HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shukantpal

206 karma · joined January 29, 2021

Infra @ Meta. Previously Teamflow, Lindy. Building agentic companies GitHub.com/impalasys/talon
submissionscomments
shukantpal··on The Tipping Point: The Economics of Taxi Fares
Yeah, but they don't get to raise their prices as fast.
shukantpal··on Making Open Source economy more viable with dual license collectives
Hmm, you're right; I was thinking of the SSPL not AGPL when I wrote that comment. Thanks for the correction.
shukantpal··on Making Open Source economy more viable with dual license collectives
AGPL is not considered a free software license.
shukantpal··on Dev corrupts NPM libs 'colors' and 'faker', breaking thousands of apps
Thanks for stating the obvious. It isn't silly at all to publish malware and vaporize your reputation, right?; maybe it was good after all, people will become careful.
shukantpal··on Oh, 2022
> hardly anyone else will

That's a democracy. Not a problem.

shukantpal··on Dev corrupts NPM libs 'colors' and 'faker', breaking thousands of apps
In an infinite loop, yes.
shukantpal··on Dev corrupts NPM libs 'colors' and 'faker', breaking thousands of apps
It isn't necessary the package was used in CI jobs only and not production servers.
shukantpal··on Dev corrupts NPM libs 'colors' and 'faker', breaking thousands of apps
> keeping software up while adding more features is costly

The software maintenance is also given out as a gift. That's a choice.

shukantpal··on Dev corrupts NPM libs 'colors' and 'faker', breaking thousands of apps
> Free as in freedom is not the same as free as in beer.

It's a choice to distribute software for "free" as in "free beer".

shukantpal··on Dev corrupts NPM libs 'colors' and 'faker', breaking thousands of apps
> That's fine, but then the downstream shouldn't complain either when the code breaks, whether intentionally or unintentionally.

There's no contract that says complaining is banned.

shukantpal··on Dev corrupts NPM libs 'colors' and 'faker', breaking thousands of apps
> Who are you to decide what is useful/legitimate or not?

Common sense.

shukantpal··on Pluton is not currently a threat to software freedom
No it’s more like “why complain about a method that isn’t being used to lock down devices instead ones that are actually being used for that purpose”
shukantpal··on Google fined €150M, Facebook €60M for for non-compliance with French legislation
> Tell that to the numerous people who see an ad for something actually relevant to them instead of something only vaguely relevant to the site's primary audience.

You're not being subjected to some kind of torture; in fact, you are responsible for sending the HTTP request and executing it on your computer.

shukantpal··on Google fined €150M, Facebook €60M for for non-compliance with French legislation
> There is a clear intention by these companies to bore or confuse people into signing their rights away

These aren’t “rights”. There’s no confusion either. And people aren’t entitled to getting a service for free so they lost nothing.

> Consider how many lawyers are on payroll or retention at these companies who are aware of the requirements of the law, then consider that G/FB made a cynical, calculated decision to ignore it.

Irrelevant

shukantpal··on Google fined €150M, Facebook €60M for for non-compliance with French legislation
You really aren’t entitled to stackOverflow so you were never “forced”
shukantpal··on Google fined €150M, Facebook €60M for for non-compliance with French legislation
Changing the response of your HTTP server does not warrant jail time
shukantpal··on Tauri – Electron alternative written in Rust
Nope, you can compile code back to whatever ECMAScript version you like with tools like Babel or TypeScript. So the devs don’t even notice that they’re compiling to 4-5 year old ES.
shukantpal··on Ask HN: How to continue to be gracious about the good fortune of rich friends?
Regardless of that statement's truthiness, that's very much irrelevant for the OP. Nowhere did they say they were broke.
shukantpal··on We need to reclaim our attention
> When a true heroin addict shoots up, is that completely voluntary or completely involuntary? Probably neither.

The heroin addict doesn't get to blame someone else for their choices; it's a bit like jumping from a building - it's not voluntary to be falling (i.e. being subject to gravity). You had a choice to not jump from the building.

The mitigation is to turn the parachute on your back on, so _continuing_ to be falling is voluntary.

So, in the moment, it may not be voluntary - but in the long term, it certainly is. And the _responsibility_, that most certainly lies with the user in this case.

> but that doesn't mean these large companies aren't still doing the sneaky things that we know they are

It's not like they're hiding anything from the user so it's not sneaky at all. The effects of social media are pretty public on the Internet.

And what are they doing, exactly? Responding to HTTP requests over the network and serving content as the user requests them via algorithms.

Not much different than any other addictive thing in life. Sure, you can try to compare the addictiveness, but it's still just a spectrum.

shukantpal··on We need to reclaim our attention
> “Stolen" in the title of the OP is not really an exaggeration.

Theft can happen only when it’s involuntary.

> the problem is systemic, essentially baked into the business model of advertising/marketing, and it should be addressed

That’s not the root cause. It is just a choke point for blame.

The root cause is the choice people make, which we’ve established exists. If people want help, there are plenty of mitigations for social media, like alternative front ends.

shukantpal··on Stanford requires booster shots for all students
Ironic
shukantpal··on A realization of why email is critical infrastructure for the Internet
Time will tell. I'm optimistic. There's no proof it can't happen.
shukantpal··on Browse the web like its 1999
And? Single data point.
shukantpal··on A realization of why email is critical infrastructure for the Internet
That's true, but the government is still further away from control; besides, web3 is bringing decentralized DNS (see Handshake Protocol) to fix that.
shukantpal··on A realization of why email is critical infrastructure for the Internet
Instead of being controlled by the government, maybe we should make it easier to setup a mail server for your domain?
shukantpal··on You block ads in your browser, why not in your city?
Well the OP's post was based on rejecting all those "reasons" you're talking about. Those reasons can also apply to other things like not doing theft, not burning down other people's properties, etc.
shukantpal··on Italian Courts Find Open Source Software Terms Enforceable
If someone somehow knew they were using GPL code before the suit, they can easily do the same check after the suit
shukantpal··on You block ads in your browser, why not in your city?
> I am talking about skyscrapers, pop-ups (actually banned by default on modern browsers), multiple flashy GIFs as banner (like in the 90s), sounds in ads (working on a tab you're not even on!).

The issue was about the real world anyway; in the case of a website, you were the one who request the website be displayed on your computer (that's what the browser does).

In the real world, however, ads are simple banners like the Google text Ads.

> I'm glad we don't have that nonsense dishonesty here in my country.

It's not dishonest even if your interpretation were true, because both parties know it's just another form of greeting.

shukantpal··on You block ads in your browser, why not in your city?
> So if I browse a website and get distracted by all the ads, it is my own fault?

At a certain point, yes - if the ad doesn’t take a major portion of your screen and is non-interactive. You are not a victim - there are reasonable boundaries of being “annoyed”.

> This has a social function, its a two way benefit. Advertising isn't. Its a one-way communication.

Not really. You could’ve easily claimed “I don’t GAF who you are and don’t say Hi to me”. The one-sidedness is an arbitrary constraint you’ve put to try to reject this scenario - it should have no bearing on the annoyingness of the sound waves.

shukantpal··on The Problem with Ponzis
> Hertz was perhaps the most famous example, where the stock was bid up even though it was already in bankruptcy proceedings and was inevitably going to $0.

Hertz shareholders did receive a material payout after Apollo's debtor-in-possession takeover of the company. https://www.wsj.com/articles/hertzs-complex-shareholder-payo...

← PreviousPage 4 of 8Next →