way, but now it's clear.

I found that once I tack on luggage, a seat with more space, etc.. they become more expensive than traditional airlines with the same package.

In other words, their business model really seems to be to cater to the "least hassle" passengers who travel light and don't need any extras.

short_sells_poo··on Opus 4.5 is not the normal AI agent experience that I have had thus far
I just had an issue where Opus misspelled variable names between usages. These are fundamental and elementary mistakes that make me deeply distrust anything slightly more complex that comes out of it.

It's great for suggesting approaches, but the code it generates looks like it doesn't actually have understanding (which is correct).

I can't trust what it writes, and if I have to go through it all with a fine toothed comb, I may as well write the code myself.

So my conclusion is that it's a very powerful research tool, and an atrocious junior developer who has dyslexia and issues with memory.

short_sells_poo··on Street Fighter II, the World Warrier (2021)
That's "just life" unfortunately. By the time most people reach their mid-30s, they accumulate enough commitments that they have to plan things in advance or they just don't happen.

If a friend turned up randomly and unannounced at my door and asked if I want to go to the pub, they have the following barriers to overcome:

I'm out for 10 hours a day during the work week and I'm asleep another ~8h. In the remaining 6h I want to go to the gym, I have to eat, I have to run errands, I have to spend time with my wife and in the remaining time I might just want some alone time. Odds are I'd have to turn my friend away, which would make me feel bad, even though I'd have gladly joined him in the pub if I could plan for it. And I have no kids! If I had kids, the odds are even worse.

We all wish we could be back in our 20s when we had all the freedom and none of the commitments, but the truth is that for 95% of people this isn't possible. When you are in uni (or fresh out), you have all the time and energy, but (generally) no money. So you can spend a lot of time with friends who are in a similar position. By mid-life (30-55), you have money and energy, but no time. And in your winter years, you have money and time, but no energy left.

In each of these phases, you can try to go against the flow and experience friction all the time, or you can try to make the most of it and adapt.

If you absolutely desire the freeform approach you describe, perhaps you need to step up and establish the clubs and spaces you'd like and select for members who have a similar desire.

Most spaces in cities have to cater to the lowest common denominator, and simply wouldn't be able to function without strict scheduling rules. It'd be patently unfair if the 20 year old uni student hogged the equipment when you turn up for your 2 hours of free time that you planned a week in advance, wouldn't it?

short_sells_poo··on Getting a Gemini API key is an exercise in frustration
Ha, bold of you to assume they'll respond!
short_sells_poo··on Reverse math shows why hard problems are hard
You are right, but this doesn't mean that the amount of work is conserved as your original message implies. The correct statement would be that "algorithmic complexity is just one aspect of actual practical complexity and an algorithm with better algorithmic complexity can end up performing worse in reality due to practical considerations of the data and the processor doing the computations".
short_sells_poo··on It’s been a very hard year
It was nothing like covid. The dot com crash lasted years where tech was a dead sector. Equity valuations kept declining year after year. People couldn't find jobs in tech at all.

There are still plenty of tech jobs these days, just less than there were during covid, but tech itself is still in a massive expansionary cycle. We'll see how the AI bubble lasts, and what the fallout of it bursting will be.

The key point is that the going is still exceptionally good. The posts talking about experienced programmers having to flip burgers in the early 2000s is not an exaggeration.

short_sells_poo··on Games using anti-cheats and their compatibility with GNU/Linux or Wine/Proton
They already do this. Including peripherals which appear as an actual mouse, but they are there only so that cheat software can take control of the input without modifying the game memory. There are cheats which run on a separate machine and access the game memory via a dedicated DMA card (which itself presents itself as an innocent piece of hardware). Note, this can still be detected either via detecting the DMA card itself, or eventually these shenanigans will be killed off by IOMMU.

Unfortunately, there are also plenty of offerings which do not touch the game memory or process at all, and work purely based on image recognition and these days they actually use AI that is trained on specific games. I have no idea how they plan to detect these. All the cheat needs is the video feed and the ability to provide input via mouse and keyboard, and as you say this is trivial to do in a way that is entirely undetectable.

short_sells_poo··on APT Rust requirement raises questions
I'm writing this as a heavy python user in my day job. Python is terrible for writing complex systems in. Both the language and the libraries are full of footguns for the novice and expert alike. It has 20 years of baggage, the packaging and environment handling is nothing short of an unmitigated disaster, although uv seems to be a minor light at the end of the tunnel. It is not a simple language at this point. It has had so many features tacked on, that it needs years of use to have a solid understanding of all the interactions.

Python is a language that became successful not because it was the best in it's class, but because it was the least bad. It became the lingua franca of quantitative analysis, because R was even worse and matlab was a closed ecosystem with strong whiffs of the 80s. It became successful because it was the least bad glue language for getting up and running with ML and later on LLMs.

In comparison, Rust is a very predictable and robust language. The tradeoff it makes is that it buys safety for the price of higher upfront complexity. I'd never use Rust to do research in. It'd be an exercise in frustration. However, for writing reliable and robust systems, it's the least bad currently.

← PreviousPage 3 of 29Next →