HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

short_sells_poo

2,257 karma · joined July 19, 2013

submissionscomments
short_sells_poo··on Aliens and the Enlightenment
But we have sent probes to other worlds? What is science fiction about this?

A manned mission to Mars is entirely feasible with current technology. In fact I'd argue it'd have been feasible with 1980s technology, it was simply costly. If we (we as in humankind) wanted, we could have a base on Mars for some time now.

Who is to say what our capabilities will be in 50 years? In 100 years?

A manned mission to another solar system is going to be very-very difficult, we'd need generational space ship/habitats. Note that difficult is not the same as impossible. Such a ship could be feasibly constructed with modern day technology, but it would be enormously costly so there was no motivation to do it.

I'd agree with your point that a mission to another galaxy is basically unimaginable with technology we can realistically theorize about today. We'd need extremely exotic physics which are unlikely to be doable ever.

short_sells_poo··on GM electric vehicles can now access Tesla Superchargers
Same experience in the UK. Just within London you have a dozen charging networks, they all have their own shitty apps, they require you to add your credit card and create an account and half the time they simply don't work and just give you some garbage error message like "charging failed".

Don't even get me started on Oxford. We arrive to a charging station and it turns out it is exclusively for electric taxis. No mention of this anywhere online.

It boils down to trial and error, and then remembering which specific charging points tend to work. For a completely new piece of infrastructure with no legacy cruft, the industry has made a complete and utter mess of it.

short_sells_poo··on US health system ranks last compared with peer nations – report
Does the Bavarian power grid also routinely go down because they don't invest in it and at the same time also refuse to add interconnects with other regions?
short_sells_poo··on US health system ranks last compared with peer nations – report
I feel the seiss system really nails it. Health insurance is mandatory. If you can't afford even the basic level, the government pays for it. The basic level itself covers basically everything from emergency care, hospital stays and gp. The extras you can pay for are things like single rooms in hospitals or access to private clinics. Compared to the local salaries, the basic package is quite cheap - doubly so compared to the UK where National Insurance extracts a very hefty portion of your paycheck and this gets you the dire waiting times of nhs...
short_sells_poo··on Bank of America raises minimum hourly pay
It seems to be a cultural thing. Perhaps by thinking about it hourly, it is implied that the contract is fully ephemeral and the corporation can nullify it on very short notice - which is certainly true in the US. Employee protections are much stronger in Europe and people get much better benefits (e.g. 5 weeks of paid vacation) even in these entry level positions.

It's very similar in the UK where plenty of full time jobs try to act like some sort of temp thing. Salary quoted as hourly rate, zero contractual hours, etc. In other words, in all aspects the employee is expected to do whatever the company demands. If they demand zero hours worked, the employee will work zero hours, and if they demand 40 hours a week, that's what the employee has to work.

In my view this should be basically illegal. Either make it a contract work where employees turn into service providers who can have multiple clients (that is true contractors), or make it full employment with pre-defined minimum hours worked so that the terms of engagement are clear for both sides.

short_sells_poo··on Simon Verity believed in working the medieval way
This is really it. There's no permanence and little to no personal consequence for bad code. In fact, everyone wants everything done ASAP. Time is money, and very few places have the culture and the resource to afford to build long term stuff.

And yet there is software that has stood the test of time. It might not be pretty from a purely ideological or aesthetic perspective, but it lays the foundation of many great things. Consider something like Numpy. The internals are a multi-decade boondoggle of graduate level python code, Lovecraftian Fortran that causes you to take psychic damage just by looking at it, and random hacks that some disgruntled researcher submitted at 10pm on a Sunday after an all weekend marathon to get his stuff finished on time.

But so much good stuff was built on this pile of bad code, because it is not the concrete code that is ultimately of value and worthy of admiration, but the concept. The implementation is sort of secondary. So perhaps it's the ideas and the concepts that have legacy in computer science, code is just a carrier. The same way that genes are the definition of the human race, an individual human is just an ephemeral implementation of those genes. It is the genes where the miracle happened really and which gave rise to beings that are self aware (to quote Richard Dawkins).

short_sells_poo··on Simon Verity believed in working the medieval way
People aren't incentivised to write code that somehow carries true legacy the same way that a master mason will want their work to be a legacy for decades, if not centuries.

This creates a positive feedback loop where people just shit out software as fast as possible, which then means the next person to come around will be met with maintaining a pile of poo. This person will also not have any time (or mental energy) to do anything to be proud of and so the circle continues.

And it's entirely understandable. Clueless PM ABC wants to increase some barely relevant KPI so they can get a pat on their head from Clueless VP XYZ. PM ABC thus invents yet another user hostile feature in Windows 11, and thus Programmer 123 gets the thankless task to integrate ads in the right-click context menu. The programmer might be an artisan at their craft, but ultimately they just want to get their 9-5 done so they can do some actually exciting stuff in their free time. Then 1 year later Programmer 124 comes around and is horrified to see the boondoggle that 123 left behind.

short_sells_poo··on AnandTech Farewell
I think Steam is an anomaly, not the rule for monopolies. Steam is privately owned with long term stable leadership. They are generating a crazy amount of money and are able to be content with that.

If steam went public and had the usual revolving door of MBA CEOs keen to "maximize efficiencies", you can bet that Steam would turn just as malign as the adtech industry.

short_sells_poo··on UK rail minister got engineer sacked for raising safety concerns
To be honest this is a general problem with the UK. Try driving on any major street and you'll realize it's plastered with mostly useless signs. A dozen warnings assault your senses at any one time, which makes it very difficult to pick out what is actually important. This is compounded by sometimes completely braindead implementation of rules. E.g. most bus lanes in London can be used by motorcyclists, but some cannot. There's no rhyme or reason, the entire thing is decided by a small blue sign at the start of a particular stretch which may or may not have an even smaller motorbike icon on it - among an icon for a bus, taxi and pushbike. Whoever thought this is a good idea is either a moron or deliberately wanted to extract fines from motorcyclists who accidentally use the wrong bus lane.
short_sells_poo··on Ruby in Jupyter Notebook
From my experience, python won out the research crowd exactly for the reasons you mentioned, but also because it is a bit of a swiss army knife platform. Python has plenty of libraries for doing pretty much anything these days. Computer Vision? Can do. ML? Can do. Dashboards? Can do. And the list goes on. This means that a researcher can do their research in python and then also do the implementation in the same language and platform they are familiar with.

If someone told me to use rust for doing any sort of interactive/iterative numerical research, I'd send them for the hills. And I love Rust. But when I want to quickly learn about the properties of some data, or try to use dataset A to predict dataset B, I don't give a rats ass about types, or type safety, or proper programming idioms. I just want to look at my data.

Then, if I convince myself that I have some sort of model that I want to use, I could theoretically reach for Rust, but generally I don't need to. I can just take the output of the research - more or less verbatim - and start using it in production. Often with minimal changes.

Yes, sometimes circumstances require to use something more performant, but these days you also have Numba or Nuitka to optimize some hot loops.

For the longest time I wanted Julia to become a success, because I felt that it combined in one language and platform the possibility to write easy no-fuss, scalable, performant and robust code. A language which could evolve a codebase from initial research analysis to strongly typed production code. Unfortunately it never seems to have gained traction, so we are left with the next best thing: python. It's not really good at anything (as a language), but it's the least bad out of everything out there and the libraries are excellent.

short_sells_poo··on Mini imported Japanese vehicles may soon be banned on Massachusetts roads
Not in a city they aren't. They are an excellent commuting tool that offers much of the flexibility of a car for a fraction of the cost and much better commute time.
short_sells_poo··on Stocks trampled as Nikkei crashes 13%
Those times are not coming back. We need to stop looking at market behavior 100 years ago. Modern markets and society function very-very differently. Even looking at 2008 as a model for how modern crises happen is very likely to give you incorrect conclusions.

Everything has sped up drastically. Information (whether valid or invalid) is priced in vastly faster. In 2008 you had a month to buy various crisis insurance products (e.g. variance swaps), in 2020 you had days. The next crisis you might only have hours.

Sure, fundamental human behavioral patterns stayed the same, but these are things like herding behavior (monkey see price go up, monkey buy, monkey see price go down, monkey sell), panics, various interests fanning the flames one way or another, etc. But the interconnectedness and the speed at which information travels across that interconnect has increased orders of magnitude just over the last decade.

It's important to recognize that the increased processing speed has a non-linear impact on the system as a whole. New kinds of failure modes and boundary conditions arise that never happened before. New feedback loops get amplified and old ones stop working as they operated on different time scales.

short_sells_poo··on Stocks trampled as Nikkei crashes 13%
Things get really out of hand when there's a big move outside of the US trading hours because liquidity is so thin. Usually it recovers of course, the scary thing is when it degenerates into a 2020 covid style selloff - 10% down day followed by a number of 10% down days.
short_sells_poo··on Stocks trampled as Nikkei crashes 13%
They've always been doing this.

Every time the market is down 10%, news outlets can't shout loud enough how the end times are upon us. Various doomsayers come out of the woodwork and point at how they predicted this crash, but conveniently gloss over the 20 other crashes they predicted and that never happened.

The media fanning the flames when the markets are down is something you have to get used to or simply ignore. Tney have no clue, they just want the clicks :D

short_sells_poo··on Stocks trampled as Nikkei crashes 13%
The idea behind long term investment is that you hold a diversified basket of assets, add a little regularly and hold for >10 years. This smoothes out the various drawdowns quite a bit.
short_sells_poo··on How great was the Great Oxidation Event?
A great man once wrote: In the beginning the Universe was created. This has made a lot of people very angry and been widely regarded as a bad move.
short_sells_poo··on AMD to buy Silo AI for $665M
You are basically paying some premium for the fact that someone already did the hiring and built the talent pool and a cohesive team. Doing that from scratch is a multi-year project, so they basically bought a shortcut.
short_sells_poo··on Cities need more trees
That's fair criticism, but perhaps it'd be much more effective to have a few but large solar farms outside the city, no?
short_sells_poo··on Cities need more trees
The photo in the article looks amazing! You basically don't see a city, you see a vast woodland! An occasional rooftop peeking through here and there are the only signs of civilization.

I'd love to live in a place like that. London is a very green city by many standards, but it is nowhere close to appearing like the unbroken forest in the article. In fact, the thing I miss the most after having moved to the UK are the forests. Most of it is private and fenced off, and it's just tiny patches of woods anyway. It's interesting how different it is compared to Switzerland for example, where one can roam freely (at risk of being chased by an occasional herd of curious cows) and there are plenty of forests where one can escape civilization.

short_sells_poo··on Cities need more trees
Unfortunately the decision is often made based on costs, and chopping them down is cheaper than employing an arborist (?) to make sure the tree is reinforced properly.

Please don't get me wrong, I agree with you. In many historic cities, there are trees that are hundreds of years old. There are trees that have been around since before the invention of the telegraph, lived through 2 world wars and are still going strong! There are efforts to keep these alive, but I feel newly planted trees won't get the chance to live that long :(

short_sells_poo··on FICO and the Credit Bureau Cartel
I think what parent actually means is that there are better solutions for it than insurance. E.g. a central registry of ownership and liens would probably solve 99% of the cases that you need insurance for. The insurance is a scam in the way that there are technical solutions that would obviate the need for this "service", but that solution is against the interests of the service providers. Very much like tax returns, which are a solved problem in many countries for the majority of the population because the authorities already have all the data they need. Most people should not need to faff around with them. In the US however, the tax return lobby is strong and effectively prevents the government from making it easy...
short_sells_poo··on LockBit claims to exfiltrate 33TB of data from US Federal Reserve
The shit that would be heaved on both the equity and bond markets if the Fed hiked rates at this point is quite possibly Biblical. I'm not disputing that the pain is better now than later - and it may be the case here as well (I don't know, I'm a trader not an economist). My view is that rate hikes aren't really warranted at this point. Inflation is still high but many of the core measures are finally starting to show signs of improvement. The question at this point is whether the Fed can justify cutting this year or only in '25.

The other side of the coin is that if the Fed hiked now, half the country would be up in arms that the Fed basically assassinated the Biden administration. I think the Fed is not in the wrong of waiting a bit, at least until after the elections. Then if inflation starts coming off, well there's nothing for them to do, and if it doesn't, they can do it without so much fuss from politicians.

Hell, if Trump wins, he might be in the lucky position of claiming that he singlehandedly fixed everything and allowed the Fed to start cutting rates :D

short_sells_poo··on EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control
It's these kind of people who really enable the far right to exist as well. Once you get to this level of lunacy, whether it's left or right is irrelevant.
short_sells_poo··on Beyond velocity and acceleration: jerk, snap and higher derivatives (2016)
> EVs jerk more. Giggity

More seriously though, I think this might be about driver training and maybe calibrating the foot pedal. It's great that EVs have a much better torque curve, but it means the old muscle memory of opening the throttle wide at low RPMs and letting the clutch slip is simply not the way to do it (nvm that there's no clutch to operate in an EV).

short_sells_poo··on Horses may have been domesticated twice
> the ones who behaved predictably and weren't willing to randomly hurt you for no apparent reason at their own expense, were eaten by our ancestors.

This doesn't make sense to me. Sure, an an animal that is generally a belligerent asshole will discourage humans from trying to tame it, but why would it discourage hunting? If anything, it would encourage hunting the bad animal to extinction, no? Humans successfully hunted Mammoths and other large game even in the stone age, so I don't see how having a bad temper would help.

short_sells_poo··on Apple unveils 'Passwords' manager app at WWDC 2024
Yeah. I want to pay the people who look after the thing that stores my most precious information. I want them to be overpaid and look after their golden goose.

It seems nuts to me that you expect someone to provide you a service for free?

short_sells_poo··on Don't be terrified of Pale Fire
Judging by the commentary in the thread, it's very likely not the Harry Potter case :D

It sounds like the best analogy to the book are abstract paintings. There are people who can appreciate them, but it is an acquired taste...

short_sells_poo··on Microsoft blocks Windows 11 workaround that enabled local accounts
Yeah. I guess you could say that the focus shifted from Windows the OS being the product to the user also becoming the product. Of course, the users never signed up for this.

I'm not sure how to prevent these kind of shenanigans, but it simply comes back to sweet adtech dollars I think. The industry is so huge and pervasive now, that regulating it back into submission is going to be very difficult. 10 years ago, regulation could've been passed that simply prevented adtech from ever becoming as normalized and intrusive as it is these days. Doing it now will cause a massive hit to the valuation of the industry, and these kind of moves tend to be unpopular. Who is going to pull off a campaign that erases hundreds of billions of dollars from the US stock market (and thus people's pensions)?

short_sells_poo··on Microsoft blocks Windows 11 workaround that enabled local accounts
Absolutely. It's just maximizing some sort of metric that ultimately translates into P&L for the PMs. Everything else is largely irrelevant. If the users bitch and moan, but the PM is getting paid more, they'll be incentivised to keep doing what they are doing. The product may end up dead in 10 years time as the userbase is driven away, but by then everyone responsible is long gone.

We can all pontificate about acting differently in their shoes, but I'm honest enough to admit that I wouldn't :D

short_sells_poo··on Microsoft blocks Windows 11 workaround that enabled local accounts
Ultimately, the only reason we need to look at is late stage capitalism (and I say this as someone who believes in the market economy). Windows was the historic money maker at Microsoft, they held all the keys, all the power. The regime is changing however. OSes are more and more commoditised and the money has moved to Cloud and now AI. But there is one rule of the market: you have to post gains every quarter. So what is the Windows team to do? There is no growth to be had anywhere else, so they become increasingly less scrupulous in an effort to squeeze more $$$ out of the product.

This is obviously a race to the bottom. They know, we know it, the market knows it. However, as long as the numbers keep going up, the market will reward this self destructive behaviour and the team will indulge it.

They aren't stupid, they know that these features are annoying, but they'll keep pushing them to find the optimal point between the users being pissed off and profit going up.

The risk is of course that they launch a positive feedback loop of exodus and end up destroying the product in the long term, but in the long term we are all dead and the PMs profiting from these user hostile policies will be long retired...

← PreviousPage 10 of 29Next →