HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sipos

188 karma · joined May 22, 2016

submissionscomments
sipos··on Google is apparently taking down all/most Fediverse apps from the Play Store
Wikipedia cites a articles that show a number of examples of the company Twitter acocunt saying anti-semetic things, for example https://web.archive.org/web/20181031162843/https://www.cnn.c....

I agree with your point - it is hard to tell the difference generally, and it is an important point to remember, but the behaviour of the company itself shows that it is not an issue this time.

sipos··on Mozilla Fires Servo Devs and Security Response Teams
Fundamentally, whether you use Firefox or not, having an organisation that has user's interests at heart, and is not a major global corp, developing a major browser, is something we all need. It ensures that the evolution of the web is in a sensible direction. Mozilla has been an important input in WebAssembly, for example. Thus, Mozilla's problems are all of our problems.

Mozilla has two major problems though. Firstly, it largely relies on what is eventually advertising revenue, in a time when users are increasingly using ad-blockers etc and privacy laws reduce the value of targeted ads. Secondly, it has little traction on mobile, where iOS basically just has Safari because of Apple's rules, and Android comes with Chrome very much set as the default (and few people change it).

I don't really buy that COVID has made much difference. I think that, ultimately, the two problems above are the issues, and I'm not sure what can be done about them.

Even if Firefox were replaced with a shiny-new brilliant FLOSS browser, we still need an organisation behind it that drives web standards in the right direction (and I think they do need to have a major browser to do that as effectively as Mozilla has), and it still needs the funding to do it, so would still face the same issues as Mozilla, even if it weren't Mozilla.

Someone should be taking Google and Apple to task over bindling their browser and not enabling proper choice on a fair basis, as the EU did to MS (and actually MS has stopped offering a fair choice of browser too, where you choose a default and it is installed, rather than have a default you have to change, that they keep changong back in updates).

sipos··on Amazon Honeycode – build web and mobile apps without writing code
That is true, but, equally, you are underestimating the time you spend trying toi do something that your no-code framework can't do, and the extra cost of working with it.
sipos··on I tried to cancel Virgin Media broadband contract
So, this didn't help me with Virgin Media in the past (though I did get it sorted by finding someone relatively senior and bothering them until they got it sorted), but it usually does, as you say.

In general, I don't allow companies messing me around to profit from it. Even if it takes longer than it is worth, I make a point of principle that I somehow get more back from them than I was cheated out of or they neglected to deliver. Usually this ends up costing them much more than just behaving reasonably in the first place. I find finding a way to do this cathartic. It isn;t always entirely legal though.

If more people did this, it wouldn't be worth companies messing people around.

sipos··on I tried to cancel Virgin Media broadband contract
When I cancelled my home braodband contract a while ago (because I was moving), I eventually ended up with a debt collector after me because they had kept billing me. They had also disconnected me, connected someone else at the same property with the same cable, billed them and been paid by them, so they were not only billing me after I had cancelled, they were billing twice for the same connection. I tried csalling their customer services to sort it, they were no help. Eventually one of their agents admitted there was nothing they, or anyone else I could call with a publicly available number, could do.

(Edit: I forgot, I had also sent recorded delivery mail about it, but got no response).

I eventually got it resolved by finding the number for the CEO's secretary or someone, and harassing them about it until they got it sorted.

Now, the same thing has happened with Virgin Media Business at work (I cancelled because it was always going down, including the PSTN phones, the service was awful and we no longer need it - we had it before I joined, they have been billing us for months after we cancelled).

Worst ISP ever.

sipos··on A one-line package broke `npm create-react-app`
Why are So Many of the Words in This Comment Capitalised? Is it a Title of Something?
sipos··on Stadia owners on Reddit blasting Google over radio silence and lack of support
Customer service for G Suite us terrible too. We have a file on Google Drive that cannot be opened, and have been waiting months for support to resolve it. We have backups independent of Google, but, without them, we'd have basically just lost our data, and their support seems to be doing basically nothing.

As someone who helps support it in a medium sized business, do not use G Suite in your business.

sipos··on When will Google shut down Stadia?
Surely if they planned to, they would say that when asked about this?
sipos··on When will Google shut down Stadia?
Were there lots of pre-ordered, or are they just launching slowly? The fact that pre-order customers can not invite friends immediately, who do not need hardware, suggests it is about limiting users to avoid overloading servers/support/ops.
sipos··on When will Google shut down Stadia?
This. I would buy games on it in a heartbeat if they did this.

The problem is that, to move them to a new platform, for example Steam, they need to pay the platform's cut of the sale price. To give users the option to do this in future, they would need to keep all of the revenue they get from selling games in reserve to possibly do this in future. They would have to do this by charging users what it cost. I think it'd still be attractive though.

sipos··on When will Google shut down Stadia?
> - Search (was once good, now just "marginally better than Bing")

It isn't noticeable better than DuckDuckGo, which is a better alternative for privacy reasons.

sipos··on When will Google shut down Stadia?
What else can you use the controller for? Is it a standard HID?
sipos··on When will Google shut down Stadia?
Yes, all 7 of them are very happy with it.
sipos··on In Defense of Richard Stallman
IMHO, the modern left has become very harsh in condemning people, showing very little compassion, and engaging in witch-hunts. I think t his is extremely unhelpful.

I think this has arisen out of a feeling of righteousness as a result of having been morally right on many things in the past several decades, but it is just indulging the same human tenancy to hate others that perceived as not being part of one's tribe as racism etc, but with a better superficial justification. It is, IMHO, more unhelpful though. People can see racism is bad, but it is quite easy to fall into the trap of thinking that abusing a racist is perfectly fine, and go along with it, but there is a reason we don't use vigilante justice for everything. People become outraged at the treatment of people that they see as unfair, and, IMHO, this is where hatred of political correctness, and unwillingness to engage in attempts to be more progressive come from. IMHO, this hatred by the left, and with-hunt like behaviour, is at least as big an obstacle to progress on many social justice issues as people holding bigoted views that it seeks to break down, because it makes the bigoted people look reasonable.

At the beginning of this issue, I saw headlines or twitter comments alleging a lot of things, read what RMS had actually said, and concluded that the headlines and tweets are bullshit, and dismissed them all, resolving to never believe this type of thing without examining the evidence myself again. This would probably have led to me dismissing a lot of complaints about people in positions of power, assuming they they are similarly unreliable. A friend has said that there are other examples of RMS being disrespectful towards women, but I haven't had a chance to look at them yet, and are not prepared to believe them without evidence, because I have seen that much of what is said second-hand is complete crap. People exaggerating what he has said probably did so because they want to see action and create a safer space for victimised groups, especially women, in CS, but the effect has been to make all allegations highly suspect, at least to me, and I suspect many others, thus having the opposite effect. In a world where allegations that aren't true aren't extremely rare, no allegation can believed without a lot of evidence, and most crimes don't leave much.

The effect of these social media with-hunts that happen when anyone says anything objectionable has been to make most of the population highly resistant to condemning people I think, making it hard to do so when someone actually says something terrible. I think that a significant part of the reason that there is someone who advocated sexual assault as president of the US is that people have heard wolf-cries about people so much that they just don't care if they hear that someone has advocated sexual assault, because last time they heard that, the person had just said something mildly insensitive or something, and so they have started dismissing all allegations unless they have a lot more evidence behind them.

I think that people on the left going overboard in hating their opponents have created more problems for their side than their opponents. I say this as someone who is extremely left wing on most issues. Exaggerating things is never helpful I don't think.

sipos··on Ray tracing in Excel
The question is, why do this?

Is it for fun? If so, great. Not my cup of tea personally, but I can imagine how it could be someone's.

If not for fun, what is the point? It presumably isn't to create a usable ray-tracing system. Perhaps a challenge to improve the author's Excel skills? If so, I suggest they move on to a proper programming language and visualisation system.

There seems to be this obsession, among some people, with using Excel for all sorts of inappropriate things, and I have a sinking feeling that this might be related to that. A system for generating contracts using Excel formulas, in Excel, instead of using mail merge, or something else, with Word or something else designed to format prose text, is a horrible example I have come across at work.

sipos··on YAML: Probably not so great after all
To be fair, the article begins by linking to a previous article by the same author about the problems with JSON. He is an equal opportunities opponent :)
sipos··on Virgin Media (UK) stores passwords in plain text, sends them through the mail
Despite this, they are completely clueless when it comes to technology. I think only a tiny minority of their staff know that they maintain a fiber network, let alone what that means.
sipos··on Virgin Media (UK) stores passwords in plain text, sends them through the mail
In my experience it doesn't make much difference whether you pay the bills or not.

They sent me to a debt collector more than a year after I had closed my account, for something I didn't owe them (it was a bill for services after I had closed my account and been physically disconnected). When I tried to talk to them about it, one of their call centre managers eventually admitted to me that there was no public number that could get me through to a call centre that had anyone able to sort it, or anyone they could transfer me to who could sort it, so I might as well stop trying and sue them.

I got it sorted by tracking down one of the company executives home contact information and calling him about it. I harrassed him considerably less than the debt collectors harrassed me.

sipos··on Virgin Media (UK) stores passwords in plain text, sends them through the mail
Files?

If my experience of Virgin Media is anything to go by, they are probably writing them down in crayon on bits of paper that they keep in a very large box, probably outside and open to the weather.

Actually, it wouldn't surprise me if they just didn't store them at all and just accepted any login attempt.

Given the level of incompetence I have experienced from them, I can only assume they are still in business because of a serious accounting error in their favour.

I found my local cabinet with the doors swinging open and a massive tangled bundle of wires inside. I reported it to them, but they haven't done anything about it for more than a year, other than remove the notice asking you to report it to them if you see it open.

Frankly, I suspect I could build a more reliable link from a bit of string and a couple of plastic cups.

Worst ISP ever.

sipos··on Common mistakes in PostgreSQL
Database migrations are not hard when you have hardly any data, when you are still building something, and they aren't that hard unless you have enormous amounts. On the other hand, having data where records have different attributes is annoying to have to handle everywhere at runtime, especially if it is because of something you have changed, and no new records are missing it. You just end up with code littered with handling of differences due to old design.

This is, IMHO, not a good reason to use NoSQL.

sipos··on I tried creating a web browser, and Google blocked me
DRM never really works.

The best implemented DRM makes it hardly any more inconvenient for people to use it, and people accept it most of the time, Steam for example. It always puts some people off, who end up pirating it when they wouldn't otherwise have, though.

Even the best DRM is always cracked by those that want to. There is no DRM system that has ever been created that will not be defeated, because it is trying to achieve the impossible. You have to give legal consumers access to the content to consume it, so they always have access to copy it. It will never work. If DRM didn't exist, piracy would be a lot less common.

Most people stopped pirating music when it became easily available without DRM.

Ultimately, all DRM gets cracked, and this is the only real response to it.

Annoyingly, DRM only doesn't hit sales harder because it is defeated. If it was impossible to defeat a particular piece of DRM, it would harm sales of content using it much more, but the harm to the content sellers is limited by the fact that it is always cracked early on and made available to consumers they have cut off. For example, I have a Netflix subscription, which I use in an otherwise open source browser, using the widevine plugin ripped out of Chrome. If this wasn't relatively easy, I would just not use Netflix. Netflix is only getting money from me because the DRM they use is easy to defeat illegally. If the DRM worked, I'd stop paying for Netflix, because I wouldn't be able to use it and it'd be much easier to watch the same content by downloading it from Usenet.

sipos··on EU to ban plastic plates, cups, and cutlery by 2021
Agreed, mostly.

Money and effort spent on reducing the use of single use plastics, would be better spent recycling plastics in the western world, improving traceability for plastic containing waste exported to the third world, and improving waste management in the third world.

We don't really need to stop using plastic. There are much more urgent problems, including not dumping plastic in rivers and the ocean. Trying to avoid using plastic hardly helps the environment. There are much more useful and urgent things we could be doing instead.

sipos··on W3C approves WebAuthn as the web standard for password-free logins
You acknowledge that biometrics have some issues they don't solve. Not being easy to steal is one of them. The problem is that you leave your fingerprint all over the place, including all over your phone, there are likely multiple pictures of you publicly available that can be used to construct a model to fool Face ID etc. Most biometrics only provide really minimal security, and the ones that provide anything more don't provide much and are inconvenient.

I use my fingerprint to prevent people casually browsing my phone if I leave it on the table while I pee, but I wouldn't rely on it for more than that, and neither should other people.

You need something else (a key, password or something) to secure most things as well as just your fingerprint.

sipos··on Linus Torvalds on Why ARM Won't Win the Server Space
On the other hand, it's easier to not have to think about it, even when it doesn't matter 99% of the time, and run the exact same container as you tested locally on the server.

I feel like this shouldn't matter really, but people are amazingly lazy/developer time valued highly.

sipos··on Amazon DocumentDB, with MongoDB compatibility
> If MongoDB Inc is successful, it should be because they run a good document-database-as-a-service people want to use

Unfortunately, something that is good, and something people want to use, are not the same thing. People will use AWS's offering even if it is worse and harder to use, because it is bundled as part of AWS. That is a safe option (it can't be that bad if AWS has released it) and an easy one (no need to think about what to use, you are using AWS already.

Being a big provider of virtual machines puts them in a very strong position to sell loads of other stuff.

sipos··on Google Exposed User Data, Feared Repercussions of Disclosing to Public
It sounds like it came up as a result of their Project Strobe audit. I would guess they launched this project precisely because the penalties were about to get bigger and they knew they had skeletons.
sipos··on Numworks: open-source, Python-compatible handheld graphing calculator
Open source is a technical term (and I believe a trademark) with a specific meaning, defined by [The Open Source Initiative](https://opensource.org/). It does not merely mean that the source is available. As you hint at, being free software is a higher requirement, but this does not meet even the lower requirement of being open source.
sipos··on The Commons Clause is an existential threat to open source
> at least the plugins/addons are still available for small companies to use for free so it's still a step up from the typical OSS freemium model where they sell the plugins.

This doesn't allow any companies (except not for profits) to use the plugins without buying them.

sipos··on The Commons Clause is an existential threat to open source
Even Microsoft doesn't think that anymore.
sipos··on The Commons Clause is an existential threat to open source
> Some are seeing that corporations are the ones making all the money on the back of open source software.

This is true of everything. This isn't a problem with open source, it is a problem with society generally.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →