> Jims review on Ars was a bit unfair, considering the enormous difference in man power involved with the Haiku community and the commercial support most other OS’s have
I get that context matters, but if you're going to write a review about a desktop operating system, you should be comparing it to the other desktop OSes that are available so that readers have a point of reference.
> It’s a young system with potential. It’s a beta of R1.
To be fair, it's taken almost twenty years to get to the R1 beta. I've been following its development on and off since the demise of BeOS. I remember reading about all of the in-fighting from the early days of OpenBeOS, so I'm glad that they've made all the progress they have.
What they've produced is indeed admirable, but you can't ignore the fact that the technology world is in a very different place since they started this project.
When I look at Haiku today, it is like opening up a time capsule of a late 90's era operating systems.
Even when I had BeOS, I still had to dual boot with Windows due to the lack of broad application support. So as a somewhat interested observer/follower of the OS's development since the project began -- once I get past that feeling of nostalgia -- it's even hard for me to see the potential that you talking about.