HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shwaj

479 karma · joined April 28, 2023

submissionscomments
shwaj··on Go grandmaster Shin defeats AI KataGo with a two-stone handicap
I was under the impression that Go also uses Elo, then I did a bit of cursory research and discovers that it varies.

Two major federations are American Go Association (AGA) and European Go Federation (EGF). EGF uses an Elo-inspired update rule since 2021. AGA uses a quite-different Bayesian system without pairwise update; they provide a paper and a C++ reference impl.

Asian countries don't bother with such numeric ratings. Instead, rankings are titles which are won through tournament promotion structures (sounds similar to Sumo to me).

Interesting, because I always thought that it was more "apples to apples", and that the higher upper limits of Go rankings was somehow indicative of the higher "dynamic range" of the game compared to chess. For example, if Elo were applied to basketball, what would the Elo of Lebron James be compared to a playground hooper (leaving aside that 1-on-1 isn't the best part of Lebron's game)... would it be higher or lower than Magnus Carlsen in chess? I don't have an intuition.

shwaj··on Apple caught off guard by AI demand for Mac Mini and Mac Studio
It was a joke referencing the typo in the message they responded to.
shwaj··on Carmack: Has early Scratch experience led to fulfilling careers?
I was housemates with a couple with a kid. The kid learned Scratch first, and made some surprisingly sophisticated apps in that semester (or two).

By now he’s moved on to textual languages (not yet old enough for a career), but Scratch was engaging and gave him a good start.

shwaj··on How much of HN is AI?
I don't know about the article about Apple News scams, but how is an article about Waymo publishing a model for self driving cars not about AI?
shwaj··on Moon (2024)
It's not plagarism, Ciechanowski didn't invent this presentation form. His presentations are examples of "active essays", a term coined by Alan Kay no later than 2006.

(I don't know whether Alan invented the concept itself, I'm not aware of him claiming that)

See: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/5350160

shwaj··on CIA funding helped keep NeXT afloat in the 80s
Your tone implies that the same people who freak out about reasonable gov intervention, are also (hypocritically) okay with the shenanigans being discussed.

Who are these straw men you refer to?

shwaj··on Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of forest area
You could be more charitable. They did say “or” which you omitted in your quote, and also “who knows”. There are possibilities too. In my view, the primary contribution of that comment was to clarify the time frame.
shwaj··on AFC Stands in Solidarity with UEFA and Concacaf to Protect the FIFA World Cup
I have to assume that was sarcasm.
shwaj··on Claude Opus 5
So highlight both then.
shwaj··on Claude Opus 5
It would still be the best model per dollar if the score was 2% lower instead of 0.1% lower. Would it be ok to still give it the highlight color then?

How big of a lie is too big? Especially when no lie needed to be told at all: many including myself would have noticed the tiny 0.1% deficit and been suitably impressed by the Opus 5 result.

I’ll admit this is a small deception by today’s standards. I’m one of those who believes in truth for truth’s sake.

Edit: typo

shwaj··on The arguments against open source AI are bad
I didn’t grow up with that hobby. The point stands anyway.

Cracking a binary circumvents authorization to provide full access to functionality the program already has. That’s very different from modifying the program to add new features.

shwaj··on Claude Opus 5
I like how they highlighted Opus 5 as the best for “Agentic Coding” even though the number is slightly lower than Fable. Close enough for marketing, I guess!
shwaj··on The arguments against open source AI are bad
Equating an open weight model to a closed source binary is ludicrous. An open weight model can be fine tuned, for example. How easy is it to modify a closed source binary for your purposes?
shwaj··on OpenAI and Hugging Face address security incident during model evaluation
They avoid the full basilisk treatment.
shwaj··on Kimi K3: Open Frontier Intelligence
Since we’re hair splitting: that’s not what bike shedding means. :-D
shwaj··on Modern decor may be straining people's brains
“Striped office floors. Flickering lights. Walls covered in repetitive geometric patterns.”

Not sentences. AI slop.

shwaj··on GPT-5.6
Inference providers, sure, but wouldn't we expect customers to win also?
shwaj··on Flock cameras track more than your license plate, and they're spreading fast
Benn Jordan, you mean. Good video.
shwaj··on Previewing GPT‑5.6 Sol: a next-generation model
> ML researcher or engineer

The charitable reading is that they meant “ML researcher or ML engineer” with the latter meaning, I guess, an engineer who works on developing LLMs not just using them.

shwaj··on Ford AI hiccups push carmaker to rehire ‘gray beard’ inspectors
I don’t think society is a monolith. Many of those who support your proverbial alimony are also against CEOs acting with impunity.
shwaj··on Cell-based architecture for resilient payment systems
It's becoming a reliable heuristic that when somebody says "... got it", they probably didn't get it.
shwaj··on Feds freaked over Fable 5 after 'fix this code', not jailbreak, say researchers
“Put it there in the back with the others”, lol.
shwaj··on Banned Book Library in a Wi-Fi Smart Light Bulb
"Formerly banned books" would be more accurate.

We no longer say that "cannabis is illegal in California"; that would be factually incorrect. Instead we say, "cannabis was formerly illegal". In standard usage of English, the same pattern applies to banned vs formerly banned books.

Edit: wording

shwaj··on Google's Antigravity bait and switch
I’ve heard about that “open secret” and I don’t understand.

What’s the incentive for Anthropic to pump up the token usage on their top end plan? Is it to move Pro users up to Max? That’s the only plausible idea I can think of.

shwaj··on US is starting to see heavy job losses in roles exposed to AI
Maybe I just don’t know how the business works. Many of the support calls that I make are for things or services that I’ve had for a while, not just purchased. So I expected that to be more of a trailing indicator rather than the first area hit.
shwaj··on US is starting to see heavy job losses in roles exposed to AI
I’m as skeptical of fiat currencies as the next guy, but denominating in Bitcoin is the ultimate cherry pick.

The price of everything has crashed in the last 10 years when denominated in Bitcoin. If we measured GDP in Bitcoins, the statistics would show that we’re in an unprecedented depression.

shwaj··on US is starting to see heavy job losses in roles exposed to AI
Sales people sure, but secretaries and support staff?
shwaj··on Why is this site named Antipope?
Not on my timeline, this has been the name the whole time.
shwaj··on Red Hot Chili Peppers ink $300M deal with Warner Music to sell catalog
Relatively small amount compared to the billions we see thrown around for AI startups a couple of years old.
shwaj··on US Government releases first batch of UAP documents and videos
I thought they’re primarily water vapor resulting from the combustion reaction, not from wing tip turbulence.
← PreviousPage 2 of 10Next →