HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shwouchk

201 karma · joined March 10, 2008

submissionscomments
shwouchk··on Aaron Swartz and Sam Altman
Devils advocate;

In order for the elite to rule, they need a rich oligarchy of support. At least that’s how it’s always been.

And you want cooperation from the mob, if you want the place in general to thrive - and you do, if you’re smart. Because your genes do. Look what eventually happens to the progeny of /most/, bad dictators these days, eventually.

Using the biggest gang as protection for smaller, even tiny gangs kills two birds with one stone; Anyone can join the protection racket so the mob is pacified, and the biggest gang gets the support of the rich gangs, who get to sit in on the council.

Terey pratchett’s genius is slowly revealed to me over the years)))

shwouchk··on iTerm2 critical security release
so was openssl
shwouchk··on iTerm2 critical security release
> Finally, security bugs are in a class of their own. Giving out free junk is OK. Giving out free secret poison is not.

It is not if it was done maliciously. If the code you got for free contained some mistakes it's ultimately your responsibility - You didn't have to take that pill you got at the party.

Accepting donations could change this, but I would say it depends on how they are presented - "campaign donations" ala Joey Hess or "Hey thanks for the the party last night, here's $40 to cover some of the booze!"

Alternatively, I'm curious how you feel about companies offering you "free email, free search, free image hosting, free social media" etc, (actually, in exchange for all your behavioral data) ((actually, even if you never directly accept anything from us))?

shwouchk··on iTerm2 critical security release
I highly recommend wezterm.
shwouchk··on Zasper: A Modern and Efficient Alternative to JupyterLab, Built in Go
Thanks, I'm quite aware of org-mode. All my emacs config is in it, I have 1000s of LOC configuring /just/ org, I use it my computers and on my phones for any kind of information management, and I absolutely love it.

I think it can be very suitable eg when you are preparing a presentation, report, a paper or a repeatable analysis/process. Especially - as with most of those examples - if you want to interleave narrative and code/results. It is less suitable for doing exploratory analysis, for any kind of interactivity, for connecting to remote sessions (it's possible but clunky), for showing a chart that you can zoom into. For displaying a table with 10,000 rows, for displaying a large plot. Or multiple plots. For being able to zoom into a plot. It's not great at integrating with LSP and similar tools. Could be better at managing code blocks, though one could write additional helpers and bindings fairly easily.

And, finally, it is quite a pain in the ass to have the code stored in a document rather than as code since it does tie me down even to my beloved emacs. I develop most of my code as library code which I can directly import/run. During the development it is still helpful to see the results of running defined functions and to be able to interact with the dataset. I currently do have a solution and a workflow but the tools aren't ideal for it.

I want to be able to have my codebase run inside a docker container, to be able to `git pull` to update it on the remote without involving emacs on the remote end, without having duplicate versions of the code in the repo (ie one in the org document and one tangled) for me to manage, and I also want to be able to make a small change in vim and push it back without involving emacs.

> Juypter has an interface and API built in. What Zasper is the reimplementation of the juypter protocol. You can see this at [1].Juypter kernels are very different from Mathematica notebooks. Mathematica notebooks aren't related to juypter.

Thank you for the explanation. Up until this very moment I thought mathematica and jupyter were exactly the same. Just to make sure, when you say they are very different and unrelated, do you mean like matlab is unrelated to numpy+ecosystem, like how Honda cars are unrelated to Ford cars, or like how pandas is unrelated to excel?

It helps when you are actually familiar with the technologies before making any - especially contradictory - claims. Mathematica for all it's faults - primary of them being proprietary - has a quite finely polished product and jupyter notebook interface draws heavily from it. I'f I'm not mistaken it is the OG notebook interface, though I'm not making a strong claim here.

Mathematica also has an interface and an API built in. You can run mathematica (or is it "wolfram" these days?) code on a headless kernel, you can connect your notebook frontend to a remote kernel, and you can make your own completely independent UI using the APIs in the language. Alternatively, you can connect the notebook interface to a kernel in another language using J/Link MathLink or C/++Link APIs. Or you can embed the mathematica kernel into jupyter - an existing project/duct and run mathematica code in jupyter/Zasper/whatever. Or run it in their webui for the past .. decade at this point?

I'll give you the benefit of doubt and not assume that you are a trollbot but I sincerely don't understand your need to offer "first page of google" suggestions when you clearly don't use the technologies you're commenting on.

shwouchk··on Zasper: A Modern and Efficient Alternative to JupyterLab, Built in Go
I can't recall exactly right now (incidentally I started recording decisions like this to be able to answer questions like this - mainly for myself - but only recently).

To refresh my memory I just started it and tried using it with a julia kernel on a remote jupyter. To start, it wouldn't connect to https endpoint. Maybe because it's signed by a private CA? idk, but the mac trusts it for eg the browser and curl. Well anyway, let's forward the http port and try connecting to localhost.

Great, that works, and I'm offered some uuid as a "choice of kernel to connect to". I don't recall having one running before I connected, so it probably was started for me. How do I name it? Ah, there's `jupyter-server-kernel-list-name-kernel`, and now I'm recalling that whatever you name it as, will disappear if you quit emacs. Let's try.

Meanwhile, I import PlotlyJS and try to create a plot. I get complaints about WebIO (julia package that facilitates interaction with browser) like I do in jupyter (the package is old and doesn't work with current jupyter), except in the browser only the back communication (browser->kernel) is broken, for interactivity. Showing plots works. Anyway, PlotlyJS displays nothing. `Plots`, which renders to a png, somehow produces the axes but not data. Eventually I get PlotlyJS to display an image using explicit image mime types.

Still no interactivity - I would need node for that, to compile widget support for whatever reason - but it does display. I should retest widget support. Sending code to repl works, although at this point I'm used to seeing an overlay over variables that get set.

Ok. Close emacs, restart, go to session list (`jupyter-server-list-kernels`). Name has been cleared. I can reassociate the buffer to the kernel, but, if I have two, open kernels, how do I tell which buffers is associates with which kernel?

Overall it mostly works although there's room for polish. However, interactivity or any kind of bidirectional communication remains somewhat difficult.

shwouchk··on Zasper: A Modern and Efficient Alternative to JupyterLab, Built in Go
Yes, I'm aware of EIN. To start, it's been abandoned by it's author/maintainer as of April 2024 IIRC.

Further, I do not need a kernel to execute emacs code - I have one and it's called emacs. The point regarding executing elisp code was a cheeky way to state that I am not looking forward to finding replacement and/or porting of all the custom code - mine and others' - that my editor runs, and that no amount of "features" from a webui editor will ever replace that. Hence I also mentioned vim since over time it got customized for me as well and I wouldn't want to port that either. Nor the convenience of the terminal, which is what vim is for.

Putting that aside as with all respect and gratitude to the author, it was rather clunky in many respects - no interactive story, poor handling of sessions and remote kernels (have you tried to start one, disconnect and reconnect?), no integration with LSP, and lack of many many more features that /could/ be made.

I don't know how much use you make of jupyter kernels or mathematica notebooks or similar technologies, but in my case I explored the available landcape quite thoroughly and regularly revisit. I know what I'm looking for and EIN is/was not it.

[EDIT] I just noticed you mentioned EIN but linked to emacs-jupyer. Used that as well, of course. Ill add a bit more detail to that in sibling

shwouchk··on Zasper: A Modern and Efficient Alternative to JupyterLab, Built in Go
I mentioned vim as well and generally proposed something that would be editor agnostic. Shoo! back to your cave.
shwouchk··on Zasper: A Modern and Efficient Alternative to JupyterLab, Built in Go
Hello and thank you for making this!

Can I sway you to take this into a ... certain direction?

From my POV any browser based editor will be inferior to emacs (and to lesser extent vim) simply because it won't run my elisp code. While a fresh and snappier UI compared to eg jupyter would be nice, I would love to see something that integrates well with emacs out of the box.

So, perhaps it would be really nice if the backend+API was really polished as an end product itself in such a way that it could easily interface with other frontends, with remote attachment.

I could go on with my list of demands but I would be thrilled and amazed at my luck if even those two happen...

shwouchk··on Trying to use Bluesky without getting burned again
You raise some good points regarding benefits of integration in AP. I mentioned some classic technologies that could be packaged well together to form something cohesive, you claim this is it. Ok, i concede - i think i would be interested in a “platformless”, websitelike protocol but that doesn’t preclude something like an interoperable forumlike protocol from being useful.

That being said, > I don't know what kad is, but most of the things you list on your spectrum of decentralization had dominant players, whether it's DNS, gpg keys, CAs, or torrent trackers. I'm not going to split hairs on whether the dominance of keybase meant gpg is not really decentralized.

Most of what i mentioned is indeed semi centralized - but also semi decentralized. it and that was the point - there is no one true way to “decentralize” - is the star trek federation decentralized? is banks’ culture?

You make some very general claims regarding what decentralized systems don’t solve, but whatever your argument, you base it off some specific model of what is decentralized (you define a binary criterion). Whatever you claim, you can claim only for that model and indeed! that model doesn’t attempt to solve many problems that found in previous decentralized models and that are desirable to solve, and hence my criticism.

We’ve designed a slightly more advanced wordpress. Let’s celebrate! I would hope for something more imaginative. And indeed some are trying.

And, people are free to work on what they like of course - who am i to judge? Well, unfortunately i find myself to not be in the position and with a strong enough passion about this to do something myself, but im affected just as everyone alive is.

I do see seemingly better attempts as we’ve discussed, and in this particular case im worried that worse is the enemy of better, due to network effects. Any traction of a worse platform takes away from a better one.

Finally, gpg keys existed way before keybase and are actually one of the actually distributed and decentralized systems, so it’s curious that you picked specifically on this example.

gpg keys are entirely local first. Actually decentralized and usable to the individual user level. On top were built various webs of trust by mutual signing and publication of public keys to various public directories.

Keybase were able to package this neatly with added features and they enjoy some network effects but their data is public - you could spin up a compatitor before the end of the year ( it is dec 31 :) without losing any data. Or with a completely separate web of trust, that could also trust keybase keys.

ssh keys are similar in this regard, except the usage patterns are different and so keys are trusted on an individual basis or when signed by some organization/“community” wide ca. Im sure you know all this already.

Both of these last two examples demonstrate that in some cases decentralization does work, well. If we go with your “decentralized” model - “power to the states, not the people” - inevitably you get monopolistic players that kill off the standard as youve observed yourself. Like happened with email, with jabber, with rss, with browsers, like will happen with AP.

This is not a faster, quieter, cleaner or more efficient dishwasher. This is the exact same one we had last year, except with chrome finish, touch buttons and built in wifi. It will get picked up by the same sort of people that bought the old version - namely ones buying their first one or whose 10 machine broke.

It will fail and be unsatisfactory in fundamentally the same ways, since nothing changed in the mechanical specs. And in 10 years some extra features will be added like a voice assistant, to justify the raised priced on the same old crap.

shwouchk··on Trying to use Bluesky without getting burned again
I understand your claim though dont agree on several counts -

1. To start, if decentralization does not "solve the problem" then what do all AP platforms bring to the table? There was already a decentralized facebook before mastodon - it used to be called a "web site". You could get a feed with just what you wanted by subscribing to rss feeds, which were also decentralized. You were not tied to 140 characters per post either, and nothing stopped someone from making an rss client that clipped posts at 140 characters in the the feed or whatever. What problem does AP solve for me? Indexing all that content? The hosting? If the whole thing is about getting banned from the domain twitter.com, open your own domain and publish your content - problem solved.

2. If we're solving a solved problem, why not bring something new to the table? eg anonymity of nosr.

3. If "decentralization is not the solution", how come other protocols - eg mentioned above - claim (convincingly imho) to offer an actual improvement if not solution?

4. You claim "decentralization is not the solution" then define some ad hoc line in the sand regarding what is "decentralized" and then make some bold claims based on that. Decentralized could mean many things: could be like ssh keys, could be like gpg keys with directories and web of trust, could be like dns or certificate authorities. Could be like email. Like torrents or like i2p, or kad. All of these are slightly different. Heck, could even mean like fb vs twitter - you are free to move to a different platform. Takeout your data, import contacts - done.

Where you claim that decentralization is not the answer i will say maybe insufficient decentralization is not the answer - with email, AP, and many other protocols, the platform ("domain") is the first class citizen so you get strong platforms and weak users. Regulation will help here just like it helped with banking - ie wont. What makes banks cooperate is mutual desire for profit.

Banks are truly fungible for the most part - make users first class and you will get the same for platforms

shwouchk··on 'Obelisks': New class of life has been found in human digestive system
This was not claimed. All that was stated is that its a new thing we know very little about, links to autoimmune disease have no immediate obvious connection, and to say anything more would require an investigation. What more can you expect?
shwouchk··on Curl-Impersonate
Require a verified account to buy high demand items.
shwouchk··on Trying to use Bluesky without getting burned again
decentralization is not some magical binary property. Real world systems can be more, or less, decentralized.

To start with, yes banking giants exists but everyone finds this undesirable to a certain extent and regulators would object if suddenly eg elon musk decided to buy out goldman and chase.

banks are highly regulated and enjoy completely different economies than email. Banks of the same nation are often legally required to be interoperable with others. Yes, there are still big players and you can eg get sanctioned by the US - which is why BRIC countries are working on alternative banking networks.

with banks, most jurisdictions would disallow a merger of two large banks specifically from decentralization considerations - guess what would happen if two email providers merge? exactly nothing.

With email, if gmail decide to ban you, you are unable to communicate with 90% of people with no recourse. A support engineer can decide to ban you on a whim and besides crying on social media, you can’t do much.

With banks, you need a large and powerful nation to tell other banks not to play with you, and you can contest this decision legally.

Most importantly, with banking money is the product and every transaction brings revenue, so there’s a strong incentive to cooperate. With email - and AP - cooperation incurs a cost on all parties instead and benefits are distributed and vague in monetary terms.

Finally, banks are required to deal with you as a customer - provided you meet certain requirements. An email provider can ban you for no reason and your only recourse is arbitration.

Compare to bitcoin. Will you still be calling it decentralized when one pool controls 90% of compute (i don’t think this can really happen tbh as there are disincentives to go 51% without abusing the network)?

Don’t get me wrong AP sure feels in the right direction compared to eg FB. Just on the principle of being able to run it completely in your own. However it would be nice if whatever new alternative that grew popular treated users, rather than providers, democratically.

shwouchk··on Trying to use Bluesky without getting burned again
I understand this, but you seem to have ignored my point in that it is trivially easy to make something similar for email and yet no one did, and that it is unclear what’s to stop the same situation from happening again when 90% of users have a lemmy.org or whatever address.

Or like happened with the original decentralized web. there was once a thing called a “blog” that you could host on your own server from your home, but these days everyone is “blogging” through fb twitter and instagram (or your choice of a few platforms). Why is this time different?

shwouchk··on Trying to use Bluesky without getting burned again
I never ran my AP server but i did run my own mail in my late teens/early twenties. I don't recall it being particularly difficult, compared to eg setting a webserver.

Just install some software from your distro PM and go through some configs. Nothing stopped some hacker from bundling configs with a point and click installer for android eg - A mail server doesnt need 100% uptime - or for servers.

As for reaching others, ive never had problems because my domains had dkim and whatever else was available set up - could be easily automated like web certificates were, and i never send spam... How is that inherently more difficult? I'm genuinely curious, not trying to argue - just citing my own experience.

What's to stop major servers ("gmail" and "hotmail" of AP) from blocking you? Obviously some aspects are different from mail as it is geared for wide distribution rather than directed communication, but it's not obvious to me that the decentralization problem is solved by a model that seems superficially close to email.

Again, im not trying to troll you as im unfamiliar with AP - i genuinely don't know.

shwouchk··on Trying to use Bluesky without getting burned again
How many people are running their own mail outside of large orgs or privacy/security niche? How many of those have had trouble sending mail to eg gmail?
shwouchk··on Are PC hardware companies driving technology into restricted closed ecosystems?
Im curious, what do you use so many "low power desktop" devices for?
shwouchk··on Fans of Iain Banks, please explain – a.k.a. "player of games" book review
Thank you for clarifying.
shwouchk··on Will that hub or dock slow your SSDs, or even make them faster?
Im sorry, despite their marketing, this is a 2 output dock. Offering TB passthrough doesnt count, just like we wouldnt call regular usb hubs "multiple display docks" if some manufacturer came out with usb screens (whih im sure exist already for lowres output).
shwouchk··on Fans of Iain Banks, please explain – a.k.a. "player of games" book review
Ill take a look, thanks. However, I think your superficially similar statement to sibling is actually saying the opposite?

In player of games, i don’t recall skipping/skimming dialogue? Is that your claim? there’s something hidden in the dialogue that i missed? I must agree i didn’t find much meaning in it nor remember any at this point - it was so vague! As if people knew they were being eavesdropped…

shwouchk··on Earth's subsurface may hold up to 5.6 × 10⁶ million metric tons of hydrogen
If siblings are to be believed, there is nothing we can do about it aside from being very careful not to release the hydrogen into the atmosphere (at which point it will “burn” whether we want to or not)
shwouchk··on Will that hub or dock slow your SSDs, or even make them faster?
Yep that was my exact story too, before the first sock gave out shortly before warranty, was replaced (at least regarding customer service im happy), and then same exact story with the second one.

Given that i had a third unrelated dock fail recently it wouldn’t be unreasonable to suspect something on my end might be causing this, but then again that’s the only hardware that failed on me in a while and i don’t do anything that unusual besides having 3x4k screens plugged into it and the occasional mouse charging/flash drive drawing power off it.

In all cases the PSU of the dock died with it (but also the docks themselves) so i suspect current DL chipsets overheat and eventually burn out when pushing clost to their max resolution.

shwouchk··on Will that hub or dock slow your SSDs, or even make them faster?
Aside from my justified negative opinions about caldigit, i was referring to docks that offer 3+ (simultaneous) screen outputs (eg not one with 2 hdmi+2dp that can use either set but not all 4 together).

That requires DP.

shwouchk··on Will that hub or dock slow your SSDs, or even make them faster?
I recently got this one (see sibling comment to parent) and am quite happy with it:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B0CMT7WMVM

Note that as all docks it requires displaylink software on mac to use more than one screen, and the software is a bit buggy - needs to be restarted every couple of times i reconnect to the dock for the displays to work right. TBH this is the first dock i experience this with but then again os and software updates, and ive seen weird flaky behavior before, just not specifically this.

shwouchk··on Will that hub or dock slow your SSDs, or even make them faster?
PSA: STAY AWAY!

I had two expensive caldigit docks (TS3 i believe). One was warranty replacement for the first one. Each died after about a year.

After that I had an expensive alogic dock. Seemed great when it was working, but after just over a year it went dead (warranty is for two years).

The dock i had is out of stock. After weeks of “checking” I was offered an exchange for a cheaper version (whatever) that doesn’t include features i rely on (3 screens).

As “compensation” I was offered about 30% of the original price, since “the item was used”.

Thanks but no thanks. Standard amortization time for computer equipment is 5 years. And in either case, who has patience to go for weeks without their familiar computing environment? And my cost is replacement of the item, i did not rent it.

I got a Kensington dock sold by amazon at slightly less than the original price of that one, with better features and a brand name that is worth more than the piece of paper it is written on.

We’ll see how it lasts

shwouchk··on Introducing S2
Ah, thank you :)
shwouchk··on GPT-5 is behind schedule
No, they don’t - they don’t have the hardware, yet. But they do parrot sensory output to eg muscles that induce the expected video sensory inputs in response, in a way that mimics the video input of “other people doing things”.
shwouchk··on GPT-5 is behind schedule
you are funny. Clearly your expertise with babies comes from reading books about history or science, rather than ever having interacted with one…

What resolution of screen do you think you would need to not distinguish from reality? For me personally i very conservatively estimate it to be on above OOM of 10 4k screens by 10, meaning 100k screens. If a typical 2h 4k is ~50gb uncompressed, that gives us about half a petabyte per 24h (even with eyes closed). Just raw unlabeled vision data.

Probably a baby has a significantly lower resolution, but then again what is the resolution from the skin and other organs?

So yes, petabytes of data within the first days of existence - well, likely before even being born since baby can hear inside the uterus, for example.

And very high signal data, as you’ve stated yourself (nothing to write home about) mainly seeing mom and dad, as well as from a feedback loop POV - a baby never tells you it is hungry subtly.

shwouchk··on One surprising psychosis treatment that works: Learning to live with the voices
I had several family members experience episodes, and i have as well. In my own case it struck me as i was preparing to board a plane. Thankfully i was allowed off briefly before the takeoff. I knew that what im experiencing is so unlikely as to be impossible (eg large scale conspiracy) but could do nothing to shake it off. Eventually i found a safehouse and just hid there, letting it ride over me until it passed after a day.

Hasnt occurred since. Unfortunately, even after having experienced and successfully (in my subjective experience) navigating this, i was able to help others do the same (at least to what i would calk that).

← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →