HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

skepticATX

1,464 karma · joined April 5, 2023

Software dev interested in security, distributed computing, and AI.
submissionscomments
skepticATX··on Doge Claimed It Saved $8B in One Contract. It Was $8M
There are more oddities for sure. For example, when they cancel a multi-year contract they are considering the entire value of the contract as savings even if a significant chunk of the money has already been distributed.
skepticATX··on Doge Claimed It Saved $8B in One Contract. It Was $8M
I think this was an honest mistake. But it demonstrates exactly why it’s so dangerous for Elon Musk and our president to make sweeping accusations before understanding the situation.

Lives are being ruined right now - federal employees, citizens who rely on the programs being cut, and people around the world who benefited from US generosity.

The sad part about all of this is that clearly in a system as large as the federal government, there is waste. Elon has the opportunity to make a real impact, but he’s demonstrated that he just cares about optics and will not put in the effort required.

skepticATX··on 20k federal workers take "buyout" so far, official says
Yes, there’s practically no chance that this is true.
skepticATX··on Payments crisis of 2025: Not “read only” access anymore
Clearly it's not happening tomorrow, but eventually Democrats (and maybe even Republicans who want to uphold the constitution!) will be in the majority.
skepticATX··on Payments crisis of 2025: Not “read only” access anymore
I think you're specifically referring to the Pentagon. I'd like to see Elon attempt to force his way into that building next.
skepticATX··on Payments crisis of 2025: Not “read only” access anymore
Not a lawyer, but it would seem that Elon and Doge employees are exposing themselves up to significant legal liability here. Maybe Trump pardons Elon (if they don't fall out before then), but is he going to pardon everyone who has a hand in this? And it seems likely that state crimes are being committed as well. The president may have broad immunity, but Elon does not.
skepticATX··on Do Insects Feel Pain?
All life is due respect and consideration. Of course, a human life gets the maximum consideration, and an insect life much less. Plant life even less, but some.

Capability to feel pain doesn’t have anything to do with this, in my mind.

skepticATX··on Stargate Project: SoftBank, OpenAI, Oracle, MGX to build data centers
Here's why I know that OpenAI is stuck in a hype cycle. For all of 2024, the cry from employees was "PhD level models are coming this year; just imagine what you can do when everyone has PhD level intelligence at their beck and call". And, indeed, PhD level models did arrive...if you consider GPQA to be a benchmark that is particularly meaningful in the real world. Why should I take this year's pronouncements seriously, given this?

OpenAI is what you get when you take Goodhart's Law to the extreme. They are so focused on benchmarks that they are completely blind to the rate of progress that actual matters (hint...it's not model capability in a vacuum).

Yann indeed does believe that AGI will arrive in a decade, but the important thing is that he is honest that this is an uncertain estimate and is based off of extrapolation.

skepticATX··on Stargate Project: SoftBank, OpenAI, Oracle, MGX to build data centers
You have hit on something that really bothers me about recent AGI discourse. It’s common to claim that “all” researchers agree that AGI is imminent, and yet when you dive into these claims “all” is a subset of researchers that excludes everyone in academia, people like Yann, and others.

So the statement becomes tautological “all researchers who believe that AGI is imminent believe that AGI is imminent”.

And of course, OpenAI and the other labs don’t perform actual science any longer (if science requires some sort of public sharing of information), so they win every disagreement by claiming that if you could only see what they have behind closed doors, you’d become a true believer.

skepticATX··on Stargate Project: SoftBank, OpenAI, Oracle, MGX to build data centers
Interestingly, there seems to be no actual government involvement aside from the announcement taking place at the White House. It all seems to be private money.
skepticATX··on Stargate Project: SoftBank, OpenAI, Oracle, MGX to build data centers
Why are corporations announcing business deals from the White House? There doesn’t seem to be any public ownership/benefit here, aside from potential job creation. Which could be significant. But the American public doesn’t seem to gain anything from this new company.
skepticATX··on The Origins of Wokeness
It’s interesting to me that a certain type of person is so susceptible to buying into this fable of wokeness, especially when it pertains to universities. Almost like there is a woke mind virus, but it’s not infecting the people they think it is.

I attended university in the mid 2010s, so close to peak “wokeness”, and I never witnessed or heard of anything like what pg is describing. In my experience it was totally fine to hold just about any political/ethical view as long as you were a decent human being to your fellow classmates. There certainly was no political correctness police forcing us to assimilate.

skepticATX··on OpenAI O3 breakthrough high score on ARC-AGI-PUB
Great catch. Super disappointing that AI companies continue to do things like this. It’s a great result either way but predictably the excitement is focused on the jump from o1, which is now in question.
skepticATX··on OpenAI: Sora
I felt this same way as image generation was rapidly improving, but I've been caught by surprise and impressed with how resilient we have been in the face of it.

Turns out it's surprisingly, at least for me, to tune out the slop. Some platforms will fall victim to it (Google image search, for one), but new platforms will spring up to take their place.

skepticATX··on OpenAI seeks to unlock investment by ditching 'AGI' clause with Microsoft
It’s not an exact figure, but plenty of employees claimed that after we train a model with 2-3 orders of magnitude of compute over GPT-4 we’d reach AGI, which puts us at $10-$100 billion.

See Situational Awareness for one example of this.

skepticATX··on OpenAI seeks to unlock investment by ditching 'AGI' clause with Microsoft
What frustrates me the most about OpenAI is that as recently as this summer they were talking non-stop about how gigantic $100 billion models are all you need for AGI and that it’s just a matter of time until we reach this scale. And if you didn’t see this you’re a simpleton who doesn’t understand how exponential curves work.

And then all of the sudden o1 comes out and the narrative from them has shifted entirely. “Obviously massive models aren’t enough to get to AGI, but all we have to do is scale up inference time compute and we’ll get there!” And if you don’t see this you’re just a simpleton.

I wish that OpenAI was called out for this shift more often. Because I haven’t heard even one of their employees acknowledge this. At some point you have to just ignore them until they start actually publishing science that supports their beliefs, but that won’t happen because it doesn’t generate revenue.

skepticATX··on Assassination is a leaky abstraction
The loudest opinions surface. I wouldn’t take lack of public sympathy to mean that the average American condones this type of behavior.

I am no more sympathetic than I am towards the many people killed each day in the US, but I think the assassination and the subsequent justification of it because he was a small cog in the system is abhorrent. And I hope that the majority of the country feels the same way.

skepticATX··on Vivek Ramaswamy on X: "Will entire agencies be deleted? Answer: yes
Elon and Vivek have no authority to close a federal agency, and Trump doesn’t either.

We’re currently in the bloviating stage of this election cycle; once attention dies down I fully expect DOGE to achieve very little and to die a slow death.

The sad part of all of this is that the government could absolutely be more efficient than it currently is, while still providing the same services. But that’d take serious thought and consensus building, which the incoming administration has no desire to engage in.

skepticATX··on Bluesky just crossed 20M users
I think it’ll keep improving as more folks move over. This is just a temporary artifact of X refugees being the first to migrate.
skepticATX··on OpenAI o1 Results on ARC-AGI-Pub
My feeling is that this is one reason they decided to hide the reasoning tokens.
skepticATX··on Learning to Reason with LLMs
> People should realize we’re reaching the point where LLMs are surpassing humans in any task limited in scope enough to be a “benchmark

This seems like a bold statement considering we have so few benchmarks, and so many of them are poorly put together.

skepticATX··on Zuckerberg claims regret on caving to White House pressure on content
Why does no one read the actual proposal before commenting?

It specifically states that this only applies to individuals with 80% of their wealth in tradeable assets. No founder is going to lose control because this doesn’t apply to them!

skepticATX··on Homebound: The Long-Term Rise in Time Spent at Home Among U.S. Adults
Zoning and car-centric design are intimately connected, though. A walkable suburb just can’t support the number of cars that a typical western suburb supports today.

If you loosen zoning, what you’re going to end up with is denser development and less room for cars.

Streetcar suburbs are an example of this. You have more room than living in the core of the city, but you don’t have enough room for 3 F150s for the family.

skepticATX··on Ask HN: What was your most humbling learning moment?
I’d argue that by definition, code producing value is good code. It may not be the best, but it has to be at least good.

Almost everything else about code is subjective, but value is objective.

skepticATX··on OpenAI didn’t copy Scarlett Johansson’s voice for ChatGPT, records show
Exactly. All this reporting says is that the actress wasn’t explicitly told to copy “Her”. We still don’t know about the intentions of OpenAI throughout all of this. With Sam’s seeming obsession with the movie, are we really supposed to believe that the company never discussed it internally?
skepticATX··on Leaked OpenAI documents reveal aggressive tactics toward former employees
I don’t believe in the AGI claims, or in X-Risk. But I do think it’s apparent that AI will only become more powerful and ubiquitous. Very concerning that someone like Sam, with a history of dishonesty and narcissism that is only becoming more obvious time, may stand to control a large chunk of this technology.

He can’t be trusted, and as a result OpenAI cannot be trusted.

skepticATX··on Statement from Scarlett Johansson on the OpenAI "Sky" voice
There are models that are nearly as good as GPT-4 now. For personal usage, I've been using them for a while now. OpenAI has jumped the shark so much that I'm going to advocate for moving to Anthropic/Google models at work now. OpenAI simply can't be trusted while Sam is at the helm.
skepticATX··on Sam and Greg's response to OpenAI Safety researcher claims
You're right, this isn't a view that is likely to be shared by the general public.

However, I don't think the general public's view of OpenAI is much better at this point, given that their exposure is Hinton on 60 Minutes claiming that AI is going to imminently end civilization, creatives arguing that OpenAI has stolen their work, and students using their products to cheat.

The only people that I do know who have historically had a positive view of OpenAI has been people working in tech. And Sam seems to be doing everything he can to destroy that goodwill.

skepticATX··on Sam and Greg's response to OpenAI Safety researcher claims
Interesting that OpenAI has completely destroyed their reputation over the last year. For me, they've gone from an admirable company to cringe-worthy. I really think that the best outcome here is for OpenAI to collapse and get absorbed by Microsoft, where adults can continue some of the good work that is being overshadowed by ego and cult-like vibes.
skepticATX··on Jan Leike's OpenAI departure statement
All I’d like to see from AI safety folks is an empirical argument demonstrating that we’re remotely close to AGI, and that AGI is dangerous.

Sorry, but sci-fi novels are not going to cut it here. If anything, the last year and a half have just supported the notion that we’re not close to AGI.

← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →