HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

skriticos2

1,028 karma · joined October 28, 2012

submissionscomments
skriticos2··on Show HN: A simple GUI Notepad using C++ natively made in my high school in 2015
I'd agree with you a decade ago, but nowadays Qt is all over the place (I still like it, just not good to start out - two GUI frameworks in the core library, which one do I choose; the docs certainly don't help). Today you fare better with something like Lazarus to start out or Python if you ignore the GUI.
skriticos2··on Show HN: A simple GUI Notepad using C++ natively made in my high school in 2015
I remember the time when I was a teen and started out with TurboPascal 8. It was a really polished experience with the inbuilt library being enough to do anything console (even a GUI framework). Very found memories and it did show me the basics that I use today without overwhelming with details, squabblings and arcanea (it was fairly consistent). Very different to the patchwork you find if you start today and the constraints to work with a limited set of tools was really great for starting out. Throw an NPM ecosystem with a million terms at a kid today who tries to start out and you have lost the spark. Kids only categorize programming as fun or chore once and it sticks. Luckily there is still Python (you can get very far by limiting yourself to the standard library and it leaves space to actually focus on the exploration of programming).
skriticos2··on Qt 5.15 LTS
Yes, pretty much this. The last time I tried it, the platform had a dark theme style that wx tried to apply, but then ended up with light grey borders within the dark parts of the widgets and there really wasn't a simple solution - there was an unresolved bug ticket.
skriticos2··on Qt 5.15 LTS
Unless you consider HTML5 in the browser, the options are quite limited (I guess you do, as you included Electron).

GTK is always GNOME first and has issues most other places or just looks ugly.

wxWidgets always looked off and had the weirdes issues.

Qt (or at least QtWidgets) was fairly solid in design and implementation. Then they kind of put that on ice and started with a second GUI framework (QML) that didn't fit together whatsoever. Now it has a split personality and the widgets part has a hard time to keep up with modern problems like high-resolution screens and and scaling (I'm writing this from KDE, so I know first hand).

Then everyone tried to re-invent the user interface paradigm and that's how we ended up in the current mess. Consistent buttons, input boxes and frameworks were replaced by flashy but fairly unusable interfaces, which of course did not work out. So now we have this weird mix of not letting go and not knowing where to go.

You could go very old school though, with something like http://www.fox-toolkit.org or https://www.lazarus-ide.org/

skriticos2··on A lot of “idiotic” things have reasonable explanations (2011)
I concur. It really depends on the reward function you chaise.

Let's say you are a genius OCD person being elated by seeing the numbers on your bank accounts go up and nothing much else. You live 60-90 years and at the end you have some big number there. In this case you were successful.

Let's say you are a more typical person, you'll probably have a larger set of reward functions and they may even change over time. Having money on the account to be able to cover costs and do some vanity spending is definitely rewarding to a point - until it becomes hollow. But then there are all those other reward functions, like maintaining a family, seeing your kids grow up, see the world, play games, learn new things and maybe build or invent a thing or two. Maybe just shine as a social focal point or any number of other things. Maybe just watching turtles in various environments.

The only thing that we can't extend as a reward function is acquiring more time, like money on the bank account. So balancing the reward functions for a reasonable contentedness with life is generally what we strive to do, even if we don't spell it out that way.

We start young and see all the possibilities and the scarceness of time is not a pressing matter - reward functions are more about enjoying life. Then with a family you see time passing, become more aware of it. You learn from the things you messed up and know that some things can't be fixed and your reward function will become more about stability and preservation.

And then you die.

skriticos2··on AWS services explained in one line each
Indeed. One of the entries like this is a dedicated robot infrastructure service (like, managing real robot hardware that does something out there - think delivery robots). Certainly out of the usual software domain. They also collaborate with a few different quantum computer companies that do different approaches to quantum computing (gate based and annealing) which is an entirely separate field of science and most likely out of the usual comfort zone of most IT people.
skriticos2··on Plasma 5.18
Kubuntu at least boots. I was trying neon first, which refused to do so on my laptop.
skriticos2··on Plasma 5.18
I just recently switched to kubuntu (KDE) back from fedora (Gnome 3).

On one hand I do like that the desktop does not try to re-define basic muscle memory things, like changing the shortcut if you try to switch between two windows of the same application. (Seriously Gnome, WTF?).

On the other hand it crashed left and right after install (less so now that it settled down a bit) and there are a million QA type problems. I have a 4K 27" screen and everything is tiny by default, so I put scaling to 1.3 and Kate + Terminal are full of lines. The computation of the window update is broken.. I browse the internet and the ticket is open - since two years.

Then there is Wayland, which I got used to on Gnome and think is a great achievement - not in KDE though, that is still highly experimental and so back it goes to ancient protocols. Yay!

So yes, we are building fancy new stuff on an eroding foundation is the message I am getting from KDE nowadays. Compared to Gnome - which is stable but weird.

Thinking back on the Gnome 2 / compiz / beryl days we have gone downhill so much it's not funny..

ps. I know I'm complaining too much and that's unfair to an open source project. And I still perceive Liunx desktops as superior to Windows which has it's own issues (technical and non-technical). Just wondering what all the effort was spent on in the last decade or two. I just don't see it.

skriticos2··on Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after secret flight tests
The problem with the 737-MAX was not that it used a computer. It was that the 737 series is generally not designed to be fly-by-wire and it was rammed in there to keep previous flight characteristics and just generally downplay the design ramifications of putting a much more massive engine below the wings that tilts the center of gravity considerably and changes flight characteristics.

Airbus is doing fine with fly-by-wire. They do so because they start with it at the design stage and don't haphazardly change major aerodynamic characteristics without going back to the drawing board and thinking through all the ramifications.

There is much more to say what went wrong and it's fairly well documented in public sources and little of it was because computers (though there is something to be said about the code quality culture at Boeing, but that's a different topic).

skriticos2··on Why Google Did Android
Nokia had a problem long before that. They were trying to play on too many playgrounds. They had S60 and Symbian as their workhorse OSs and then were dabbling in various custom Linux stacks (I had an N800 back than, GTK+ based - could skin it like a tricorder - fun times). Then they acquired Qt (Trolltech) and instead of building a UI on the Widgets tech stack they wanted to re-invent the wheel with QML - which is how the Qt framework became this weird two GUI frameworks in one that don't really mesh to this day.

Granted, Google was also just throwing stuff at the wall and seeing what stuck, but at least they are a tech company with multiple revenue streams - while Nokia wasn't either of those - so without a laser focus they were doomed from the get go. And they did not have it.

skriticos2··on WHO Director-General: “We may only be seeing the tip of the iceberg”
I was thinking about that too - and all the articles about the Chinese ghost towns. Few people are going out most places where the epidemic is raging - society basically came to a stop. My guess is that that would indeed modify the function that dictates infection rates.

Now granted, the articles are anecdotal and not statistically representative, so there is some extrapolation in these assumptions. The actual numbers are probably somewhere in between.

skriticos2··on A moon landing in 2024? NASA says it'll happen
Metallurgy is fascinating! This reminds me of the semi-secret one crystal cooling process for airplane turbine segments. The entire thing comes out as one crystal and you need very precise temperature control not just as a whole or in various spots but in various gradients of the oven to get the thing come out properly. It would take anyone forever to replicate this from scratch, even though I can easily explain what the expected end result should look like.
skriticos2··on Flight risk: can we take the carbon out of air travel?
I concur. Also in feudal times people lived 30 years on average and had horrible quality of life, spending most of the time with back breaking work. Death was common before, during and after birth. We just like to romanticize it. I like fantasy too, but that does hardly reflect history.

We as a spices have one advantage that have brought us where we are: the advent of tool usage. And that will be the solution too. On a time frame of 100-200 years we will solve energy scarcity through various means (fusion, focused space solar arrays, rentables, etc.). Then we can build the tools to maintain our current and future lifestyle. We can produce synthetic meat / plant meat. We can start stacked farming with in-door illumination. We can capture methane in in-door stables with advanced air management techniques. We can create terraforming towers mega-structures that remove all the carbon dioxide we blew into the atmosphere and put it back into the ground or into hydrocarbon fuel tanks or something. We are really good at these kind of things, but only once it starts to really hurt.

So far it doesn't. There is the specter of hurt to come and a few early warning signs, but in aggregate we don't give a damn about it so far. When we start to burn, our plains become barren and our population is collapsing, then we will start address the actual problems and do something about them. Maybe, the optimistic version. We have the potential to do it.

Alternatively we can just bitch about it until the population is decimated and then have the remaining few survivors start a new civilization a few hundred years down the line.

Or we just annihilate ourselves because of pent up aggression about the miserable state of affair we brought ourself into. We can be very vengeful if we are cornered.

Whatever it will be, it probably will be interesting (for an outside observer).

skriticos2··on As Costs Skyrocket, More U.S. Cities Stop Recycling
Most supermarkets have bottle recycling ATMs (outside the entrance) around here in Germany. The homeless scavenging bottles from public bins and returning them are doing just fine. I'm not aware of the lot of mess this causes though, not sure what you are talking about there.
skriticos2··on As Costs Skyrocket, More U.S. Cities Stop Recycling
It's about 30 USD ct in Germany (25 euro ct) for plastic bottles (that you have to pay up front). Very few bottles are not returned around here.
skriticos2··on As Costs Skyrocket, More U.S. Cities Stop Recycling
Person from Germany here where we have 4 different bins per household - paper, recyclables (metal, plastic), compostables and dump (+ glass by color, batteries and electronics at dedicated sites). We get to a recycling rate of about 20-30% (effective at plant) with really wanting to and having it ingrained into our culture.

Recycling is hard at the best of times. Unless packaging gets much better at identifying as recyclable it will be a long road ahead (it's the small things, black plastic is hard to identify and get's burned, composite plastics are problematic, like different plastic foil over plastic canister). At least people think about it around here, but it is a very hard problem.

skriticos2··on Volkswagen’s Costly Bet on Electric Cars
Yep. That's the current problem. They have built a ton of wind-farms out in the north sea and have industry in the very south of the country. So they want to build a set of power-lines that connects these places called SuedLink. They started sometime around 2014 and are still only a fraction of the way there.

So charging in the north will be fine, not so much in the middle or south.

Nobody wants a giant power-line around them and they faced stiff protests against the routes. If I recall correctly, they now want to bury the power-lines underground to avoid some of the public opposition.

In the meantime Germany is switching off its nuclear infrastructure (because people hate that too) so that they can buy nuclear power from France (which is perfectly fine?).

Also Germany spent billions on the green energy initiative in the past decade and is still hooked ~35% on lignite, one of the most polluting sorts of coal out there.

Without the power-lines that bring green energy from the sea, the e-car revolution will be difficult (unless we want to burn coal of course).

Established modern society is so dysfunctional when it comes to big projects that aim to change an existing system.

skriticos2··on France’s new high-speed trains
Yes, but Japan also has trice the population density of France and most of the people are focused in the gargantuan city landscapes like the greater Tokyo bay area. Makes it a lot easier to saturate the trains while maintaining a reasonable timetable.
skriticos2··on Space Colony Art from the 1970s
That's why they reminded me of the series immediately. :) One of my favorites.
skriticos2··on Space Colony Art from the 1970s
My thoughts exactly. Especially since it's much easier to simulate 1 gravity in space with rotating space stations. (You live long enough on Mars/Moon/etc., you are not coming back without being crushed).

The stations would need to be rather large, but that's just an engineering and motivation problem. But with a little extra shielding (lot's of water in the hull - could be obtained from asteroids) they'd be very useful as living space (especially after climate change ravages our home planet).

They'd also be much better staging places for solar system exploration and have an advantage in trade (refueling, low energy requirement to get anywhere, excellent target for asteroid refinement without having to bring stuff into a gravity well and back up).

Not having to fight the atmosphere for solar energy is also a plus.

But humanity still clings to traditional gravity wells like the images in the OP show. Old Italian land-house style dwellings in an orbital ring station..

skriticos2··on Microsoft’s Azure DevOps: An Unsatisfying Adventure
I love vim, but that .xinitrc stuff is really out of date by now. Gnome 3 now uses Wayland fairly well and the setup is done with the GUI app Tweaks and the system settings.
skriticos2··on Microsoft’s Azure DevOps: An Unsatisfying Adventure
It's not even about the price. I have no problem tweaking my Linux desktop to use an international Dvorak layout (useful for those European languages with ä's and é's) and switching the caps and ctrl keys. Say what you want about Gnome 3, but this works just fine.

On Windows.. I get a US only bare bone Dvorak layout and few ways to remap the caps/ctrl keys. Messing with the registry is at best annoying on my gaming (only) PC but impossible on a corporate locked down desktop. Then I'm lucky if the corporate package repo comes with AutoHotkey that can remap keys in a very hacky way.

A lot of Windows 98 still shines through in the basic usability suite even on the newest versions of Windows. Even the on-screen keyboard on a (Android) phone is more fun than the HID mess in Windows.

skriticos2··on Microsoft is building a Chromium browser to replace Edge on Windows 10
Nah, wrong comparison. Microsoft mostly stayed in their corner (Software) while the others (Google, Amazon) are branching out to everything else. Things like Waymo will probably even take over the revenue of pure digital services (though it's tied into). Transportation is a big business.

Better analog would be Wayland-Yutani I guess. The corporations that are manifesting currently are nothing that the world has ever seen before in size and interconnections.

Not that I'm against it, it's just my observation. I'm an avid customer of both.

skriticos2··on My Grandfather Thought He Solved a Cosmic Mystery
Not the same problem, but I have been on and off thinking about infinite/recursive compression and compression of random data. Finding patterns in numbers can be very compelling.
skriticos2··on Mars likely to have enough oxygen to support life: study
I concur. It's an interesting endeavour though - which mashes well with humanities impulse to progress and push the boundaries. Not everybody cares about that, but there are enough dreamers that marvel about humanity becoming an space faring civilization. The demand for science fiction is proof of that.

However, I personally don't understand why everyone wants to land on a dirtball that has a fraction of earths gravity. It will be crippling for the human physiology and pretty much precludes travel back to earth after a few generations of adaption.

I'd much prefer to build rotating orbital space stations that provide 1G centrifugal force. Easier on the body, better view out the window and no need to enter/escape gravity wells all the time. The dirtballs can be colonized by robots that don't care about gravity that much and can harvest resources for the stations.

Not that I have a say about this at all.

skriticos2··on 3D engine entirely made of MS Excel formulae
For me it usually is "I would like to use some sensible tools, but corporate policy requires me to not do that (because they are not available) - so I have to (ab)use Excel/Office/VBA to get things done." It's not pretty, stable, efficient or really maintainable, but if you are forced to use a hammer..

ps. Excel does some things OK, like drawing pretty graphs on smallish datasets and visualize quick analysis with pivot tables. It just lacks a sensible scripting language and is generally very brittle once the data is getting nontrivial and more than one person is involved.

skriticos2··on Linus Torvalds apologizes for his behavior, takes time off
This reminds me of employee work reviews in Germany when they leave, that are mandated by law to be positive (not kidding).

The result is that it spawned a new code language for HR people (there are dictionaries) that "translate" the review.

Everybody is polite..

For instance the level of praise in with the various points indicates a scoring.

Here are a few examples:

He showed understanding for his work. -> He did not do anything.

He did all the work with great diligence and interest. -> Eager, but not very efficient.

He tried to do his job justice. -> The will was there, more unfortunately not.

He has used his skills. -> He did what he could. That was not much.

Here is a Google Translated page about it: https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=y&pr...

skriticos2··on Optical fibre made in orbit should be better than the terrestrial sort
With a capsule you load the machine and feedstock comfortably on the ground, shoot it up and press the start button. Wait for it to complete, deorbit, unload. With Dragon you have about 6 tons of weight to work with, so even if the aperture is 1-2 tons, you still can process 4-5 tons of material. Fairly reasonable and achievable with the right design.

With an orbital station: first you need to build a station and keep it where it is (there are not a ton of orbital stations for a reason, they are expensive). If it has humans on it, everything becomes massively expensive. If not, well, you need future tech for onboard logistics and maintenance.

Even if you ignore the ridiculous cost of building and maintaining an orbital station, life support and other crew issues..

You still need to rendezvous, dock, transfer feedstock, produce, transfer product back to capsule, land. Even just a station that works like a printer with the feedstock seamlessly plugging in it would make everything more complicated and expensive.

Not even talking about how to fix your automated orbital platform when it breaks down.

Now in a few hundred years when we have massive orbital platforms with readily available workforce for hire and workshops for rent.. maybe then. But with today's technology you are looking at cost differences between maybe a 100 million all in with a single shot automated capsule (+ your stuff) vs. several billions for the most simple station designs + a ton of risk and technical hurdles.

Space is hard as we are fairly new to it (relatively speaking). It's all custom built as of now. Each moving peace you add increases cost exponentially. Adding humans just puts you on an entirely different chart altogether.

skriticos2··on Optical fibre made in orbit should be better than the terrestrial sort
Yes, but you'd simplify logistics. Maintaining a space station is magnitudes more expensive. Construction, complexity, upkeep, loading logistics. If the machines fit, you almost always come out ahead cost-wise.
skriticos2··on Optical fibre made in orbit should be better than the terrestrial sort
Why not just send the weawer fitted to a dragon for a few dozen orbits and then land the produce? With block 5 they can make the trip for 50 million. Unless the machines are too big it won't get any cheaper. Little logistics needed.
← PreviousPage 2 of 11Next →