HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sirwitti

1,721 karma · joined March 21, 2010

https://schwerpunkt.digital
submissionscomments
sirwitti··on What's SAP, and why's it worth $163B? (2020)
If anyone thinks about going for odoo - which I did for a customer - do yourself a favor and try anything else. Here's why:

The developer experience is terrible, simple template changes need a your modules to be "upgraded" which means every change takes several seconds at least.

The quality of the app ecosystem is so bad you almost can't install any non-core apps if you want to be able to maintain your project. And apps are incredibly expensive (250€ for a GDPR compliant cookie banner). Most apps have quite few downloads so you don't know if you get what you're paying for.

The documentation is partially non-existing and you're supposed to read odoo's code to know how things works - which is true, but quite time consuming.

If you google technical questions you find odoo forum entries (which could be ok) that often contain just links to youtube videos or simply bad and out-of-date answers.

Here's a link to a forum post (full disclaimer - of me) about some of the things that kept me from getting things done with odoo: https://www.odoo.com/de_DE/forum/hilfe-1/rant-developing-wit...

These issues are just the tip of the iceberg. I honestly wonder how people working on/with odoo deal with this. Things literally take multiples of the time they should and the whole process is a PITA.

Funny sidenote: If you google odoo developer experience and try to find what others have to say about this, you get their conferences since they're called "odoo developer experience".

sirwitti··on Tell HN: I DDoSed myself using CloudFront and Lambda Edge and got a $4.5k bill
Fair point. If your usecase actually needs to be able to handle massive loads, then things might be different.

But then there will probably needs to be a devops team and careful planning how to architect infrastructure anyway.

Also in such cases cloud pricing becomes prohibitively expensive unless you get a special deal.

sirwitti··on Tell HN: I DDoSed myself using CloudFront and Lambda Edge and got a $4.5k bill
I'm very much on the boring technology side of things with respect to hosting.

40€ / month gets you a very powerful dedicated server that can easily handle millions of requests per day and performs incredibly well and can be managed easily.

If you also use containers you even get quite a bit of flexibility and agility.

To be honest I don't really understand the sentiment that developers can get away with not knowing basic sysadmin stuff and at the same time have to spend relevant amounts of time, energy and money to get up to speed with cloud solutions, k8s and so on.

But then again, I'm not one of the cool kids...

sirwitti··on The most livable cities
What makes you say that?
sirwitti··on Sega Megadriver Synthesizer in Depth Look (2020) [video]
Unfortunately it seems that catskull has stopped selling them, otherwise I would have loved to play around with my old megadrive again!
sirwitti··on Dave Smith, ‘Father of MIDI’, has died
Previous HN discussion, currently on still on front page: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31589839
sirwitti··on Ask HN: What’s a good laptop for software development at around $2k?
Having used 2 XPS13 (9343 and 9370) as my daily driver for years, this is simply not true in my experience.

On my 9343 bluetooth did not work initially, and on the 9370 the fingerprint reader is not available (no driver available), but apart from that linux is just working - and I'm not particular fond of spending time on setting things up.

Much more of an issue is that the xps, as every non apple computer does not support s3 sleep anymore. So just closing the lid and putting it in a bag can lead to overheating and battery drain.

Honestly I don't get, why we can't have decent power management unless you buy a mac.

sirwitti··on MDN Plus
Same for me, I'd love to get a subscription for Firefox!
sirwitti··on Update Firmware of Samsung SSDs in Linux
Same thing for me.

A quick search did not result in any official changelog, but some forum entries (e.g. [1] and [2]) suggest that random read + write performance under windows seems to have been improved.

[1] https://www.elevenforum.com/t/samsung-980-pro-firmware-updat...

[2] (in german) https://www.deskmodder.de/blog/2022/01/26/samsung-firmwareup...

sirwitti··on Ask HN: Should we own the free stuff we pay for?
That's the reason why paying for a domain and custom e-mail adresses is the best option in my opinion.

Changing infrastructure / hosting can be done quickly for myself if necessary.

Apart from that, knowing that every e-mail I get or send is being processed by google and potentially read by US authorities simply makes me cringe - even though there's nothing special in my e-mails.

I'd love to self host e-mail and love to read HN posts about it, but I think self-hosting e-mail can become a time sink quite easily.

sirwitti··on Ask HN: How do you stay afloat in the subscription economy?
Maybe it's just me, but personally I simply don't use saas services unless I really have to or very much like to use it regularly.

For the business (I run a small consultancy) the story is different though. It pays for several services on a monthly basis somewhere between 50 and 100€ / month, if they provide value.

The business can afford it and if a service helps the business paying for it is just fair.

sirwitti··on Austrian DPA Ruling Against Google Paves the Way to EU-Based Cloud Services
This is already affecting websites and web apps.

At least all of our customers are moving away from Google Analytics and many try to also get rid of other Google services like fonts and maps.

I'm very interested to see what this changes in other european countries.

sirwitti··on Saving on egress switching from AWS to Hetzner
What's interesting to me is that from my limited experience with cloud services it feels like the technical skills to set up cloud hostings and a good architecture to be just as much work as setting up dedicated servers or even vps.

Or maybe being 38 makes me really old in the way I approach things...

sirwitti··on Tell HN: A Conversation Needs to Be Had over Subscription Software
Even though I don't like paying for software monthly, I think that the JetBrains suite of tools is an example of how this can be a fair deal.

100€/year for tools I use professionally every day and that improve my business is a no-brainer to me. Also I really like the way the prices go down if you use it for more than a year.

sirwitti··on How bad is my gas stove?
I happened to buy a used quality induction stove, that has knobs. At the time I didn't think a lot about it, but to me it's the best stove I ever used.

I honestly don't know thw reasoning for using toch controls on induction stoves. They are a pain to use for most people.

sirwitti··on More than 1M fewer students are in college, the lowest numbers in 50 years
This headline is worded in a way that makes it quite hard to grasp its meaning.

I guess I just like simple language.

sirwitti··on Ask HN: Are most of us developers lying about how much work we do?
I think that it's an illusion for developers (or any creative for that matter) to be productive for most of the time we spend on work.

However large or small the actual number is, and what exactly being productive means - I don't know.

I also believe that not your life revolving around other things apart from development is a good thing.

sirwitti··on Ask HN: My client want an agent on my laptop. Is this the new normal?
I had a similar issues this year - a client's admin wanted me to hand over my device for him to setup vpn access.

My response was that I'm contractually forbidden to allow that since on my device there's data GDPR-relevant and otherwise of other customers.

You can also make up a company-policy (even if you're a single person) and communicate it that way. "There's a strict company policy preventing me/us from installing this kind of software."

Apart from that, this violates the no-asshole-rule.

sirwitti··on Ask HN: How to support Firefox / Mozilla as a small business?
Absolutely! We make a point of our products working under Firefox!
sirwitti··on FarPlay: Low-Latency Audio over the Internet
As it happens I used to play the organ and yes latency can be a real issue, especially in orchestras.

Orchestras are notoriously behind conductors to the point that conductors conduct ahead of the time they want the beat to be. Drummers in orchestras need to guess (and have the experience) at which point after the conductor's beat they hit in order to be in sync with most of the other musicians. That's a tough spot to be in latency-wise :)

Apart from that organ music tends not to have a strong focus on rhythm and groove, in which case latency is less of an issue.

sirwitti··on FarPlay: Low-Latency Audio over the Internet
I love the idea of connecting musicians over the internet.

But in many music technology applications latency is critical and from a musician's standpoint the technically achievable latency is not suitable for actual music making apart from some exceptions - even with dedicated hardware.

When making music that depends on a beat, pocket or groove any roundtrip latency larger than 3ms is noticeable and >6ms is not playable.

If you play software synthesizers on your computer you probably will be aware of the issue since the sample rate and buffer settings of your soundcard alone introduce latency that ranges from playable (for me <4ms) to unacceptable.

Since network latency alone can easily get worse than that I don't see technology like this being usable for playing serious music that focusses on rhythm.

Note that the demo they use is piano and singer which in combination with the chosen song is decently forgiving latency-wise.

I'd like to hear a demo with a grove where they switch between each participant to hear each musicians version.

sirwitti··on Ask HN: Is back end dev generally easier than front end?
In my experience one of the big differences between backend and frontend (and even app development) is that frontend development has an incredibly fast rate of change.

What are best practices now might be considered code smell in 3 months. The tempo, in which the technologies are being swapped out and the number different general directions (react vs vue vs angular vs traditional server side rendered,...) make frontend hard in the sense that keeping up with the fast pace of changes takes up quite some time and energy.

I think that the pace of change in the underlying technologies is a lot slower on the backend and that you can even get away with being an expert for "legacy" technology for quite a while.

Another huge difference is your impact on the UI/UX. Working on frontend always means that the developer has direct impact - and responsibility - about many details of the final product that noone else might have thought about.

If you're into this type of work perfect, but if this stresses you out frontend might not be the right fit for you.

sirwitti··on M1 Pro 14“ MacBook Pro Running KDE Plasma 5 on Arch Linux ARM
What makes you say that?
sirwitti··on Ask HN: Which NoCode platforms are fine?
Thank you! I will check these out!
sirwitti··on Ask HN: Which NoCode platforms are fine?
Slighlty offtopic:

Having shipped an Odoo project this year, how is the developer experience for you?

It seems like Odoo forces developers into time consuming and frustrating workflows (for example using xpath + upgrade modules + possibly reload the server) that make developing for it a pain. Or I might be missing something?

sirwitti··on How does apt render its fancy progress bar?
I recently started using python click [1], which is awesome after wrapping my head around some things. Click also provides a useful abstraction for creating progress bars.

[1] https://palletsprojects.com/p/click/

sirwitti··on Six reasons the EU should force the iPhone to use USB-C
Legislation like this already allows all people in the EU to reuse standardized chargers.

This is one of the (now) small things I appreciate every single day since I only have to manage ~2 usb connector types instead of 10+ proprietory ones.

sirwitti··on Perfect pitch study: Why can’t we identify music notes as well as colors?
I studied musicology with a focus on perception of sound.

As far as I understand it, we evolved to be able to perceive distinct colors because it's relevant to distinguish surfaces from another visually.

For auditory sensations on the other hand rough pitch estimations sufficed but relations between pitches (think of hearing 2 pitches. you probably won't know the exact note or frequency but have learned to recognize patterns in the relations between them - e.g. musical intervals) which comes down to periodicities in the signal turned out to be a lot more relevant or helpful.

As to why we needed to be able to relate pitches to one another: Without looking up literature on the topic I hypothezise that it might be a byproduct of the way we calculate a single perceived pitch out of a harmonic frequency spectrum.

When hearing a note that is not a sinus wave in the frequency spectrum there are at least parts of the multiples of the base frequency.

Since we do something like frequency analysis by detecting periodicities our brain tries to determine a single pitch for the signal, which it does by calculating the base frequency of harmonic spectrum (this works even of only part of the harmonics are availabe.).

In order to do that the processing needs to treat the base frequency differently than the overtones.

Since overtones roughly correlate with western musical intervals and we needed the processing to get extract them. We might have gotten relative pitch perception and part od what is music as a byproduct.

Anecdata for this: Try determining the existence and intervals of notes when the higher note is an octave or an octave and a fifth above the first one (1st and 2nd overtone). Depending on the instrument this can be quite hard.

Disclaimer: These are my interpretations / theories, but since I'm not working in this field, the literature might tell a different story.

sirwitti··on The recycling myth: A plastic waste solution littered with failure
> Then when you look at plastic pollution and see that for the most part North America is quite good at properly disposing of plastic you wonder why we are so obsessed with this as a problem.

As someone who was struck by the magnitude of careless resource use when visiting the US this felt wrong when reading it. But I thought commenting did not help anyone.

Ironically not even a day later the first link on HN is titled: "U.S. generates more plastic trash than any other nation, report finds" [1]

[1] https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/us-pl...

sirwitti··on Ask HN: Tools you have made for yourself?
This is going straight into my bash_aliases. Thanks!
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →