HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

short_sells_poo

2,257 karma · joined July 19, 2013

submissionscomments
short_sells_poo··on Revolt: Open-Source Alternative to Discord
Let me preface this by saying I use Discord daily to keep in touch with friends. It's a great digital campfire where you can relax with people, talk with them over voice and video or just post random stuff.

The issue is that Discord has replaced things which it shouldn't have, the internet forums. Discord is the epitome of a golden cage. It is a prison for information, a black hole.

I'm not even talking about the absolutely atrocious search functionality, but the fact that information inside the Discord walls is impossible to find from the outside. You can't search across discord communities, none of the content there is indexed by web search engines. Entire communities have FAQs and knowledge as pins inside threads inside Discord servers. Things which used to be on the web.

15 years ago, these discussions would've taken place on forums and on IRC to a lesser extent. IRC itself was a really bad information black hole, but at least the forums were great. They supported long running discussions and were easy to search.

Now everything disappeared into effectively hidden Discord chats and youtube videos where you need to watch 8 different idiots bramble on for 10 minutes before you find the 30 second segment of information that you were actually looking for and could've been a single paragraph.

short_sells_poo··on Apple unveils new Mac Studio
It has terrible compute performance...
short_sells_poo··on The Pentium contains a complicated circuit to multiply by three
I disagree on this: "Performance is an absolute thing"

I think the core misunderstanding is what is being discussed. You say "Performance is an absolute thing, not a relative thing. Amount of work per second, not percentage-over-previous!"

But nobody here is concerned with the absolute performance number. Absolute performance is only about what we can do right now with what we have. The discussion is about the performance improvements and how they evolve over time.

Performance improvements are inherently a relative metric. The entire industry, society and economy - everything is built on geometric growth expectations. You cannot then go back to the root metric and say "ah but what really matters is that we can now do X TFlops more", when that number is a mere 10% improvement, nobody will care.

Built into everything around computing is the potential for geometric growth. Startups, AI, video games - it's all predicated on the expectation that our capabilities will grow in geometric fashion. The only way to benchmark geometric growth is by using % improvements. Again, it is wholly irrelevant to everyone that the 5090 can do 20 tflops more than the 4090. 20 TFlops is some number, but whether it is a big improvement or not - ie is it expanding our capabilities at the expected geometric rate or not - is not possible to divine from this number.

And when we look it up, it turns up that we went from 80 tflops to 100 tflops, which is a paltry 25% increase, well short of the expectations of performance growth from Nvidia which was in the 50% region.

20 tflops might or might not be a lot. The only way to judge is to compare how much of an improvement it is relative to what we could have before.

short_sells_poo··on The Pentium contains a complicated circuit to multiply by three
You seem to be completely confused about why absolute vs relative matters. Moore's law literally states: "[Moore's law] is the observation that the number of transistors in an integrated circuit (IC) doubles about every two years".

This is literally a relative measurement. You cannot reason about Moore's Law in absolute changes.

The other poster has laid it out for you in the simplest terms: a 1 billion transistor increase could mean anything. It could be a 1000% improvement - which is absolutely humongous - or a 10% improvement, which is basically irrelevant. If you want to measure how impactful an increase is, you have to look at relative change. 1 billion transistors on it's own means nothing. It is only interesting with respect to the number of transistors in the previous generation - which is a relative change measurement.

Say we are at Generation 1 with 100 billion transistors. By your reasoning, if we add 1 more billion of transistors to this, that's big. 1 billion transistors are a lot. But this is absolutely incorrect! Because we started out with 100 billion transistors, the change is actually irrelevant.

short_sells_poo··on Time Warp: Delayed-choice quantum erasure
I hope this is a sarcastic post about telescopes :)
short_sells_poo··on Tesla sales in Europe down 45% in January
Yes and many people don't. What is your point? Many people are upset with what Elon is doing, that's what is being discussed. Like it or not, Tesla and Elon are the same thing. It's his choice. He wants to be the public face of a company, he can't then selectively choose to shield said company from his antics when they backfire.

Nothing stopped Elon from divesting himself of his commercial holdings and announce that he wants to enter politics. Then I, and many others, would have no qualms about buying Tesla cars.

Obviously, doing so would've required a degree of personal integrity and humility, which he seems to be lacking.

short_sells_poo··on Tesla sales in Europe down 45% in January
So you are saying I should instead happily give him my money even though I deeply disagree with what he's doing? Let's take your argument ad absurdum: you'd happily give money to a mass murder as long as he was making a product you like?
short_sells_poo··on Tesla sales in Europe down 45% in January
> I find it very sad that purchasing a car from a publicly traded company with tens of thousands of employees is somehow interpreted as supporting the politics of the CEO of said company.

I'm sure there were also good people in IG Farben who just wanted to get through their day during WW2, right?

Nobody would bat an eye if some random shmuck on the Tesla manufacturing floor held some silly ideas, but arguing that the extremely public facing CEO of a company gets a pass because he's just one of many at a large firm is a wrong take, I'm sorry.

The CEO is the company. If the janitor posts a silly youtube video doing a sieg heil, the janitor is in trouble. If the CEO of the company does a nazi salute, the company is in trouble.

short_sells_poo··on Tesla sales in Europe down 45% in January
> but what about all the workers who have nothing to do with his politics?

This is a preposterous argument, I'm sorry. Should I feel sorry for people who enable Musk's antics? Why? They get paid very well to work for him I'm sure.

I disagree with Musk's antics and as such I'm not going to give him money. What's so difficult to understand about this?

I don't care that in 20 years time he'll be forgotten. We are here and now, and the best way to send him a message that what he is doing is not OK is by hurting his wallet.

short_sells_poo··on Tesla sales in Europe down 45% in January
> I don't really care about what he does in American politics.

You should. Whether you like it or not, what he is doing in the US is going to affect you one way or another, irrespective of his meddling in UK politics. Even if he focused his attention solely on US, the world is connected and particularly the US/European relationship has been one of the defining features of geopolitics over the last 70 years. Musk and company are basically dismantling this relationship.

The current US administration will profoundly alter the relationships between countries and power blocks for the foreseeable future. The US will cease being a reliable partner for it's old allies the UK included.

Musk was doing many cool things, but currently his focus seems to be to dismantle democracy, and this should definitely worry you if you value freedom.

short_sells_poo··on US court upholds Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes's conviction
It was probably worse, I'm merely agreeing with the parent poster that the conditional justice that seems to be getting ever more prevalent in the US (and across the world) can play into her cards just fine if she pivots to talking to the right portion of the population.
short_sells_poo··on US court upholds Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes's conviction
I guess if only she was peddling drinking bleach or antiparasitic drugs as a cure for cancer, she'd have been already made the head of the FDA.
short_sells_poo··on Tesla sales in Europe down 45% in January
If it was 1940, I'd avoid buying one. If you are aware of the Volkswagen profits going directly to a known nazi supporter, I'd love to know.

People can change, as can ownership of companies. If Musk divested himself completely of Tesla, I'd be happy to buy one. I have no bias against Tesla or it's employees, I have a bias against the owner currently hard at work trying to destroy democracy in the US and across the globe.

More to the point, are you deliberately trolling or you genuinely do not see the point being made?

short_sells_poo··on Tesla sales in Europe down 45% in January
Yes, yes it does. Why is it inconceivable that people don't want to give money to Musk? It's called voting with your wallet. I may like the car, but I deeply disagree with the business owner's views and deranged behavior over the last couple of years. The easiest thing I can do is to give my money to someone else instead.

Ultimately it doesn't matter whether Musk truly believes some of the lunacy he says, his actions speak for him. I disagree with his actions and don't want to support him. He could make the best car in the world for all I care.

short_sells_poo··on Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII
It matters because it becomes very quickly obvious. And the moment that it becomes obvious that you are not playing against an opponent that tries to use cunning and strategy, but merely an equation - a puzzle - which you have to solve, the entire house of cards comes down. Puzzle games can be fun, but the very people in this thread are arguing that CIV games are not about being a puzzle, but about roleplaying a civilization. There's a puzzle aspect of course, but a blatantly cheating AI is just a puzzle and nothing else.

It matters for the same reason that people don't want to play against a human-like AI, because that AI would be a double crossing bastard who tries to win at all costs. They want to play against a roleplaying AI who tries to appear like Ghenghis Khan or Tutanchamon. But if I see my sworn enemy Attila the Hun spawn in an endless stream of battering rams out of thin air, and yet is so utterly incompetent and dumb that it cannot navigate a simple pass between mountains, that's a worse transgression against my suspension of disbelief than if he was just plain bad at the game.

short_sells_poo··on Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII
I think the great mass of the bell curve also hasn't actually seen a good CIV AI experience because they never played the 4th iteration. But people know there is something wrong with the AI. One just needs to look at the steam forums and reviews. By and large, everyone agrees that the AI does not really know how to play the game. Which is a shame because I think the games themselves are genuinely built with love and care.
short_sells_poo··on Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII
I'm not disagreeing with what you are saying, but I think the issue at hand is very different than what you are arguing about and must be taken in context of the greater game design: past CIV 4, the game design got disconnected and ran ahead of the AI. I'd imagine that the AI in the later games is actually much more advanced, but it feels incredibly dumb. Truly catastrophically dumb, because the game mechanics were not made in mind with the capabilities of the AI, or the AI was not made smart enough to function with the game mechanics. I'd argue the latter is much more difficult to do (and here we agree), but it doesn't excuse the development team.

Take one of the most controversial features of CIV 5: one unit per tile. On the face of it, this is a great feature that opens up interesting tactical opportunities. Blockading, the importance of terrain, formations etc.

Unfortunately, whether due to unwillingness or lack of competence, the AI was completely befuddled by this. It'd make big armies, and then be fundamentally incapable of moving them. It would shuffle units one by one around endlessly and get stuck in the smallest of congestions.

This is not about whether an AI should play to win like a human or it should roleplay. I agree - and the majority of playerbase agrees - that the CIV AI should primarily roleplay. We all remember the frustrating double-crossing bastards during the early days of CIV 5.

This is not about the AI being complex or not. This is about making a game where the AI is competent, and this is not just the AI being some super smart intelligence in absolute terms. It is (mostly) about designing the game such that the AI can appear competent and pose a threat where the human player can feel like they are playing against an opponent that can test their skill, instead of just trying to beat some pre-determined math that is stacked against them.

CIV 4 was a game built in an era where computers were orders of magnitude less capable, and yet the AI in the game poses a much better and more competent appearing threat than in the current iterations. Not because it was more advanced, but because the game was built such that the AI didn't need to be that advanced. The AI still cheated of course, but it only needed a few simple heuristics and rules to build doomstacks that appeared "smart". A simple A* was enough for it to navigate this doomstack to your capital and make you sweat.

Now we have very complex tactical battles with positioning and formations, but this would require vastly more complex AI to do well. Unfortunately, the AI has not kept up, so we are left with opponents that appear dumb as bricks because they don't play the game the human plays. The AI simply spawns resources and armies into existence out of thin air in ever more blatant ways. The less the AI plays by the same rules the player has to, the less it feels like a story and more like a math puzzle.

short_sells_poo··on Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII
That's a very good point as well. Again, I think the point is not about making the AI human-like (ie play to win), but making it competent. Firaxis seems unwilling or incapable of making the AI competent.

We could argue that making a competent AI is difficult - it is! But then a competent game designer comes up with mechanics that the AI can handle. A well designed game is put together knowing the capabilities of each game component so that they work together, not against each other.

This is I feel the source of brilliance of CIV 4. It was a game running on vastly less powerful machines than what we have today, and yet the AI felt vastly more competent. It is likely actually less "smart" than the AI in CIV 7 in absolute terms, but it was operating in a world which it understood and could reason about much better.

It's an issue with a lot of modern games. People have starry ideas about fancy features, but then they can't integrate the features together into a cohesive whole. I think this is something we lost in the modern days of game development. It has never been easier and more accessible, but this accessibility (which I support wholeheartedly), has made it easy for people to design themselves into a corner.

short_sells_poo··on Microsoft Cancels Leases for AI Data Centers, Analyst Says
Highly regarded people unite :D

More seriously though: unless you have privileged information or have done truly extensive research, do not short stocks. And if you do have privileged information, still don't short stocks because unless you have enough money to defend yourself against insider trading like Musk and it's ilk, it's not going to be worth it.

It's perfectly reasonable to determine that a particular high growth stock is not going to perform as well going forward, in which case I'd shift allocation to other, better candidates.

Generally, being long equities is a long term positive expected value trade. You don't have to time the market, just be persistent. On the other hand, as you correctly alluded to, shorting equities requires decently precise timing, both on entry and exit.

short_sells_poo··on Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII
You are right, but the issue here is slightly more nuanced. The CIV AI is just plain atrocious at playing the game. It's not about having a personality, it's that the developers add game mechanics that the AI is fundamentally incapable of dealing with. To give you an example, CIV 5 introduced the concept of 1 unit per tile - it used to be that you could stack as many units as you wanted into one tile before. Neat idea, right? Terrain and unit placement suddenly mattered!

But there was a significant issue with this: the AI was terrible at moving units and armies. It'd get confused by the smallest congestion. The AI would build a large army, and then be incapable of moving it anywhere.

The AI can still have personality and roleyplay instead of attempting to win, and yet be a competent strategist and tactician.

short_sells_poo··on Fluoxetine promotes metabolic defenses to protect from sepsis-induced lethality
You are technically correct (the best kind of correct), but I guess parent was asking whether this has any anti-bacterial side effects that might affect the gut flora. I'm wondering about this as well. The drug in question isn't an anti-biotic per-se, it doesn't help fight sepsis by making your body even more indiscriminately angry at bacteria - quite the opposite. Based on that, my suspicion is that the gut flora would not be affected directly, and would be happy on the basis of the host itself surviving the sepsis.
short_sells_poo··on US and UK refuse to sign AI safety declaration at summit
Thank you for this excellent comment! It seems then that basically everything that's revolutionary - whether technology, government, beliefs, and so on - will tend to extract a blood price before the dust settles. I guess it sort of makes sense: big societal upheavals are difficult to handle peacefully.

So basically we are a bit screwed in our current timeline. We are at the cusp of a post-scarcity society, possibly reach AGI within our lifetimes and possibly even become a space faring civilization. However, it is highly likely that we are going to pay the pound of flesh and only subsequent generations - perhaps yet unborn - will be the ones who will be truly better off.

I suppose it's not all doom and gloom, we can draw stoic comfort from the fact that people in the near future will have an incredibly exciting era full of discovery and wonder ahead of them!

short_sells_poo··on Nvidia's RTX 5090 power connectors are melting
This is the top end halo product. What's wrong with pushing the envelope? Should we all play tetris because "what's wrong with block graphics?".

I'm not defending the shitty design here, but I'm all for always pushing the boundaries.

short_sells_poo··on Beavers finish seven-year dam project in two days saving – $1M
I posit they'll find out that living inside London is terrible and they'll all move to the location that'd be Surrey. Turning that area terrible in turn.
short_sells_poo··on Teen on Musk's DOGE team graduated from 'The Com'
Another way of looking at it might be that the crowd who liked Musk in the 2010s is a tough audience. I was among them too - I liked what Musk (appeared) to stand for. Expanding mankind's reach, unafraid to take a task that previously was deemed "impossible" and pretending that with enough determination it can be achieved. All the while maintaining a bit of childish cheek and humor about things. I really liked both the vibe and the approach. It was the quintessential "young and starry eyed rich genius who is prepared to throw lots of money at moonshot ideas - if only to see what happens".

But this audience is more diverse in it's views and is perhaps more willing to challenge it's idols and leaders. Keeping this audience on your side is a constant dialogue where you are constantly challenged and it's a symbiotic-adversarial relationship that results in a stronger whole. Only by getting challenged in a constructive discussion can truly great ideas be born.

But this is hard work and in some sense annoying. Inevitably he gets surrounded by sycophants and yes-men, because these people butter his ego, and comes to realize that there's an audience around who will unquestionably eat up anything their leader says irrespective of it's truthfulness. An audience who doesn't care whether their leaders are good, just that the leader is on their side.

And thus we find ourselves in the current situation, with an entire establishment in the US who will happily broadcast broad faced lies, but these lies are only for their own audience who believes them without question. Or they just don't care at all, because it's not about the truth, it's only about tribalism.

short_sells_poo··on Vanguard's average fee is now 0.07% after biggest-ever cut
Yeah duh. I was explaining to the parent.
short_sells_poo··on Vanguard's average fee is now 0.07% after biggest-ever cut
If you know the index rules, it's fairly simple to calculate the turnover it is going to generate when it rebalances and subsequently the impact the rebalance is going to have on prices. This is a fairly well known behavior and a lot of players have been doing this for a long time. Basically every index of any significance is already being monitored and rebalancing effects are "front-run" this way.

I put the word in quotes, because this is a perfectly legitimate way of front running. The major indices are all public, and anyone can take a crack at this. In other words, if I announce to the world a month in advance that on a specific day and a very specific time of the day (at the closing auction) I'm going to buy X amount of specific stocks and sell Y amount in other stocks, I can't blame people for using that information against me.

short_sells_poo··on "A computer can never be held accountable"
Your post might have been tongue in cheek, but assuming it's not: the issue with ceding decision making to a superintelligence is that we'll likely lose the ability to reason about it's decisions and we'll struggle to take back control if it starts making choices we don't like. It's reasoning is far beyond our own capabilities after all.
short_sells_poo··on Nuclear fusion: it's time for a reality check
You are correct, but I wonder if space travel applications allow us to take certain liberties with the reactor design that are not feasible down on Earth. E.g. a simple(r) confinement design that expels the fusion products could work well in space, but is a non starter on Earth for obvious reasons.

I'm not sure how much of the design on Earth is bulky and cumbersome because it needs to be vastly safer and more complicated than what a rocket engine needs to be. Taken to the extreme, nuclear propulsion in space can be very dumb: just detonate nukes some distance behind the rocket and ride the shockwave with a pusher plate. It's a radically different design than anything we'd attempt for terrestrial applications.

short_sells_poo··on Nuclear fusion: it's time for a reality check
In fact I meant it in a general sense, and both ion drive and a more classic confinement engine like design that expels the fusion products. I don't know enough about the intricacies to argue for one vs the other, but fusion fuel is the most energy dense fuel we have within reach, by a huge margin. The variable then becomes the mass of the engine (and supporting plumbing), but we have control over this.

Can we shrink a fusion reactor small enough to make the rocket as a whole feasible? I don't know. My hope is that for space travel, we can make certain tradeoffs that are not feasible on Earth - e.g. expelling radioactive waste products into the environment. A rocket engine doesn't need to be all that efficient at generating electricity either, it mostly needs to be efficient for propulsion, which might make it's design much simpler.

← PreviousPage 6 of 29Next →