HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

silkodyssey

1,516 karma · joined March 17, 2009

Founder of Safyah Solutions http://www.safyah.com kelvin.pompey@gmail.com
submissionscomments
silkodyssey··on Clojure Protocols & Datatypes — A sneak peek
So does this make Clojure a hybrid functional / object oriented language like Scala? Or how do these features compare to the object oriented features of Scala? Which approach do you prefer?
silkodyssey··on An open letter to Kevin Rose from Reddit cofounder Alexis Ohanian
User-created sections like the subreddits on reddit would be cool. In fact I think the subreddits are what I prefer about reddit over digg. I mainly go to the programming subreddit and sometimes I am deceived into thinking that all of reddit is about programming because it in itself is a large community.

But apart from the programming subreddit I go to the AMA section from time to time and that has allowed me to really grasp the beauty of the subreddit system. It allows each subreddit to develop it's own personality in that it's not just the topics that change as is the case with a category system but the feel and concept of the community changes as well and it offers a unique experience to learn and interact.

You guys really did a great job with Reddit!

silkodyssey··on An open letter to Kevin Rose from Reddit cofounder Alexis Ohanian
You don't like the direction Digg is going. If you were the one making the decisions what would you do?
silkodyssey··on Mark Zuckerberg: I Donated to Diaspora project
The 11 Companies That Tried To Buy Facebook

http://www.businessinsider.com/all-the-companies-that-ever-t...

silkodyssey··on I've Changed My Mind About The iPad
This is a powerful endorsement of the iPad. To me the message is you can't really judge the iPad based on the features it has or the list of things it can or can't do but instead it has to be experienced.
silkodyssey··on And The Winner Of TechCrunch Disrupt Is… Soluto
As far as disruptive technologies go I think saluto, if they deliver on their promise of solving users' computer problems deserves this accolade.

I have always lamented the fact that personal computers users have to double as system administrators to keep their systems running smoothly and the tech industry has been trying to alleviate the pain by moving to web based applications and alternative easier to use devices such as the iPad but if saluto can really deliver it may just give the desktop a second chance at life and that would truly be disruptive!

silkodyssey··on Is java dead for startups?
I've never looked at grails so I can't offer an opinion but I have some links that may be helpful to you. The first is a HN discussion on the play framework and the second a discussion on google groups about the differences between the two frameworks.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=898738

http://groups.google.com/group/play-framework/browse_thread/...

silkodyssey··on Is java dead for startups?
The play framework sounds like something you'd be interested in. It abandons the Java conventions for a more rails like experience. http://www.playframework.org/
silkodyssey··on Facebook's Culture Problem May Be Fatal
I think you're focusing too much on Ning. What I am really referring to is the business model that it uses. As you've suggested it's imperfect and maybe Ning hasn't run their business very well but I don't think because of that we should say that another company cannot implement the model successfully.

The model I envision is very similar to the shared hosting model employed on the web. You sign up for hosting and you install a CMS like drupal or wordpress and you have yourself a community and you pay a subcription fee. But instead of drupal there could be a social networking application. Each network creator would be responsble for it's promotion and marketing but I think it's a viable model because there are existing real world communities that would like to establish an online presence and something like this may be a great way to do that.

silkodyssey··on Facebook's Culture Problem May Be Fatal
See my reply here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1377750
silkodyssey··on Facebook's Culture Problem May Be Fatal
Well maybe Ning's execution of the model leaves much to be desired but what I wanted to express was the idea that a social network where the owner of the network paid for it is a good system because the provider of the service has to cater for the needs of the customer. And if the customer is a user and not an advertiser then I think the user should get better service.
silkodyssey··on Programming Languages: Application and Interpretation by Shriram Krishnamurthi
I also have SICP on my reading list so I just thought this would make a great follow up to that text since by then I would have a good grasp of scheme and functional programming.
silkodyssey··on Programming Languages: Application and Interpretation by Shriram Krishnamurthi
Just glanced through the book and was pleasantly surprised to see that the code is lisp. Adding this to my reading list.
silkodyssey··on Facebook's Culture Problem May Be Fatal
I like the Ning model. I think the value of a social network is in the common traits among users. Ning facilitates this extremely well by allowing users to create their own social network. The creator of the network pays for the network so no need for Ning to monetize people's private data because the users are the customers unlike facebook where they're the product.
silkodyssey··on Facebook's Culture Problem May Be Fatal
I think facebook is a perfect example of what happens when businesses are created "by accident", where a product is created first then a business model is grafted on afterwards. As the article mentions the needs of the users are in conflict with those of advertisers and it's a problem.

An increase in value for advertisers means a decrease in value for users. Users want privacy, advertisers want everything in the open. Facebook in an attempt to sustain growth has effectively forced users to accept people within their networks that they aren't really close to and this makes users less comfortable in their own space.

Facebook is at a critical juncture and its future depends on how it manages the problems they are facing now because the house of cards can come tumbling down at any moment. What they have going for it though is that there isn't really any clear alternative at the moment that users can turn to. What clear though is that people do want an alternative but till then I suspect most will bear with it till the alternative comes to their rescue.

silkodyssey··on Announcing Clojure/core
Would you care to elaborate? Your assertion implies that arc is going to surpass clojure in popularity. Why do you think so? Personally I think that's unlikely to happen given the traction that clojure has been getting already. Clojure has been designed for practical use and is already being used in real world projects whereas I get the impression that arc is sort of a research project where Paul is just experimenting with some ideas and is not constrained by the desire to do practical work.
silkodyssey··on Google acquires Ruba.com
An acquisition seems to be the logical outcome because if the team is going to be working at Google then that raises the question of what's going to happen to the ruba.com site. It doesn't seem plausible that the project would just be abandoned because I think it's reasonable for the owners to expect some compensation for the work they've done.
silkodyssey··on [dead]
I actually think that the Black Eyed Peas make great music! In terms of lyrical content no but there is a lot more to music than just the lyrics and this is even more true in the case of the Black Eyed Peas. I get the impression that for the group the sound and production take center stage and the lyrics are just an after thought but I think it's a worthy trade off because the musical arrangements themselves tend to be very creative and the novelty of the sound intrigues as the brain tries to make sense of something quite unlike anything it's heard before.
silkodyssey··on Duck Duck Go = Perfect search engine for programmers
I would like to know what was the motivation for starting the project. I don't think it's necessarily a bad idea for David to tackle Goliath but there has to be a unique value proposition.

Based on the information I have found about the project the only area I can see this competing is in the user experience (scrolling results, encrypted search etc). Maybe someone who knows more about the project can enlighten us.

silkodyssey··on Duck Duck Go = Perfect search engine for programmers
I am current taking the search engine for a spin and it has made a great first impression. I particularly like that instead of paging the search results it displays the results on demand using ajax. I prefer this interface because with less effort I see more results. I've found that with Google I tend to not to move past the first page and by doing that I probably miss out on information that may have been useful to me.

I wonder if Google has ever considered a similar interface for their search results.

silkodyssey··on Patent Troll Larry Horn of MPEG-LA Assembling VP8 Patent Pool
Google has stated that they are already using vp8 on youtube so I guess this may be part of their strategy. Youtube is a big target and if they don't have patent troubles then this may ease the concerns of other users. Alternatively if Youtube is taken to court then the ruling would settle the dispute once and for all.
silkodyssey··on Ask HN: Does the No-Humor Policy Have Unintended Consequences?
I think the relationship between the content of hacker news and the userbase is like an ecosystem and maintaining the fidelity of this system is necessary to preserve the mission of the community. People are attracted to hacker news because of the content and they in turn become a new source of similar content. If hacker news were to allow more lightweight material to the site then we may see users joining for that type of content and the repercussions of this I would would be undesirable. So while the perceived authoritarian nature of HN may be a bother sometimes I think it's a small price to pay to keep it the way it is meant to be.
silkodyssey··on Anyone else think that the constant Apple jabs at I/O are really poor form?
This is typical competitive business behaviour. I don't see a problem with it as long as it doesn't go overboard and I don't consider this to be the case here.

People tend to choose between competing products based on comparisons so the perceived value of the android platform would be based on how it compares to the iphone platform.

silkodyssey··on A 13-Year-Old Takes On Everest, and Sets Off a Debate
Russian roulette.
silkodyssey··on Ask HN: how to get into a data analysis / machine learning career?
Bradford cross who does machine learning work at flightcaster addresses this question in the following post:

http://measuringmeasures.com/blog/2010/3/12/learning-about-m...

silkodyssey··on Should Mozilla Fork Firefox?
The competition between firefox and chrome is friendly competition. They're both opensource browsers that follow web standards so we aren't losing much by chrome gaining market share at the expense of firefox.

If it were losing ground to internet explorer that would have been another issue though. As a result I don't really see the need for a fork of firefox. All they need to do is just focus of making a great browser. We're all fighting on the same side.

silkodyssey··on An Open Letter To Mark Zuckerberg: “Don’t Do A Mugabe To Facebook”
Theres no doubt that it would be a profitable venture but Facebook is concerned about more than just profit and at the moment. I get the impression that revenue is not their primary concern or least they aren't focused on maximizing revenue at the moment. Instead they're tweaking their product and growing the userbase to try to position themselves to maximize revenues later and become a force in the business world to compete with the likes of Google, Apple, Microsoft etc.
silkodyssey··on An Open Letter To Mark Zuckerberg: “Don’t Do A Mugabe To Facebook”
I am not sure selling privacy is such a great idea. People tend to see privacy as more of a right then a privilege and facebook's actions of late has been viewed as a violation of these rights. To ask users to pay to keep their content private would probably make matters worse and send facebook on a similar path to the one mugabe took zimbabwe on.

I think the premium services model is an interesting one however. This could provide an additional revenue source for facebook but I think it raises an interesting question. Are the users of facebook more valuable to the company as customers or as products. Or in other words, is there more money to be made in advertising than in premium services?

With all the brain power and talent of the people at facebook it's likely that these ideas and more have already been considered and in the initiatives that the company has taken recently shows which model they prefer.

silkodyssey··on Clojure in the field (presented by Stuart Halloway)
Slides: http://github.com/stuarthalloway/clojure-presentations/raw/m...
silkodyssey··on World's Largest Social Network - The Open Web
Great point. Hacker news is a great example of a space that is both open and social.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →