HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sjeohp

121 karma · joined September 18, 2014

submissionscomments
sjeohp··on Google Fires Employee Behind Controversial Diversity Memo
Class =/= race|gender. Could be argued that race|gender equality distracts from class divisions that are far more ingrained.
sjeohp··on Google Fires Employee Behind Controversial Diversity Memo
I only skimmed it but wasn't he just questioning the policy of positive discrimination?

Or is there something else? Because that's a pretty mild question to get so upset about.

sjeohp··on We Evolved to Run But We're Doing It Wrong
No, I think his competitive strength is probably mental fortitude, but that's just speculation.

We're splitting hairs now.

The numbers tilt steeply towards toe-striking at the competitive end, because toe-striking has a higher technical floor and ceiling.

sjeohp··on We Evolved to Run But We're Doing It Wrong
> Meb Keflezghi, winner of both the Boston and New York marathon, that he's not built to run. He's a prime example of a heel striker [1], though slightly less prominent in his later years.

Trained hard and overcame the limitation for a time? I did say there are exceptions.

> More generally, in [2], a study of elite level runners in the half marathon, found that at the 15km point the top 50 was comprised of 62% rear-foot strikers, 36% mid-foot, and 2.0% fore-foot strikers.

Reflects that heel-strikers are more common.

From a quick search:

1,991 runners were classified by foot-strike pattern, revealing a heel-strike prevalence of 93.67% (n=1,865). A significant difference between foot-strike classification and performance was found using a Kruskal-Wallis test (p < 0.0001), with more elite performers being less likely to heel-strike.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4801105/

sjeohp··on We Evolved to Run But We're Doing It Wrong
As a lifelong athlete the on-your-toes style of barefoot running is the best way to run. If you cannot run on your toes you are not built to run. There are rare heel-running sportspeople but running is not their competitive strength. Over long distances it is easy to fall back on heel-running out of laziness, because the impact is absorbed more by joints and less by tired muscles, but that is a failure of fitness and a sub-optimal style.

Barefoot vs shoes is more of a personal choice. A cushioned heel can permit bad style by reducing pain, whereas barefoot forces proper technique or else breaks your feet. However proper technique once you have it doesn't depend on footwear.

sjeohp··on Consciousness and its Place in Nature (2002)
In that case what else is consciousness but the illusion?

If the only known example is my subjective experience then what I call conscious experience is identical to the simulation of conscious experience. IE there's no distinction.

sjeohp··on Consciousness and its Place in Nature (2002)
Is it so clear? For one thing consciousness is not necessarily synonymous with the ability to reason.

Observe your own consciousness; observe the generation of each individual thought and experience. Are you conscious of their origin or do they simply arise in a stream from the darkness of your subconscious?

If the later is true (IE if your subconscious is doing the real work), then is consciousness essential to reason or merely coincidental?

sjeohp··on Cryptoeconomics 101
The entire world banking system for hundreds of years was based on credit backed by gold, so it definitely can work.

My only point was that this wouldn't equate to more btc in circulation, just more credit.

sjeohp··on Cryptoeconomics 101
You can give out credit backed by BTC but it's impossible to give out more actual BTC than you hold, much like gold, unlike fiat.
sjeohp··on Are ants capable of self recognition? (2015) [pdf]
I would draw a distinction between that kind of olfactory/territorial self-recognition and the kind suggested by this test which actually implies some kind of mental representation of the self.
sjeohp··on Are ants capable of self recognition? (2015) [pdf]
Not really since that's not an explanation of the results. The simplest explanation of the results is that ants have some degree of self-awareness.
sjeohp··on Are ants capable of self recognition? (2015) [pdf]
That is interesting. How do they test that?
sjeohp··on Are ants capable of self recognition? (2015) [pdf]
Self recognition is considered a big deal because very few animals that we know of are capable of it: most apes, some monkeys, dolphins, elephants, magpies, etc. Notice they also happen to be among the most sapient animals.

In this case self-recognition == self-awareness. The ants had a stored representation of themselves in memory that didn't include a blue dot on the head. When met with their reflection they were able to deduce that:

a) they were looking at themselves

b) the blue dot was not a part of them and so should be removable

Whether it's possible to be unconsciously self-aware is an interesting question.

sjeohp··on Are ants capable of self recognition? (2015) [pdf]
By the time cordyceps fruits the ant has already climbed and died. There would be nothing to see before then.
sjeohp··on Are ants capable of self recognition? (2015) [pdf]
Methodology is important but given that (assuming the results are valid):

- Ants ignore other ants behind clear glass but inspect their own reflections.

- An ant with a blue dot on its head when shown its reflection will rub at the dot.

- An ant with a brown/invisible dot on its head will ignore it.

- An ant with a blue dot on the back of its head where it can't be seen in the mirror will ignore it.

At a certain point Occam's razor comes into play, doesn't it?

sjeohp··on Are ants capable of self recognition? (2015) [pdf]
> these species have plenty more brain calls than ants

Much less complex societies though, for what it's worth.

sjeohp··on Are ants capable of self recognition? (2015) [pdf]
I agree about the journal but these are the authors: https://scholar.google.ca/scholar?start=0&q=%22Marie-Claire+...
sjeohp··on The Secret Life of Time
are you suggesting it can't?
sjeohp··on The Byzantine Generals Problem (1982) [pdf]
The two chains will fall out of sync before they're finished. Chance of all 12 proofs being completed at exactly the same time and broadcast to groups of identical computing power every step of the way is very small.
sjeohp··on Is nature a low-complexity sampler?
Consciousness is more likely to be an emergent property than a fundamental component of a theory of everything. It is a property of systems of neurons; physical theories operate at a much lower level.
sjeohp··on A clock that can detect tiny shifts in the flow of time itself
> There is not a fixed state of each 'quarter' in each 'box'. They are truly not determined until one is resolved;

Isn't that unknowable? And aren't both situations (fixed vs undetermined) effectively the same from an observer's point of view?

← PreviousPage 2 of 2